by Susan Glaspell
I. “ONE OF THOSE IMPOSSIBLE AMERICANS”
II. THE PLEA
III. FOR LOVE OF
V. FROM A TO Z
VI. THE MAN OF
FLESH AND BLOOD
VII. HOW THE
VIII. THE LAST
IX. “OUT THERE”
XI. HIS AMERICA
I. “ONE OF THOSE IMPOSSIBLE
“N'avez-vous pas—” she was bravely demanding of the clerk when she
saw that the bulky American who was standing there helplessly dangling
two flaming red silk stockings which a copiously coiffured young woman
assured him were bien chic was edging nearer her. She was never
so conscious of the truly American quality of her French as when a
countryman was at hand. The French themselves had an air of “How
marvellously you speak!” but fellow Americans listened superciliously
in an “I can do better than that myself” manner which quite untied the
Gallic twist in one's tongue. And so, feeling her French was being
compared, not with mere French itself, but with an arrogant new
American brand thereof, she moved a little around the corner of the
counter and began again in lower voice: “Mais, n'avez—”
“Say, Young Lady,” a voice which adequately represented the figure
broke in, “you, aren't French, are you?”
She looked up with what was designed for a haughty stare. But what
is a haughty stare to do in the face of a broad grin? And because it
was such a long time since a grin like that had been grinned at her it
happened that the stare gave way to a dimple, and the dimple to a
laughing: “Is it so bad as that?”
“Oh, not your French,” he assured her. “You talk it just like the
rest of them. In fact, I should say, if anything—a little more so. But
do you know,”—confidentially—“I can just spot an American girl every
“How?” she could not resist asking, and the modest black hose she
was thinking of purchasing dangled against his gorgeous red ones in
“Well, Sir—I don't know. I don't think it can be the
clothes,”—judicially surveying her.
“The clothes,” murmured Virginia, “were bought in Paris.”
“Well, you've got me. Maybe it's the way you wear 'em. Maybe
it's 'cause you look as if you used to play tag with your brother.
Something—anyhow—gives a fellow that 'By jove there's an American
girl!' feeling when he sees you coming round the corner.”
“Lord—don't begin on why. You can say why to
anything. Why don't the French talk English? Why didn't they lay Paris
out at right angles? Now look here, Young Lady, for that matter—why
can't you help me buy some presents for my wife? There'd be nothing
wrong about it,” he hastened to assure her, “because my wife's a mighty
The very small American looked at the very large one. Now Virginia
was a well brought up young woman. Her conversations with strange men
had been confined to such things as, “Will you please tell me the
nearest way to—?” but preposterously enough—she could not for the
life of her have told why—frowning upon this huge American—fat was
the literal word—who stood there with puckered-up face swinging the
flaming hose would seem in the same shameful class with snubbing the
little boy who confidently asked her what kind of ribbon to buy for his
“Was it for your wife you were thinking of buying these red
stockings?” she ventured.
“Sure. What do you think of 'em? Look as if they came from Paris all
right, don't they?”
“Oh, they look as though they came from Paris, all right,” Virginia
repeated, a bit grimly. “But do you know”—this quite as to that little
boy who might be buying the ribbon—“American women don't always care
for all the things that look as if they came from Paris. Is your
wife—does she care especially for red stockings?”
“Don't believe she ever had a pair in her life. That's why I thought
it might please her.”
Virginia looked down and away. There were times when dimples made
things hard for one.
Then she said, with gentle gravity: “There are quite a number of
women in America who don't care much for red stockings. It would seem
too bad, wouldn't it, if after you got these clear home your wife
should turn out to be one of those people? Now, I think these grey
stockings are lovely. I'm sure any woman would love them. She could
wear them with grey suede slippers and they would be so soft and
“Um—not very lively looking, are they? You see I want something to
cheer her up. She—well she's not been very well lately and I thought
something—oh something with a lot of dash in it, you know,
would just fill the bill. But look here. We'll take both. Sure—that's
the way out of it. If she don't like the red, she'll like the grey, and
if she don't like the—You like the grey ones, don't you? Then
here”—picking up two pairs of the handsomely embroidered grey
stockings and handing them to the clerk—“One,” holding up his thumb to
denote one—“me,”—a vigorous pounding of the chest signifying me.
“One”—holding up his forefinger and pointing to the
“Oh no—no—no!” cried Virginia, her face instantly the colour of
the condemned stockings. Then, standing straight: “Certainly not.”
“No? Just as you say,” he replied good humouredly. “Like to have you
have 'em. Seems as if strangers in a strange land oughtn't to stand on
The clerk was bending forward holding up the stockings alluringly. “
Pour mademoiselle, n'est-ce-pas?”
“Mais—non!” pronounced Virginia, with emphasis.
There followed an untranslatable gesture. “How droll!” shoulder and
outstretched hands were saying. “If the kind gentleman wishes to
give mademoiselle the joli bas—!”
His face had puckered up again. Then suddenly it unpuckered. “Tell
you what you might do,” he solved it. “Just take 'em along and send
them to your mother. Now your mother might be real glad to have 'em.”
Virginia stared. And then an awful thing happened. What she was
thinking about was the letter she could send with the stockings.
“Mother dear,” she would write, “as I stood at the counter buying
myself some stockings to-day along came a nice man—a stranger to me,
but very kind and jolly—and gave me—”
There it was that the awful thing happened. Her dimple was
showing—and at thought of its showing she could not keep it from
showing! And how could she explain why it was showing without its going
on showing? And how—?
But at that moment her gaze fell upon the clerk, who had taken the
dimple as signal to begin putting the stockings in a box. The
Frenchwoman's eyebrows soon put that dimple in its proper place. “And
so the petite Americaine was not too—oh, not too—“
those French eyebrows were saying.
All in an instant Virginia was something quite different from a
little girl with a dimple. “You are very kind,” she was saying, and her
mother herself could have done it no better, “but I am sure our little
joke had gone quite far enough. I bid you good-morning”. And with that
she walked regally over to the glove counter, leaving red and grey and
black hosiery to their own destinies.
“I loathe them when their eyebrows go up,” she fumed. “Now his
weren't going up—not even in his mind.”
She could not keep from worrying about him. “They'll just 'do' him,”
she was sure. “And then laugh at him in the bargain. A man like that
has no business to be let loose in a store all by himself.”
And sure enough, a half hour later she came upon him up in the dress
department. Three of them had gathered round to “do” him. They were
making rapid headway, their smiling deference scantily concealing their
amused contempt. The spectacle infuriated Virginia. “They just think
they can work us!” she stormed. “They think we're easy. I
suppose they think he's a fool. I just wish they could get him
in a business deal! I just wish—!”
“I can assure you, sir,” the English-speaking manager of the
department was saying, “that this garment is a wonderful value. We are
able to let you have it at so absurdly low a figure because—”
Virginia did not catch why it was they were able to let him have it
at so absurdly low a figure, but she did see him wipe his brow and look
helplessly around. “Poor thing,” she murmured, almost tenderly,
“he doesn't know what to do. He just does need somebody to look
after him.” She stood there looking at his back. He had a back a good
deal like the back of her chum's father at home. Indeed there were
various things about him suggested “home.” Did one want one's own
jeered at? One might see crudities one's self, but was one going to
have supercilious outsiders coughing those sham coughs behind their
“For seven hundred francs,” she heard the suave voice saying.
Seven hundred francs! Virginia's national pride, or, more
accurately, her national rage, was lashed into action. It was with very
red cheeks that the small American stepped stormily to the rescue of
“Seven hundred francs for that?” she jeered, right in the
face of the enraged manager and stiffening clerks. “Seven hundred
francs—indeed! Last year's model—a hideous colour, and ”—picking it
up, running it through her fingers and tossing it contemptuously
“Gee, but I'm grateful to you!” he breathed, again wiping his brow.
“You know, I was a little leery of it myself.”
The manager, quivering with rage and glaring uglily, stepped up to
Virginia. “May I ask—?”
But the fat man stepped in between—he was well qualified for that
position. “Cut it out, partner. The young lady's a friend of mine
—see? She's looking out for me—not you. I don't want your stuff,
anyway.” And taking Virginia serenely by the arm he walked away.
“This was no place to buy dresses,” said she crossly.
“Well, I wish I knew where the places were to buy things,” he
replied, humbly, forlornly.
“Well, what do you want to buy?” demanded she, still crossly.
“Why, I want to buy some nice things for my wife. Something the real
thing from Paris, you know. I came over from London on purpose. But
Lord,”—again wiping his brow—“a fellow doesn't know where to go.”
“Oh well,” sighed Virginia, long-sufferingly, “I see I'll just have
to take you. There doesn't seem any way out of it. It's evident you
can't go alone. Seven hundred francs!”
“I suppose it was too much,” he conceded meekly. “I tell you I
will be grateful if you'll just stay by me a little while. I never
felt so up against it in all my life.”
“Now, a very nice thing to take one's wife from Paris,” began
Virginia didactically, when they reached the sidewalk, “is lace.”
“L—ace? Um! Y—es, I suppose lace is all right. Still it never
struck me there was anything so very lively looking about lace.”
“'Lively looking' is not the final word in wearing apparel,”
pronounced Virginia in teacher-to-pupil manner. “Lace is always in good
taste, never goes out of style, and all women care for it. I will take
you to one of the lace shops.”
“Very well,” acquiesced he, truly chastened. “Here, let's get in
Virginia rode across the Seine looking like one pondering the
destinies of nations. Her companion turned several times to address
her, but it would have been as easy for a soldier to slap a general on
the back. Finally she turned to him.
“Now when we get there,” she instructed, “don't seem at all
interested in things. Act—oh, bored, you know, and seeming to want to
get me away. And when they tell the price, no matter what they say,
just—well sort of groan and hold your head and act as though you are
absolutely overcome at the thought of such an outrage.”
“U—m. You have to do that here to get—lace?”
“You have to do that here to get anything—-at the price you
should get it. You, and people who go shopping the way you do, bring
discredit upon the entire American nation.”
“That so? Sorry. Never meant to do that. All right, Young Lady, I'll
do the best I can. Never did act that way, but suppose I can, if the
rest of them do.”
“Groan and hold my head,” she heard him murmuring as they entered
He proved an apt pupil. It may indeed be set down that his aptitude
was their undoing. They had no sooner entered the shop than he pulled
out his watch and uttered an exclamation of horror at the sight of the
time. Virginia could scarcely look at the lace, so insistently did he
keep waving the watch before her. His contempt for everything shown was
open and emphatic. It was also articulate. Virginia grew nervous,
seeing the real red showing through in the Frenchwoman's cheeks. And
when the price was at last named—a price which made Virginia
jubilant—there burst upon her outraged ears something between a jeer
and a howl of rage, the whole of it terrifyingly done in the form of a
groan; she looked at her companion to see him holding up his hands and
wobbling his head as though it had been suddenly loosened from his
spine, cast one look at the Frenchwoman—then fled, followed by her
“I didn't mean you to act like that!” she stormed.
“Why, I did just what you told me to! Seemed to me I was following
directions to the letter. Don't think for a minute I'm going to
bring discredit on the American nation! Not a bad scheme—taking out my
watch that way, was it?”
“Oh, beautiful scheme. I presume you notice, however, that we
have no lace.”
They walked half a block in silence. “Now I'll take you to another
shop,” she then volunteered, in a turning the other cheek fashion, “and
here please do nothing at all. Please just—sit.”
“Sort of as if I was feeble-minded, eh?”
“Oh, don't try to look feeble-minded,” she begged, alarmed at
seeming to suggest any more parts; “just sit there—as if you were
thinking of something very far away.”
“Say, Young Lady, look here; this is very nice, being put on to the
tricks of the trade, but the money end of it isn't cutting much ice,
and isn't there any way you can just buy things—the way you do
in Cincinnati? Can't you get their stuff without making a comic opera
out of it?”
“No, you can't,” spoke relentless Virginia; “not unless you want
them to laugh and say 'Aren't Americans fools?' the minute the door is
“Fools—eh? I'll show them a thing or two!”
“Oh, please show them nothing here! Please just—sit.”
While employing her wiles to get for three hundred and fifty francs
a yoke and scarf aggregating four hundred, she chanced to look at her
American friend. Then she walked rapidly to the rear of the shop,
buried her face in her handkerchief, and seemed making heroic efforts
to sneeze. Once more he was following directions to the letter. Chin
resting on hands, hands resting on stick, the huge American had taken
on the beatific expression of a seventeen-year-old girl thinking of
something “very far away.” Virginia was long in mastering the sneeze.
On the sidewalk she presented him with the package of lace and also
with what she regarded the proper thing in the way of farewell speech.
She supposed it was hard for a man to go shopping alone; she
could see how hard it would be for her own father; indeed it was seeing
how difficult it would be for her father had impelled her to go with
him, a stranger. She trusted his wife would like the lace; she thought
it very nice, and a bargain. She was glad to have been of service to a
fellow countryman who seemed in so difficult a position.
But he did not look as impressed as one to whom a farewell speech
was being made should look. In fact, he did not seem to be hearing it.
Once more, and in earnest this time, he appeared to be thinking of
something very far away. Then all at once he came back, and it was in
anything but a far-away voice he began, briskly: “Now look here, Young
Lady, I don't doubt but this lace is great stuff. You say so, and I
haven't seen man, woman or child on this side of the Atlantic knows as
much as you do. I'm mighty grateful for the lace—don't you forget
that, but just the same—well, now I'll tell you. I have a very special
reason for wanting something a little livelier than lace. Something
that seems to have Paris written on it in red letters—see? Now, where
do you get the kind of hats you see some folks wearing, and where do
you get the dresses—well, it's hard to describe 'em, but the kind they
have in pictures marked 'Breezes from Paris'? You see—S-ay!—
what do you think of that?“
“That” was in a window across the street. It was an opera cloak. He
walked toward it, Virginia following. “Now there,” he turned to
her, his large round face all aglow, “is what I want.”
It was yellow; it was long; it was billowy; it was insistently and
“That's the ticket!” he gloated.
“Of course,” began Virginia, “I don't know anything about it. I am
in a very strange position, not knowing what your wife likes or—or
has. This is the kind of thing everything has to go with or one
“Sure! Good idea. We'll just get everything to go with it.”
“It's the sort of thing one doesn't see worn much outside of
Paris—or New York. If one is—now my mother wouldn't care for that
coat at all.” Virginia took no little pride in that tactful finish.
“Can't sidetrack me!” he beamed. “I want it. Very thing I'm
after, Young Lady.”
“Well, of course you will have no difficulty in buying the coat
without me,” said she, as a dignified version of “I wash my hands of
you.” “You can do here as you said you wished to do, simply go in and
pay what they ask. There would be no use trying to get it cheap. They
would know that anyone who wanted it would”—she wanted to say “have
more money than they knew what to do with,” but contented herself with,
“be able to pay for it.”
But when she had finished she looked at him; at first she thought
she wanted to laugh, and then it seemed that wasn't what she wanted to
do after all. It was like saying to a small boy who was one beam over
finding a tin horn: “Oh well, take the horn if you want to, but you
can't haul your little red waggon while you're blowing the horn.” There
seemed something peculiarly inhuman about taking the waggon just when
he had found the horn. Now if the waggon were broken, then to take away
the horn would leave the luxury of grief. But let not shadows fall upon
With the full ardour of her femininity she entered into the
purchasing of the yellow opera cloak. They paid for that decorative
garment the sum of two thousand five hundred francs. It seemed it was
embroidered, and the lining was—anyway, they paid it.
And they took it with them. He was going to “take no chances on
losing it.” He was leaving Paris that night and held that during his
stay he had been none too impressed with either Parisian speed or
Then they bought some “Breezes from Paris,” a dress that would “go
with” the coat. It was violet velvet, and contributed to the sense of
doing one's uttermost; and hats—“the kind you see some folks wearing.”
One was the rainbow done into flowers, and the other the kind of black
hat to outdo any rainbow. “If you could just give me some idea what
type your wife is,” Virginia was saying, from beneath the willow
plumes. “Now you see this hat quite overpowers me. Do you think it will
“Guess not. Anyway, if it don't look right on her head she may enjoy
having it around to look at.”
Virginia stared out at him. The oddest man! As if a hat were
any good at all if it didn't look right on one's head!
Upon investigation—though yielding to his taste she was still
vigilant as to his interests—Virginia discovered a flaw in one of the
plumes. The sylph in the trailing gown held volubly that it did not
fait rien; the man with the open purse said he couldn't see that it
figured much, but the small American held firm. That must be replaced
by a perfect plume or they would not take the hat. And when she saw who
was in command the sylph as volubly acquiesced that naturellement
it must be tout a fait perfect. She would send out and get one
that would be oh! so, so, so perfect. It would take half an
“Tell you what we'll do,” Virginia's friend proposed, opera cloak
tight under one arm, velvet gown as tight under the other, “I'm
tired—hungry—thirsty; feel like a ham sandwich—and something. I'm
playing you out, too. Let's go out and get a bite and come back for the
so, so, so perfect hat.”
She hesitated. But he had the door open, and if he stood holding it
that way much longer he was bound to drop the violet velvet gown. She
did not want him to drop the velvet gown and furthermore, she would
like a cup of tea. There came into her mind a fortifying thought about
the relative deaths of sheep and lambs. If to be killed for the sheep
were indeed no worse than being killed for the lamb, and if a cup of
tea went with the sheep and nothing at all with the lamb—?
So she agreed. “There's a nice little tea-shop right round the
corner. We girls often go there.”
“Tea? Like tea? All right, then”—and he started manfully on.
But as she entered the tea-shop she was filled with keen sense of
the desirableness of being slain for the lesser animal. For, cosily
installed in their favourite corner, were “the girls.”
Virginia had explained to these friends some three hours before that
she could not go with them that afternoon as she must attend a musicale
some friends of her mother's were giving. Being friends of her
mother's, she expatiated, she would have to go.
Recollecting this, also for the first time remembering the musicale,
she bowed with the hauteur of self-consciousness.
Right there her friend contributed to the tragedy of a sheep's death
by dropping the yellow opera cloak. While he was stooping to pick it up
the violet velvet gown slid backward and Virginia had to steady it
until he could regain position. The staring in the corner gave way to
tittering—and no dying sheep had ever held its head more haughtily.
The death of this particular sheep proved long and painful. The legs
of Virginia's friend and the legs of the tea-table did not seem well
adapted to each other. He towered like a human mountain over the dainty
thing, twisting now this way and now that. It seemed Providence—or at
least so much of it as was represented by the management of that
shop—had never meant fat people to drink tea. The table was rendered
further out of proportion by having a large box piled on either side of
Expansively, and not softly, he discoursed of these things. What did
they think a fellow was to do with his knees? Didn't they sell
tea enough to afford any decent chairs? Did all these women pretend to
really like tea?
Virginia's sense of humour rallied somewhat as she viewed him eating
the sandwiches. Once she had called them doll-baby sandwiches; now that
seemed literal: tea-cups, petit gateau, the whole service gave
the fancy of his sitting down to a tea-party given by a little girl for
But after a time he fell silent, looking around the room. And when
he broke that pause his voice was different.
“These women here, all dressed so fine, nothing to do but sit around
and eat this folderol, they have it easy—don't they?”
The bitterness in it, and a faint note of wistfulness, puzzled her.
Certainly he had money.
“And the husbands of these women,” he went on; “lots of 'em, I
suppose, didn't always have so much. Maybe some of these women helped
out in the early days when things weren't so easy. Wonder if the men
ever think how lucky they are to be able to get it back at 'em?”
She grew more bewildered. Wasn't he “getting it back?” The money he
had been spending that day!
“Young Lady,” he said abruptly, “you must think I'm a queer one.”
She murmured feeble protest.
“Yes, you must. Must wonder what I want with all this stuff, don't
“Why, it's for your wife, isn't it?” she asked, startled.
“Oh yes, but you must wonder. You're a shrewd one, Young Lady;
judging the thing by me, you must wonder.”
Virginia was glad she was not compelled to state her theory. Loud
and common and impossible were terms which had presented themselves,
terms which she had fought with kind and good-natured and generous.
Their purchases she had decided were to be used, not for a knock, but
as a crashing pound at the door of the society of his town. For her
part, Virginia hoped the door would come down.
“And if you knew that probably this stuff would never be worn at
all, that ten to one it would never do anything more than lie round on
chairs—then you would think I was queer, wouldn't you?”
She was forced to admit that that would seem rather strange.
“Young Lady, I believe I'll tell you about it. Never do talk about
it to hardly anybody, but I feel as if you and I were pretty well
acquainted—we've been through so much together.”
She smiled at him warmly; there was something so real about him when
he talked that way.
But his look then frightened her. It seemed for an instant as though
he would brush the tiny table aside and seize some invisible thing by
the throat. Then he said, cutting off each word short: “Young Lady,
what do you think of this? I'm worth more 'an a million dollars—and my
wife gets up at five o'clock every morning to do washing and
“Oh, it's not that she has to,” he answered her look, “but
she thinks she has to. See? Once we were poor. For twenty years
we were poor as dirt. Then she did have to do things like that. Then I
struck it. Or rather, it struck me. Oil. Oil on a bit of land I had. I
had just sense enough to make the most of it; one thing led to
another—well, you're not interested in that end of it. But the fact is
that now we're rich. Now she could have all the things that these women
have—Lord A'mighty she could lay abed every day till noon if she
wanted to! But—you see?—it got her—those hard, lonely,
grinding years took her. She's”—he shrunk from the terrible
word and faltered out—“her mind's not—”
There was a sobbing little flutter in Virginia's throat. In a dim
way she was glad to see that the girls were going. She could not
have them laughing at him—now.
“Well, you can about figure out how it makes me feel,” he continued,
and looking into his face now it was as though the spirit redeemed the
flesh. “You're smart. You can see it without my callin' your attention
to it. Last time I went to see her I had just made fifty thousand on a
deal. And I found her down on her knees thinking she was scrubbing the
Unconsciously Virginia's hand went out, following the rush of
sympathy and understanding. “But can't they—restrain her?” she
“Makes her worse. Says she's got it to do—frets her to think she's
not getting it done.”
“But isn't there some way?” she whispered. “Some way to make
He pointed to the large boxes. “That,” he said simply, “is the
meaning of those. It's been seven years—but I keep on trying.”
She was silent, the tears too close for words. And she had thought
it cheap ambition!—vulgar aspiration—silly show—vanity!
“Suppose you thought I was a queer one, talking about lively looking
things. But you see now? Thought it might attract her attention,
thought something real gorgeous like this might impress money on her.
Though I don't know,”—he seemed to grow weary as he told it; “I got
her a lot of diamonds, thinking they might interest her, and she
thought she'd stolen 'em, and they had to take them away.”
Still the girl did not speak. Her hand was shading her eyes.
“But there's nothing like trying. Nothing like keeping right on
trying. And anyhow—a fellow likes to think he's taking his wife
something from Paris.”
They passed before her in their heartbreaking folly, their tragic
uselessness, their lovable absurdity and stinging irony—those things
they had bought that afternoon: an opera cloak—a velvet
dress—those hats—red silk stockings.
The mockery of them wrung her heart. Right there in the tea-shop
Virginia was softly crying.
“Oh, now that's too bad,” he expostulated clumsily. “Why, look here,
Young Lady, I didn't mean you to take it so hard.”
When she had recovered herself he told her much of the story. And
the thing which revealed him—glorified him—was less the grief he gave
to it than the way he saw it. “It's the cursed unfairness of it,” he
concluded. “When you consider it's all because she did those
things—when you think of her bein' bound to 'em for life just because
she was too faithful doin' 'em—when you think that now—when I
could give her everything these women have got!—she's got to go right
on worrying about baking the bread and washing the dishes—did it for
me when I was poor—and now with me rich she can't get out of
it—and I can't reach her—oh, it's rotten! I tell you
it's rotten! Sometimes I can just hear my money laugh at
me! Sometimes I get to going round and round in a circle about it till
it seems I'm going crazy myself.”
“I think you are a—a noble man,” choked Virginia.
That disconcerted him. “Oh Lord—don't think that. No, Young Lady,
don't try to make any plaster saint out of me. My life goes on.
I've got to eat, drink and be merry. I'm built that way. But just the
same my heart on the inside's pretty sore, Young Lady. I want to tell
you that the whole inside of my heart is sore as a boil!”
They were returning for the hats. Suddenly Virginia stopped, and it
was a soft-eyed and gentle Virginia who turned to him after the pause.
“There are lovely things to be bought in Paris for women who aren't
well. Such soft, lovely things to wear in your room. Not but what I
think these other things are all right. As you say, they may—interest
her. But they aren't things she can use just now, and wouldn't you like
her to have some of those soft lovely things she could actually wear?
They might help most of all. To wake in the morning and find herself in
something so beautiful—”
“Where do you get 'em?” he demanded promptly.
And so they went to one of those shops which have, more than all the
others, enshrined Paris in feminine hearts. And never was lingerie
selected with more loving care than that which Virginia picked out that
afternoon. A tear fell on one particularly lovely robe de nuit
—so soothingly soft, so caressingly luxurious, it seemed that surely it
might help bring release from the bondage of those crushing years.
As they were leaving they were given two packages. “Just the kimona
thing you liked,” he said, “and a trinket or two. Now that we're such
good friends, you won't feel like you did this morning.”
“And if I don't want them myself, I might send them to my mother,”
Virginia replied, a quiver in her laugh at her own little joke.
He had put her in her cab; he had tried to tell her how much he
thanked her; they had said good-bye and the cocher had cracked
his whip when he came running after her. “Why, Young Lady,” he called
out, “we don't know each other's names.”
She laughed and gave hers. “Mine's William P. Johnson,” he said.
“Part French and part Italian. But now look here, Young Lady—or I
mean, Miss Clayton. A fellow at the hotel was telling me something last
night that made me sick. He said American girls sometimes got
awfully up against it here. He said one actually starved last year.
Now, I don't like that kind of business. Look here, Young Lady, I want
you to promise that if you—you or any of your gang—get up against it
you'll cable William P. Johnson, of Cincinnati, Ohio.”
The twilight grey had stolen upon Paris. And there was a mist which
the street lights only penetrated a little way—as sometimes one's
knowledge of life may only penetrate life a very little way. Her cab
stopped by a blockade, she watched the burly back of William P. Johnson
disappearing into the mist. The red box which held the yellow opera
cloak she could see longer than all else.
“You never can tell,” murmured Virginia. “It just goes to show that
you never can tell.”
And whatever it was you never could tell had brought to Virginia's
girlish face the tender knowingness of the face of a woman.
II. THE PLEA
Senator Harrison concluded his argument and sat down. There was no
applause, but he had expected none. Senator Dorman was already saying
“Mr. President?” and there was a stir in the crowded galleries, and an
anticipatory moving of chairs among the Senators. In the press gallery
the reporters bunched together their scattered papers and inspected
their pencil-points with earnestness. Dorman was the best speaker of
the Senate, and he was on the popular side of it. It would be the great
speech of the session, and the prospect was cheering after a deluge of
railroad and insurance bills.
“I want to tell you,” he began, “why I have worked for this
resolution recommending the pardon of Alfred Williams. It is one of the
great laws of the universe that every living thing be given a chance.
In the case before us that law has been violated. This does not resolve
itself into a question of second chances. The boy of whom we are
speaking has never had his first.”
Senator Harrison swung his chair half-way around and looked out at
the green things which were again coming into their own on the
State-house grounds. He knew—in substance—what Senator Dorman would
say without hearing it, and he was a little tired of the whole affair.
He hoped that one way or other they would finish it up that night, and
go ahead with something else. He had done what he could, and now the
responsibility was with the rest of them. He thought they were
shouldering a great deal to advocate the pardon in the face of the
united opposition of Johnson County, where the crime had been
committed. It seemed a community should be the best judge of its own
crimes, and that was what he, as the Senator from Johnson, had tried to
impress upon them.
He knew that his argument against the boy had been a strong one. He
rather liked the attitude in which he stood. It seemed as if he were
the incarnation of outraged justice attempting to hold its own at the
floodgates of emotion. He liked to think he was looking far beyond the
present and the specific and acting as guardian of the future—and the
whole. In summing it up that night the reporters would tell in highly
wrought fashion of the moving appeal made by Senator Dorman, and then
they would speak dispassionately of the logical argument of the leader
of the opposition. There was more satisfaction to self in logic than in
mere eloquence. He was even a little proud of his unpopularity. It
He wondered why it was Senator Dorman had thrown himself into it so
whole-heartedly. All during the session the Senator from Maxwell had
neglected personal interests in behalf of this boy, who was nothing to
him in the world. He supposed it was as a sociological and
psychological experiment. Senator Dorman had promised the Governor to
assume guardianship of the boy if he were let out. The Senator from
Johnson inferred that as a student of social science his eloquent
colleague wanted to see what he could make of him. To suppose the
interest merely personal and sympathetic would seem discreditable.
“I need not dwell upon the story,” the Senator from Maxwell was
saying, “for you all are familiar with it already. It is said to have
been the most awful crime ever committed in the State. I grant you that
it was, and then I ask you to look for a minute into the conditions
leading up to it.
“When the boy was born, his mother was instituting divorce
proceedings against his father. She obtained the divorce, and remarried
when Alfred was three months old. From the time he was a mere baby she
taught him to hate his father. Everything that went wrong with him she
told him was his father's fault. His first vivid impression was that
his father was responsible for all the wrong of the universe.
“For seven years that went on, and then his mother died. His
stepfather did not want him. He was going to Missouri, and the boy
would be a useless expense and a bother. He made no attempt to find a
home for him; he did not even explain—he merely went away and left
him. At the age of seven the boy was turned out on the world, after
having been taught one thing—to hate his father. He stayed a few days
in the barren house, and then new tenants came and closed the doors
against him. It may have occurred to him as a little strange that he
had been sent into a world where there was no place for him.
“When he asked the neighbours for shelter, they told him to go to
his own father and not bother strangers. He said he did not know where
his father was. They told him, and he started to walk—a distance of
fifty miles. I ask you to bear in mind, gentlemen, that he was only
seven years of age. It is the age when the average boy is beginning the
third reader, and when he is shooting marbles and spinning tops.
“When he reached his father's house he was told at once that he was
not wanted there. The man had remarried, there were other children, and
he had no place for Alfred. He turned him away; but the neighbours
protested, and he was compelled to take him back. For four years he
lived in this home, to which he had come unbidden, and where he was
never made welcome.
“The whole family rebelled against him. The father satisfied his
resentment against the boy's dead mother by beating her son, by
encouraging his wife to abuse him, and inspiring the other children to
despise him. It seems impossible such conditions should exist. The only
proof of their possibility lies in the fact of their existence.
“I need not go into the details of the crime. He had been beaten by
his father that evening after a quarrel with his stepmother about
spilling the milk. He went, as usual, to his bed in the barn; but the
hay was suffocating, his head ached, and he could not sleep. He arose
in the middle of the night, went to the house, and killed both his
father and stepmother.
“I shall not pretend to say what thoughts surged through the boy's
brain as he lay there in the stifling hay with the hot blood pounding
against his temples. I shall not pretend to say whether he was sane or
insane as he walked to the house for the perpetration of the awful
crime. I do not even affirm it would not have happened had there been
some human being there to lay a cooling hand on his hot forehead, and
say a few soothing, loving words to take the sting from the loneliness,
and ease the suffering. I ask you to consider only one thing: he was
eleven years old at the time, and he had no friend in all the world. He
knew nothing of sympathy; he knew only injustice.”
Senator Harrison was still looking out at the budding things on the
State-house grounds, but in a vague way he was following the story. He
knew when the Senator from Maxwell completed the recital of facts and
entered upon his plea. He was conscious that it was stronger than he
had anticipated—more logic and less empty exhortation. He was telling
of the boy's life in reformatory and penitentiary since the commission
of the crime,—of how he had expanded under kindness, of his mental
attainments, the letters he could write, the books he had read, the
hopes he cherished. In the twelve years he had spent there he had been
known to do no unkind nor mean thing; he responded to affection—craved
it. It was not the record of a degenerate, the Senator from Maxwell was
A great many things were passing through the mind of the Senator
from Johnson. He was trying to think who it was that wrote that book,
“Put Yourself in His Place.” He had read it once, and it bothered him
to forget names. Then he was wondering why it was the philosophers had
not more to say about the incongruity of people who had never had any
trouble of their own sitting in judgment upon people who had known
nothing but trouble. He was thinking also that abstract rules did not
always fit smoothly over concrete cases, and that it was hard to make
life a matter of rules, anyway.
Next he was wondering how it would have been with the boy Alfred
Williams if he had been born in Charles Harrison's place; and then he
was working it out the other way and wondering how it would have been
with Charles Harrison had he been born in Alfred Williams's place. He
wondered whether the idea of murder would have grown in Alfred
Williams's heart had he been born to the things to which Charles
Harrison was born, and whether it would have come within the range of
possibility for Charles Harrison to murder his father if he had been
born to Alfred Williams's lot. Putting it that way, it was hard to
estimate how much of it was the boy himself, and how much the place the
world had prepared for him. And if it was the place prepared for him
more than the boy, why was the fault not more with the preparers of the
place than with the occupant of it? The whole thing was very confusing.
“This page,” the Senator from Maxwell was saying, lifting the little
fellow to the desk, “is just eleven years of age, and he is within
three pounds of Alfred Williams's weight when he committed the murder.
I ask you, gentlemen, if this little fellow should be guilty of a like
crime to-night, to what extent would you, in reading of it in the
morning, charge him with the moral discernment which is the first
condition of moral responsibility? If Alfred Williams's story were this
boy's story, would you deplore that there had been no one to check the
childish passion, or would you say it was the inborn instinct of the
murderer? And suppose again this were Alfred Williams at the age of
eleven, would you not be willing to look into the future and say if he
spent twelve years in penitentiary and reformatory, in which time he
developed the qualities of useful and honourable citizenship, that the
ends of justice would then have been met, and the time at hand for the
world to begin the payment of her debt?”
Senator Harrison's eyes were fixed upon the page standing on the
opposite desk. Eleven was a younger age than he had supposed. As he
looked back upon it and recalled himself when eleven years of age—his
irresponsibility, his dependence—he was unwilling to say what would
have happened if the world had turned upon him as it had upon Alfred
Williams. At eleven his greatest grievance was that the boys at school
called him “yellow-top.” He remembered throwing a rock at one of them
for doing it. He wondered if it was criminal instinct prompted the
throwing of the rock. He wondered how high the percentage of children's
crimes would go were it not for countermanding influences. It seemed
the great difference between Alfred Williams and a number of other
children of eleven had been the absence of the countermanding
There came to him of a sudden a new and moving thought. Alfred
Williams had been cheated of his boyhood. The chances were he had never
gone swimming, nor to a ball game, or maybe never to a circus. It might
even be that he had never owned a dog. The Senator from Maxwell was
right when he said the boy had never been given his chance, had been
defrauded of that which has been a boy's heritage since the world
itself was young.
And the later years—how were they making it up to him? He recalled
what to him was the most awful thing he had ever heard about the State
penitentiary: they never saw the sun rise down there, and they never
saw it set. They saw it at its meridian, when it climbed above the
stockade, but as it rose into the day, and as it sank into the night,
it was denied them. And there, at the penitentiary, they could not even
look up at the stars. It had been years since Alfred Williams raised
his face to God's heaven and knew he was part of it all. The voices of
the night could not penetrate the little cell in the heart of the
mammoth stone building where he spent his evenings over those
masterpieces with which, they said, he was more familiar than the
average member of the Senate. When he read those things Victor Hugo
said of the vastness of the night, he could only look around at the
walls that enclosed him and try to reach back over the twelve years for
some satisfying conception of what night really was.
The Senator from Johnson shuddered: they had taken from a living
creature the things of life, and all because in the crucial hour there
had been no one to say a staying word. Man had cheated him of the
things that were man's, and then shut him away from the world that was
God's. They had made for him a life barren of compensations.
There swept over the Senator a great feeling of self-pity. As
representative of Johnson County, it was he who must deny this boy the
whole great world without, the people who wanted to help him, and what
the Senator from Maxwell called “his chance.” If Johnson County carried
the day, there would be something unpleasant for him to consider all
the remainder of his life. As he grew to be an older man he would think
of it more and more—what the boy would have done for himself in the
world if the Senator from Johnson had not been more logical and more
powerful than the Senator from Maxwell.
Senator Dorman was nearing the end of his argument. “In spite of the
undying prejudice of the people of Johnson County,” he was saying, “I
can stand before you today and say that after an unsparing
investigation of this case I do not believe I am asking you to do
anything in violation of justice when I beg of you to give this boy his
It was going to a vote at once, and the Senator from Johnson County
looked out at the budding things and wondered whether the boy down at
the penitentiary knew the Senate was considering his case that
afternoon. It was without vanity he wondered whether what he had been
trained to think of as an all-wise providence would not have preferred
that Johnson County be represented that session by a less able man.
A great hush fell over the Chamber, for ayes and noes followed
almost in alternation. After a long minute of waiting the secretary
called, in a tense voice:
“Ayes, 30; Noes, 32.”
The Senator from Johnson had proven too faithful a servant of his
constituents. The boy in the penitentiary was denied his chance.
The usual things happened: some women in the galleries, who had boys
at home, cried aloud; the reporters were fighting for occupancy of the
telephone booths, and most of the Senators began the perusal of the
previous day's Journal with elaborate interest. Senator Dorman indulged
in none of these feints. A full look at his face just then told how
much of his soul had gone into the fight for the boy's chance, and the
look about his eyes was a little hard on the theory of psychological
Senator Harrison was looking out at the budding trees, but his face
too had grown strange, and he seemed to be looking miles beyond and
years ahead. It seemed that he himself was surrendering the voices of
the night, and the comings and goings of the sun. He would never look
at them—feel them—again without remembering he was keeping one of his
fellow creatures away from them. He wondered at his own presumption in
denying any living thing participation in the universe. And all the
while there were before him visions of the boy who sat in the cramped
cell with the volume of a favourite poet before him, trying to think
how it would seem to be out under the stars.
The stillness in the Senate-Chamber was breaking; they were going
ahead with something else. It seemed to the Senator from Johnson that
sun, moon, and stars were wailing out protest for the boy who wanted to
know them better. And yet it was not sun, moon, and stars so much as
the unused swimming hole and the uncaught fish, the unattended ball
game, the never-seen circus, and, above all, the unowned dog, that
brought Senator Harrison to his feet.
They looked at him in astonishment, their faces seeming to say it
would have been in better taste for him to have remained seated just
“Mr. President,” he said, pulling at his collar and looking straight
ahead, “I rise to move a reconsideration.”
There was a gasp, a moment of supreme quiet, and then a mighty burst
of applause. To men of all parties and factions there came a single
thought. Johnson was the leading county of its Congressional district.
There was an election that fall, and Harrison was in the race. Those
eight words meant to a surety he would not go to Washington, for the
Senator from Maxwell had chosen the right word when he referred to the
prejudice of Johnson County on the Williams case as “undying.” The
world throbs with such things at the moment of their doing—even though
condemning them later, and the part of the world then packed within the
Senate-Chamber shared the universal disposition.
The noise astonished Senator Harrison, and he looked around with
something like resentment. When the tumult at last subsided, and he saw
that he was expected to make a speech, he grew very red, and grasped
his chair desperately.
The reporters were back in their places, leaning nervously forward.
This was Senator Harrison's chance to say something worth putting into
a panel by itself with black lines around it—and they were sure he
would do it.
But he did not. He stood there like a schoolboy who had forgotten
his piece—growing more and more red. “I—I think,” he finally jerked
out, “that some of us have been mistaken. I'm in favour now of—of
giving him his chance.”
They waited for him to proceed, but after a helpless look around the
Chamber he sat down. The president of the Senate waited several minutes
for him to rise again, but he at last turned his chair around and
looked out at the green things on the State-house grounds, and there
was nothing to do but go ahead with the second calling of the roll.
This time it stood 50 to 12 in favour of the boy.
A motion to adjourn immediately followed—no one wanted to do
anything more that afternoon. They all wanted to say things to the
Senator from Johnson; but his face had grown cold, and as they were
usually afraid of him, anyhow, they kept away. All but Senator
Dorman—it meant too much with him. “Do you mind my telling you,” he
said, tensely, “that it was as fine a thing as I have ever known a man
The Senator from Johnson moved impatiently. “You think it 'fine,'“
he asked, almost resentfully, “to be a coward?”
“Coward?” cried the other man. “Well, that's scarcely the word. It
“Oh no,” said Senator Harrison, and he spoke wearily, “it was a
clear case of cowardice. You see,” he laughed, “I was afraid it might
haunt me when I am seventy.”
Senator Dorman started eagerly to speak, but the other man stopped
him and passed on. He was seeing it as his constituency would see it,
and it humiliated him. They would say he had not the courage of his
convictions, that he was afraid of the unpopularity, that his judgment
had fallen victim to the eloquence of the Senator from Maxwell.
But when he left the building and came out into the softness of the
April afternoon it began to seem different. After all, it was not he
alone who leaned to the softer side. There were the trees—they were
permitted another chance to bud; there were the birds—they were
allowed another chance to sing; there was the earth—to it was given
another chance to yield. There stole over him a tranquil sense of
unison with Life.
III. FOR LOVE OF THE HILLS
“Sure you're done with it?”
“Oh, yes,” replied the girl, the suggestion of a smile on her face,
and in her voice the suggestion of a tear. “Yes; I was just going.”
But she did not go. She turned instead to the end of the alcove and
sat down before a table placed by the window. Leaning her elbows upon
it she looked about her through a blur of tears.
Seen through her own eyes of longing, it seemed that almost all of
the people whom she could see standing before the files of the daily
papers were homesick. The reading-room had been a strange study to her
during those weeks spent in fruitless search for the work she wanted to
do, and it had likewise proved a strange comfort. When tired and
disconsolate and utterly sick at heart there was always one thing she
could do—she could go down to the library and look at the paper from
home. It was not that she wanted the actual news of Denver. She did not
care in any vital way what the city officials were doing, what
buildings were going up, or who was leaving town. She was only
indifferently interested in the fires and the murders. She wanted the
comforting companionship of that paper from home.
It seemed there were many to whom the papers offered that same
sympathy, companionship, whatever it might be. More than anything else
it perhaps gave to them—the searchers, drifters—a sense of anchorage.
She would not soon forget the day she herself had stumbled in there and
found the home paper. Chicago had given her nothing but rebuffs that
day, and in desperation, just because she must go somewhere, and did
not want to go back to her boarding-place, she had hunted out the city
library. It was when walking listlessly about in the big reading-room
it had occurred to her that perhaps she could find the paper from home;
and after that when things were their worst, when her throat grew tight
and her eyes dim, she could always comfort herself by saying: “After a
while I'll run down and look at the paper.”
But to-night it had failed her. It was not the paper from home
to-night; it was just a newspaper. It did not inspire the belief that
things would be better to-morrow, that it must all come right soon. It
left her as she had come—-heavy with the consciousness that in her
purse was eleven dollars, and that that was every cent she had in the
It was hard to hold back the tears as she dwelt upon the fact that
it was very little she had asked of Chicago. She had asked only a
chance to do the work for which she was trained, in order that she
might go to the art classes at night. She had read in the papers of
that mighty young city of the Middle West—the heart of the
continent—of its brawn and its brain and its grit. She had supposed
that Chicago, of all places, would appreciate what she wanted to do.
The day she drew her hard-earned one hundred dollars from the bank in
Denver—how the sun had shone that day in Denver, how clear the sky had
been, and how bracing the air!—she had quite taken it for granted that
her future was assured. And now, after tasting for three weeks the
cruelty of indifference, she looked back to those visions with a hard
She rose to go, and in so doing her eyes fell upon the queer little
woman to whom she had yielded her place before the Denver paper.
Submerged as she had been in her own desolation she had given no heed
to the small figure which came slipping along beside her beyond the
bare thought that she was queer-looking. But as her eyes rested upon
her now there was something about the woman which held her.
She was a strange little figure. An old-fashioned shawl was pinned
tightly about her shoulders, and she was wearing a queer, rusty little
bonnet. Her hair was rolled up in a small knot at the back of her head.
She did not look as though she belonged in Chicago. And then, as the
girl stood there looking at her, she saw the thin shoulders quiver, and
after a minute the head that was wearing the rusty bonnet went down
into the folds of the Denver paper.
The girl's own eyes filled, and she turned to go. It seemed she
could scarcely bear her own unhappiness that day, without coming close
to the heartache of another. But when she reached the end of the alcove
she glanced back, and the sight of that shabby, bent figure, all alone
before the Denver paper, was not to be withstood.
“I am from Colorado, too,” she said softly, laying a hand upon the
The woman looked up at that and took the girl's hand in both of her
thin, trembling ones. It was a wan and a troubled face she lifted, and
there was something about the eyes which would not seem to have been
left there by tears alone.
“And do you have a pining for the mountains?” she whispered, with a
timid eagerness. “Do you have a feeling that you want to see the sun go
down behind them tonight and that you want to see the darkness come
stealing up to the tops?”
The girl half turned away, but she pressed the woman's hand tightly
in hers. “I know what you mean,” she murmured.
“I wanted to see it so bad,” continued the woman, tremulously, “that
something just drove me here to this paper. I knowed it was here
because my nephew's wife brought me here one day and we come across it.
We took this paper at home for more 'an twenty years. That's why I
come. 'Twas the closest I could get.”
“I know what you mean,” said the girl again, unsteadily.
“And it's the closest I will ever get!” sobbed the woman.
“Oh, don't say that,” protested the girl, brushing away her own
tears, and trying to smile; “you'll go back home some day.”
The woman shook her head. “And if I should,” she said, “even if I
should, 'twill be too late.”
“But it couldn't be too late,” insisted the girl. “The mountains,
you know, will be there forever.”
“The mountains will be there forever,” repeated the woman, musingly;
“yes, but not for me to see.” There was a pause. “You see,”—she said
it quietly—“I'm going blind.”
The girl took a quick step backward, then stretched out two
impulsive hands. “Oh, no, no you're not! Why—the doctors, you know,
they do everything now.”
The woman shook her head. “That's what I thought when I come here.
That's why I come. But I saw the biggest doctor of them all today—they
all say he's the best there is—and he said right out 'twas no use to
do anything. He said 'twas—hopeless.”
Her voice broke on that word. “You see,” she hurried on, “I wouldn't
care so much, seems like I wouldn't care 't all, if I could get there
first! If I could see the sun go down behind them just one night! If I
could see the black shadows come slippin' over 'em just once! And then,
if just one morning—just once!—I could get up and see the sunlight
come a streamin'—oh, you know how it looks! You know what 'tis I want
“Yes; but why can't you? Why not? You won't go—your eyesight will
last until you get back home, won't it?”
“But I can't go back home; not now.”
“Why not?” demanded the girl. “Why can't you go home?”
“Why, there ain't no money, my dear,” she explained, patiently.
“It's a long way off—Colorado is, and there ain't no money. Now,
George—George is my brother-in-law—he got me the money to come; but
you see it took it all to come here, and to pay them doctors with. And
George—he ain't rich, and it pinched him hard for me to come—he says
I'll have to wait until he gets money laid up again, and—well he can't
tell just when 't will be. He'll send it soon as he gets it,” she
hastened to add.
“But what are you going to do in the meantime? It would cost less to
get you home than to keep you here.”
“No, I stay with my nephew here. He's willin' I should stay with him
till I get my money to go home.”
“Yes, but this nephew, can't he get you the money? Doesn't he know,”
she insisted, heatedly, “what it means to you?”
“He's got five children, and not much laid up. And then, he never
seen the mountains. He doesn't know what I mean when I try to tell him
about gettin' there in time. Why, he says there's many a one living
back in the mountains would like to be livin' here. He don't
understand—my nephew don't,” she added, apologetically.
“Well, someone ought to understand!” broke from the girl. “I
understand! But—” she did her best to make it a laugh—“eleven dollars
is every cent I've got in the world!”
“Don't!” implored the woman, as the girl gave up trying to control
the tears. “Now, don't you be botherin'. I didn't mean to make you feel
so bad. My nephew says I ain't reasonable, and maybe I ain't.”
The girl raised her head. “But you are reasonable. I tell
you, you are reasonable!”
“I must be going back,” said the woman, uncertainly. “I'm just
making you feel bad, and it won't do no good. And then they may be
stirred up about me. Emma—Emma's my nephew's wife—left me at the
doctor's office 'cause she had some trading to do, and she was to come
back there for me. And then, as I was sittin' there, the pinin' came
over me so strong it seemed I just must get up and start! And”—-she
smiled wanly—-"this was far as I got.”
“Come over and sit down by this table,” said the girl, impulsively,
“and tell me a little about your home back in the mountains. Wouldn't
you like to?”
The woman nodded gratefully. “Seems most like getting back to them
to find someone that knows about them,” she said, after they had drawn
their chairs up to the table and were sitting there side by side.
The girl put her rounded hand over on the thin, withered one. “Tell
me about it,” she said again.
“Maybe it wouldn't be much interesting to you, my dear. It's just a
common life—mine is. You see, William and I—William was my
husband—we went to Georgetown before it really was any town at all.
Years and years before the railroad went through, we was there. Was you
ever there?” she asked wistfully.
“Oh, very often,” replied the girl. “I love every inch of that
A tear stole down the woman's face. “It's most like being home to
find someone that knows about it,” she whispered.
“Yes, William and I went there when 'twas all new country,” she went
on, after a pause. “We worked hard, and we laid up a little money.
Then, three years ago, William took sick. He was sick for a year, and
we had to live up most of what we'd saved. That's why I ain't got none
now. It ain't that William didn't provide.”
The girl nodded.
“We seen some hard days. But we was always harmonious—William and I
was. And William had a great fondness for the mountains. The night
before he died he made them take him over by the window and he looked
out and watched the darkness come stealin' over the daylight—you know
how it does in them mountains. 'Mother,' he said to me—his voice was
that low I could no more 'an hear what he said—'I'll never see another
sun go down, but I'm thankful I seen this one.'“
She was crying outright now, and the girl did not try to stop her.
“And that's the reason I love the mountains,” she whispered at last.
“It ain't just that they're grand and wonderful to look at. It ain't
just the things them tourists sees to talk about. But the mountains has
always been like a comfortin' friend to me. John and Sarah is buried
there—John and Sarah is my two children that died of fever. And then
William is there—like I just told you. And the mountains was a comfort
to me in all those times of trouble. They're like an old friend. Seems
like they're the best friend I've got on earth.”
“I know what you mean,” said the girl, brokenly. “I know all about
“And you don't think I'm just notional,” she asked wistfully, “in
pinin' to get back while—whilst I can look at them?”
The girl held the old hand tightly in hers with a clasp more
responsive than words.
“It ain't but I'd know they was there. I could feel they was there
all right, but”—her voice sank with the horror of it—“I'm 'fraid I
might forget just how they look!”
“Oh, but you won't,” the girl assured her. “You'll remember just how
“I'm scared of it. I'm scared there might be something I'd forget.
And so I just torment myself thinkin'—'Now do I remember this? Can I
see just how that looks?' That's the way I got to thinkin' up in the
doctor's office, when he told me there was nothing to do, and I was so
worked up it seemed I must get up and start!”
“You must try not to worry about it,” murmured the girl. “You'll
“Well, maybe so. Maybe I will. But that's why I want just one more
look. If I could look once more I'd remember it forever. You see I'd
look to remember it, and I would. And do you know—seems like I
wouldn't mind going blind so much then? When I'd sit facin' them I'd
just say to myself: 'Now I know just how they look. I'm seeing them
just as if I had my eyes!' The doctor says my sight'll just kind of
slip away, and when I look my last look, when it gets dimmer and dimmer
to me, I want the last thing I see to be them mountains where William
and me worked and was so happy! Seems like I can't bear it to have my
sight slip away here in Chicago, where there's nothing I want to look
at! And then to have a little left—to have just a little left!—and to
know I could see if I was there to look—and to know that when I get
there 'twill be—Oh, I'll be rebellious-like here—and I'd be contented
there! I don't want to be complainin'—I don't want to!—but when I've
only got a little left I want it—oh, I want it for them things I want
“You will see them,” insisted the girl passionately. “I'm not going
to believe the world can be so hideous as that!”
“Well, maybe so,” said the woman, rising. “But I don't know where
'twill come from,” she added doubtfully.
She took her back to the doctor's office and left her in the care of
the stolid Emma. “Seems most like I'd been back home,” she said in
parting; and the girl promised to come and see her and talk with her
about the mountains. The woman thought that talking about them would
help her to remember just how they looked.
And then the girl returned to the library. She did not know why she
did so. In truth she scarcely knew she was going there until she found
herself sitting before that same secluded table at which she and the
woman had sat a little while before. For a long time she sat there with
her head in her hands, tears falling upon a pad of yellow paper on the
table before her.
Finally she dried her eyes, opened her purse, and counted her money.
It seemed that out of her great desire, out of her great new need,
there must be more than she had thought. But there was not, and she
folded her hands upon the two five-dollar bills and the one silver
dollar and looked hopelessly about the big room.
She had forgotten her own disappointments, her own loneliness. She
was oblivious to everything in the world now save what seemed the
absolute necessity of getting the woman back to the mountains while she
had eyes to see them.
But what could she do? Again she counted the money. She could make
herself, some way or other, get along without one of the five-dollar
bills, but five dollars would not take one very close to the mountains.
It was at that moment that she saw a man standing before the Denver
paper, and noticed that another man was waiting to take his place. The
one who was reading had a dinner pail in his hand. The clothes of the
other told that he, too, was of the world's workers. It was clear to
the girl that the man at the file was reading the paper from home; and
the man who was ready to take his place looked as if waiting for
something less impersonal than the news of the day.
The idea came upon her with such suddenness, so full born, that it
made her gasp. They—the people who came to read the Denver paper, the
people who loved the mountains and were far from them, the people who
were themselves homesick and full of longing—were the people to
It took her but a minute to act. She put the silver dollar and one
five-dollar bill back in her purse. She clutched the other bill in her
left hand, picked up a pencil, and began to write. She headed the
petition: “To all who know and love the mountains,” and she told the
story with the simpleness of one speaking from the heart, and the
directness of one who speaks to those sure to understand. “And so I
found her here by the Denver paper,” she said, after she had stated the
tragic facts, “because it was the closest she could come to the
mountains. Her heart is not breaking because she is going blind. It is
breaking because she may never again look with seeing eyes upon those
great hills which rise up about her home. We must do it for her simply
because we would wish that, under like circumstances, someone would do
it for us. She belongs to us because we understand.
“If you can only give fifty cents, please do not hold it back
because it seems but little. Fifty cents will take her twenty miles
nearer home—twenty miles closer to the things upon which she longs
that her last seeing glance may fall.”
After she had written it she rose, and, the five-dollar bill in one
hand, the sheets of yellow paper in the other, walked down the long
room to the desk at which one of the librarians sat. The girl's cheeks
were very red, her eyes shining as she poured out the story. They
mingled their tears, for the girl at the desk was herself young and far
from home, and then they walked back to the Denver paper and pinned the
sheets of yellow paper just above the file. At the bottom of the
petition the librarian wrote: “Leave your money at the desk in this
room. It will be properly attended to.” The girl from Colorado then
turned over her five-dollar bill and passed out into the gathering
Her heart was brimming with joy. “I can get a cheaper boarding
place,” she told herself, as she joined the home-going crowds, “and
until something else turns up I'll just look around and see if I can't
get a place in a store.”
* * * * *
One by one they had gathered around while the woman was telling the
story. “And so, if you don't mind,” she said, in conclusion, “I'd like
to have you put in a little piece that I got to Denver safe, so's they
can see it. They was all so worked up about when I'd get here. Would
that cost much?” she asked timidly.
“Not a cent,” said the city editor, his voice gruff with the attempt
to keep it steady.
“You might say, if it wouldn't take too much room, that I was much
pleased with the prospect of getting home before sundown to-night.”
“You needn't worry but what we'll say it all,” he assured her.
“We'll say a great deal more than you have any idea of.”
“I'm very thankful to you,” she said, as she rose to go.
They sat there for a moment in silence. “When one considers,”
someone began, “that they were people who were pushed too close even to
subscribe to a daily paper—”
“When one considers,” said the city editor, “that the girl who
started it had just eleven dollars to her name—” And then he, too,
stopped abruptly and there was another long moment of silence.
After that he looked around at the reporters. “Well, it's too bad
you can't all have it, when it's so big a chance, but I guess it falls
logically to Raymond. And in writing it, just remember, Raymond, that
the biggest stories are not written about wars, or about politics, or
even murders. The biggest stories are written about the things which
draw human beings closer together. And the chance to write them doesn't
come every day, or every year, or every lifetime. And I'll tell you,
boys, all of you, when it seems sometimes that the milk of human
kindness has all turned sour, just think back to the little story you
heard this afternoon.”
* * * * *
Slowly the sun slipped down behind the mountains; slowly the long
purple shadows deepened to black; and with the coming of the night
there settled over the everlasting hills, and over the soul of one who
had returned to them, that satisfying calm that men call peace.
IV. FRECKLES M'GRATH
Many visitors to the State-house made the mistake of looking upon
the Governor as the most important personage in the building. They
would walk up and down the corridors, hoping for a glimpse of some of
the leading officials, when all the while Freckles McGrath, the real
character of the Capitol, and by all odds the most illustrious person
in it, was at once accessible and affable.
Freckles McGrath was the elevator boy. In the official register his
name had gone down as William, but that was a mere concession to the
constituents to whom the official register was sent out. In the
newspapers—and he appeared with frequency in the newspapers—he was
always “Freckles,” and every one from the Governor down gave him that
title, the appropriateness of which was stamped a hundred fold upon his
shrewd, jolly Irish face.
Like every one else on the State pay-roll, Freckles was keyed high
during this first week of the new session. It was a reform Legislature,
and so imbued was it with the idea of reforming that there was grave
danger of its forcing reformation upon everything in sight. It happened
that the Governor was of the same faction of the party as that dominant
in the Legislature; reform breathed through every nook and crevice of
the great building.
But high above all else in importance towered the Kelley Bill. From
the very opening of the session there was scarcely a day when some of
Freckles' passengers did not in hushed whispers mention the Kelley
Bill. From what he could pick up about the building, and what he read
in the newspapers, Freckles put together a few ideas as to what the
Kelley Bill really was. It was a great reform measure, and it was going
to show the railroads that they did not own the State. The railroads
were going to have to pay more taxes, and they were making an awful
fuss about it; but if the Kelley Bill could be put through it would be
a great victory for reform, and would make the Governor “solid” in the
Freckles McGrath was strong for reform. That was partly because the
snatches of speeches he heard in the Legislature were more thrilling
when for reform than when against it; it was partly because he adored
the Governor, and in no small part because he despised Mr. Ludlow.
Mr. Ludlow was a lobbyist. Some of the members of the Legislature
were Mr. Ludlow's property—or at least so Freckles inferred from
conversation overheard at his post. There had been a great deal of talk
that session about Mr. Ludlow's methods.
Freckles himself was no snob. Although he had heard Mr. Ludlow
called disgraceful, and although he firmly believed he was disgraceful,
he did not consider that any reason for not speaking to him. And so
when Mr. Ludlow got in all alone one morning, and the occasion seemed
to demand recognition of some sort, Freckles had chirped:
But the man, possibly deep in something else, simply knit together
his brows and gave no sign of having heard. After that, Henry Ludlow,
lobbyist, and Freckles McGrath, elevator boy, were enemies.
A little before noon, one day near the end of the session, a member
of the Senate and a member of the House rode down together in the
“There's no use waiting any longer,” the Senator was saying as they
got in. “We're as strong now as we're going to be. It's a matter of
Stacy's vote, and that's a matter of who sees him last.”
Freckles widened out his ears and gauged the elevator for very slow
running. Stacy had been written up in the papers as a wabbler on the
“He's all right now,” pursued the Senator, “but there's every chance
that Ludlow will see him before he casts his vote this afternoon, and
then—oh, I don't know!” and with a weary little flourish of his hands
the Senator stepped off.
Freckles McGrath sat wrapped in deep thought. The Kelley Bill was
coming up in the Senate that afternoon. If Senator Stacy voted for it,
it would pass. If he voted against it, it would fail. He would vote for
it if he didn't see Mr. Ludlow; he wouldn't vote for it if he did. That
was the situation, and the Governor's whole future, Freckles felt, was
The bell rang sharply, and he was vaguely conscious then that it had
been ringing before. In the next half-hour he was very busy taking down
the members of the Legislature. Strangely enough, Senator Stacy and the
Governor went down the same trip, and Freckles beamed with approbation
when, he saw them walk out of the building together.
Stacy was one of the first of the senators to return. Freckles sized
him up keenly as he stepped into the elevator, and decided that he was
still firm. But there was a look about Senator Stacy's mouth which
suggested that there was no use in being too sure of him. Freckles
considered the advisability of bursting forth and telling him how much
better it would be to stick with the reform fellows; but just as the
boy got his courage screwed up to speaking point, Senator Stacy got
About ten minutes later Freckles had the elevator on the ground
floor, and was sitting there reading a paper, when he heard a step that
made him prick up his ears. The next minute Mr. Ludlow turned the
corner. He was immaculately dressed, as usual, and his iron-grey
moustache seemed to stand out just a little more pompously than ever.
There was a sneering look in his eyes as he stepped into the car. It
seemed to be saying: “They thought they could beat me, did they? Oh,
they're easy, they are!”
Freckles McGrath slammed the door of the cage and started the car
up. He did not know what he was going to do, but he had an idea that he
did not want any other passenger. When half way between the basement
and the first floor, he stopped the elevator. He must have time to
think. If he took that man up to the Senate Chamber, he would simply
strike the death-blow to reform! And so he knelt and pretended to be
fixing something, and he thought fast and hard.
“Something broke?” asked an anxious voice.
Freckles looked around into Mr. Ludlow's face, and he saw that the
eminent lobbyist was nervous.
“Yes,” he said calmly. “It's acting queer. Something's all out of
“Well, drop it to the basement and let me out,” said Mr. Ludlow
“Can't drop it,” responded Freckles. “She's stuck.”
Mr. Ludlow came and looked things over, but his knowledge did not
extend to the mechanism of elevators.
“Better call someone to come and take us out,” he said nervously.
Freckles straightened himself up. A glitter had come into his small
grey eyes, and red spots were burning in his freckled cheeks.
“I think she'll run now,” he said.
And she did run. Never in all its history had that State-house
elevator run as it ran then. It rushed past the first and second floors
like a thing let loose, with an utter abandonment that caused the blood
to forsake the eminent lobbyist's face.
“Stop it, boy!” he cried in alarm.
“Can't!” responded Freckles, his voice thick with terror. “Running
away!” he gasped.
“Will it—fall?” whispered the lobbyist.
“I—I think so!” blubbered Freckles.
The central portion of the State-house was very high. Above that
part of the building which was in use there was a long stretch leading
to the tower. The shaft had been built clear up, though practically
unused. Past floors used for store-rooms, past floors used for nothing
at all, they went—the man's face white, the boy wailing out incoherent
supplications. And then, within ten feet of the top of the shaft, and
within a foot of the top floor of the building, the elevator came to a
rickety stop. It wabbled back and forth; it did strange and terrible
“She's falling!” panted Freckles. “Climb!”
And Henry Ludlow climbed. He got the door open, and he clambered up.
No sooner had the man's feet touched the solid floor than Freckles
reached up and slammed the door of the cage. Why he did that he was not
sure at the time. Later he felt that something had warned him not to
give his prisoner's voice a full sweep down the shaft.
Henry Ludlow was far from dull. As he saw the quick but even descent
of the car, he knew that he had been tricked. He would have been more
than human had there not burst from him furious and threatening words.
But what was the use? The car was going down—down—down, and there he
was, perhaps hundreds of feet above any one else in the
building—alone, tricked, beaten!
Of course he tried the door at the head of the winding stairway,
knowing full well that it would be locked. They always kept it locked;
he had heard one of the janitors asking for the keys to take a party up
just a few days before. Perhaps he could get out on top of the building
and make signals of distress. But the door leading outside was locked
also. There he was—helpless. And below—well, below they were passing
the Kelley Bill!
He rattled the grating of the elevator shaft. He made strange, loud
noises, knowing all the while he could not make himself heard. And then
at last, alone in the State-house attic, Henry Ludlow, eminent
lobbyist, sat down on a box and nursed his fury.
Below, Freckles McGrath, the youngest champion of reform in the
building, was putting on a bold front. He laughed and he talked and he
whistled. He took people up and down with as much nonchalance as if he
did not know that up at the top of that shaft angry eyes were straining
themselves for a glimpse of the car, and terrible curses were
descending, literally, upon his stubby red head.
It was a great afternoon at the State-house. Every one thronged to
the doors of the Senate Chamber, where they were putting through the
Kelley Bill. The speeches made in behalf of the measure were brief. The
great thing now was not to make speeches; it was to reach “S” on
roll-call before a man with iron-grey hair and an iron-grey moustache
could come in and say something to the fair-haired member with the weak
mouth who sat near the rear of the chamber.
Freckles was called away just as it went to a vote. When he came
back Senator Kelley was standing out in the corridor, and a great crowd
of men were standing around slapping him on the back. The Governor
himself was standing on the steps of the Senate Chamber; his eyes were
bright, and he was smiling.
Freckles turned his car back to the basement. He wanted to be all
alone for a minute, to dwell in solitude upon the fact that it was he,
Freckles McGrath, who had won this great victory for reform. It was he,
Freckles McGrath, who had assured the Governor's future. Why, perhaps
he had that afternoon made for himself a name which would be handed
down in the histories!
Freckles was a kind little boy, and he knew that an elegant
gentleman could not find the attic any too pleasant a place in which to
spend the afternoon, go he decided to go up and get Mr. Ludlow. It took
courage; but he had won his victory and this was no time for faltering.
There was something gruesome about the long ascent. He thought of
stories he had read of lonely turrets in which men were beheaded, and
otherwise made away with. It seemed he would never come to the top, and
when at last he did it was to find two of the most awful-looking eyes
he had ever seen—eyes that looked as though furies were going to
escape from them—peering down upon him.
The sight of that car, moving smoothly and securely up to the top,
and the sight of that audacious little boy with the freckled face and
the bat-like eyes, that little boy who had played his game so well, who
had wrought such havoc, was too much for Henry Ludlow's self-control.
Words such as he had never used before, such as he would not have
supposed himself capable of using, burst from him. But Freckles stood
calmly gazing up at the infuriated lobbyist, and just as Mr. Ludlow was
saying, “I'll beat your head open, you little brat!” he calmly reversed
the handle and sent the car skimming smoothly to realms below. He was
followed by an angry yell, and then by a loud request to return, but he
heeded them not, and for some time longer the car made its usual rounds
between the basement and the legislative chambers.
In just an hour Freckles tried it again. He sent the car to within
three feet of the attic floor, and then peered through the grating, his
face tied in a knot of interrogation. The eminent lobbyist stood there
gulping down wrath and pride, knowing well enough what was expected of
“Oh—all right,” he muttered at last, and with that much of an
understanding Freckles sent the car up, opened the door, and Henry
Ludlow stepped in.
No word was spoken between them until the light from the floor upon
which the Senate Chamber was situated came in view. Then Freckles
turned with a polite inquiry as to where the gentleman wished to get
“You may take me down to the office of the Governor,” said Mr.
Ludlow stonily, meaningly.
“Sure,” said Freckles cheerfully. “Guess you'll find the Governor in
his office now. He's been in the Senate most of the afternoon, watching
'em pass that Kelley Bill.”
Mr. Ludlow's lips drew in tightly. He squared his shoulders, and his
silence was tremendous.
In just fifteen minutes Freckles was sent for from the executive
“I demand his discharge!” Mr. Ludlow was saying as the elevator boy
“It happens you're not running this building,” the Governor returned
with a good deal of acidity. “Though of course,” he added with dignity,
“the matter will be carefully investigated.”
The Governor was one great chuckle inside, and his heart was full of
admiration and gratitude; but would Freckles be equal to bluffing it
through? Would the boy have the finesse, the nice subtlety, the real
master hand, the situation demanded? If not, then—imp of salvation
though he was—in the interest of reform, Freckles would have to go.
It was a very innocent looking boy who stood before him and looked
inquiringly into his face.
“William,” began the Governor—Freckles was pained at first, and
then remembered that officially he was William—“this gentleman has
made a very serious charge against you.”
Freckles looked at Mr. Ludlow in a hurt way, and waited for the
Governor to proceed.
“He says,” went on the chief executive, “that you deliberately took
him to the top of the building and wilfully left him there a prisoner
all afternoon. Did you do that?”
“Oh, sir,” burst forth Freckles, “I did the very best I could to
save his life! I was willing to sacrifice mine for him. I—”
“You little liar!” broke in Ludlow.
The Governor held up his hand. “You had your chance. Let him have
“You see, Governor,” began Freckles, as if anxious to set right a
great wrong which had been done him, “the car is acting bad. The
engineer said only this morning it needed a going over. When it took
that awful shoot, I lost control of it. Maybe I'm to be discharged for
losing control of it, but not”—Freckles sniffled pathetically—-"but
not for anything like what he says I done. Why Governor,” he went on,
ramming his knuckles into his eyes, “I ain't got nothing against him!
What'd I take him to the attic for?”
“Of course not for money,” sneered Mr. Ludlow.
The Governor turned on him sharply. “When you can bring any proof of
that, I'll be ready to hear it. Until you can, you'd better leave it
out of the question.”
“Strange it should have happened this very afternoon,” put in the
The Governor looked at him with open countenance. “You were
especially interested in something this afternoon? I thought you told
me you had no vital interest here this session.”
There was nothing to be said. Mr. Ludlow said nothing.
“Now, William,” pursued the Governor, fearful in his heart that this
would be Freckles' undoing, “why did you close the door of the shaft
before you started down?”
“Well, you see, sir,” began Freckles, still tremulously, “I'm so
used to closin' doors. Closin' doors has become a kind of second nature
with me. I've been told about it so many times. And up there, though I
thought I was losin' my life, still I didn't neglect my duty.”
The Governor put his hand to his mouth and coughed.
“And why,” he went on, more secure now, for a boy who could get out
of that could get out of anything, “why was it you didn't make some
immediate effort to get Mr. Ludlow down? Why didn't you notify someone,
or do something about it?”
“Why, I supposed, of course, he walked down by the stairs,” cried
Freckles. “I never dreamed he'd want to trust the elevator after the
way she had acted.”
“The door was locked,” snarled the eminent lobbyist.
“Well, now, you see, I didn't know that,” explained Freckles
expansively. “Late in the afternoon I took a run up just to test the
car—and there you were! I never was so surprised in my life. I
supposed, of course, sir, that you'd spent the afternoon in the Senate,
along with everybody else.”
Once more the Governor put his hand to his mouth.
“Your case will come before the executive council at its next
meeting, William. And if anything like this should happen again, you
will be discharged on the spot.” Freckles bowed. “You may go now.”
When he was almost at the door the Governor called to him.
“Don't you think, William,” he said—the Governor felt that he and
Freckles could afford to be generous—“that you should apologise to the
gentleman for the really grave inconvenience to which you have been the
means of subjecting him?”
Freckles' little grey eyes grew steely. He looked at Henry Ludlow,
and there was an ominous silence. Then light broke over his face. “On
behalf of the elevator,” he said, “I apologise.”
And a third time the Governor's hand was raised to his mouth.
The next week Freckles was wearing a signet ring; long and audibly
had he sighed for a ring of such kind and proportions. He was at some
pains in explaining to everyone to whom he showed it that it had been
sent him by “a friend up home.”
V. FROM A TO Z
Thus had another ideal tumbled to the rubbish heap! She seemed to be
breathing the dust which the newly fallen had stirred up among its
longer dead fellows. Certainly she was breathing the dust from
During her senior year at the university, when people would ask:
“And what are you going to do when you leave school, Miss Willard?” she
would respond with anything that came to hand, secretly hugging to her
mind that idea of getting a position in a publishing house. Her
conception of her publishing house was finished about the same time as
her class-day gown. She was to have a roll-top desk—probably of
mahogany—and a big chair which whirled round like that in the office
of the under-graduate dean. She was to have a little office all by
herself, opening on a bigger office—the little one marked “Private.”
There were to be beautiful rugs—the general effect not unlike the
library at the University Club—books and pictures and cultivated
gentlemen who spoke often of Greek tragedies and the Renaissance. She
was a little uncertain as to her duties, but had a general idea about
getting down between nine and ten, reading the morning paper, cutting
the latest magazine, and then “writing something.”
Commencement was now four months past, and one of her professors had
indeed secured for her a position in a Chicago “publishing house.” This
was her first morning and she was standing at the window looking down
into Dearborn Street while the man who was to have her in charge was
fixing a place for her to sit.
That the publishing house should be on Dearborn Street had been her
first blow, for she had long located her publishing house on that
beautiful stretch of Michigan Avenue which overlooked the lake. But the
real insult was that this publishing house, instead of having a
building, or at least a floor, all to itself, simply had a place penned
off in a bleak, dirty building such as one who had done work in
sociological research instinctively associated with a box factory. And
the thing which fairly trailed her visions in the dust was that the
partition penning them off did not extend to the ceiling, and the
adjoining room being occupied by a patent medicine company, she was
face to face with glaring endorsements of Dr. Bunting's Famous Kidney
and Bladder Cure. Taken all in all there seemed little chance for Greek
tragedies or the Renaissance.
The man who was “running things”—she buried her phraseology with
her dreams—wore a skull cap, and his moustache dragged down below his
chin. Just at present he was engaged in noisily pulling a most
unliterary pine table from a dark corner to a place near the window.
That accomplished, an ostentatious hunt ensued, resulting in the
triumphant flourish of a feather duster. Several knocks at the table,
and the dust of many months—perhaps likewise of many dreams—ascended
to a resting place on the endorsement of Dr. Bunting's Kidney and
Bladder Cure. He next produced a short, straight-backed chair which she
recognised as brother to the one which used to stand behind their
kitchen stove. He gave it a shake, thus delicately indicating that she
was receiving special favours in this matter of an able-bodied chair,
and then announced with brisk satisfaction: “So! Now we are ready to
begin.” She murmured a “Thank you,” seated herself and her buried hopes
in this chair which did not whirl round, and leaned her arms upon a
table which did not even dream in mahogany.
In the other publishing house, one pushed buttons and
uniformed menials appeared—noiselessly, quickly and deferentially. At
this moment a boy with sandy hair brushed straight back in a manner
either statesmanlike or clownlike—things were too involved to know
which—shuffled in with an armful of yellow paper which he flopped down
on the pine table. After a minute he returned with a warbled “Take Me
Back to New York Town” and a paste-pot. And upon his third appearance
he was practising gymnastics with a huge pair of shears, which he
finally presented, grinningly.
There was a long pause, broken only by the sonorous voice of Dr.
Bunting upbraiding someone for not having billed out that stuff to
Apple Grove, and then the sandy-haired boy appeared bearing a large
dictionary, followed by the man in the skull cap behind a dictionary of
equal unwieldiness. These were set down on either side of the yellow
paper, and he who was filling the position of cultivated gentleman
pulled up a chair, briskly.
“Has Professor Lee explained to you the nature of our work?” he
wanted to know.
“No,” she replied, half grimly, a little humourously, and not far
from tearfully, “he didn't—explain.”
“Then it is my pleasure to inform you,” he began, blinking at her
importantly, “that we are engaged here in the making of a dictionary.”
“A dic—?” but she swallowed the gasp in the laugh coming up
to meet it, and of their union was born a saving cough.
“Quite an overpowering thought, is it not?” he agreed pleasantly.
“Now you see you have before you the two dictionaries you will use
most, and over in that case you will find other references. The main
thing”—his voice sank to an impressive whisper—“is not to
infringe the copyright. The publisher was in yesterday and made a
little talk to the force, and he said that any one who handed in a
piece of copy infringing the copyright simply employed that means of
writing his own resignation. Neat way of putting it, was it not?”
“Yes, wasn't it—neat?” she agreed, wildly.
She was conscious of a man's having stepped in behind her and taken
a seat at the table next hers. She heard him opening his dictionaries
and getting out his paper. Then the man in the skull cap had risen and
was saying genially: “Well, here is a piece of old Webster, your first
'take'—no copyright on this, you see, but you must modernise and
expand. Don't miss any of the good words in either of these
dictionaries. Here you have dictionaries, copy-paper, paste, and
Professor Lee assures me you have brains—all the necessary ingredients
for successful lexicography. We are to have some rules printed
to-morrow, and in the meantime I trust I've made myself clear. The main
thing”—he bent down and spoke it solemnly—“is not to infringe
the copyright.” With a cheerful nod he was gone, and she heard him
saying to the man at the next table: “Mr. Clifford, I shall have to ask
you to be more careful about getting in promptly at eight.”
She removed the cover from her paste-pot and dabbled a little on a
piece of paper. Then she tried the unwieldy shears on another piece of
paper. She then opened one of her dictionaries and read studiously for
fifteen minutes. That accomplished, she opened the other dictionary and
pursued it for twelve minutes. Then she took the column of “old
Webster,” which had been handed her pasted on a piece of yellow paper,
and set about attempting to commit it to memory. She looked up to be
met with the statement that Mrs. Marjory Van Luce De Vane, after
spending years under the so-called best surgeons of the country, had
been cured in six weeks by Dr. Bunting's Famous Kidney and Bladder
Cure. She pushed the dictionaries petulantly from her, and leaning her
very red cheek upon her hand, her hazel eyes blurred with tears of
perplexity and resentment, her mouth drawn in pathetic little lines of
uncertainty, looked over at the sprawling warehouse on the opposite
side of Dearborn Street. She was just considering the direct manner of
writing one's resignation—not knowing how to infringe the
copyright—when a voice said: “I beg pardon, but I wonder if I can help
She had never heard a voice like that before. Or, had she
heard it?—and where? She looked at him, a long, startled gaze.
Something made her think of the voice the prince used to have in
long-ago dreams. She looked into a face that was dark and thin
and—different. Two very dark eyes were looking at her kindly, and a
mouth which was a baffling combination of things to be loved and things
to be deplored was twitching a little, as though it would like to join
the eyes in a smile, if it dared.
Because he saw both how funny and how hard it was, she liked him. It
would have been quite different had he seen either one without the
“You can tell me how not to infringe the copyright,” she
laughed. “I'm not sure that I know what a copyright is.”
He laughed—a laugh which belonged with his voice. “Mr. Littletree
isn't as lucid as he thinks he is. I've been here a week or so, and
picked up a few things you might like to know.”
He pulled his chair closer to her table then and gave her a lesson
in the making of copy. Edna Willard was never one-half so attractive as
when absorbed in a thing which someone was showing her how to do. Her
hazel eyes would widen and glisten with the joy of comprehending; her
cheeks would flush a deeper pink with the coming of new light, her
mouth would part in a child-like way it had forgotten to outgrow, her
head would nod gleefully in token that she understood, and she had a
way of pulling at her wavy hair and making it more wavy than it had
been before. The man at the next table was a long time in explaining
the making of a dictionary. He spoke in low tones, often looking at the
figure of the man in the skull cap, who was sitting with his back to
them, looking over copy. Once she cried, excitedly: “Oh—I see!”
and he warned, “S—h!” explaining, “Let him think you got it all from
him. It will give you a better stand-in.” She nodded, appreciatively,
and felt very well acquainted with this kind man whose voice made her
think of something—called to something—she did not just know what.
After that she became so absorbed in lexicography that when the men
began putting away their things it was hard to realise that the morning
had gone. It was a new and difficult game, the evasion of the copyright
furnishing the stimulus of a hazard.
The man at the next table had been watching her with an amused
admiration. Her child-like absorption, the way every emotion from
perplexity to satisfaction expressed itself in the poise of her head
and the pucker of her face, took him back over years emotionally barren
to the time when he too had those easily stirred enthusiasms of youth.
For the man at the next table was far from young now. His mouth had
never quite parted with boyishness, but there was more white than black
in his hair, and the lines about his mouth told that time, as well as
forces more aging than time, had laid heavy hand upon him. But when he
looked at the girl and told her with a smile that it was time to stop
work, it was a smile and a voice to defy the most tell-tale face in all
During her luncheon, as she watched the strange people coming and
going, she did much wondering. She wondered why it was that so many of
the men at the dictionary place were very old men; she wondered if it
would be a good dictionary—one that would be used in the schools; she
wondered if Dr. Bunting had made a great deal of money, and most of all
she wondered about the man at the next table whose voice was like—like
a dream which she did not know that she had dreamed.
When she had returned to the straggling old building, had stumbled
down the narrow, dark hall and opened the door of the big bleak room,
she saw that the man at the next table was the only one who had
returned from luncheon. Something in his profile made her stand there
very still. He had not heard her come in, and he was looking straight
ahead, eyes half closed, mouth set—no unsurrendered boyishness there
now. Wholly unconsciously she took an impulsive step forward. But she
stopped, for she saw, and felt without really understanding, that it
was not just the moment's pain, but the revealed pain of years. Just
then he began to cough, and it seemed the cough, too, was more than of
the moment. And then he turned and saw her, and smiled, and the smile
As the afternoon wore on the man stopped working and turning a
little in his chair sat there covertly watching the girl. She was just
typically girl. It was written that she had spent her days in the happy
ways of healthful girlhood. He supposed that a great many young fellows
had fallen in love with her—nice, clean young fellows, the kind she
would naturally meet. And then his eyes closed for a minute and he put
up his hand and brushed back his hair; there was weariness, weariness
weary of itself, in the gesture. He looked about the room and scanned
the faces of the men, most of them older than he, many of them men
whose histories were well known to him. They were the usual hangers on
about newspaper offices; men who, for one reason or other—age,
dissipation, antiquated methods—had been pitched over, men for whom
such work as this came as a godsend. They were the men of
yesterday—men whom the world had rushed past. She was the only one
there, this girl who would probably sit here beside him for many
months, with whom the future had anything to do.
Youth!—Goodness!—Joy!—Hope!—strange things to bring to a place like
this. And as if their alienism disturbed him, he moved restlessly,
almost resentfully, bit his lips nervously, moistened them, and began
putting away his things.
As the girl was starting home along Dearborn Street a few minutes
later, she chanced to look in a window. She saw that it was a saloon,
but before she could turn away she saw a man with a white face—white
with the peculiar whiteness of a dark face, standing before the bar
drinking from a small glass. She stood still, arrested by a look such
as she had never seen before: a panting human soul sobbingly fluttering
down into something from which it had spent all its force in trying to
rise. When she recalled herself and passed on, a mist which she could
neither account for nor banish was dimming the clear hazel of her eyes.
The next day was a hard one at the dictionary place. She told
herself it was because the novelty of it was wearing away, because her
fingers ached, because it tired her back to sit in that horrid chair.
She did not admit of any connection between her flagging interest and
the fact that the place at the next table was vacant.
The following day he was still absent. She assumed that it was
nervousness occasioned by her queer surroundings made her look around
whenever she heard a step behind her. Where was he? Where had that look
carried him? If he were in trouble, was there no one to help him?
The third day she did an unpremeditated thing. The man in the skull
cap had been showing her something about the copy. As he was leaving,
she asked: “Is the man who sits at the next table coming back?”
“Oh yes,” he replied grimly, “he'll be back.”
“Because,” she went on, “if he wasn't, I thought I would take his
shears. These hurt my fingers.”
He made the exchange for her—and after that things went better.
He did return late the next morning. After he had taken his place he
looked over at her and smiled. He looked sick and shaken—as if
something that knew no mercy had taken hold of him and wrung body and
“You have been ill?” she asked, with timid solicitude.
“Oh no,” he replied, rather shortly.
He was quiet all that day, but the next day they talked about the
work, laughed together over funny definitions they found. She felt that
he could tell many interesting things about himself, if he cared to.
As the days went on he did tell some of those things—out of the way
places where he had worked, queer people whom he had known. It seemed
that words came to him as gifts, came freely, happily, pleased,
perhaps, to be borne by so sympathetic a voice. And there was another
thing about him. He seemed always to know just what she was trying to
say; he never missed the unexpressed. That made it easy to say things
to him; there seemed a certain at-homeness between his thought and
hers. She accounted for her interest in him by telling herself she had
never known any one like that before. Now Harold, the boy whom she knew
best out at the university, why one had to say things to Harold
to make him understand! And Harold never left one wondering—wondering
what he had meant by that smile, what he had been going to say when he
started to say something and stopped, wondering what it was about his
face that one could not understand. Harold never could claim as his the
hour after he had left her, and was one ever close to anyone with whom
one did not spend some of the hours of absence? She began to see that
hours spent together when apart were the most intimate hours of all.
And as Harold did not make one wonder, so he did not make one worry.
Never in all her life had there been a lump in her throat when she
thought of Harold. There was often a lump in her throat when the man at
the next table was coughing.
One day, she had been there about two months, she said something to
him about it. It was hard; it seemed forcing one's way into a room that
had never been opened to one—there were several doors he kept closed.
“Mr. Clifford,” she turned to him impetuously as they were putting
away their things that night, “will you mind if I say something to
He was covering his paste-pot. He looked up at her strangely. The
closed door seemed to open a little way. “I can't conceive of 'minding'
anything you might say to me, Miss Noah,”—he had called her Miss Noah
ever since she, by mistake, had one day called him Mr. Webster.
“You see,” she hurried on, very timid, now that the door had opened
a little, “you have been so good to me. Because you have been so good
to me it seems that I have some right to—to—”
His head was resting upon his hand, and he leaned a little closer as
though listening for something he wanted to hear.
“I had a cousin who had a cough like yours,”—brave now that she
could not go back—“and he went down to New Mexico and stayed for a
year, and when he came back—when he came back he was as well as any of
us. It seems so foolish not to”—her voice broke, now that it had so
valiantly carried it—“not to—”
He looked at her, and that was all. But she was never wholly the
same again after that look. It enveloped her being in a something which
left her richer—different. It was a look to light the dark place
between two human souls. It seemed for the moment that words would
follow it, but as if feeling their helplessness—perhaps
needlessness—they sank back unuttered, and at the last he got up,
abruptly, and walked away.
One night, while waiting for the elevator, she heard two of the men
talking about him. When she went out on the street it was with head
high, cheeks hot. For nothing is so hard to hear as that which one has
half known, and evaded. One never denies so hotly as in denying to
one's self what one fears is true, and one never resents so bitterly as
in resenting that which one cannot say one has the right to resent.
That night she lay in her bed with wide open eyes, going over and
over the things they had said. “Cure?”—one of them had scoffed,
after telling how brilliant he had been before he “went to
pieces”—“why all the cures on earth couldn't help him! He can go just
so far, and then he can no more stop himself—oh, about as much as an
ant could stop a prairie fire!”
She finally turned over on her pillow and sobbed; and she wondered
why—wondered, yet knew.
But it resulted in the flowering of her tenderness for him. Interest
mounted to defiance. It ended in blind, passionate desire to “make it
up” to him. And again he was so different from Harold; Harold did not
impress himself upon one by upsetting all one's preconceived ideas.
She felt now that she understood better—understood the closed
doors. He was—she could think of no better word than sensitive.
And that is why, several mornings later, she very courageously—for
it did take courage—threw this little note over on his desk—they had
formed a habit of writing notes to each other, sometimes about the
words, sometimes about other things.
“IN-VI-TA-TION, n. That which Miss Noah extends to Mr.
Webster for Friday evening, December second, at the house where she
lives—hasn't she already told him where that is? It is the wish of
Miss Noah to present Mr. Webster to various other Miss Noahs, all of
whom are desirous of making his acquaintance.”
She was absurdly nervous at luncheon that day, and kept telling
herself with severity not to act like a high-school girl. He was late
in returning that noon, and though there seemed a new something in his
voice when he asked if he hadn't better sharpen her pencils, he said
nothing about her new definition of invitation. It was almost five
o'clock when he threw this over on her desk:
“AP-PRE-CI-A-TION, n. That sentiment inspired in Mr. Webster
by the kind invitation of Miss Noah for Friday evening.
“RE-GRET, n. That which Mr. Webster experiences because, for
reasons into which he cannot go in detail, it is impossible for him to
accept Miss Noah's invitation.
“RE-SENT-MENT, n. That which is inspired in Mr. Webster by
the insinuation that there are other Miss Noahs in the world.”
Then below he had written: “Three hours later. Miss Noah, the world
is queer. Some day you may find out—though I hope you never will—that
it is frequently the things we most want to do that we must leave
undone. Miss Noah, won't you go on bringing me as much of yourself as
you can to Dearborn Street, and try not to think much about my not
being able to know the Miss Noah of Hyde Park? And little Miss Noah—I
thank you. There aren't words enough in this old book of ours to tell
you how much—or why.”
That night he hurried away with never a joke about how many words
she had written that day. She did not look up as he stood there putting
on his coat.
It was spring now, and the dictionary staff had begun on W.
They had written of Joy, of Hope and Life and Love, and many other
things. Life seemed pressing just behind some of those definitions,
pressing the harder, perhaps, because it could not break through the
For it did not break through; it flooded just beneath.
How did she know that he cared for her? She could not possibly have
told. Perhaps the nearest to actual proof she could bring was that he
always saw that her overshoes were put in a warm place. And when one
came down to facts, the putting of a girl's rubbers near the radiator
did not necessarily mean love.
Perhaps then it was because there was no proof of it that she was
most sure. For some of the most sure things in the world are things
which cannot be proved.
It was only that they worked together and were friends; that they
laughed together over funny definitions they found, that he was kind to
her, and that they seemed remarkably close together.
That is as far as facts can take it.
And just there—it begins.
For the force which rushes beneath the facts of life, caring nothing
for conditions, not asking what one desires or what one thinks best,
caring as little about a past as about a future—save its own
future—the force which can laugh at man's institutions and batter over
in one sweep what he likes to call his wisdom, was sweeping them on.
And because it could get no other recognition it forced its way into
the moments when he asked her for an eraser, when she wanted to know
how to spell a word. He could not so much as ask her if she needed more
copy-paper without seeming to be lavishing upon her all the love of all
And so the winter had worn on, and there was really nothing whatever
to tell about it.
She was quiet this morning, and kept her head bent low over her
work. For she had estimated the number of pages there were between W
and Z. Soon they would be at Z;—and then? Then? Shyly she turned and
looked at him; he too was bent over his work. When she came in she had
said something about its being spring, and that there must be wild
flowers in the woods. Since then he had not looked up.
Suddenly it came to her—tenderly, hotly, fearfully yet bravely,
that it was she who must meet Z. She looked at him again, covertly. And
she felt that she understood. It was the lines in his face made it
clearest. Years, and things blacker, less easily surmounted than
years—oh yes, that too she faced fearlessly—were piled in between.
She knew now that it was she—not he—who could push them aside.
It was all very unmaidenly, of course; but maidenly is a word love
and life and desire may crowd from the page.
Perhaps she would not have thrown it after all—the little note she
had written—had it not been that when she went over for more
copy-paper she stood for a minute looking out the window. Even on
Dearborn Street the seductiveness of spring was in the air. Spring, and
all that spring meant, filled her.
Because, way beyond the voice of Dr. Bunting she heard the songs of
far-away birds, and because beneath the rumble of a printing press she
could get the babble of a brook, because Z was near and life was
strong, the woman vanquished the girl, and she threw this over to his
“CHAFING-DISH, n. That out of which Miss Noah asks Mr. Webster to
eat his Sunday night lunch tomorrow. All the other Miss Noahs are going
to be away, and if Mr. Webster does not come, Miss Noah will be all
alone. Miss Noah does not like to be lonely.”
She ate no lunch that day; she only drank a cup of coffee and walked
He did not come back that afternoon. It passed from one to two, from
two to three, and then very slowly from three to four, and still he had
He too was walking about. He had walked down to the lake and was
standing there looking out across it.
Why not?—he was saying to himself—fiercely, doggedly. Over and
over again—Well, why not?
A hundred nights, alone in his room, he had gone over it. Had not
life used him hard enough to give him a little now?—longing had
pleaded. And now there was a new voice—more prevailing voice—the
voice of her happiness. His face softened to an almost maternal
tenderness as he listened to that voice.
Too worn to fight any longer, he gave himself up to it, and sat
there dreaming. They were dreams of joy rushing in after lonely years,
dreams of stepping into the sunlight after long days in fog and cold,
dreams of a woman before a fireplace—her arms about him, her cheer and
her tenderness, her comradeship and her passion—all his to take! Ah,
dreams which even thoughts must not touch—so wonderful and sacred they
A long time he sat there, dreaming dreams and seeing visions. The
force that rules the race was telling him that the one crime was the
denial of happiness—his happiness, her happiness; and when at last his
fight seemed but a puerile fight against forces worlds mightier than
he, he rose, and as one who sees a great light, started back toward
On the way he began to cough. The coughing was violent, and he
stepped into a doorway to gain breath. And after he had gone in there
he realised that it was the building of Chicago's greatest newspaper.
He had been city editor of that paper once. Facts, the things he
knew about himself, talked to him then. There was no answer.
It left him weak and dizzy and crazy for a drink. He walked on
slowly, unsteadily, his white face set. For he had vowed that if it
took the last nerve in his body there should be no more of that until
after they had finished with Z. He knew himself too well to vow more.
He was not even sure of that.
He did not turn in where he wanted to go, but resistance took the
last bit of force that was in him. He was trembling like a sick man
when he stepped into the elevator.
She was just leaving. She was in the little cloak room putting on
her things. She was all alone in there.
He stepped in. He pushed the door shut, and stood there leaning
against it, looking at her, saying nothing.
“Oh—you are ill?” she gasped, and laid a frightened hand upon him.
The touch crazed him. All resistance gone, he swept her into his
arms; he held her fiercely, and between sobs kissed her again and
again. He could not let her go. He frightened her. He hurt her. And he
did not care—he did not know.
Then he held her off and looked at her. And as he looked into her
eyes, passion melted to tenderness. It was she now—not he; love—not
hunger. Holding her face in his two hands, looking at her as if getting
something to take away, his white lips murmured words too inarticulate
for her to hear. And then again he put his arms around her—all
differently. Reverently, sobbingly, he kissed her hair. And then he was
He did not come out that Sunday afternoon, but Harold dropped in
instead, and talked of some athletic affairs over at the university.
She wondered why she did not go crazy in listening to him, and yet she
could answer intelligently. It was queer—what one could do.
They had come at last to Z. There would be no more work upon the
dictionary after that day. And it was raining—raining as in Chicago
alone it knows how to rain.
They wrote no notes to each other now. It had been different since
that day. They made small effort to cover their raw souls with the
mantle of commonplace words.
Both of them had tried to stay away that last day. But both were in
their usual places.
The day wore on eventlessly. Those men with whom she had worked, the
men of yesterday, who had been kind to her, came up at various times
for little farewell chats. The man in the skull cap told her that she
had done excellent work. She was surprised at the ease with which she
could make decent reply, thinking again that it was queer—what one
He was moving. She saw him lay some sheets of yellow paper on the
desk in front. He had finished with his “take.” There would not be
another to give him. He would go now.
He came back to his desk. She could hear him putting away his
things. And then for a long time there was no sound. She knew that he
was just sitting there in his chair.
Then she heard him get up. She heard him push his chair up to the
table, and then for a minute he stood there. She wanted to turn toward
him; she wanted to say something—do something. But she had no power.
She saw him lay an envelope upon her desk. She heard him walking
away. She knew, numbly, that his footsteps were not steady. She knew
that he had stopped; she was sure that he was looking back. But still
she had no power.
And then she heard him go.
Even then she went on with her work; she finished her “take” and
laid down her pencil. It was finished now—and he had gone. Finished?—
Gone? She was tearing open the envelope of the letter.
This was what she read:
“Little dictionary sprite, sunshine vender, and girl to be loved, if
I were a free man I would say to you—Come, little one, and let us
learn of love. Let us learn of it, not as one learns from dictionaries,
but let us learn from the morning glow and the evening shades. But Miss
Noah, maker of dictionaries and creeper into hearts, the bound must not
call to the free. They might fittingly have used my name as one of the
synonyms under that word Failure, but I trust not under Coward.
“And now, you funny little Miss Noah from the University of Chicago,
don't I know that your heart is blazing forth the assurance that you
don't care for any of those things—the world, people, common
sense—that you want just love? They made a grand failure of you out at
your university; they taught you philosophy and they taught you Greek,
and they've left you just as much the woman as women were five thousand
years ago. Oh, I know all about you—you little girl whose hair tried
so hard to be red. Your soul touched mine as we sat there writing
words—words—words, the very words in which men try to tell things,
and can't—and I know all about what you would do. But you shall not do
it. Dear little copy maker, would a man standing out on the end of a
slippery plank have any right to cry to someone on the shore—'Come out
here on this plank with me?' If he loved the someone on the shore,
would he not say instead—'Don't get on this plank?' Me get off the
plank—come with you to the shore—you are saying? But you see, dear,
you only know slippery planks as viewed from the shore—God grant you
may never know them any other way!
“It was you, was it not, who wrote our definition of happiness? Yes,
I remember the day you did it. You were so interested; your cheeks grew
so very red, and you pulled and pulled at your wavy hair. You said it
was such an important definition. And so it is, Miss Noah, quite the
most important of all. And on the page of life, Miss Noah, may
happiness be written large and unblurred for you. It is because I
cannot help you write it that I turn away. I want at least to leave the
“I carry a picture of you. I shall carry it always. You are sitting
before a fireplace, and I think of that fireplace as symbolising the
warmth and care and tenderness and the safety that will surround you.
And sometimes as you sit there let a thought of me come for just a
minute, Miss Noah—not long enough nor deep enough to bring you any
pain. But only think—I brought him happiness after he believed all
happiness had gone. He was so grateful for that light which came after
he thought the darkness had settled down. It will light his way to the
“We've come to Z, and it's good-bye. There is one thing I can give
you without hurting you,—the hope, the prayer, that life may be very,
very good to you.”
The sheets of paper fell from her hands. She sat staring out into
Dearborn Street. She began to see. After all, he had not understood
her. Perhaps men never understood women; certainly he had not
understood her. What he did not know was that she was willing to pay
for her happiness—pay—pay any price that might be exacted. And
anyway—she had no choice. Strange that he could not see that! Strange
that he could not see the irony and cruelty of bidding her good-bye and
then telling her to be happy!
It simplified itself to such an extent that she grew very
calm. It would be easy to find him, easy to make him see—for it was so
very simple—and then....
She turned in her copy. She said good-bye quietly, naturally, rode
down in the lumbering old elevator and started out into the now
drenching rain toward the elevated trains which would take her to the
West Side; it was so fortunate that she had heard him telling one day
where he lived.
When she reached the station she saw that more people were coming
down the stairs than were going up. They were saying things about the
trains, but she did not heed them. But at the top of the stairs a man
in uniform said: “Blockade, Miss. You'll have to take the surface
She was sorry, for it would delay her, and there was not a minute to
lose. She was dismayed, upon reaching the surface cars, to find she
could not get near them; the rain, the blockade on the “L” had caused a
great crowd to congregate there. She waited a long time, getting more
and more wet, but it was impossible to get near the cars. She thought
of a cab, but could see none, they too having all been pressed into
She determined, desperately, to start and walk. Soon she would
surely get either a cab or a car. And so she started, staunchly, though
she was wet through now, and trembling with cold and nervousness.
As she hurried through the driving rain she faced things fearlessly.
Oh yes, she understood—everything. But if he were not well—should he
not have her with him? If he had that thing to fight, did he not need
her help? What did men think women were like? Did he think she was one
to sit down and reason out what would be advantageous? Better a little
while with him on a slippery plank than forever safe and desolate upon
She never questioned her going; were not life and love too great to
be lost through that which could be so easily put right?
The buildings were reeling, the streets moving up and down—that
awful rain, she thought, was making her dizzy. Labouriously she walked
on—more slowly, less steadily, a pain in her side, that awful reeling
in her head.
Carriages returning to the city were passing her, but she had not
strength to call to them, and it seemed if she walked to the curbing
she would fall. She was not thinking so clearly now. The thing which
took all of her force was the lifting of her feet and the putting them
down in the right place. Her throat seemed to be closing up—and her
side—and her head....
Someone had her by the arm. Then someone was speaking her name;
speaking it in surprise—consternation—alarm.
It was Harold.
It was all vague then. She knew that she was in a carriage, and that
Harold was talking to her kindly. “You're taking me there?” she
“Yes—yes, Edna, everything's all right,” he replied soothingly.
“Everything's all right,” she repeated, in a whisper, and leaned her
head back against the cushions.
They stopped after a while, and Harold was standing at the open door
of the cab with something steaming hot which he told her to drink. “You
need it,” he said decisively, and thinking it would help her to tell
it, she drank it down.
The world was a little more defined after that, and she saw things
which puzzled her. “Why, it looks like the city,” she whispered, her
throat too sore now to speak aloud.
“Why sure,” he replied banteringly; “don't you know we have to go
through the city to get out to the South Side?”
“Oh, but you see,” she cried, holding her throat, “but you see, it's
the other way!”
“Not to-night,” he insisted; “the place for you to-night is home.
I'm taking you where you belong.”
She reached over wildly, trying to open the door, but he held her
back; she began to cry, and he talked to her, gently but unbendingly.
“But you don't understand!” she whispered, passionately. “I've
got to go!”
“Not to-night,” he said again, and something in the way he said it
made her finally huddle back in the corner of the carriage.
Block after block, mile after mile, they rode on in silence. She
felt overpowered. And with submission she knew that it was Z. For the
whole city was piled in between. Great buildings were in between, and
thousands of men running to and fro on the streets; man, and all man
had builded up, were in between. And then Harold—Harold who had always
seemed to count for so little, had come and taken her away.
Dully, wretchedly—knowing that her heart would ache far worse
to-morrow than it did to-night—she wondered about things. Did things
like rain and street-cars and wet feet and a sore throat determine
life? Was it that way with other people, too? Did other people have
barriers—whole cities full of them—piled in between? And then did the
Harolds come and take them where they said they belonged? Were there
not some people strong enough to go where they wanted to go?
VI. THE MAN OF FLESH AND BLOOD
The elements without were not in harmony with the spirit which it
was desired should be engendered within. By music, by gay decorations,
by speeches from prominent men, the board in charge of the boys'
reformatory was striving to throw about this dedication of the new
building an atmosphere of cheerfulness and good-will—an atmosphere
vibrant with the kindness and generosity which emanated from the State,
and the thankfulness and loyalty which it was felt should emanate from
Outside the world was sobbing. Some young trees which had been
planted along the driveway of the reformatory grounds, and which were
expected to grow up in the way they should go, were rocking back and
forth in passionate insurrection. Fallen leaves were being spit
viciously through the air. It was a sullen-looking landscape which
Philip Grayson, he who was to be the last speaker of the afternoon, saw
stretching itself down the hill, across the little valley, and up
another little hill of that rolling prairie state. In his ears was the
death wail of the summer. It seemed the spirit of out-of-doors was
sending itself up in mournful, hopeless cries.
The speaker who had been delivering himself of pedantic
encouragement about the open arms with which the world stood ready to
receive the most degraded one, would that degraded one but come to the
world in proper spirit, sat down amid perfunctory applause led by the
officers and attendants of the institution, and the boys rose to sing.
The brightening of their faces told that their work as performers was
more to their liking than their position as auditors. They threw back
their heads and waited with well-disciplined eagerness for the signal
to begin. Then, with the strength and native music there are in some
three hundred boys' throats, there rolled out the words of the song of
There were lips which opened only because they must, but as a whole
they sang with the same heartiness, the same joy in singing, that he
had heard a crowd of public-school boys put into the song only the week
before. When the last word had died away it seemed to Philip Grayson
that the sigh of the world without was giving voice to the sigh of the
world within as the well-behaved crowd of boys sat down to resume their
duties as auditors.
And then one of the most important of the professors from the State
University was telling them about the kindness of the State: the State
had provided for them this beautiful home; it gave them comfortable
clothing and nutritious food; it furnished that fine gymnasium in which
to train their bodies, books and teachers to train their minds; it
provided those fitted to train their souls, to work against the
unfortunate tendencies—the professor stumbled a little there—which
had led to their coming. The State gave liberally, gladly, and in
return it asked but one thing: that they come out into the world and
make useful, upright citizens, citizens of which any State might be
proud. Was that asking too much? the professor from the State
University was saying.
The sobbing of the world without was growing more intense. Many
pairs of eyes from among the auditors were straying out to where the
summer lay dying. Did they know—those boys whom the State classed as
unfortunates—that out of this death there would come again life? Or
did they see but the darkness—the decay—of to-day?
The professor from the State University was putting the case very
fairly. There were no flaws—seemingly—to be picked in his logic. The
State had been kind; the boys were obligated to good citizenship. But
the coldness!—comfortlessness!—of it all. The open arms of the
world!—how mocking in its abstractness. What did it mean? Did it mean
that they—the men who uttered the phrase so easily—would be willing
to give these boys aid, friendship when they came out into the world?
What would they say, those boys whose ears were filled with
high-sounding, non-committal phrases, if some man were to stand before
them and say, “And so, fellows, when you get away from this place, and
are ready to get your start in the world, just come around to my office
and I'll help you get a job?” At thought of it there came from Philip
Grayson a queer, partly audible laugh, which caused those nearest him
to look his way in surprise.
But he was all unconscious of their looks of inquiry, absorbed in
the thoughts that crowded upon him. How far away the world—his kind of
people—must seem to these boys of the State Reform School. The
speeches they had heard, the training that had been given them, had
taught them—unconsciously perhaps, but surely—to divide the world
into two great classes: the lucky and the unlucky, those who made
speeches and those who must listen, the so-called good and the
so-called bad; perhaps—he smiled a little at his own cynicism—those
who were caught and those who were not.
There came to him these words of a poet of whom he used to be fond:
In men whom men pronounce as ill,
I find so much of goodness still;
In men whom men pronounce divine,
I find so much of sin and blot;
I hesitate to draw the line
Between the two, when God has not.
When God has not! He turned and looked out at the sullen sky,
returning—as most men do at times—to that conception of his childhood
that somewhere beyond the clouds was God. God! Did God care for the
boys of the State Reformatory? Was that poet of the western mountains
right when he said that God was not a drawer of lines, but a seer of
the good that was in the so-called bad, and of the bad in the so-called
good, and a lover of them both?
If that was God, it was not the God the boys of the reformatory had
been taught to know. They had been told that God would forgive the
wicked, but it had been made clear to them—if not in words, in
implications—that it was they who were the wicked. And the so-called
godly men, men of such exemplary character as had been chosen to
address them that afternoon, had so much of the spirit of God that
they, too, were willing to forgive, be tolerant, and—he looked out at
the bending trees with a smile—disburse generalities about the open
arms of the world.
What would they think—those three hundred speech-tired boys—if
some man who had been held before them as exemplary were to rise and
lay bare his own life—its weaknesses, its faults, perhaps its
crimes—and tell them there was weakness and there was strength in
every human being, and that the world-old struggle of life was to
overcome one's weakness with one's strength.
The idea took strange hold on him. It seemed the method of the
world—at any rate it had been the method of that afternoon—for the
men who stood before their fellows with clean hands to plant themselves
on the far side of a chasm of conventions, or narrow self-esteem, or
easily won virtue, and cry to those beings who struggled on the other
side of that chasm—to those human beings whose souls had never gone to
school: “Look at us! Our hands are clean, our hearts are pure. See how
beautiful it is to be good! Come ye, poor sinners, and be good also.”
And the poor sinners, the untaught, birthmarked human souls, would look
over at the self-acclaimed goodness they could see far across the
chasm, and even though attracted to it (which, he grimly reflected,
would not seem likely) the thing that was left with them was a sense of
the width of the chasm.
He had a sense of needless waste, of unnecessary blight. He looked
down at those three hundred faces and it was as if looking at human
waste; and it was human stupidity, human complacency and cowardice kept
those human beings human drift.
With what a smug self-satisfaction—under the mask of
benevolence—the speakers of that afternoon had flaunted their
virtue—their position! How condescendingly they had spoken of the home
which we, the good, prepare for you, the bad, and what namby-pambyness
there was, after all, in that sentiment which all of them had
voiced—and now you must pay us back by being good!
Oh for a man of flesh and blood to stand up and tell how he himself
had failed and suffered! For a man who could bridge that chasm with
strong, broad, human understanding and human sympathies—a man who
would stand among them pulse-beat to pulse-beat and cry out, “I know! I
understand! I fought it and I'll help you fight it too!”
The sound of his own name broke the spell that was upon him. He
looked to the centre of the stage and saw that the professor from the
State University had seated himself and that the superintendent of the
institution was occupying the place of the speaker. And the
superintendent was saying:
“We may esteem ourselves especially fortunate in having him with us
this afternoon. He is one of the great men of the State, one of the men
who by high living, by integrity and industry, has raised himself to a
position of great honour among his fellow men. A great party—may I say
the greatest of all parties?—has shown its unbounded confidence in him
by giving him the nomination for the governorship of the State. No man
in the State is held in higher esteem to-day than he. And so it is with
special pleasure that I introduce to you that man of the future—Philip
The superintendent sat down then, and he himself—Philip
Grayson—was standing in the place where the other speakers had stood.
It was with a rush which almost swept away his outward show of calm
that it came to him that he—candidate for the governorship—was well
fitted to be that man of flesh and blood for whom he had sighed. That
he himself was within grasp of an opportunity to get beneath the
jackets and into the very hearts and souls of those boys, and make them
feel that a man of sins and virtues, of weaknesses and strength, a man
who had had much to conquer, and for whom the fight would never be
finally won, was standing before them stripped of his coat of
conventions and platitudes, and in nakedness of soul and sincerity of
heart was talking to them as a man who understood.
Almost with the inception of the idea was born the consciousness of
what it might cost. And as in answer to the silent, blunt question, Is
it worth it? there looked up at him three hundred pairs of eyes—eyes
behind which there was good as well as bad, eyes which had burned with
the fatal rush of passion, and had burned, too, with the hot tears of
remorse—eyes which had opened on a hostile world.
And then the eyes of Philip Grayson could not see the eyes which
were before him, and he put up his hand to break the mist—little
caring what the men upon the platform would think of him, little
thinking what effect the words which were crowding into his heart would
have upon his candidacy. But one thing was vital to him now: to bring
upon that ugly chasm the levelling forces of a common humanity, and to
make those boys who were of his clay feel that a being who had fallen
and risen again, a fellow being for whom life would always mean a
falling and a rising again, was standing before them, and—not as the
embodiment of a distant goodness, not as a pattern, but as one among
them, verily as man to man—was telling them a few things which his own
life had taught him were true.
It was his very consecration which made it hard to begin. He was
fearful of estranging them in the beginning, of putting between them
and him that very thing he was determined there should not be.
“I have a strange feeling,” he said, with a winning little smile,
“that if I were to open my heart to-day, just open it clear up the way
I'd like to if I could, that you boys would look into it, and then jump
back in a scared kind of way and cry, 'Why—that's me!' You would be a
little surprised—wouldn't you?—if you could look back and see the
kind of boy I was, and find I was much the kind of boy you are?
“Do you know what I think? I think hypocrisy is the worst thing in
the world. I think it's worse than stealing, or lying, or any of the
other bad things you can name. And do you know where I think lots of
the hypocrisy comes from? I think it comes from the so-called self-made
men—from the real good men, the men who say 'I haven't got one bad
thing charged up to my account.'
“Now the men out campaigning for me call me a self-made man. Your
superintendent just now spoke of my integrity, of the confidence
reposed in me, and all that. But do you know what is the honest truth?
If I am any kind of a man worth mentioning, if I am deserving of any
honour, any confidence, it is not because I was born with my heart
filled with good and beautiful things, for I was not. It is because I
was born with much in my heart that we call the bad, and because, after
that bad had grown stronger and stronger through the years it was
unchecked, and after it had brought me the great shock, the great
sorrow of my life, I began then, when older than you boys are now, to
see a little of that great truth which you can put briefly in these
words: 'There is good and there is bad in every human heart, and it is
the struggle of life to conquer the bad with the good.' What I am
trying to say is, that if I am worthy any one's confidence to-day, it
is because, having seen that truth, I have been able, through never
ceasing trying, through slow conquering, to crowd out some of the bad
and make room for a little of the good.
“You see,” he went on, three hundred pairs of eyes hard upon him
now, “some of us are born to a harder struggle than others. There are
people who would object to my saying that to you, even if I believed
it. They would say you would make the fact of being born with much
against which to struggle an excuse for being bad. But look here a
minute; if you were born with a body not as strong as other boys'
bodies, if you couldn't run as far, or jump as high, you wouldn't be
eternally saying, 'I can't be expected to do much; I wasn't born
right.' Not a bit of it! You'd make it your business to get as strong
as you could, and you wouldn't make any parade of the fact that you
weren't as strong as you should be. We don't like people who whine,
whether it's about weak bodies or weak souls.
“I've been sitting here this afternoon wondering what to say to you
boys. I had intended telling some funny stories about things which
happened to me when I was a boy. But for some reason a serious mood has
come over me, and I don't feel just like those stories now. I haven't
been thinking of the funny side of life in the last half-hour. I've
been thinking of how much suffering I've endured since the days when I,
too, was a boy.”
He paused then; and when he went on his voice tested to the utmost
the silence of the room: “There is lots of sorrow in this old world.
Maybe I'm on the wrong track, but as I see it to-day human beings are
making a much harder thing of their existence than there is any need
of. There are millions and millions of them, and year after year,
generation after generation, they fight over the same old battles, live
through the same old sorrows. Doesn't it seem all wrong that after the
battle has been fought a million times it can't be made a little easier
for those who still have it before them?
“If a farmer had gone over a bad road, and the next day saw another
farmer about to start over the same road, wouldn't he send him back?
Doesn't it seem too bad that in things which concern one's whole life
people can't be as decent as they are about things which involve only
an inconvenience? Doesn't it seem that when we human beings have so
much in common we might stand together a little better? I'll tell you
what's the matter. Most of the people of this world are coated round
and round with self-esteem, and they're afraid to admit any
understanding of the things which aren't good. Suppose the farmer had
thought it a disgrace to admit he had been over that road, and so had
said: 'From what I have read in books, and from what I have learned in
a general way, I fancy that road isn't good.' Would the other farmer
have gone back? I rather think he would have said he'd take his
chances. But you see the farmer said he knew; and how did he
know? Why, because he'd been over the road himself.”
As he paused again, looking at them, he saw it all with a clarifying
simplicity. He himself knew life for a fine and beautiful thing. He had
won for himself some of the satisfactions of understanding, certain
rare delights of the open spirit. He wanted to free the spirits of
these boys to whom he talked; wanted to show them that spirits could
free themselves, indicate to them that self-control and
self-development carried one to pleasures which sordid self-indulgences
had no power to bestow. It was a question of getting the most from
life. It was a matter of happiness.
It was thus he began, slowly, the telling of his life's story:
“I was born with strange, wild passions in my heart. I don't know
where they came from; I only know they were there. I resented
authority. If someone who had a right to dictate to me said, 'Philip,
do this,' then Philip would immediately begin to think how much he
would rather do the other thing. And,” he smiled a little, and some of
the boys smiled with him in anticipation, “it was the other thing which
Philip usually did.
“I didn't go to a reform school, for the very good reason that there
wasn't any in the State where I lived.” Some of he boys smiled again,
and he could hear the nervous coughing of one of the party managers
sitting close to him. “I was what you would call a very bad boy. I
didn't mind any one. I was defiant—insolent. I did bad things just
because I knew they were bad, and—and I took a great deal of
satisfaction out of it.”
The sighing of the world without was the only sound which vibrated
through the room. “I say,” he went on, “that I got a form of
satisfaction from it. I did not say I got happiness; there is a vast
difference between a kind of momentary satisfaction and that
thing—that most precious of all things—which we call happiness.
Indeed, I was very far from happy. I had hours when I was so morose and
miserable that I hated the whole world. And do you know what I thought?
I thought there was no one in all the world who had the same kind of
things surging up in his heart that I did. I thought there was no one
else with whom it was as easy to be bad, or as hard to be good. I
thought that no one understood. I thought that I was all alone.
“Did you ever feel like that? Did you ever feel that no one else
knew anything about such feelings as you had? Did you ever feel that
here was you, and there was the rest of the world, and that the rest of
the world didn't know anything about you, and was just generally down
on you? Now that's the very thing I want to talk away from you to-day.
You're not the only one. We're all made of the same kind of stuff, and
there's none of us made of stuff that's flawless. We all have a fight;
some an easy one, and some a big one, and if you have formed the idea
that there is a kind of dividing-line in the world, and that on the one
side is the good, and on the other side the bad, why, all I can say is
that you have a wrong notion of things.
“Well, I grew up to be a man, and because I hadn't fought against
any of the stormy things in my heart they kept growing stronger and
stronger. I did lots of wild, ugly things, things of which I am
bitterly ashamed. I went to another place, and I fell in with the kind
of fellows you can imagine I felt at home with. I had been told when I
was a boy that it was wrong to drink and gamble. I think that was the
chief reason I took to drink and gambling.”
There was another cough, more pronounced this time, from the party
manager, and the superintendent was twisting uneasily in his seat. It
was the strangest speech that had ever been delivered at the boys'
reformatory. The boys were leaning forward—self-forgetful, intent.
“One night I was playing cards with a crowd of my friends, and one of
the men, the best friend I had, said something that made me mad. There
was a revolver right there which one of the men had been showing us.
Some kind of a demon got hold of me, and without so much as a thought I
picked up that revolver and fired at my friend.”
The party manager gave way to an exclamation of horror, and the
superintendent half rose from his seat. But before any one could say a
word Philip Grayson continued, looking at the half-frightened faces
before him: “I suppose you wonder why I am not in the penitentiary. I
had been drinking, and I missed my aim; and I was with friends, and it
was hushed up.”
He rested his hand upon the table, and looked out at the sullen
landscape. His voice was not steady as he went on: “It's not an easy
thing to talk about, boys. I never talked about it to any one before in
all my life. I'm not telling it now just to entertain you or to create
a sensation. I'm telling it,” his voice grew tense in its earnestness,
“because I believe that this world could be made a better and a sweeter
place if those who have lived and suffered would not be afraid to reach
out their hands and cry: 'I know that road—it's bad! I steered off to
a better place, and I'll help you steer off, too.'“
There was not one of the three hundred pairs of eyes but was riveted
upon the speaker's colourless face. The masks of sullenness and
defiance had fallen from them. They were listening now—not because
they must, but because into their hungry and thirsty souls was being
poured the very sustenance for which—unknowingly—they had yearned.
“We sometimes hear people say,” resumed the candidate for Governor,
“that they have lived through hell. If by that they mean they've lived
through the deepest torments the human heart can know, then I can say
that I, too, have lived through hell. What I suffered after I went home
that night no one in this world will ever know. Words couldn't tell it;
it's not the kind of thing words can come anywhere near. My whole life
spread itself out before me; it was not a pleasant thing to look at.
But at last, boys, out of the depths of my darkness, I began to get a
little light. I began to get some understanding of the battle which it
falls to the lot of some of us human beings to wage. There was good in
me, you see, or I wouldn't have cared like that, and it came to me
then, all alone that terrible night, that it is the good which lies
buried away somewhere in our hearts must fight out the bad. And so—all
alone, boys—I began the battle of trying to get command of my own
life. And do you know—this is the truth—it was with the beginning of
that battle I got my first taste of happiness. There is no finer
feeling in this world than the sense of coming into mastery of one's
self. It is like opening a door that has shut you in. Oh, you don't do
it all in a minute. This is no miracle I'm talking about. It's a fight.
But it's a fight that can be won. It's a fight that's gloriously worth
the winning. I'm not saying to you, 'Be good and you'll succeed.' Maybe
you won't succeed. Life as we've arranged it for ourselves makes
success a pretty tough proposition. But that doesn't alter the fact
that it pays to be a decent sort. You and I know about how much
happiness there is in the other kind of thing. And there is happiness
in feeling you're doing what you can to develop what's in you. Success
or failure, it brings a sense of having done your part,—that bully
sense of having put up the best fight you could.”
He leaned upon the table then, as though very weary. “I don't know,
I am sure, what the people of my State will think of all this. Perhaps
they won't want a man for their Governor who once tried to kill another
man. But,” he looked around at them with that smile of his which got
straight to men's hearts, “there's only one of me, and there are three
hundred of you, and how do I know but that in telling you of that
stretch of bad road ahead I've made a dozen Governors this very
He looked from row to row of them, trying to think of some last word
which would leave them with a sense of his sincerity. What he did say
was: “And so, boys, when you get away from here, and go out into the
world to get your start, if you find the arms of that world aren't
quite as wide open as you were told they would be, if there seems no
place where you can get a hold, and you are saying to yourself, 'It's
no use—I'll not try,' before you give up just remember there was one
man who said he knew all about it, and give that one man a chance to
show he meant what he said. So look me up, if luck goes all against
you, and maybe I can give you a little lift.” He took a backward step,
as though to resume his seat, and then he said, with a dry little smile
which took any suggestion of heroics from what had gone before, “If I'm
not at the State-house, you'll find my name in the directory of the
city where your programme tells you I live.”
He sat down, and for a moment there was silence. Then, full-souled,
heart-given, came the applause. It was not led by the attendants this
time; it was the attendants who rose at last to stop it. And when the
clapping of the hands had ceased, many of those hands were raised to
eyes which had long been dry.
The exercises were drawn to a speedy close, and he found the party
manager standing by his side. “It was very grand,” he sneered, “very
high-sounding and heroic, but I suppose you know,” jerking his hand
angrily toward a table where a reporter for the leading paper of the
opposition was writing, “that you've given them the winning card.”
As he replied, in far-off tone, “I hope so,” the candidate for
Governor was looking, not at the reporter who was sending out a new cry
for the opposition, but into those faces aglow with the light of new
understanding and new-born hopes. He stood there watching them filing
out into the corridor, craning their necks to throw him a last look,
and as he turned then and looked from the window it was to see that the
storm had sobbed itself away, and that along the driveway of the
reformatory grounds the young trees—unbroken and unhurt—were rearing
their heads in the way they should go.
VII. HOW THE PRINCE SAW AMERICA
They began work at seven-thirty, and at ten minutes past eight every
hammer stopped. In the Senate Chamber and in the House, on the
stairways and in the corridors, in every office from the Governor's to
the custodian's they laid down their implements and rose to their feet.
A long whistle had sounded through the building. There was magic in its
“What's the matter with you fellows?” asked the attorney-general,
swinging around in his chair.
“Strike,” declared one of the men, with becoming brevity.
“Strike of what?”
“Carpet-Tackers' Union Number One,” replied the man, kindly
gathering up a few tacks.
“Never heard of it.”
“Organised last night,” said the carpet-tacker, putting on his coat.
“Well I'll—” he paused expressively, then inquired: “What's your
“Well, you see, boss, this executive council that runs the
State-house has refused our demands.”
“What are your demands?”
“Double pay! Now how do you figure it out that you ought to have
“Rush work. You see we were under oath, or pretty near that, to get
every carpet in the State-house down by four o'clock this afternoon.
Now you know yourself that rush work is hard on the nerves. Did you
ever get rush work done at a laundry and not pay more for it? We was
anxious as anybody to get the Capitol in shape for the big show this
afternoon. But there's reason in all things.”
“Yes,” agreed his auditor, “there is.”
The man looked at him a little doubtfully. “Our president—we
elected Johnny McGuire president last night—went to the Governor this
morning with our demands.”
The Governor's fellow official smiled—he knew the Governor pretty
well. “And he turned you down?”
The striker nodded. “But there's an election next fall; maybe the
turning down will be turned around.”
“Maybe so—you never can tell. I don't know just what power
Carpet-Tackers' Union Number One will wield, but the Governor's pretty
solid, you know, with Labour as a whole.”
That was true, and went home. The striker rubbed his foot
uncertainly across the floor, and took courage from its splinters.
“Well, there's one thing sure. When Prince Ludwig and his train-load of
big guns show up at four o'clock this afternoon they'll find bare
floors, and pretty bum bare floors, on deck at this place.”
The attorney-general rubbed his own foot across the splintered,
miserable boards. “They are pretty bum,” he reflected. “I wonder,” he
added, as the man was half-way out of the door, “what Prince Ludwig
will think of the American working-man when he arrives this afternoon?”
“Just about as much,” retorted the not-to-be-downed carpet-tacker,
“as he does about American generosity. And he may think a few things,”
he added weightily, “about American independence.”
“Oh, he's sure to do that,” agreed the attorney-general.
He joined the crowd in the corridor. They were swarming out from all
the offices, all talking of the one thing. “It was a straight case of
hold-up,” declared the Governor's secretary. “They supposed they had us
on the hip. They were getting extra money as it was, but you see they
just figured it out we'd pay anything rather than have these wretched
floors for the reception this afternoon. They thought the Governor
would argue the question, and then give in, or, at any rate,
compromise. They never intended for one minute that the Prince should
find bare floors here. And I rather think,” he concluded, “that they
feel a little done up about it themselves.”
“What's the situation?” asked a stranger within the gates.
“It's like this,” a newspaper reporter told him; “about a month ago
there was a fire here and the walls and carpets were pretty well
knocked out with smoke and water. The carpets were mean old things
anyway, so they voted new ones. And I want to tell you”—he swelled
with pride—“that the new ones are beauties. The place'll look great
when we get 'em down. Well, you know Prince Ludwig and his crowd cross
the State on their way to the coast, and of course they were invited to
stop. Last week Billy Patton—he's running the whole show—declined the
invitation on account of lack of time, and then yesterday comes a
telegram saying the Prince himself insisted on stopping. You know he's
keen about Indian dope—and we've got Indian traditions to burn. So Mr.
Bill Patton had to make over his schedule to please the Prince, and of
course we were all pretty tickled about it, for more reasons than one.
The telegram didn't come until five o'clock yesterday afternoon, but
you know what a hummer the Governor is when he gets a start. He made up
his mind this building should be put in shape within twenty-four hours.
They engaged a whole lot of fellows to work on the carpets to-day. Then
what did they do but get together last night—well, you know the rest.
Pretty bum-looking old shack just now, isn't it?” and the reporter
looked around ruefully.
It was approaching the hour for the legislature to convene, and the
members who were beginning to saunter in swelled the crowd—and the
indignation—in the rotunda.
The Governor, meanwhile, had been trying to get other men, but
Carpet-Tackers' Union Number One had looked well to that. The biggest
furniture dealer in the city was afraid of the plumbers. “Pipes burst
last night,” he said, “and they may not do a thing for us if we get
mixed up in this. Sorry—but I can't let my customers get pneumonia.”
Another furniture man was afraid of the teamsters. For one reason or
another no one was disposed to respond to the Macedonian cry, and when
the Governor at last gave it up and walked out into the rotunda he was
about as disturbed as he permitted himself to get. “It's the idea of
lying down,” he said. “I'd do anything—anything!—if I could only
think what to do.”
A popular young member of the House overheard the remark. “By
George, Governor,” he burst forth, after a minute's deep
study—“say—by Jove, I say, let's do it ourselves!”
They all laughed, but the Governor's laugh stopped suddenly, and he
looked hard at the young man.
“Why not?” the young legislator went on. “It's a big job, but there
are a lot of us. We've all put down carpets at home; what are we afraid
to tackle it here for?”
Again the others laughed, but the Governor did not. “Say, Weston,”
he said, “I'd give a lot—I tell you I'd give a lot—if we just could!”
“Leave it to me!”—and he was lost in the crowd.
The Governor's eyes followed him. He had always liked Harry Weston.
He was the very sort to inspire people to do things. The Governor
smiled knowingly as he noted the men Weston was approaching, and his
different manner with the various ones. And then he had mounted a few
steps of the stairway, and was standing there facing the crowd.
“Now look here,” he began, after silence had been obtained, “this
isn't a very formal meeting, but it's a mighty important one. It's a
clear case of Carpet-Tackers' Union against the State. What I want to
know is—Is the State going to lie down?”
There were loud cries of “No!”—“Well, I should say not!”
“Well, then, see here. The Governor's tried for other men and can't
get them. Now the next thing I want to know is—What's the matter with
They didn't get it for a minute, and then everybody laughed.
“It's no joke! You've all put down carpets at home; what's the use
of pretending you don't know how to do it? Oh yes—I know, bigger
building, and all that, but there are more of us, and the principle of
carpet-tacking is the same, big building or little one. Now my scheme
is this—Every fellow his own carpet-tacker! The Governor's office puts
down the Governor's carpet; the Secretary's office puts down the
Secretary's carpet; the Senate puts down the Senate carpet—and we'll
look after our little patch in the House!”
“But you've got more fellows than anybody else,” cried a member of
“Right you are, and we'll have an over-flow meeting in the corridors
and stairways. The House, as usual, stands ready to do her part,”—that
brought a laugh for the Senators, and from them.
“Now get it out of your heads this is a joke. The carpets are here;
the building is full of able-bodied men; the Prince is coming at
four—by his own request, and the proposition is just this: Are we
going to receive him in a barn or in a palace? Let's hear what Senator
Arnold thinks about it.”
That was a good way of getting away from the idea of its being a
joke. Senator Arnold was past seventy. Slowly he extended his right arm
and tested his muscle. “Not very much,” he said, “but enough to drive a
tack or two.” That brought applause and they drew closer together, and
the atmosphere warmed perceptibly. “I've fought for the State in more
ways than one,”—Senator Arnold was a distinguished veteran of the
Civil War—“and if I can serve her now by tacking down carpets, then
it's tacking down carpets I'm ready to go at. Just count on me for what
little I'm worth.”
Someone started the cry for the Governor. “Prince Ludwig is being
entertained all over the country in the most lavish manner,” he began,
with his characteristic directness in stating a situation. “By his own
request he is to visit our Capitol this afternoon. I must say that I,
for one, want to be in shape for him. I don't like to tell him that we
had a labour complication and couldn't get the carpets down. Speaking
for myself, it is a great pleasure to inform you that the carpet in the
Governor's office will be in proper shape by four o'clock this
That settled it. Finally Harry Weston made himself heard
sufficiently to suggest that when the House and Senate met at nine
o'clock motions to adjourn be entertained. “And as to the rest of you
fellows,” he cried, “I don't see what's to hinder your getting busy
There were Republicans and there were Democrats; there were friends
and there were enemies; there were good, bad and—no, there were no
indifferent. An unprecedented harmony of thought, a millennium-like
unity of action was born out of that sturdy cry—Every man his own
carpet-tacker! The Secretary of State always claimed that he drove the
first tack, but during the remainder of his life the Superintendent of
Public Instruction also contended hotly for that honour. The rivalry as
to who would do the best job, and get it done most quickly, became
intense. Early in the day Harry Weston made the rounds of the building
and announced a fine of one-hundred dollars for every wrinkle. There
were pounded fingers and there were broken backs, but slowly, steadily
and good-naturedly the State-house carpet was going down. It was a good
deal bigger job than they had anticipated, but that only added zest to
the undertaking. The news of how the State officials were employing
themselves had spread throughout the city, and guards were stationed at
every door to keep out people whose presence would work more harm than
good. All assistance from women was courteously refused. “This is
solemn business,” said the Governor, in response to a telephone from
some of the fair sex, “and the introduction of the feminine element
might throw about it a social atmosphere which would result in loss of
time. And then some of the boys might feel called upon to put on their
collars and coats.”
Stretch—stretch—stretch, and tack—tack—tack, all morning long it
went on, for the State-house was large—oh, very large. There should
have been a Boswell there to get the good things, for the novelty of
the situation inspired wit even in minds where wit had never glowed
before. Choice bits which at other times would fairly have gone on
official record were now passed almost unnoticed, so great was the
surfeit. Instead of men going out to lunch, lunch came in to them.
Bridget Haggerty, who by reason of her long connection with the
boarding-house across the street was a sort of unofficial official of
the State, came over and made the coffee and sandwiches, all the while
calling down blessings on the head of every mother's son of them, and
announcing in loud, firm tones that while all five of her boys belonged
to the union she'd be after tellin' them what she thought of this day's
It was a United States Senator who did the awful trick, and, to be
fair, the Senator did not think of it as an awful trick at all. He came
over there in the middle of the morning to see the Governor, and in a
few hurried words—it was no day for conversation—was told what was
going on. It was while standing out in the corridor watching the
perspiring dignitaries that the idea of his duty came to him, and one
reason he was sure he was right was the way in which it came to him in
the light of a duty. Here was America in undress uniform! Here was—not
a thing arranged for show, but absolutely the thing itself! Prince
Ludwig had come with a sincere desire to see America. Every one knew
that he was not seeing it at all. He would go back with memories of
bands and flags and people all dressed up standing before him making
polite speeches. But would he carry back one small whiff of the spirit
of the country? Again Senator Bruner looked about him. The Speaker of
the House was just beginning laying the stair carpet; a judge of the
Supreme Court was contending hotly for a better hammer. “It's an insult
to expect any decent man to drive tacks with a hammer like this,” he
was saying. Here were men—real, live men, men with individuality,
spirit. When the Prince had come so far, wasn't it too bad that he
should not see anything but uniforms and cut glass and dress suits and
other externals and non-essentials? Senator Bruner was a kind man; he
was a good fellow; he was hospitable—patriotic. He decided now in
favour of the Prince.
He had to hurry about it, for it was almost twelve then. One of the
vice-presidents of the road lived there, and he was taken into
confidence, and proved an able and eager ally. They located the special
train bearing the Prince and ordered it stopped at the next station.
The stop was made that Senator Patton might receive a long telegram
from Senator Bruner. “I figure it like this,” the Senator told the
vice-president. “They get to Boden at a quarter of one and were going
to stop there an hour. Then they were going to stop a little while at
Creyville. I've told Patton the situation, and that if he wants to do
the right thing by the prince he'll cut out those stops and rush right
through here. That will bring him in—well, they could make it at a
quarter of two. I've told him I'd square it with Boden and Creyville.
Oh, he'll do it all right.”
And even as he said so came the reply from Patton: “Too good to
miss. Will rush through. Arrive before two. Have carriage at Water
“That's great!” cried the Senator. “Trust Billy Patton for falling
in with a good thing. And he's right about missing the station crowd.
Patton can always go you one better,” he admitted, grinningly.
They had luncheon together, and they were a good deal more like
sophomores in college than like a United States Senator and a big
railroad man. “You don't think there's any danger of their getting
through too soon?” McVeigh kept asking, anxiously.
“Not a bit,” the Senator assured him. “They can't possibly make it
before three. We'll come in just in time for the final skirmish. It's
going to be a jolly rush at the last.”
They laid their plans with skill worthy of their training. The State
library building was across from the Capitol, and they were connected
by tunnel. “I never saw before,” said the Senator, “what that tunnel
was for, but I see now what a great thing it is. We'll get him in at
the west door of the library—we can drive right up to it, you know,
and then we walk him through the tunnel. That's a stone floor”—the
Senator was chuckling with every sentence—“so I guess they won't be
carpeting it. There's a little stairway running up from the
tunnel—-and say, we must telephone over and arrange about those keys.
There'll be a good deal of climbing, but the Prince is a good fellow,
and won't mind. It wouldn't be safe to try the elevator, for Harry
Weston would be in it taking somebody a bundle of tacks. The third
floor is nothing but store rooms; we'll not be disturbed up there, and
we can look right down the rotunda and see the whole show. Of course
we'll be discovered in time; some one is sure to look up and see us,
but we'll fix it so they won't see us before we've had our fun, and it
strikes me, McVeigh, that for two old fellows like you and me we've put
the thing through in pretty neat shape.”
It was a very small and unpretentious party which stepped from the
special at Water Street a little before two. The Prince was wearing a
long coat and an automobile cap and did not suggest anything at all
formidable or unusual. “You've saved the country,” Senator Patton
whispered in an aside. “He was getting bored. Never saw a fellow jolly
up so in my life. Guess he was just spoiling for some fun. Said it
would be really worth while to see somebody who wasn't looking for
Senator Bruner beamed. “That's just the point. He's caught my idea
It went without a hitch. “I feel,” said the Prince, as they were
hurrying him through the tunnel, “that I am a little boy who has run
away from school. Only I have a terrible fear that at any minute some
band may begin to play, and somebody may think of making a speech.”
They gave this son of a royal house a seat on a dry-goods box, so
placed that he could command a good view, and yet be fairly secure. The
final skirmish was on in earnest. Two State Senators—coatless,
tieless, collarless, their faces dirty, their hair rumpled, were
finishing the stair carpet. The chairman of the appropriations
committee in the House was doing the stretching in a still uncarpeted
bit of the corridor, and a member who had recently denounced the
appropriations committee as a disgrace to the State was presiding at
the hammer. They were doing most exquisitely harmonious team work. A
railroad and anti-railroad member who fought every time they came
within speaking distance of one another were now in an earnest and very
chummy conference relative to a large wrinkle which had just been
discovered on the first landing. Many men were standing around holding
their backs, and many others were deeply absorbed in nursing their
fingers. The doors of the offices were all open, and there was a
general hauling in of furniture and hanging of pictures. Clumsy but
well-meaning fingers were doing their best with “finishing touches.”
The Prince grew so excited about it all that they had to keep urging
him not to take too many chances of being seen.
“And I'll tell you,” Senator Bruner was saying, “it isn't only
because I knew it would be funny that I wanted you to see it;
but—well, you see America isn't the real America when she has on her
best clothes and is trying to show off. You haven't seen anybody who
hasn't prepared for your coming, and that means you haven't seen them
as they are at all. Now here we are. This is us! You see that fellow
hanging a picture down there? He's president of the First National
Bank. Came over a little while ago, got next to the situation, and
stayed to help. And—say, this is good! Notice that red-headed fellow
just getting up from his knees? Well, he's president of the teamsters'
union—figured so big in a strike here last year. I call that pretty
rich! He's the fellow they are all so afraid of, but I guess he liked
the idea of the boys doing it themselves, and just sneaked in and
helped.—There's the Governor. He's a fine fellow. He wouldn't be held
up by anybody—not even to get ready for a Prince, but he's worked like
a Trojan all day to make things come his way. Yes sir—this is the
sure-enough thing. Here you have the boys off dress parade. Not that we
run away from our dignity every day, but—see what I mean?”
“I see,” replied the Prince, and he looked as though he really did.
“You know—say, dodge there! Move back! No—too late. The Governor's
caught us. Look at him!”
The Governor's eyes had turned upward, and he had seen. He put his
hands on his back—he couldn't look up without doing that—and gave a
long, steady stare. First, Senator Bruner waved; then Senator Patton
waved; then Mr. McVeigh waved; and then the Prince waved. Other people
were beginning to look up. “They're all on,” laughed Patton, “let's go
At first they were disposed to think it pretty shabby treatment. “We
worked all day to get in shape,” grumbled Harry Weston, “and then you
go ring the curtain up on us before it's time for our show to begin.”
But the Prince made them feel right about it. He had such a good
time that they were forced to concede the move had been a success. And
he said to the Governor as he was leaving: “I see that the only way to
see America is to see it when America is not seeing you.”
VIII. THE LAST SIXTY MINUTES
“Nine—ten—” The old clock paused as if in dramatic appreciation of
the situation, and then slowly, weightily, it gave the final stroke,
The Governor swung his chair half-way round and looked the timepiece
full in the face. Already the seconds had begun ticking off the last
hour of his official life. On the stroke of twelve another man would be
Governor of the State. He sat there watching the movement of the minute
The sound of voices, some jovial, some argumentative, was borne to
him through the open transom. People were beginning to gather in the
corridors, and he could hear the usual disputes about tickets of
admission to the inaugural.
His secretary came in just then with some letters. “Could you see
Whitefield now?” he asked. “He's waiting out here for you.”
The old man looked up wearily. “Oh, put him off, Charlie. Tell him
you can talk to him about whatever it is he wants to know.”
The secretary had his hand on the knob, when the Governor added,
“And, Charlie, keep everybody out, if you can. I'm—I've got a few
private matters to go over.”
The younger man nodded and opened the door. He half closed it behind
him, and then turned to say, “Except Francis. You'll want to see him if
he comes in, won't you?”
He frowned and moved impatiently as he answered, curtly: “Oh, yes.”
Francis! Of course it never occurred to any of them that he could
close the door on Francis. He drummed nervously on his desk, then
suddenly reached down and, opening one of the drawers, tossed back a
few things and drew out a newspaper. He unfolded this and spread it out
on the desk. Running across the page was the big black line, “Real
Governors of Some Western States,” and just below, the first of the
series, and played up as the most glaring example of nominal and real
in governorship, was a sketch of Harvey Francis.
He sat there looking at it, knowing full well that it would not
contribute to his peace of mind. It did not make for placidity of
spirit to be told at the end of things that he had, as a matter of
fact, never been anybody at all. And the bitterest part of it was that,
looking back on it now, getting it from the viewpoint of one stepping
from it, he could see just how true was the statement: “Harvey Francis
has been the real Governor of the State; John Morrison his mouthpiece
He walked to the window and looked out over the January landscape.
It may have been the snowy hills, as well as the thoughts weighing him
down, that carried him back across the years to one snowy afternoon
when he stood up in a little red schoolhouse and delivered an oration
on “The Responsibilities of Statesmanship.” He smiled as the title came
back to him, and yet—what had become of the spirit of that
seventeen-year-old boy? He had meant it all then; he could remember the
thrill with which he stood there that afternoon long before and poured
out his sentiments regarding the sacredness of public trusts. What was
it had kept him, when his chance came, from working out in his life the
things he had so fervently poured into his schoolboy oration?
Someone was tapping at the door. It was an easy, confident tap, and
there was a good deal of reflex action in the Governor's “Come in.”
“Indulging in a little meditation?”
The Governor frowned at the way Francis said it, and the latter went
on, easily: “Just came from a row with Dorman. Everybody is holding him
up for tickets, and he—poor young fool—looks as though he wanted to
jump in the river. Takes things tremendously to heart—Dorman does.”
He lighted a cigar, smiling quietly over that youthful quality of
Dorman's. “Well,” he went on, leaning back in his chair and looking
about the room, “I thought I'd look in on you for a minute. You see
I'll not have the entree to the Governor's office by afternoon.”
He laughed, the easy, good-humoured laugh of one too sophisticated to
spend emotion uselessly.
It was he who fell into meditation then, and the Governor sat
looking at him; a paragraph from the newspaper came back to him:
“Harvey Francis is the most dangerous type of boss politician. His is
not the crude and vulgar method that asks a man what his vote is worth.
He deals gently and tenderly with consciences. He knows how to get a
man without fatally injuring that man's self-respect.”
The Governor's own experience bore out the summary. When elected to
office as State Senator he had cherished old-fashioned ideas of serving
his constituents and doing his duty. But the very first week Francis
had asked one of those little favours of him, and, wishing to show his
appreciation of support given him in his election, he had granted it.
Then various courtesies were shown him; he was let in on a “deal,” and
almost before he realised it, it seemed definitely understood that he
was a “Francis man.”
Francis roused himself and murmured: “Fools!—amateurs.”
“Leyman?” ventured the Governor.
“Leyman and all of his crowd!”
“And yet,” the Governor could not resist, “in another hour this same
fool will be Governor of the State. The fool seems to have won.”
Francis rose, impatiently. “For the moment. It won't be lasting. In
any profession, fools and amateurs may win single victories. They can't
keep it up. They don't know how. Oh, no,” he insisted,
cheerfully, “Leyman will never be re-elected. Fact is, I'm counting on
this contract business we've saved up for him getting in good work.” He
was moving toward the door. “Well,” he concluded, with a curious little
laugh, “see you upstairs.”
The Governor looked at the clock. It pointed now to twenty-five
minutes past eleven. The last hour was going fast. In a very short time
he must join the party in the anteroom of the House. But weariness had
come over him. He leaned back in his chair and closed his eyes.
He was close upon seventy, and to-day looked even older than his
years. It was not a vicious face, but it was not a strong one. People
who wanted to say nice things of the Governor called him pleasant or
genial or kindly. Even the men in the appointive offices did not
venture to say he had much force.
He felt it to-day as he never had before. He had left no mark; he
had done nothing, stood for nothing. Never once had his personality
made itself felt. He had signed the documents; Harvey Francis had
always “suggested”—the term was that man's own—the course to be
pursued. And the “suggestions” had ever dictated the policy that would
throw the most of influence or money to that splendidly organised
machine that Francis controlled.
With an effort he shook himself free from his cheerless retrospect.
There was a thing or two he wanted to get from his desk, and his time
was growing very short. He found what he wanted, and then, just as he
was about to close the drawer, his eye fell on a large yellow envelope.
He closed the drawer; but only to reopen it, take out the envelope
and remove the documents it contained; and then one by one he spread
them out before him on the desk.
He sat there looking down at them, wondering whether a man had ever
stepped into office with as many pitfalls laid for him. During the last
month they had been busy about the old State-house setting traps for
the new Governor. The “machine” was especially jubilant over those
contracts the Governor now had spread out before him. The convict
labour question was being fought out in the State just then—organised
labour demanding its repeal; country taxpayers insisting that it be
maintained. Under the system the penitentiary had become
self-supporting. In November the contracts had come up for renewal; but
on the request of Harvey Francis the matter had been put off from time
to time, and still remained open. Just the week before, Francis had put
it to the Governor something like this:
“Don't sign those contracts. We can give some reason for holding
them off, and save them up for Leyman. Then we can see that the
question is agitated, and whatever he does about it is going to prove a
bad thing for him. If he doesn't sign, he's in bad with the country
fellows, the men who elected him. Don't you see? At the end of his
administration the penitentiary, under you self-sustaining, will have
cost them a pretty penny. We've got him right square!”
The clock was close to twenty minutes of twelve, and he concluded
that he would go out and join some of his friends he could hear in the
other room. It would never do for him to go upstairs with a long,
serious face. He had had his day, and now Leyman was to have his, and
if the new Governor did better than the old one, then so much the
better for the State. As for the contracts, Leyman surely must
understand that there was a good deal of rough sailing on political
But it was not easy to leave the room. Walking to the window he
again stood there looking out across the snow, and once more he went
back now at the end of things to that day in the little red schoolhouse
which stood out as the beginning.
He was called back from that dreaming by the sight of three men
coming up the hill. He smiled faintly in anticipation of the things
Francis and the rest of them would say about the new Governor's
arriving on foot. Leyman had requested that the inaugural parade be
done away with—but one would suppose he would at least dignify the
occasion by arriving in a carriage. Francis would see that the opposing
papers handled it as a grand-stand play to the country constituents.
And then, forgetful of Francis, and of the approaching ceremony, the
old man stood there by the window watching the young man who was coming
up to take his place. How firmly the new Governor walked! With what
confidence he looked ahead at the State-house. The Governor—not
considering the inconsistency therein—felt a thrill of real pride in
thought of the State's possessing a man like that.
Standing though he did for the things pitted against him, down in
his heart John Morrison had all along cherished a strong admiration for
that young man who, as District Attorney of the State's metropolis, had
aroused the whole country by his fearlessness and unquestionable
sincerity. Many a day he had sat in that same office reading what the
young District Attorney was doing in the city close by—the fight he
was making almost single-handed against corruption, how he was striking
in the high places fast and hard as in the low, the opposition,
threats, and time after time there had been that same secret thrill at
thought of there being a man like that. And when the people of the
State, convinced that here was one man who would serve them,
began urging the District Attorney for chief executive, Governor
Morrison, linked with the opposing forces, doing all he could to bring
about Leyman's defeat, never lost that secret feeling for the young
man, who, unbacked by any organisation, struck blow after blow at the
machine that had so long dominated the State, winning in the end that
almost incomprehensible victory.
The new Governor had passed from sight, and a moment later his voice
came to the ear of the lonely man in the executive office. Some friends
had stopped him just outside the Governor's door with a laughing
“Here's hoping you'll do as much for us in the new office as you did in
the old,” and the new Governor replied, buoyantly: “Oh, but I'm going
to do a great deal more!”
The man within the office smiled a little wistfully and with a sigh
sat down before his desk. The clock now pointed to thirteen minutes of
twelve; they would be asking for him upstairs. There were some scraps
of paper on his desk and he threw them into the waste-basket,
murmuring: “I can at least give him a clean desk.”
He pushed his chair back sharply. A clean desk! The phrase opened to
deeper meanings.... Why not clean it up in earnest? Why not give him a
square deal—a real chance? Why not sign the contracts?
Again he looked at the clock—not yet ten minutes of twelve. For ten
minutes more he was Governor of the State! Ten minutes of real
governorship! Might it not make up a little, both to his own soul and
to the world, for the years he had weakly served as another man's
puppet? The consciousness that he could do it, that it was not within
the power of any man to stop him, was intoxicating. Why not break the
chains now at the last, and just before the end taste the joy of
He took up his pen and reached for the inkwell. With trembling,
excited fingers he unfolded the contracts. He dipped his pen into the
ink; he even brought it down on the paper; and then the tension broke.
He sank back in his chair, a frightened, broken old man.
“Oh, no,” he whispered; “no, not now. It's—” his head went lower
and lower until at last it rested on the desk—“too late.”
When he raised his head and grew more steady, it was only to see the
soundness of his conclusion. He had not the right now in the final hour
to buy for himself a little of glory. It would only be a form of
self-indulgence. They would call it, and perhaps rightly, hush money to
his conscience. They would say he went back on them only when he was
through with them. Oh, no, there would be no more strength in it than
in the average deathbed repentance. He would at least step out with
He folded the contracts and put them back into the envelope. The
minute hand now pointed to seven minutes to twelve. Some one was
tapping at the door, and the secretary appeared to say they were
waiting for him upstairs. He replied that he would be there in a
minute, hoping that his voice did not sound as strange to the other man
as it had to himself.
Slowly he walked to the door leading into the corridor. This, then,
was indeed the end; this the final stepping down from office! After
years of what they called public service, he was leaving it all now
with a sense of defeat and humiliation. A lump was in the old man's
throat; his eyes were blurred. “But you, Frank Leyman,” he whispered
passionately, turning as if for comfort to the other man, “it will be
different with you! They'll not get you—not you!”
It lifted him then as a great wave—this passionate exultation that
here was one man whom corruption could not claim as her own. Here was
one human soul not to be had for a price! There flitted before him
again a picture of that seventeen-year-old boy in the little red
schoolhouse, and close upon it came the picture of this other young man
against whom all powers of corruption had been turned in vain. With the
one it had been the emotional luxury of a sentiment, a thing from
life's actualities apart; with the other it was a force that dominated
all things else, a force over which circumstances and design could not
prevail. “I know all about it,” he was saying. “I know about it all! I
know how easy it is to fall! I know how fine it is to stand!”
His sense of disappointment in his own empty, besmirched career was
almost submerged then as he projected himself on into the career of
this other man who within the hour would come there in his stead. How
glorious was his opportunity, how limitless his possibilities, and how
great to his own soul the satisfaction the years would bring of having
done his best!
It had all changed now. That passionate longing to vindicate
himself, add one thing honourable and fine to his own record, had
altogether left him, and with the new mood came new insight and what
had been an impulse centred to a purpose.
It pointed to three minutes to twelve as he walked over to his desk,
unfolded the contracts, and one by one affixed his signature. In a dim
way he was conscious of how the interpretation of his first motive
would be put upon it, how they would call him traitor and coward; but
that mattered little. The very fact that the man for whom he was doing
it would never see it as it was brought him no pang. And when he had
carefully blotted the papers, affixed the seal and put them away, there
was in his heart the clean, sweet joy of a child because he had been
able to do this for a man in whom he believed.
The band was playing the opening strains as he closed the door
behind him and started upstairs.
IX. “OUT THERE”
The old man held the picture up before him and surveyed it with
admiring but disapproving eye. “No one that comes along this way'll
have the price for it,” he grumbled. “It'll just set here 'till
It did seem that the picture failed to fit in with the rest of the
shop. A persuasive young fellow who claimed he was closing out his
stock let the old man have it for what he called a song. It was only a
little out-of-the-way store which subsisted chiefly on the framing of
pictures. The old man looked around at his views of the city, his
pictures of cats and dogs and gorgeous young women, his flaming bits of
landscape. “Don't belong in here,” he fumed, “any more 'an I belong in
And yet the old man was secretly proud of his acquisition. He seemed
all at once to be lifted from his realm of petty tradesman to that of
patron of art. There was a hidden dignity in his scowling as he
shuffled about pondering the least ridiculous place for the picture.
It is not fair to the picture to try repainting it in words, for
words reduce it to a lithograph. It was a bit of a pine forest, through
which there exuberantly rushed an unspoiled little mountain stream.
Chromos and works of art may deal with kindred subjects. There is just
that one difference of dealing with them differently. “It ain't what
you see, so much as what you can guess is there,” was the
thought it brought to the old man who was dusting it. “Now this frame
ain't three feet long, but it wouldn't surprise me a bit if that timber
kept right on for a hundred miles. I kind of suspect it's on a
mountain—looks cool enough in there to be on a mountain. Wish I was
there. Bet they never see no such days as we do in Chicago. Looks as
though a man might call his soul his own—out there.”
He began removing some views of Lincoln Park and some corpulent
Cupids in order to make room in the window for the new picture. When he
went outside to look at it he shook his head severely and hastened in
to take away some ardent young men and women, some fruit and flowers
and fish which he had left thinking they might “set it off.” It was
evident that the new picture did not need to be “set off.” “And
anyway,” he told himself, in vindication of entrusting all his goods to
one bottom, “I might as well take them out, for the new one makes them
look so kind of sick that no one would have them, anyhow.” Then he went
back to mounting views with the serenity of one who stands for the
His clamorous little clock pointed to a quarter of six when he
finally came back to the front of the store. It was time to begin
closing up for the night, but for the minute he stood there watching
the crowd of workers coming from the business district not far away
over to the boarding-house region, a little to the west. He watched
them as they came by in twos and threes and fours: noisy people and
worn-out people, people hilarious and people sullen, the gaiety and the
weariness, the acceptance and the rebellion of humanity—he saw it
pass. “As if any of them could buy it,” he pronounced severely,
adding, contemptuously, “or wanted to.”
The girl was coming along by herself. He watched her as she crossed
to his side of the street, thinking it was too bad for a poor girl to
be as tired as that. She was dressed like many of the rest of them, and
yet she looked different—like the picture and the chromo. She turned
an indifferent glance toward the window, and then suddenly she stood
there very still, and everything about her seemed to change. “For all
the world,” he told himself afterward, “as if she'd found a long-lost
friend, and was 'fraid to speak for fear it was too good to be true.”
She did seem afraid to speak—afraid to believe. For a minute she
stood there right in the middle of the sidewalk, staring at the
picture. And when she came toward the window it was less as if coming
than as if drawn. What she really seemed to want to do was to edge
away; yet she came closer, as close as she could, her eyes never
leaving the picture, and then fear, or awe, or whatever it was made her
look so queer gave way to wonder—that wondering which is ready to open
the door to delight. She looked up and down the street as one rubbing
one's eyes to make sure of a thing, and then it all gave way to a joy
which lighted her pale little face like—“Well, like nothing I ever saw
before,” was all the old man could say of it. “Why, she'd never know if
the whole fire department was to run right up here on the sidewalk,” he
gloated. Just then she drew herself up for a long breath. “See?” he
chuckled, delightedly. “She knows it has a smell!” She looked toward
the door, but shook her head. “Knows she can't pay the price,” he
interpreted her. Then, she stepped back and looked at the number above
the door. “Coming again,” he made of that; “ain't going to run no
chances of losing the place.” And then for a long time she stood there
before the picture, so deeply and so strangely quiet that he could not
translate her. “I can't just get the run of it,” was his bewildered
conclusion. “I don't see why it should make anybody act like that.” And
yet he must have understood more than he knew, for suddenly he was
seeing her through a blur of tears.
As he began shutting up for the night he was so excited about the
way she looked when she finally turned away that it never occurred to
him to be depressed about her inability to pay the price.
He kept thinking of her, wondering about her, during the next day.
At a little before six he took up his station near the front window.
Once more the current of workers flowed by. “I'm an old fool,” he told
himself, irritated at the wait; “as if it makes any difference whether
she comes or not—when she can't buy it, anyhow. She's just as big a
fool as I am—liking it when she can't have it, only I'm the biggest
fool of all—caring whether she likes it or not.” But just then the
girl passed quickly by a crowd of girls who were ahead of her and came
hurrying across the street. She was walking fast, and looked excited
and anxious. “Afraid it might be gone,” he said—adding, grimly:
“Needn't worry much about that.”
She came up to the picture as some people would enter a church. And
yet the joy which flooded her face is not well known to churches. “I'll
tell you what it's like”—the old man's thoughts stumbling right into
the heart of it—“it's like someone that's been wandering round in a
desert country all of a sudden coming on a spring. She's thirsty
—she's drinking it in—she can't get enough of it. It's—it's the water
of life to her!” And then, ashamed of saying a thing that sounded as if
it were out of a poem, he shook his shoulders roughly as if to shake
off a piece of sentiment unbecoming his age and sex.
He went to the door and watched her as she passed away. “I'll bet
she'd never tip the scale to one hundred pounds,” he decided. “Looks
like a good wind could blow her away.” She stooped a little and just as
she passed from sight he saw that she was coughing.
Then the old man made what he prided himself was a great deduction.
“She's been there, and she wants to go back. This kind of takes her
back for a minute, and when she gets the breath of it she ain't so
All through those July days he watched each night for the
frail-looking little girl who liked the picture of the pines. She would
always come hurrying across the street in the same eager way, an
eagerness close to the feverish. But the tenseness would always relax
as she saw the picture. “She never looks quite so wilted down when she
goes away as she does when she comes,” the old man saw. “Upon my soul,
I believe she really goes there. It's—oh, Lord”—irritated at
getting beyond his depth—“I don't know!”
He never called it anything now but “Her Picture.” One day at just
ten minutes of six he took it out of the window. “Seems kind of mean,”
he admitted, “but I just want to find out how much she does think of
And when he found out he told himself that of all the mean men God
had ever let live, he was the meanest. The girl came along in the usual
hurried, anxious fashion. And when she saw the empty window he thought
for a minute she was going to sink right down there on the sidewalk.
Everything about her seemed to give way—as if something from which she
had been drawing had been taken from her. The luminousness gone from
her face, there were cruel revelations. “Blast my soul!” the old
man muttered angrily, not far from tearfully. She looked up and down
the noisy, dirty, parched street, then back to the empty window. For a
minute she just stood there—that was the worst minute of all. And
then—accepting—she turned and walked slowly away, walked as the
too-weary and the too-often disappointed walk.
It was with not wholly steady hand that the old man hastened to
replace the picture, all the while telling himself what he thought of
himself: more low-down than the cat who plays with the mouse, meaner
than the man who'd take the bone from the dog, less to be loved than
the man who would kick over the child's play-house, only to be compared
with the brute who would snatch the cup of water from the dying—such
were the verdicts he pronounced. He thought perhaps she would come
back, and stayed there until almost seven, waiting for her, though
pretending it was necessary that he take down and then put up again the
front curtains. All the next day he was restless and irritable. As if
to make up to the girl for the contemptible trick he had played he
spent a whole hour that afternoon arranging a tapestry background for
the picture. “She'll think,” he told himself, “that this was why it was
out, and won't be worried about its being gone again. This will just be
a little sign to her that it's here to stay.”
He began his watch that night at half-past five. After fifteen
minutes the thought came to him that she might be so disheartened she
would go home by another street. He became so gloomily certain she
would do this that he was jubilant when he finally saw her coming along
on the other side—coming purposelessly, shorn of that eagerness which
had always been able, for the moment, to vanquish the tiredness. But
when she came to the place where she always crossed the street she only
stood there an instant and then, a little more slowly, a little more
droopingly, walked on. She had given up! She was not coming over!
But she did come. After she had gone a few steps she hesitated again
and this time started across the street. “That's right,” approved the
old man, “never give up the ship!”
She passed the store as if she were not going to look in; she seemed
trying not to look, but her head turned—and she saw the picture. First
her body seemed to stiffen, and then something—he couldn't make out
whether or not it was a sob—shook her, and as she came toward the
picture on her white, tired face were the tears.
“Don't you worry,” he murmured affectionately to her retreating
form, “it won't never be gone again.”
The very next week he was put to the test. The kind of lady who did
not often pass along that street entered the shop and asked to see the
picture in the window. He looked at her suspiciously. Then he frowned
at her, as he stood there, fumbling. Her picture! What would she
think? What would she do? Then a crafty smile stole over his face and
he walked to the window and got the picture. “The price of this
picture, madame,” he said, haughtily, “is forty dollars,”—adding to
himself, “That'll fix her.”
But the lady made no comment, and stood there holding the picture up
before her. “I will take it,” she said, quietly.
He stared at her stupidly. Forty dollars! Then it must be that the
picture was better than the young man had known. “Will you wrap it,
please?” she asked. “I will take it with me.”
He turned to the back of the store. Forty dollars!—he kept
repeating it in dazed fashion. And they had raised the rent on him, and
the papers said coal would be high that winter—those facts seemed to
have something to do with forty dollars. Forty dollars!—it was
hammering at him, overwhelmed him, too big a sum to contend with. With
long, grim stroke he tore off the wrapping paper; stoically he began
folding it. But something was the matter. The paper would not go on
right. Three times he took it off, and each time he could not help
looking down at the picture of the pines. And each time the forest
seemed to open a little farther; each time it seemed bigger—bigger
even than forty dollars; it seemed as if it knew things—things
more important than even coal and rent. And then the strangest thing of
all happened: the forest faded away into its own shadowy distances, and
in its place was a noisy, crowded, sun-baked street, and across the
street was eagerly hurrying an anxious little girl, a frail little wisp
of a girl who probably should not be crossing hot, noisy streets at
all—then a light in tired eyes, a smile upon a worn face, relief as
from a cooling breeze—and anyway, suddenly furious at the lady,
furious at himself—“he'd be gol-darned if it wasn't her
He walked firmly back to the front of the store.
“I forgot at first,” he said, brusquely, “that this picture belongs
to someone else.”
The lady looked at him in astonishment. “I do not understand,” she
“There's nothing to understand,” he fairly shouted, “except that it
belongs to someone else!”
She turned away, but came back to him. “I will give you fifty
dollars for it,” she said, in her quiet way.
“Madame,” he thundered at her, “you can stand there and offer me
five hundred dollars, and I'm here to tell you that this picture is not
for sale. Do you hear?”
“I certainly do,” replied the lady, and walked from the store.
He was a long time in cooling off. “I tell you,” he stormed to a
very blue Lake Michigan he was putting into a frame, “it's hers—it's
hern—and anybody that comes along here with any nonsense is just
going to hear from me!”
In the days which followed he often thought to go out and speak to
her, but perhaps the old man had a restraining sense of values. He
planned some day to go out and tell her the picture was hers, but that
seemed a silly thing to tell her, for surely she knew it anyway. He
worried a good deal about her cough, which seemed to be getting worse,
and he had it all figured out that when cold weather came he would have
her come in where it was warm, and take her look in there. He felt that
he knew all about her, and though he did not know her name, though he
had never heard her speak one word, in some ways he felt closer to her
than to any one else in the world.
Yet if the old man had known just how it was with the girl it is
altogether unlikely that he would have understood. It would have
mystified and disappointed him had he known that she had never seen a
pine forest or a mountain in her life. Indeed there was a great deal
about the little girl which the old man, together with almost all the
rest of the world, would not have understood.
Not that the surface facts about her were either incomprehensible or
interesting. The tale of her existence would sound much like that of a
hundred other girls in the same city. Inquiry about her would have
developed the facts that she did typewriting for a land company, that
she did not seem to have any people, and lived at a big boarding-house.
At the boarding-house they would have told you that she was a nice
little thing, quiet as a mouse, and that it was too bad she had to
work, for she seemed more than half sick. There the story would have
rested, and the real things about her would not have been touched.
She worked for the Chicago branch of a big Northwestern land
company. They dealt in the lands of Idaho, Montana, Oregon and
Washington. The things she sat at her typewriter and wrote were of the
wonders of that great country: the great timber lands, the valleys and
hills, towering mountain peaks and rushing rivers. She typewrote
“literature” telling how there was a chance for every man out there,
how the big, exhaustless land was eager to yield of its store to all
who would come and seek. Day after day she wrote those things telling
how the sick were made well and the poor were made rich, how it was a
land of indescribable wonders which the feeble pen could not hope to
And the girl with whom almost everything in life had gone wrong came
to think of Out There as the place where everything was right. It was
the far country where there was no weariness nor loneliness, the land
where one did not grow tired, where one never woke up in the morning
too tired to get up, where no one went to bed at night too tired to go
to sleep. The street-cars did not ring their gongs so loud Out There,
the newsboys had pleasant voices, and there were no elevated trains. It
was a pure, high land which knew no smoke nor dirt, a land where great
silences drew one to the heart of peace, where the people in the next
room did not come in and bang things around late at night. Out There
was a wide land where buildings were far apart and streets were not
crowded. Even the horses did not grow tired Out There. Oh, it was a
land where dreams came true—a beautiful land where no one ate prunes,
where the gravy was never greasy and the potatoes never burned. It was
a land of flowers and birds and lovely people—a land of wealth and
health and many smiles.
Her imagination made use of it all. She knew how men were reclaiming
the desert of Idaho, of the tremendous undeveloped wealth of what had
been an almost undiscovered State. She thrilled to the poetry of
irrigation. Often when hot and tired and dusty her fancy would follow
the little mountain stream from its birth way up in the clouds, her
imagination rushing with it through sweetening forest and tumbling with
it down cooling rocks until finally strong, bold, wise men guided it to
the desert which had yearned for it through all the years, and the
grateful desert smiled rich smiles of grain and flowers. She could make
it more like a story than any story in any book. And she could always
breathe better in thinking of the pine forests of Oregon. There was
something liberating—expanding—in just the thought of them. She
dreamed cooling dreams about them, dreams of their reaching farther
than one's fancy could reach, big widening dreams of their standing
there serene in the consciousness of their own immensity. They stood to
her for a beautiful idea: the idea of space, of room—room for
everybody, and then much more room! Even one's understanding grew big
as one turned to them.
And she loved to listen for the Pacific Ocean, coming from
incomprehensible distances and unknowable countries, now rushing with
passion to the wild coast of Oregon, again stealing into the Washington
harbours. She loved to address the letters to Portland, Seattle,
Spokane, Tacoma—all those pulsing, vivid cities of a country of big
chances and big beauty. She loved to picture Seattle, a city builded
upon many hills—how wonderful that a city should be builded upon
hills!—in Chicago there was nothing that could possibly be thought of
as a hill. And she loved to shut her eyes and let the great mountain
peak grow in the distance, as one could see it from Portland—how noble
a thing to see a mountain peak from a city! Sometimes she trembled
before that consciousness of a mountain. Often when so tired she
scarcely knew what she was doing she found she was saying her prayers
to a mountain. Indeed, Out There seemed the place to send one's
prayers—for was it not a place where prayers were answered?
During that summer when the West was overrun with tourists who
grumbled about everything from the crowded trains to the way in which
sea-foods were served, this little girl sat in one of the hot office
buildings of Chicago and across the stretch of miles drew to herself
the spirit of that country of coming days. Thousands rode in Pullman
cars along the banks of the Columbia—saw, and felt not; she sat before
her typewriter in a close, noisy room and heard the cooling rush of
waters and got the freeing message of the pines. In some rare moments
when she rose from the things about her to the things of which she
dreamed she possessed the whole great land, and as the sultry days
sapped of her meagre strength, and the bending over the typewriter
cramped an already too cramped chest she clung with a more and more
passionate tenacity to the bigness and the beauty and rightness of
things Out There. And it was so kind to her—that land of deep breaths
and restoring breezes. It never shut her out. It always kept itself
bigger and more wonderful than one could ever hope to fancy it.
And the night she found the picture she knew that it was all really
so. That was why it was so momentous a night. The picture was a dream
visualised—a dreamer vindicated. They had pictures in the office, of
course—some pictures trying to tell of that very kind of a place. But
those were just pictures; this proved it, told what it meant. It
told that she had been right, and there was joy in knowing that she had
known. She clung to the picture as one would to that which proves as
real all one has long held dear, loved it as the dreamer loves that
which secures him in his dreaming.
She came to think of it as her own abiding place. Often when too
tired for long wings of fancy she would just sink down in the deep,
cool shadows of the pines, beside the little river which one knew so
well was the gift of distant snows. It rested her most of all; it
She smiled sometimes to think how no one in the office knew about
it, wondered what they would think if they knew. Often she would find
someone in the office looking at her strangely. She used to wonder
about it a little.
And then one day Mr. Osborne sent for her to come into his office.
He acted so queerly. As she came in and sat down near his desk he swung
his chair around and sat there with his back to her. After that he got
up and walked to the window.
The head stenographer had complained of her cough. She said she did
not think it right either to the girl or to the rest of them for her to
be there. She said she hated to speak of it, but could not stand it any
longer. That had been the week before, and ever since he had been
putting it off. But now he could put it off no longer; the head
stenographer was valuable, and besides he knew that she was right.
And so he told her—this was all he could think of just then—that
they were contemplating some changes in the office, and for a time
would have less desk room. If he sent her machine to her home, would
she be willing to do her work there for a while? Hers was the kind of
work that could be done at home.
She was sorry, for she wondered if she could find a place in her
room for the typewriter, and it did not seem there would be air enough
there to last her all day long. And she had grown fond of the office,
with its “literature” and pictures and maps and the men who had just
come from Out There coming in every once in a while. It was a bond—a
place to touch realities. But of course there was nothing for her to do
but comply, and she made no comment on the arrangement.
She pushed her chair back and rose to go. “Are you alone in the
world?” he asked abruptly then,
“Yes; I—oh yes.”
It was too much for him. “How would you like,” he asked recklessly,
“to have me get you transportation out West?”
She sank back in her chair. Every particle of colour had left her
face. Her deep eyes had grown almost wild. “Oh,” she gasped—“you can't
mean—you don't think—”
“You wouldn't want to go?”
“I mean”—it was but a whisper—“it would be—too wonderful.”
“You would like it then?”
She only nodded; but her lips were parted, her eyes glowing. He
wondered why he had never seen before how different looking and—yes,
beautiful, in a strange kind of way—she was.
“I see you have a cold,” he said, “and I think you would get along
better out there. I'll see if I can fix up the transportation, and get
something with our people in one of the towns that would be good for
She leaned back in her chair and sat there smiling at him. Something
in the smile made him say, abruptly: “That's all; you may go now, and
I'll send a boy with your machine.”
She walked through the streets as one who had already found another
country. More than one turned to look at her. She reached her room at
last and pulling her one little chair up to the window sat staring out
across the alley at the brick wall across from her. But she was not
seeing a narrow alley and a high brick wall. She was seeing rushing
rivers and mighty forests and towering peaks. She leaned back in her
chair—an indulgence less luxurious than it sounds, as the chair only
reached the middle of her back—and looked out at the high brick wall
and saw a snow-clad range of hills. But she was tired; this tremendous
idea was too much for her; the very wonder of it was exhausting. She
lay down on her bed—radiant, but languid. Soon she heard a rush of
waters. At first it was only someone filling the bath-tub, but after a
while it was the little stream which flowed through her forest. And
then she was not lying on a lumpy bed; she was sinking down under pine
trees—all so sweet and still and cool. But an awful thing was
happening!—the forest was on fire—it was choking and burning her! She
awoke to find smoke from the building opposite pouring into her room;
flies were buzzing about, and her face and hands were hot.
She did little work in the next few days. It was hard to go on with
the same work when waiting for a thing which was to make over one's
whole life. The stress of dreams changing to hopes caused a great
languor to come over her. And her chair was not right for her
typewriter, and the smoke came in all the time. Strangely enough Out
There seemed farther away. Sometimes she could not go there at all; she
supposed it was because she was really going.
At the close of the week she went to the office with her work. She
was weak with excitement as she stepped into the elevator. Would Mr.
Osborne have the transportation for her? Would he tell her when she was
But she did not see Mr. Osborne at all. When she asked for him the
clerk just replied carelessly that he was not there. She was going to
ask if he had left any message for her, but the telephone rang then and
the man to whom she was talking turned away. Someone was sitting at her
old desk, and they did not seem to be making the changes they had
contemplated; everyone in the office seemed very busy and uncaring, and
because she knew her chin was trembling she turned away.
She had a strange feeling as she left the office: as if standing on
ground which quivered, an impulse to reach out her hand and tell
someone that something must be done right away, a dreadful fear that
she was going to cry out that she could not wait much longer.
All at once she found that she was crossing the street, and saw
ahead the little art store with the wonderful picture which proved it
was all really so. In the same old way, her step quickened. It would
show her again that it was all just as she had thought it was, and if
that were true, then it must be true also that Mr. Osborne was going to
get her the transportation. It would prove that everything was all
But a cruel thing happened. It failed her. It was just as
beautiful—but something a long way off, impossible to reach. Try as
she would, she could not get into it, as she used to. It was
only a picture; a beautiful picture of some pine trees. And they were
very far away, and they had nothing at all to do with her.
Through the window, at the back of the store, she saw the old man
standing with his back to her. She thought of going in and asking to
sit down—she wanted to sit down—but perhaps he would say something
cross to her—he was such a queer looking old man—and she knew she
would cry if anything cross was said to her. That he had watched for
her each night, that he had tried and tried to think of a way of
finding her, that he would have been more glad to see her than to see
anyone in the world, would have been kinder to her than anyone on earth
would have been—those were the things she did not know. And so—more
lonely than she had ever been before—she turned away.
On Monday she felt she could wait no longer. It did not seem that it
would be safe. She got ready to go to see Mr. Osborne, but the
getting ready tired her so that she sat a long time resting, looking
out at the high brick wall beyond which there was nothing at all. She
was counting the blocks, thinking of how many times she would have to
cross the street. But just then it occurred to her that she could
When she came back upstairs she crept up on the bed and lay there
very still. The boy had said that Mr. Osborne was away and would be
gone two weeks. No one in the office had heard him say anything about
All through the day she lay there, and what she saw before her was a
narrow alley and a high brick wall. She had lost her mountains and her
forests and her rivers and her lakes. She tried to go out to them in
the same old way—but she could not get beyond the high brick wall. She
was shut in. She tried to draw them to her, but they could not come
across the wall. It shut them out. She tried to pray to the great
mountain which one could see from Portland. But even prayers could get
no farther than the wall.
Late that afternoon, because she was so shut in that she was
choking, because she was consumed with the idea that she must claim her
country now or lose it forever, she got up and started for the picture.
It was a long, long way to go, and dreadful things were in
between—people who would bump against her, hot, uneven streets, horses
that might run over her—but she must make the journey. She must make
it because the things that she lived on were slipping from her—and she
was choking—sinking down—and all alone.
Step by step, never knowing just how her foot was going to make the
next step, sick with the fear that people were going to run into
her—the streets going up and down, the buildings round and round, she
did go; holding to the window casings for the last few steps—each step
a terrible chasm which she was never sure she was going to be able to
cross—she was there at last. And in the window as she stood there,
swayingly, was a dark, blurred thing which might have been anything at
all. She tried to remember why she had come. What was it—? And
then she was sinking down into an abyss.
That the hemorrhage came then, that the old man came out and found
her and tenderly took her in, that he had her taken where she should
have been taken long before, that the doctors said it was too late, and
that soon their verdict was confirmed—those are the facts which would
seem to tell the rest of the story. But deep down beneath facts rests
truth, and the truth is that this is a story with the happiest kind of
a happy ending. What facts would call the breeze from an electric fan
was in truth the gracious breath of the pines. And when the nurse said
“She's going,” she was indeed going, but to a land of great spaces and
benign breezes, a land of deep shadows and rushing waters. For a most
wondrous thing had happened. She had called to the mountain, and the
mountain had heard her voice; and because it was so mighty and so
everlasting it drew her to itself, across high brick walls and past
millions of hurrying, noisy people—oh, a most triumphant flight! And
the mountain said—“I give you this whole great land. It is yours
because you have loved it so well. Hills and valleys and rivers and
forests and lakes—it is all for you.” Yes, the nurse was quite right;
she was going: going for a long sweet sleep beneath trees of many
shadows, beside clear waters which had come from distant snows—really
going “Out There.”
X. THE PREPOSTEROUS MOTIVE
The Governor was sitting alone in his private office with an open
letter in his hand. He was devoutly and gloomily wishing that some
other man was just then in his shoes. The Governor had not devoted a
large portion of his life to nursing a desire of that nature, for he
was a man in whose soul the flame of self-satisfaction glowed
cheeringly; but just now there were reasons, and he deemed them ample,
for deploring that he had been made chief executive of his native
Had he chosen to take you into his confidence—a thing the Governor
would assuredly choose not to do—he would have told you there were
greater things in the world than the governorship of that State. He
might have suggested a seat in the Senate of the United States as one
of those things. It was of the United States Senate his Excellency was
thinking as he sat there alone moodily deploring the gubernatorial
The senior Senator was going to die. He differed therein from his
fellows in that he was going to die soon, almost immediately. He had
reached the tottering years even at the time of his reelection, and it
had never been supposed that his life would outstretch his term. He had
been sent back, not for another six years of service, but to hold out
the leader of the Boxers, as they called themselves—the younger and
unorthodox element of the party in the State, an element growing to
dangerous proportions. It was only by returning the aged Senator, whom
they held it would be brutal to turn down after a life of service to
the party, that the “machine” won the memorable fight of the previous
From the viewpoint of the machine, the Governor was the senior
Senator's logical successor. Had it not been for the heavy inroads of
the Boxers, his Excellency would even then have been sitting in the
Senate Chamber at Washington. It had not been considered safe to
nominate the Governor. Had his supporters conceded that the time was at
hand for a change, there would have been a general clamour for the
leader of the Boxers—Huntington, undeniably the popular man of the
State. And so they concocted a beautiful sentiment about “rounding out
the veteran's career,” and letting him “die with his boots on”; and
through the omnipotence of sentiment, they won.
Down in his heart the venerable Senator was not seeking to die with
his boots on. He would have preferred sitting in a large chair before
the fire and reading quietly of what other men were doing in the Senate
of the United States. But they told him he must sacrifice that wish,
for if he retired he would be succeeded by a dangerous man. And the old
man, believing them, had gone dutifully back into the arena.
Now it seemed that a power outside man's control was declaring
against the well-laid plans of the machine. As the machine saw things,
the time was not ripe for the senior Senator to die. He had just
entered upon his new term, and the Governor himself had but lately
stepped into a second term. They had assumed that the Senator would
live on for at least two years, but now they heard that he was likely
to die almost at once. His Excellency could not very well name himself
for the vacancy, and it seemed dangerous just then to risk a call of
the Assembly. They dared not let the Governor appoint a weaker man,
even if he would consent to do so, for they would need the best they
had to put up against the leader of the Boxers. With the Governor, they
believed they could win, but the question of appointing him had
suddenly become a knotty one.
The Governor himself was bowed with chagrin. He saw now that he had
erred in taking a second term, and he was not the man to enjoy
reviewing his mistakes. As he sat there reading and rereading the
letter which told him that the work of the senior Senator was almost
done, he said to himself that it was easy enough to wrestle with men,
but a harder thing to try one's mettle with fate. He spent a gloomy and
Late in the afternoon a telegram reached the executive office.
Styles was coming to town that night, and wanted to see the Governor at
the hotel. Things always cleared when Styles came to town; and so,
though still unable to foresee the outcome, he brightened at once.
Styles was a railroad man, and rich. People to whom certain things
were a sealed book said that it was nice of Mr. Styles to take an
interest in politics when he had so many other things on his mind, and
that he must be a very public-spirited man. That he took an interest in
politics, no one familiar with the affairs of the State would deny. The
orthodox papers painted him as a public benefactor, but the Boxers
arrayed him with hoofs and horns.
The Governor and Mr. Styles were warm friends. It was said that
their friendship dated from mere boyhood, and that the way the two men
had held together through all the vicissitudes of life was touching and
beautiful—at least, so some people observed. There were others whose
eyebrows went up when the Governor and Mr. Styles were mentioned in
their Damon and Pythias capacity.
That night, in the public benefactor's room at the hotel, the
Governor and his old friend had a long talk. When twelve o'clock came
they were still talking; more than that, the Governor was excitedly
pacing the floor.
“I tell you, Styles,” he expostulated, “I don't like it! It doesn't
put me in a good light. It's too apparent, and I'll suffer for it, sure
as fate. Mark my words, we'll all suffer for it!”
Mr. Styles was sitting in an easy attitude before the table. The
public benefactor never paced the floor; it did not seem necessary. He
smoked in silence for a minute; then raised himself a little in his
“Well, have you anything better to offer?”
“No, I haven't,” replied the Governor, tartly; “but it seems to me
you ought to have.”
Styles sank back in his chair and for several minutes more devoted
himself to the art of smoking. There were times when this philanthropic
dabbler in politics was irritating.
“I think,” he began presently, “that you exaggerate the unpleasant
features of the situation. It will cause talk, of course; but isn't it
worth it? You say it's unheard of; maybe, but so is the situation, and
wasn't there something in the copy-books about meeting new situations
with new methods? If you have anything better to offer, produce it; if
not, we've got to go ahead with this. And really, I don't see that it's
so bad. You have to go South to look after your cotton plantation; you
find now that it's going to take more time than you feel you should
take from the State; you can't afford to give it up; consequently, you
withdraw in favor of the Lieutenant-Governor. We all protest, but you
say Berriman is a good man, and the State won't suffer, and you simply
can't afford to go on. Well, we can keep the Senator's condition pretty
quiet here; and after all, he's sturdy, and may live on to the close of
the year. After due deliberation Berriman appoints you. A little
talk?—Yes. But it's worth a little talk. It seems to me the thing
works out very smoothly.”
When Tom Styles leaned back in his chair and declared a thing worked
out very smoothly, that thing was quite likely to go. In three days the
Governor went South. When he returned, the newspaper men were startled
by the announcement that business considerations which he could not
afford to overlook demanded his withdrawal from office. Previous to
this time the Lieutenant-Governor and Mr. Styles had met and the result
of their meeting was not made a matter of public record.
As the Governor had anticipated, many things were said. Inquiries
were made into the venerable Senator's condition—which, the orthodox
papers declared, was but another example of the indecency of the Boxer
journals. The Governor went to his cotton plantation. The
Lieutenant-Governor went into office, and was pronounced a worthy
successor to a good executive. The venerable Senator continued to live.
As Mr. Styles had predicted, the gossip soon quieted into a friendly
hope that the Governor would realise large sums with his cotton.
It was late in the fall when the senior Senator finally succumbed.
The day the papers printed the story of his death, they printed
speculative editorials on his probable successor. When the bereaved
family commented with bitterness on this ill-concealed haste, they were
told that it was politics—enterprise—life.
The old man's remains lay in state in the rotunda of the State
Capitol, and the building was draped in mourning. Many came and looked
upon the quiet face; but far more numerous than those who gathered at
his bier to weep were those who assembled in secluded corners to
speculate on the wearing of his toga. It was
Mr. Styles told the Lieutenant-Governor to be deliberate. There was
no need of an immediate appointment, he said. And so for a time things
went on about the State-house much as usual, save that the absorbing
topic was the senatorial situation, and that every one was watching the
new chief executive. The retired Governor now spent part of his time in
the South, and part at home. The cotton plantation was not demanding
all his attention, after all.
It could not be claimed that John Berriman had ever done any great
thing. He was not on record as having ever risen grandly to an
occasion; but there may have been something in the fact that an
occasion admitting of a grand rising had never presented itself. Before
he became Lieutenant-Governor, he had served inoffensively in the State
Senate for two terms. No one had ever worked very hard for Senator
Berriman's vote. He had been put in by the machine, and it had always
been assumed that he was machine property.
Berriman himself had never given the matter of his place in the
human drama much thought. He had an idea that it was proper for him to
vote with his friends, and he always did it. Had he been called a tool,
he would have been much ruffled; he merely trusted to the infallibility
of the party.
The Boxers did not approach him now concerning the appointment of
Huntington. That, of course, was a fixed matter, and they were not
young and foolish enough to attempt to change it.
One day the Governor received a telegram from Styles suggesting that
he “adjust that matter” immediately. He thought of announcing the
appointment that very night, but the newspaper men had all left the
building, and as he had promised that they should know of it as soon as
it was made, he concluded to wait until the next morning.
Governor Berriman had a brother in town that week, attending a
meeting of the State Agricultural Society. Hiram Berriman had a large
farm in the southern part of the State. He knew but little of political
methods, and had primitive ideas about honesty. There had always been a
strong tie between the brothers, despite the fact that Hiram was
fifteen years the Governor's senior. They talked of many things that
night, and the hour was growing late. They were about to retire when
the Governor remarked, a little sleepily:
“Well, to-morrow morning I announce the senatorial appointment.”
“You do, eh?” returned the farmer.
“Yes, there's no need of waiting any longer, and it's getting on to
the time the State wants two senators in Washington.”
“Well, I suppose, John,” Hiram said, turning a serious face to his
brother, “that you've thought the matter all over, and are sure you are
The Governor threw back his head with a scoffing laugh.
“I guess it didn't require much thought on my part,” he answered
“I don't see how you figure that out,” contended Hiram warmly.
“You're Governor of the State, and your own boss, ain't you?”
It was the first time in all his life that anyone had squarely
confronted John Berriman with the question whether or not he was his
own boss, and for some reason it went deep into his soul, and rankled
“Now see here, Hiram,” he said at length, “there's no use of your
putting on airs and pretending you don't understand this thing. You
know well enough it was all fixed before I went in.” The other man
looked at him in bewilderment, and the Governor continued brusquely:
“The party knew the Senator was going to die, and so the Governor
pulled out and I went in just so the thing could be done decently when
the time came.”
The old farmer was scratching his head.
“That's it, eh? They got wind the Senator was goin' to die, and so
the Governor told that lie about having to go South just so he could
step into the dead man's shoes, eh?”
“That's the situation—if you want to put it that way.”
“And now you're going to appoint the Governor?”
“Of course I am; I couldn't do anything else if I wanted to.”
“Why, look here, Hiram, haven't you any idea of political
obligation? It's expected of me.”
“Oh, it is, eh? Did you promise to appoint the Governor?”
“Why, I don't know that I exactly made any promises, but that
doesn't make a particle of difference. The understanding was that the
Governor was to pull out and I was to go in and appoint him. It's a
matter of honour;” and Governor Berriman drew himself up with pride.
The farmer turned a troubled face to the fire.
“I suppose, then,” he said finally, “that you all think the Governor
is the best man we have for the United States Senate. I take it that in
appointing him, John, you feel sure he will guard the interests of the
people before everything else, and that the people—I mean the working
people of this State—will always be safe in his hands; do you?”
“Oh, Lord, no, Hiram!” exclaimed the Governor irritably. “I don't
think that at all!”
Hiram Berriman's brown face warmed to a dull red.
“You don't?” he cried. “You mean to sit there, John Berriman, and
tell me that you don't think the man you're going to put in the United
States Senate will be an honest man? What do you mean by saying you're
going to put a dishonest man in there to make laws for the people, to
watch over them and protect them? If you don't think he's a good man,
if you don't think he's the best man the State has”—the old farmer was
pounding the table heavily with his huge fist—“if you don't think
that, in God's name, why do you appoint him?”
“I wish I could make you understand, Hiram,” said the Governor in an
injured voice, “that it's not for me to say.”
“Why ain't it for you to say? Why ain't it, I want to know? Who's
running you, your own conscience or some gang of men that's trying to
steal from the State? Good God, I wish I had never lived to see the day
a brother of mine put a thief in the United States Senate to bamboozle
the honest, hard-working people of this State!”
“Hold on, please—that's a little too strong!” flamed the Governor.
“It ain't too strong. If a Senator ain't an honest man, he's a
thief; and if he ain't lookin' after the welfare of the people, he's
bamboozlin' them, and that's all there is about it. I don't know much
about politics, but I ain't lived my life without learning a little
about right and wrong, and it's a sorry day we've come to, John
Berriman, if right and wrong don't enter into the makin' of a Senator!”
The Governor could think of no fitting response, so he held his
peace. This seemed to quiet the irate farmer, and he surveyed his
brother intently, and not unkindly.
“You're in a position now, John,” he said, and there was a kind of
homely eloquence in his serious voice, “to be a friend to the people.
It ain't many of us ever get the chance of doin' a great thing. We work
along, and we do the best we can with what comes our way, but most of
us don't get the chance to do a thing that's goin' to help thousands of
people, and that the whole country's goin' to say was a move for the
right. You want to think of that, and when you're thinkin' so much
about honour, you don't want to clean forget about honesty. Don't you
stick to any foolish notions about bein' faithful to the party; it
ain't the party that needs helpin'. No matter how you got where you
are, you're Governor of the State right now, John, and your first duty
is to the people of this State, not to Tom Styles or anybody else. Just
you remember that when you're namin' your Senator in the morning.”
It was long before the Governor retired. He sat there by the
fireplace until after the fire had died down, and he was too absorbed
to grow cold. He thought of many things. Like the man who had preceded
him in office, he wished that some one else was just then encumbered
with the gubernatorial shoes.
The next morning there was a heavy feeling in his head which he
thought a walk in the bracing air might dispel, so he started on foot
for the Statehouse. A light snow was on the ground, and there was
something reassuring in the crispness of the morning. It would make a
slave feel like a free man to drink in such air, he was thinking.
Snatches of his brother's outburst of the night before kept breaking
into his consciousness but curiously enough they did not greatly
disturb him. He concluded that it was wonderful what a walk in the
bracing air could do. From the foot of the hill he looked up at the
State-house, for the first time in his experience seeing and thinking
about it—not simply taking it for granted. There seemed a nobility
about it—in the building itself, and back of that in what it stood
As he walked through the corridor to his office he was greeted with
cheerful, respectful salutations. His mood let him give the greetings a
value they did not have and from that rose a sense of having the trust
and goodwill of his fellows.
But upon reaching his desk he found another telegram from Styles. It
was imperatively worded and as he read it the briskness and
satisfaction went from his bearing. He walked to the window and stood
there looking down at the city, and, as it had been in looking ahead at
the State-house, he now looked out over the city really seeing and
understanding it, not merely taking it for granted. He found himself
wondering if many of the people in that city—in that State—looked to
their Governor with the old-fashioned trust his brother had shown. His
eyes dimmed; he was thinking of the satisfaction it would afford his
children, if—long after he had gone—they could tell how a great
chance had once come into their father's life, and how he had proved
himself a man.
“Will you sign these now, Governor?” asked a voice behind him.
It was his secretary, a man who knew the affairs of the State well,
and whom every one seemed to respect.
“Mr. Haines,” he said abruptly, “who do you think is the best man we
have for the United States Senate?”
The secretary stepped back, dumfounded; amazed that the question
should be put to him, startled at that strange way of putting it. Then
he told himself he must be discreet. Like many of the people at the
State-house, in his heart Haines was a Boxer.
“Why, I presume,” he ventured, “that the Governor is looked upon as
the logical candidate, isn't he?”
“I'm not talking about logical candidates. I want to know who you
think is the man who would most conscientiously and creditably
represent this State in the Senate of the United States.”
It was so simply spoken that the secretary found himself answering
it as simply. “If you put it that way, Governor, Mr. Huntington is the
man, of course.”
“You think most of the people feel that way?”
“I know they do.”
“You believe if it were a matter of popular vote, Huntington would
be the new Senator?”
“There can be no doubt of that, Governor. I think they all have to
admit that. Huntington is the man the people want.”
“That's all, Mr. Haines. I merely wondered what you thought about
Soon after that Governor Berriman rang for a messenger boy and sent
a telegram. Then he settled quietly down to routine work. It was about
eleven when one of the newspaper men came in.
“Good-morning, Governor,” he said briskly “how's everything to-day?”
“All right, Mr. Markham. I have nothing to tell you to-day, except
that I've made the senatorial appointment.”
“Oh,” laughed the reporter excitedly, “that's all, is it?”
“Yes,” replied the Governor, smiling too; “that's all!”
The reporter looked at the clock. “I'll just catch the noon
edition,” he said, “if I telephone right away.”
He was moving to the other room when the Governor called to him.
“See here, it seems to me you're a strange newspaper man!”
“Why, I tell you I've made a senatorial appointment—a matter of
some slight importance—and you rush off never asking whom I've
The reporter gave a forced laugh. He wished the Governor would not
detain him with a joke now when every second counted.
“That's right,” he said, with strained pleasantness. “Well, who's
The Governor raised his head. “Huntington,” he said quietly, and
resumed his work.
“What?” gasped the reporter. “What?”
Then he stopped in embarrassment, as if ashamed of being so easily
taken in. “Guess you're trying to jolly me a little, aren't you,
“Jolly you, Mr. Markham? I'm not given to 'jollying' newspaper
reporters. Here's a copy of the telegram I sent this morning, if you
are still sceptical. Really, I don't see why you think it so
impossible. Don't you consider Mr. Huntington a fit man for the place?”
But for the minute the reporter seemed unable to speak. “May I ask,”
he fumbled at last, “why you did it?”
“I had but one motive, Mr. Markham. I thought the matter over and it
seemed to me the people should have the man they wanted. I am with them
in believing Huntington the best man for the place.” He said it simply,
and went quietly back to his work.
For many a long day politicians and papers continued the search for
“the motive.” Styles and his crowd saw it as a simple matter of selling
out; they knew, of course, that it could be nothing else. After their
first rage had subsided, and they saw there was nothing they could do,
they wondered, sneeringly, why he did not “fix up a better story.” That
was a little too simple-minded. Did he think people were fools?
And even the men who profited by the situation puzzled their brains for
weeks trying to understand it. There was something behind it, of
XI. HIS AMERICA
He hated to see the reporter go. With the closing of that door it
seemed certain that there was no putting it off any longer.
But even when the man's footsteps were at last sounding on the
stairway, he still clung to him.
“Father,” he asked, fretfully, “why do you always talk to those
Herman Beckman turned in his chair and stared at his son. Then he
laughed. “Now, that's a fine question to come from the honour man of a
law school! I hope, Fritz, that your oration to-night is going to have
a little more sense in it than that.”
The calling up of his oration made him reach out another clutching
hand to the vanished reporter. “But it's farcical, father, to be always
interviewed by a paper nobody reads.”
“Why, nobody cares anything about the Leader. It's dead.”
Herman Beckman looked at his son sharply; something about him seemed
strange. He decided that he was nervous about the commencement
programme. Fritz had the one oration.
The boy had opened the drawer of his study table and was fingering
some papers he had taken out.
“Sure you know it?” the man asked with affectionate parental
“Oh, I know it all right,” Fred answered grimly, and again the
father decided that he was nervous about the thing. He wasn't just like
The man walked to the window and stood looking across at the
university buildings. Colleges had always meant much to Herman Beckman.
The very day Fritz was born he determined that the boy was to go to
college. It was good to witness the fulfilment of his dreams. He turned
his glance to the comfortable room.
“Pretty decent comfortable sort of place, isn't it, father?” Fred
asked, following his father's look and thought from the Morris chair to
the student's lamp, and all those other things which nowadays seem an
inevitable part of the acquirement of learning.
It made his father laugh. “Yes, my boy, I should call it decent—and
comfortable.” He grew thoughtful after that.
“Pretty different from the place you had, father?”
“Oh—me? My place to study was any place I could find. Sometimes on
top of a load of hay, lots of times by the light of the logs. I've
studied in some funny places, Fritz.”
“Well, you got there, father!” the boy burst out with
feeling. “By Jove, there aren't many of them know the things you
“I know enough to know what I don't know,” said the old man, a
little sadly. “I know enough to know what I missed. I wanted to go to
college. No one will ever know how I wanted to! I began to think I'd
never feel right about it. But I have a notion that when I sit there
to-night listening to you, Fritz, knowing that you're speaking for two
hundred boys, half of whose fathers did go to college, I think I'm
going to feel better about it then.”
The boy turned away. Something in the kindly words seemed as the cut
of a whip across his face.
“Well, Fritz,” his father continued, getting into his coat, “I'll be
going downtown. Leave you to put on an extra flourish or two.” He
laughed in proud parental fashion. “Anyway, I have some things to see
The boy stood up. “Father, I have something to tell you.” He said it
shortly and sharply.
The father stood there, puzzled.
“You won't like my oration to-night, father.”
And still the man did not speak. The words would not have bothered
him much—it was the boy's manner.
“In fact, father, you're going to be desperately disappointed in
The dull red was creeping into the man's cheeks. He was one to have
little patience with that thing of not doing one's work. “Why am I
going to be disappointed? This is no time to shirk! You should—”
“Oh, you'll not complain of the time and thought I've put on it,”
the boy broke in with a short, hard laugh. “But, you see, father—you
see”—his armour had slipped from him—“it doesn't express—your
“Did I ever say I wanted you to express 'my views'? Did I bring you
up to be a mouthpiece of mine? Haven't I told you to think?” But
with a long, sharp glance at his boy anger gave way. “Come, boy”—going
over and patting him on the back—“brace up now. You're acting like a
seven-year-old girl afraid to speak her first piece,” and his big laugh
rang out, eager to reassure.
“You won't see it! You won't believe it! I don't suppose you'll
believe it when you hear it!” He turned away, overwhelmed by a sudden
realisation of just how difficult was the thing that lay before him.
The man started toward his son, but instead he walked over and sat
down at the opposite side of the table, waiting. He was beginning to
see that there was something in this which he did not understand.
At last the boy turned to him, fighting back some things, taking on
other things. He gazed at the care-worn, rugged face—face of a worker
and a dreamer, reading in those lines the story of that life, seeing
more clearly than he had ever seen before the beauty and futility of
it. Here was the idealist, the man who would give his whole lifetime to
a dream he had dreamed. He loved his father very tenderly as he looked
at him, read him, then.
“Father,” he asked quietly, “are you satisfied with your life?”
The man simply stared—waiting, seeking his bearings.
“You came to this country when you were nineteen years old—didn't
you, father?” The man nodded. “And now you're—it's sixty-one, isn't
Again he nodded.
“You've been in America, then, forty-two years. Father, do you think
as much of it now as you did forty-two years ago?”
“I don't know what you mean,” the man said, searching his son's
quiet, passionate face. “I can't make you out, Fritz.”
“My favourite story as a kid,” the boy went on, “was to hear you
tell of how you felt when your boat came sailing into New York Harbour,
and you saw the first outlines of a country you had dreamed about all
through your boyhood, which you had saved pennies for, worked nights
for, ever since you were old enough to know the meaning of America. I
mean,” he corrected, significantly, “the meaning of what you thought
“It's a bully story, father,” he continued, with a smile at once
tender and hard; “the simple German boy, born a dreamer, standing there
looking out at the dim shores of that land he had idealised. If ever a
man came to America bringing it rich gifts, that man was you!”
“Fritz,” his father's voice was rendered harsh by mystification and
foreboding, “tell me what you're talking about. Come to the point.
Clear this up.”
“I'm talking about American politics—your party—having ruined your
life! I'm talking about working like a slave all your days and having
nothing but a mortgaged farm at sixty-one! I'm talking about playing a
losing game! I'm saying, What's the use? Father, I'm telling you
that I'm going to join the other party and make some money!”
The man just sat there, staring.
“Well,” the boy took it up defiantly, “why not?”
And then he moved, laid a not quite steady hand out upon the table.
“My boy, you're not well. You've studied too hard. Now brace yourself
up for to-night, and then we'll go down home and fix you up. What you
need, Fritz,” he said, trying to laugh, “is the hayfield.”
“You're not seeing it!” The boy pushed back his chair and
began moving about the room. “The only way I can brace myself up for
to-night is to get so mad—father, usually you see things so easily!
Don't you understand? It was my chance, my one moment, my time to
strike. It will be years before I get such a hearing again. You see,
father, the thing will be printed, and the men I want to have hear it,
the men who own this State, will be there. One of them is to
preside. And the story of it, the worth of it, to them, is that I'm
your son. You see, after all,” he seized at this wildly, “I'm getting
my start on the fact that I'm your son.”
“Go on,” said the man; the brown of his wind-beaten face had yielded
to a tinge of grey. “Just what is it you are going to say?”
“I call it 'The New America,' a lot of this talk about doing things,
the glory of industrial America, the true Americans the men of
constructive genius, the patriotism of railroad and factory building, a
eulogy of railroad officials and corporation presidents,” he rushed on
with a laugh. “Singing the song of Capital. Father, can't you see
The old man had risen. “Tell me this,” he said. “None of it matters
much, if you just tell me this: You believe these things? You've
thought it all out for yourself—and you feel that way? You're
honest, aren't you, Fritz?” He put that last in a whisper.
The boy made no reply; after a minute the man sank back to his
chair. The years seemed coming to him with the minutes.
Fred was leaning against the wall. “Father,” he said at last, “I
hope you'll let me be a little roundabout. It's only fair to me to let
me ramble on a little. I've got to put it all right before you
or—or—You know, dad,”—he came back to his place by the table, “the
first thing I remember very clearly is those men, your party managers,
coming down to the farm one time and asking you to run for Governor.
How many times is it you've run for Governor, father?” He put the
“Five,” said the man heavily.
“I don't know which time this was; but you didn't want to. You were
sorry when you saw them coming. I heard some of the talk. You talked
about your farm, what you wanted to do that summer, how you couldn't
afford the time or the money. They argued that you owed it to the
party—they always got you there; how no other man could hold down
majorities as you could—a man like you giving the best years of his
life to holding down majorities! They said you were the one man against
whom no personal attack could be made. And when there was so much to
fight, anyway—oh, I know that speech by heart! They've made great
capital of your honesty and your clean life. In fact, they've held that
up as a curtain behind which a great many things could go on. Oh,
you didn't know about them; you were out in front of the curtain,
but I haven't lived in this town without finding out that they needed
your integrity and your clean record pretty bad!
“That was out on the side porch. Mother had brought out some
buttermilk, and they drank it while they talked. You put up a good
fight. Your time was money to you at that time of year; a man shouldn't
neglect his farm—but you never yet could hold out against that
'needing-you' kind of talk. They knew there was no chance for your
election. You knew it. But it takes a man of just your grit to put any
snap into a hopeless campaign.
“Mother cried when you went to drive them back to town. You see, I
remember all those things. She told about how hard you would work, and
how it would do no good—that the State belonged to the other party.
She talked about the farm, too, and the addition she had wanted for the
house, and how now she wouldn't have it. Mother felt pretty bad that
night. She's gone through a lot of those times.”
There was a silence.
“You were away a lot that summer, and all fall. You looked pretty
well used up when you came home, but you said that you had held down
Again there was silence. It was the silences that seemed to be
saying the most.
“You had one term in Congress—that's the only thing you ever had.
Then you did so much that they concentrated in your district and saw to
it that you never got back. Julius Caesar couldn't have been elected
again,” he laughed harshly.
“Father,” the boy went on, after a pause, “you asked me if I were
honest. There are two kinds of honesty. The primitive kind—like
yours—and then the kind you develop for yourself. Do I believe the
things I'm going to say to-night? No—not now. But I'll believe them
more after I've heard the applause I'm sure to get. I'll believe them
still more after I've had my first case thrown to me by our railroad
friends who own this State. More and more after I've said them over in
campaigning next fall, and pretty soon I'll be so sure I believe them
that I really will believe them—and that,” he concluded, flippantly,
“is the new brand of American honesty. Why, any smart man can persuade
himself he's not a hypocrite!”
“My God!” it wrenched from the man. “This? If you'd
stolen money—killed a man—but hypocrisy, cant—the very thing I've
fought hardest, hated most! You lived all your life with me to learn
“I lived all my life with you to learn what pays, and what doesn't.
I lived all my life with you to learn from failure the value of
“I never was sure I was a failure until this hour.”
“Father! Can't you see—”
“Oh, don't talk to me!” cried the old man, rising, reaching
out his fist as though he would strike him. “Son of mine sitting there
telling me he is fixing up a brand of honesty for himself!”
The boy grew quieter as self-restraint left his father. “I mean
that—just that,” he said at last. “Let a man either give or get. If he
gives, let it be to the real thing. There are two Americas. The America
of you dreamers—and then the real America. Yours is an idea—an idea
quite as much as an ideal. I don't think you have the slightest
comprehension of how far apart it is from the real America. The people
who dream of it over in Europe are a great deal nearer it than you
people who work for it here. Father, the spirit of this country flows
in a strong, swift, resistless current. You never got into it at all.
Your kind of idealists influence it about as much—about as much as red
lights burned on the banks of the great river would influence the
current of that river. You're not of it. You came here,
throbbing with the love for America; and with your ideal America you've
fought the real, and you've worked and you've believed and you've
sacrificed. Father, what's the use? In this State, anyway, it's
hopeless. It has been so through your lifetime; it will be through
The man sat looking at him. He felt that he should say something,
but the words did not come—held back, perhaps, by a sense of their
uselessness. It was not so much what Fred said as it was the look in
his eyes as he said it. There was nothing impetuous or youthful about
that look, nothing to be laughed at or argued away. He had always felt
that Fred had a mind which saw things straight, saw them in their right
relations, and at that moment he had no words to plead for what Fred
called the America of the dreamers.
“I'm of the second generation, dad,” the boy went on, at length,
“and the second generation has an ideal of its own, and that ideal is
Success. It took us these forty years to come to understand the spirit
of America. You were a dreamer who loved America. I'm an American.
We've translated democracy and brotherhood and equality into enterprise
and opportunity and success—and that's getting Americanised. Now,
father,” he sought refuge in the tone of every-day things, “you'll get
used to it—won't you? I don't expect you to feel very good about it,
but you aren't going to be broken up about it—are you? After all,
father,” laughing and moving about as if to break the seriousness of
things, “there's nothing criminal about being one of the other
fellows—is there? Just remember that there are folks who even
think it's respectable!” The father had risen and picked up his hat.
“No, Fred,” he said, with a sadness in which there was great dignity,
“there is nothing criminal in it if a man's conviction sends him that
way. But to me there is something—something too sad for words in a
man's selling his own soul.”
“Father! How extravagant! Why is it selling one's soul to sit
down and figure out what's the best thing to do?” He hesitated, hating
to add hurt to hurt, not wanting to say that his father's fight should
have been with the revolutionists, that his life was ineffective
because, seeing his dream from within a dream, his thinking had been
muddled. He only said: “As I say, father, it's a question of giving or
getting. I couldn't even give in your way. And I've seen enough of
giving to want a taste of getting. I want to make things go—and I see
my chance. Why father,” he laughed, trying to turn it, “there's nothing
so American as wanting to make things go.”
He looked at him for a long minute. “My boy,” he said, “I fear you
are becoming so American that I am losing you.”
“Father,” the boy pleaded, affectionately, “now don't—”
The old man held up his hand. “You've tried to make me understand
it,” he said, “and succeeded. You can't complain of the way you've
succeeded. I don't know why I don't argue with you—plead; there are
things I could say—should say, perhaps—but something assures me it
would be useless. I feel a good many years older than I did when I came
into this room, but the reason for it is not that you're joining the
other party. You know what I think of the men who control this State,
the men with whom you desire to cast your lot, but I trust the years
I've spent fighting them haven't made a bigot of me. It's not joining
their party—it's using it—makes this the hardest thing I've
been called upon to meet.”
“Father, don't look like that! How do you think I am going to get up
and speak tonight with that face before me?”
“You didn't think, did you,” the man laughed bitterly, “that I would
inspire you to your effort?”
The boy stood looking at his father, a strange new fire in his eyes.
“Yes,” he said, quietly, tenderly, “you will inspire me. When I get
up before those men tonight I'm going to see the picture of that boy
straining for his first glimpse of New York Harbour. I'm going to think
for just a minute of the things that boy brought with him—things he
has never lost. And then I'll see you as you stand here now—-it will
be enough. What I need to do is to get mad. If I falter I'll just think
of some of those times when you came home from your campaigns—how you
looked—what you said. It will bring the inspiration. Father, I figure
it out like this. We're going to get it back. We're going to get what's
coming to us. There's another America than the America of you dreamers.
To yours you have given; from mine I will get. And the irony of
it—don't think I don't see the irony of it—is that I will be called
the real American. Do you know what I'm going to do? I'm going to make
the railroads of this State—oh, it sounds like schoolboy talk, but
just give me a little time—I'm going to make the railroads of this
State pay off every cent of that mortgage on your farm! Father,” he
finished, impetuously, in a last appeal, “you're broken up now,
disappointed, but would you honestly want me to travel the road you've
“My boy,” answered the old man, and the tears came with it, “I
wanted you to travel the road of an honest man.”
Herman Beckman did not go to the commencement exercises that night.
There was no train home until morning, so he had the night to spend in
town. He was alone, for his friends assumed that he would be out at the
university. But he preferred being alone.
He sat in his room at the hotel, reading. And he could read. Years
of discipline stood him in good stead now. His life had taught him to
read anywhere, at any time. He had never permitted himself the luxury
of not being “in the mood.” It was only the men who had gone to college
who could do that. He had to read. He always carried some little
book with him, for how did a man know that he might not have to wait an
hour for a train somewhere? The man had a simple-minded veneration for
knowledge. He wanted to know about things. And he had never learned to
pretend that he didn't want to know. He quite lacked the modern art of
flippancy. He believed in great books.
And so on the night that his son was being graduated from college he
sat in his room at the hotel—cheap room in a mediocre hotel; he had
never learned to feel at home in the rich ones—reading Marcus
Aurelius. But his hand as he turned the pages trembled as the hand of a
very old man. At midnight some reporters came in to ask him what he
thought of his son's oration. They wanted a statement from him.
He told them that he had never believed the sins of a parent should
be visited on a child, and that it was even so with the thought. He had
always contended that a man should do his own thinking. The contention
applied to his son.
“Gamey old brute!” was what one of the reporters said in the
He could not read Marcus Aurelius after that. He went to bed, but he
did not sleep. Many things passed before him. His anticipations, his
dreams for Fritz, had brought the warmest pleasure of his stern,
unrelaxing life. There was a great emptiness tonight. What was a man to
turn to, think about, when he seemed stripped, not only of the future,
but of the past? He seemed called upon to readjust the whole of his
life, giving up that which he had held dearest. What was left? Daylight
found him turning it over and over.
In the morning he went home. He got away without seeing any of his
He did not try to read this morning; somehow it seemed there was no
use in trying to read any more. He watched the country through which
they were passing, thinking of the hundreds of times he had ridden over
it in campaigning. He wondered, vaguely, just how much money he had
spent on railroad fare—he had never accepted mileage. Fred's “What's
the use?” kept ringing in his ears. There was something about that
phrase which made one feel very tired and old. It even seemed there was
no use looking out to see how the crops were getting on. What's the
use? What's the use? Was that a phrase one learned in college?
There had been two things to tell “mother” that night. The first was
that he had stopped in town and told Claus Hansen he could have that
south hundred and sixty he had been wanting for two years.
It was not easy to tell the woman who had worked shoulder to
shoulder with him for thirty years, the woman who during those years
had risen with him in the early morning and worked with him until
darkness rescued the weary bodies, that in their old age they must
surrender the fruit of their toil. They would have left just what they
had started with. They had just held their own.
Coming down on the train he had made up his mind that if Hansen were
in town he would tell him that he could have the land. He felt so very
tired and old, so bowed down with Fred's “What's the use?” that he saw
that he himself would never get the mortgage paid off. And Fred had
said something about making the railroads pay it. He did not know just
how the boy figured that out—indeed, he was getting a little dazed
about the whole thing—but if Fritz had any idea of having the
railroads pay off the mortgage on his farm—he couldn't forget
how the boy looked when he said it, face white, eyes burning—he would
see to it right now that there was no chance of that.
He tried not to look at the land as he drove past it on the way
home. He wondered just how much campaign literature it had paid for. He
wondered if he would ever get used to seeing Claus Hansen putting up
his hay over there in that field.
He had felt so badly about telling mother that he told it very
bluntly. And because he felt so sorry for her he said not one kind
word, but just sat quiet, looking the other way.
She was clearing off the table. He heard her scraping out the potato
dish with great care. Then she was coming over to him. She came
awkwardly, hesitatingly—her life had not schooled her in meeting
emotional moments beautifully—but she laid her hand upon him, patted
him on the shoulder as one would a child. “Never mind, papa—never you
mind. It will make it easier for us. There's enough left—and it will
make it easier. We're getting on—we're—” There she broke off abruptly
into a vigorous scolding of the dog, who was lifting covetous nostrils
to a piece of meat.
That was all. And there was no woman in the country had worked
harder. And Martha was ambitious; she liked land, and she did not like
Claus Hansen's wife.
Yes, he had had a good wife.
Then there was that other thing to tell her—about Fritz. That was
Mother had not gone up to the city to hear Fritz “speak” because her
feet were bothering her, and she could not wear her shoes. He had had a
vague idea of how disappointed she was, though she had said very little
about it. Martha never had been one to say much about things. When he
came back, of course she had wanted to know all about it, and he had
put her off. Now he had to tell her.
It was much harder; and in the telling of it he broke down.
This time she did not come over and pat his shoulder. Perhaps Martha
knew—likely she had never heard the word intuition, but, anyway, she
knew—that it was beyond that.
It seemed difficult for her to comprehend. She was bewildered to
find that Fritz could change parties all in a minute. She seemed to
grasp, first of all, that it was disrespectful to his father. Some boys
at school had been putting notions into his head.
But gradually she began to see it. Fritz wanted to make money. Fritz
wanted to have it easier. And the other people did “have it easier.”
It divided her feeling: sorry and indignant for the father, secretly
glad and relieved for the boy. “He will have it easier than we had it,
papa,” she said at the last. “But it was not right of Fritz,” she
concluded, vaguely but severely.
As she washed the dishes Martha was thinking that likely Fritz's
wife would have a hired girl.
Then Martha went up to bed. He said that he would come in a few
minutes, but many minutes went by while he sat out on the side porch
trying to think it out.
The moon was shining brightly down on that hundred and sixty which
Claus Hansen was to have. And the moon, too, seemed to be saying:
“What's the use?”
Well, what was the use? Perhaps, after all, the boy was
right. What had it all amounted to? What was there left? What had he
Two Americas, Fred had said, and his but the America of the
dreamers. He had always thought that he was fighting for the real. And
now Fred said that he had never become an American at all.
From the time he was twelve years old he had wanted to be an
American. A queer old man back in the German village—an old man, he
recalled strangely now, who had never been in America—told him about
it. He told how all men were brothers in America, how the poor and the
rich loved each other—indeed, how there were no poor and rich at all,
but the same chance for every man who would work. He told about the
marvellous resources of that distant America—gold in the earth, which
men were free to go and get, hundreds upon hundreds of miles of
untouched forests and great rivers—all for men to use, great cities no
older than the men who were in them, which men at that present moment
were making—every man his equal chance. He told of rich land
which a man could have for nothing, which would be his, if he
would but go and work upon it. In the heart of the little German boy
there was kindled then a fire which the years had never put out. His
cheeks grew red, his eyes bright and very deep as he listened to the
story. He went home that night and dreamed of going to America. And
through the years of his boyhood, penny by penny, he saved his money
for America. It was his dream. It was the passion of his life. More
plainly than the events of yesterday, he remembered his first glimpse
of those wonderful shores—the lump in his throat, the passionate
excitement, the uplift. Leaning over the railing of his boat, staring,
searching, penetrating, worshipping, he lifted up his heart and sent
out his pledge of allegiance to the new land. How he would love
America, work for it, be true to it!
He had three dollars and sixty cents in his pocket when he stepped
upon American soil. He wondered if any man had ever felt richer. For
had he not reached the land where there was an equal chance for every
man who would work, where men loved each other as brothers, and where
the earth itself was so rich and so gracious in its offerings?
The old man crossed one leg over the other—slowly, stiffly. It made
him tired and stiff now just to think of the work he had done between
that day and this.
But there was something which he had always had—that something was
his America. That had never wavered, though he soon learned that
between it and realities were many things which were wrong and
unfortunate. With the whole force and passion of his nature, with all
his single mindedness—would some call it simple mindedness?—he threw
himself into the fight against those things which were blurring men's
vision of his America. No work, no sacrifice was too great, for America
had enemies who called themselves friends, men who were striking heavy
blows at that equal chance for every man. When he failed, it was
because he did not know enough; he must work, he must study, he must
think, in order to make more real to other men the America which was in
his heart. He must fight for it because it was his.
And now it seemed that the end had come; he was old, he was tired,
he was not sure. Claus Hansen would have his land and his son would
join hands with the things which he had spent his life in fighting. And
far deeper and sadder and more bitter than that, he had not transmitted
the America of his heart even to his own son. He was not leaving
someone to fight for it in his stead, to win where he had failed. Fred
saw in it but a place for gain. “I lived all my life with you to learn
from failure the value of success.” That was what he had given to his
boy. Yes, that was what he had bequeathed to America. Could the
failure, the futility of his life be more clearly revealed?
Twice Martha had called to him, but still he sat, smoking, thinking.
There was much to think about to-night.
Finally, it was not thought, but visions. Too tired for conscious
thinking, he gave himself up to what came—Fred's America, his America,
the America of the dreamers—and the things which stood between. The
America of the future—-what would that America be?
At the last, taking form from many things which came and went,
shaping itself slowly, form giving place to new form, he seemed to see
it grow. Out beyond that land Claus Hansen was to have, a long way off,
there rose the vision of the America of the future—an America of
realities, and yet an America of dreams; for the dreamers had become
the realists—-or was it that the realists had become dreamers? In the
manifold forms taken on and cast aside destroying dualism had made way
for the strength and the dignity and harmony of unity. He watched it as
breathlessly, as yearningly, as the nineteen-year-old boy had watched
the other America taking shape in the distance some forty years before.
“How did you come?” he whispered. “What are you?”
And the voice of that real America seemed to answer: “I came because
for a long-enough time there were enough men who held me in their
hearts. I came because there were men who never gave me up. I was won
by men who believed that they had failed.”
Again there was a lump in his throat—once more an exultation
flooded all his being. For to the old man—tired, stiff, smitten though
he had been, there came again that same uplift which long before had
come to the boy. Was there not here an answer to “What's the use?” For
he would leave America as he came to it—loving it, believing in it.
What were the work and the failure of a lifetime when there was
something in his heart which was his? Should he say that he had fought
in vain when he had kept it for himself? It was as real, as
wonderful—yes as inevitable, as it had been forty years before.
Realities had taken his land, his career, his hopes for the boy. But
realities had not stripped him of his dream. The futility of the years
could not harm the things which were in his heart. Even in America he
had not lost His America.
“Perhaps it is then that it is like that,” he murmured, his vision
carrying him back to the days of his broken English. “Perhaps it is
that every man's America is in the inside of his own heart. Perhaps it
is that it will come when it has grown big—big and very strong—in the
XII. THE ANARCHIST: HIS DOG
Stubby had a route, and that was how he happened to get a dog. For
the benefit of those who have never carried papers it should be thrown
in that having a route means getting up just when there is really some
fun in sleeping, lining up at the Leader office—maybe having a
scrap with the fellow who says you took his place in the line—getting
your papers all damp from the press and starting for the outskirts of
the city. Then you double up the paper in the way that will cause all
possible difficulty in undoubling and hurl it with what force you have
against the front door. It is good to have a route, for you at least
earn your salt, so your father can't say that any more. If he
does, you know it isn't so.
When you have a route, you whistle. All the fellows whistle. They
may not feel like it, but it is the custom—as could be sworn to by
many sleepy citizens. And as time goes on you succeed in acquiring the
easy manner of a brigand.
Stubby was little and everything about him seemed sawed off just a
second too soon,—his nose, his fingers, and most of all, his hair. His
head was a faithful replica of a chestnut burr. His hair did not lie
down and take things easy. It stood up—and out!—gentle ladies
couldn't possibly have let their hands sink into it—as we are told
they do—for the hands just wouldn't sink. They'd have to float.
And alas, gentle ladies didn't particularly want their hands to sink
into it. There was not that about Stubby's short person to cause the
hands of gentle ladies to move instinctively to his head. Stubby
bristled. That is, he appeared to bristle. Inwardly, Stubby yearned,
though he would have swung into his very best brigand manner on the
spot were you to suggest so offensive a thing. Just to look at Stubby
you'd never in a thousand years guess what a funny feeling he had
sometimes when he got to the top of the hill where his route began and
could see a long way down the river and the town curled in on the other
side. Sometimes when the morning sun was shining through a mist—making
things awful queer—some of the mist got into Stubby's squinty little
eyes. After the mist behaved that way he always whistled so rakishly
and threw his papers with such abandonment that people turned over in
their beds and muttered things about having that little heathen of a
paper boy shot.
All along the route are dogs. Indeed, routes are distinguished by
their dogs. Mean routes are those that have terraces and mean dogs;
good routes—where the houses are close together and the dogs run out
and wag their tails. Though Stubby's greater difficulty came through
the wagging tails; he carried in a collie neighbourhood, and all
collies seemed consumed with mighty ambitions to have routes. If you
spoke to them—and how could you help speaking to a collie when
he came bounding out to you that way?—you had an awful time chasing
him back, and when he got lost—and it seemed collies spent most of
their time getting lost—the woman would put her head out next morning
and want to know if you had coaxed her dog away.
Some of the fellows had dogs that went with them on their routes.
One day one of them asked Stubby why he didn't have a dog and he
replied in surly fashion that he didn't have one 'cause he didn't want
one. If he wanted one, he guessed he'd have one.
And there was no one within ear-shot old enough or wise enough—or
tender enough?—to know from the meanness of Stubby's tone, and by his
evil scowl, that his heart was just breaking to own a dog.
One day a new dog appeared along the route. He was yellow and looked
like a cheap edition of a bull-dog. He was that kind of dog most
accurately described by saying it is hard to describe him, the kind you
say is just dog—and everybody knows.
He tried to follow Stubby; not in the trusting, bounding manner of
the collies—not happily, but hopingly. Stubby, true to the ethics of
his profession, chased him back where he had come from. That there
might be nothing whatever on his conscience, he even threw a stone
after him. Stubby was an expert in throwing things at dogs. He could
seem to just miss them and yet never hit them.
The next day it happened again; but just as he had a clod poised for
throwing, a window went up and a woman called: “For pity sake,
little boy, don't chase him back here.”
“Why—why, ain't he yours?” called Stubby.
“Mercy, no. We can't chase him away.”
“Who's is he?” demanded Stubby.
“Why, he's nobody's! He just hangs around. I wish you'd coax him
Well, that was a new one! And then all in a heap it rushed
over Stubby that this dog who was nobody's dog could, if he coaxed him
away—and the woman wanted him coaxed away—be his dog.
And because that idea had such a strange effect on him he sang out,
in off-hand fashion: “Oh, all right, I'll take him away and drown him
“Oh, little boy,” called the woman, “why, don't drown
“Oh, all right, I'll shoot him then!” called obliging Stubby,
whistling for the dog—while all morning long the woman grieved over
having sent a helpless little dog away with that perfectly brutal
Stubby's mother was washing. She looked up from her tubs on the back
porch to say, “Wish you'd take that bucket—” then seeing what was
slinking behind her son, straightway assumed the role of destiny with,
“Git out o' here!”
Stubby snapped his fingers behind his back as much as to say, “Wait
“A woman gave him to me,” he said to his mother.
“Gave him to you?” she scoffed. “I sh' think she would!”
Then something happened that had not happened many times in Stubby's
short lifetime. He acknowledged his feelings.
“I'd like to keep him. I'd like to have a dog.”
His mother shook her hands and the flying suds seemed expressing her
scorn. “Huh! That ugly good-for-nothing thing?”
The dog had edged in between Stubby's feet and crouched there. “He
could go with me on my route,” said Stubby. “He'd kind of be company
And when he had said that he knew all at once just how lonesome he
had been sometimes on his route, how he had wanted something to “kind
of be company” for him.
His face twitched as he stooped down to pat the dog. Mrs. Lynch
looked at her son—youngest of her five. Not the hardness of her heart
but the hardness of her life had made her unpractised in moments of
tenderness. Something in the way Stubby was patting the dog suggested
to her that Stubby was a “queer one.” He was kind of little to
be carrying papers all by himself.
Stubby looked up. “He could eat what's thrown away.”
That was an error in diplomacy. The woman's face hardened. “Mighty
little'll be thrown away this winter,” she muttered.
But just then Mrs. Johnson appeared on the other side of the fence
and began hanging up her clothes and with that Mrs. Lynch saw her way
to justify herself in indulging her son. Mrs. Johnson and Mrs. Lynch
had “had words.” “You just let him stay around, Stubby,” she called,
and you would have supposed from her tone it was Stubby who was on the
other side of the fence, “maybe he'll keep the neighbour's chickens
out! Them that ain't got chickens o' their own don't want to be
bothered with the neighbours'!”
That was how it happened that he stayed; and no one but Stubby
knew—and possibly Stubby didn't either—how it happened that he was
named Hero. It would seem that Hero should be a noble St. Bernard, or a
particularly mean-looking bulldog, not a stocky, shapeless, squint-eyed
yellow dog with one ear bitten half off and one leg built on an
entirely different plan from its fellow legs. Possibly Stubby's own
spiritual experiences had suggested to him that you weren't necessarily
the way you looked.
The chickens were pretty well kept out, though no one ever saw Hero
doing any of it. Perhaps Hero had been too long associated with chasing
to desire any part in it—even with roles reversed. If Stubby could
help it, no one really saw Stubby doing the chasing either; he became
skilled in chasing when he did not appear to be chasing; then he would
get Hero to barking and turn to his mother with, “Guess you don't see
so many chickens round nowadays.”
The fellows in the line jeered at Hero at first, but they soon tired
of it when Stubby said he didn't want the cur but his mother made him
stay around to keep the chickens out. He was a fine chicken dog, Stubby
grudgingly admitted. He couldn't keep him from following, said Stubby,
so he just let him come. Sometimes when they were waiting in line
Stubby made ferocious threats at Hero. He was going to break his back
and wring his head off and do other heartless things which for some
reason he never started in right then and there to accomplish.
It was different when they were alone—and they were alone a good
deal. Stubby's route wasn't nearly so long after he had Hero to go with
him. When winter came and five o'clock was dark and cold for starting
out it was pretty good to have Hero trotting at his heels. And Hero
always wanted to go; it was never so rainy nor so cold that that yellow
dog seemed to think he would rather stay home by the fire. Then Hero
was always waiting for him when he came home from school. Stubby would
sing out, “Hello, cur!” and the tone was such that Hero did not grasp
that he was being insulted. Sometimes when there was nobody about,
Stubby picked Hero up in his arms and squeezed him—Stubby had not had
a large experience with squeezing. At those times Hero would lick
Stubby's face and whimper a little love whimper and such were the
workings of Stubby's heart and mind that that made him of quite as much
account as if he really had chased the chickens. Stubby, who had seen
the way dogs can look at you out of their eyes, was not one to say of a
dog, “What good is he?”
But it seemed there were such people. There were even people who
thought you oughtn't to have a dog to love and to love you if you
weren't one of those rich people who could pay two dollars and a half a
year for the luxury.
Stubby first heard of those people one night in June. The father of
the Lynch family was sitting in the back yard reading the paper when
Hero and Stubby came running in from the alley. It was one of those
moments when Hero, forgetting the bleakness of his youth, abandoned
himself to the joy of living. He was tearing round and round Stubby,
barking, when Stubby's father called out: “Here!—shut up there, you
cur. You better lie low. You're going to be shot the first of August.”
Stubby, and as regards the joy of living Hero had done as much for
Stubby as Stubby for Hero, came to a halt. The fun and frolic just died
right out of him and he stood there staring at his father, who had
turned the page and was settling himself to a new horror. At last
Stubby spoke. “Why's he going to be shot on the first of August?” he
asked in a tight little voice.
His father looked up. “Why's he going to be shot? You got any two
dollars and a half to pay for him?”
He laughed as though that were a joke. Well, it was something of a
joke. Stubby got ten cents a week out of his paper money. The rest he
Then he went back to his paper. There was another long pause before
Stubby asked, in that tight queer little voice: “What'd I have to pay
two dollars and a half for? Nobody owns him.”
His parent stirred scornfully. “Suppose you never heard of a dog
tax, did you? S'pose they don't learn you nothing like that at school?”
Yes, Stubby did know that dogs had to have checks, but he hadn't
thought anything about that in connection with Hero. He ventured
another question. “You have to have 'em for all dogs, even if you just
picked 'em up on the street and took care of 'em when nobody else
“You bet you do,” his parent assured him genially. “You pay your dog
tax or the policeman comes on the first of August and shoots your dog.”
With that he dismissed it for good, burying himself in his paper.
For a minute the boy stood there in silence. Then he walked slowly
round the house and sat down where his father couldn't see him. Hero
followed—it was a way Hero had. The dog sat down beside the boy and
after a couple of minutes the boy's arm stole furtively around him and
they sat there very still for a long time.
As nobody but Hero paid much attention to him, nobody save Hero
noticed how quiet and queer Stubby was for the next three days. Hero
must have noticed it, for he was quiet and queer too. He followed
wherever Stubby would let him, and every time he got a chance he would
nestle up to him and look into his face—that way even cur dogs have of
doing when they fear something is wrong.
At the end of three days Stubby, his little freckled face set and
grim, took his stand in front of his father and came right out with: “I
want to keep one week's paper money to pay Hero's tax.”
His father's chair had been tilted back against a tree. Now it came
down with a thud. “Oh, you do, do you?”
“I can earn the other fifty cents at little jobs.”
“You can, can you? Now ain't you smart!”
The tone brought the blood to Stubby's face. “I think I got a right
to,” he said, his voice low.
The man's face, which had been taunting, grew ugly. “Look a-here,
young man, none o' your lip!”
The tears rushed to Stubby's eyes but he stumbled on: “I guess
Hero's got a right to some of my paper money when he goes with me every
day on my route.”
At that his father stared for a minute and then burst into a loud
laugh. Blinded with tears, the boy turned to the house.
After she had gone to bed that night Stubby's mother heard a sound
from the alcove at the head of the stairs where her youngest child
slept. As the sound kept on she got out of her bed and went to Stubby's
“Look here,” she said, awkwardly but not unkindly, “this won't do.
We're poor folks, Freddie” (it was only once in a while she called him
that), “all we can do to live these times—we can't pay no dog tax.”
As Stubby did not speak she added: “I know you've taken to the dog,
but just the same you ain't to feel hard to your pa. He can't help
it—and neither can I. Things is as they is—and nobody can help it.”
As, despite this bit of philosophy Stubby was still gulping back
sobs, she added what she thought a master stroke in consolation. “Now
you just go right to sleep, and if they come to take this dog away
maybe you can pick up another one in the fall.”
The sobs suddenly stopped and Stubby stared at her. And what he said
after a long stare was: “I guess there ain't no use in you and me
talking about it.”
“That's right,” said she, relieved; “now you go right off to sleep.”
And she left him, never dreaming why Stubby had seen there was no use
talking about it.
Nor did he talk about it; but a change came over Stubby's funny
little person in the next few days. The change was particularly
concerned with his jaw, though there was something different, too, in
the light in his eyes as he looked straight ahead, and something
different in his voice when he said: “Come on, Hero.”
He got so he could walk into a store and demand, in a hard little
voice: “Want a boy to do anything for you?” and when they said, “Got
more boys than we know what to do with, sonny,” Stubby would say, “All
right,” and stalk sturdily out again. Sometimes they laughed and said:
“What could you do?” and then Stubby would stalk out, but
possibly a little less sturdily.
Vacation came the next week, and still he had found nothing. His
father, however, had been more successful. He found a place where they
wanted a boy to work in a yard a couple of hours in the morning. For
that Stubby was to get a dollar and a half a week. But that was to be
turned in for his “keep.” There were lots of mouths to feed—as
Stubby's mother was always calling to her neighbour across the alley.
But the yard gave Stubby an idea, and he earned some dimes and one
quarter in the next week. Most folks thought he was too little—one
kind lady told him he ought to be playing, not working—but there were
people who would let him take a big shears and cut grass around flower
beds, and things like that. This he had to do afternoons, when he was
supposed to be off playing, and when he came home his mother sometimes
said some folks had it easy—playing around all day.
It was now the first week in July and Stubby had a dollar and twenty
cents. It was getting to the point where he would wake in the night and
find himself sitting up in bed, hands clenched. He dreamed dreams about
how folks would let him live if he had ninety-nine cents but how he
only had ninety-seven and a half, so they were going to shoot him.
Then one day he found Mr. Stuart. He was passing the house after
having asked three people if they wanted a boy, and they didn't, and
seemed so surprised at the idea of their wanting him that Stubby's
throat was all tight, when Mr. Stuart sang out: “Say, boy, want a
It seemed at first it must be a joke—or a dream—anybody asking him
if he wanted one, but the man was beckoning to him, so he pulled
himself together and ran up the steps.
“Now here's a little package”—he took something out of the mail
box. “It doesn't belong here. It's to go to three-hundred-two Pleasant
street. You take it for a dime?”
As he was going down the steps the man called: “Say, boy, how'd you
like a steady job?”
For the first minute it seemed pretty mean—making fun of a fellow
“This will be here every day. Suppose you come each day, about this
time, and take it over there—not mentioning it to anybody.”
Stubby felt weak. “Why, all right,” he managed to say.
“I'll give you fifty cents a week. That fair?”
“Yes, sir,” said Stubby, doing some quick calculation.
“Then here goes for the first week”—and he handed him the other
It was funny how fast the world could change! Stubby wanted to
run—he hadn't been doing much running of late. He wanted to go home
and get Hero to go with him to Pleasant street, but didn't. No, sir, when you had a job you had to 'tend to things!
Well, a person could do things, if he had to, thought Stubby. No use
saying you couldn't, you could, if you had to. He was back in
tune with life. He whistled; he turned up his collar in the old rakish
way; he threw a stick at a cat. Back home he jumped over the fence
instead of going in the gate—lately he had actually been using the
gate. And he cried, “Get out of my sight, you cur!” in tones which, as
Hero understood things, meant anything but getting out of his sight.
He was a little boy again. He slept at night as little boys sleep.
He played with Hero along the route—taught him some new tricks. His
jaw relaxed from its grown-upishness.
It was funny about those Stuarts. Sometimes he saw Mr. Stuart, but
never anybody else; the place seemed shut up. But each day the little
package was there, and every day he took it to Pleasant street and left
it at the door there—that place seemed shut up, too.
When it was well into the second week Stubby ventured to say
something about the next fifty cents.
The man fumbled in his pockets. Something in his face was familiar
to experienced Stubby. It suggested a having to have two dollars and a
half by August first and only having a dollar and a quarter state of
“I haven't got the change. Pay you at the end of next week for the
whole business. That all right?”
Stubby considered. “I've got to have it before the first of August,”
At that the man laughed—funny kind of laugh, it was, and muttered
something. But he told Stubby he would have it before the first.
It bothered Stubby. He wished the man had given it to him then. He would rather get it each week and keep it himself. A little of the
grown-up look stole back.
After that he didn't see Mr. Stuart, and one day, a week or so
later, the package was not in the box and a man who wore the kind of
clothes Stubby's father wore came around the house and asked him what
he was doing.
Stubby was wary. “Oh, I've got a little job I do for Mr. Stuart.”
The man laughed. “I had a little job I did for Mr. Stuart, too. You
paid in advance?”
Stubby pricked up his ears.
“'Cause if you ain't, I'd advise you to look out for a little job
Then it came out. Mr. Stuart was broke; more than that, he was “off
his nut.” Lots of people were doing little jobs for him—there was no
sense in any of them, and now he had suddenly been called out of town!
There was a trembly feeling through Stubby's insides, but outwardly
he was bristling just like his hair bristled as he demanded: “Where am
I to get what's coming to me?”
“'Fraid you won't get it, sonny. We're all in the same boat.” He
looked Stubby up and down and then added: “Kind of little for that
“I got to have it!” cried Stubby. “I tell you, I got
The man shook his head. “That cuts no ice. Hard luck, sonny,
but we've got to take our medicine in this world. 'Taint no medicine
for kids, though,” he muttered.
Stubby's face just then was too much for him. He put his hand in his
pocket and drew out a dime, saying: “There now. You run along and get
you a soda and forget your troubles. It ain't always like this. You'll
have better luck next time.”
But Stubby did not get the soda. He put the dime in his pocket and
turned toward home. Something was the matter with his legs—they acted
funny about carrying him. He tried to whistle, but something was the
matter with his lips, too.
Counting this dime, he now had a dollar and eighty cents, and it was
the twenty-eighth day of July. “Thirty days has September—April, June
and November—” he was saying to himself. Then July was one of the long
ones. Well, that was a good thing! Been a great deal worse if
July was a short one. Again he tried to whistle, and that time did
manage to pipe out a few shrill little notes.
When Hero came running up the hill to meet him he slapped him on the
back and cried, “Hello, Hero!” in tones fairly swaggering with bravado.
That night he engaged his father in conversation—the phrase is well
adapted to the way Stubby went about it. “How is it about—'bout things
like taxes”—Stubby crossed his knees and swung one foot to show his
indifference—“if you have almost enough—do they sometimes let
you off?”—the detachment was a shade less perfect on that last.
His father laughed scoffingly. “Well, I guess not!“
“I thought maybe,” said Stubby, “if a person had tried awful
hard—and had most enough—”
Something inside him was all shaky, so he didn't go on. His father
said that trying didn't have anything to do with it.
It was hard for Stubby not to sob out that he thought trying
ought to have something to do with it, but he only made a hissing
noise between his teeth that took the place of the whistle that
“Kind of seems,” he resumed, “if a person would have had enough if
they hadn't been beat out of it, maybe—if he done the best he could—”
His father snorted derisively and informed him that doing the best
you could made no difference to the government; hard luck stories
didn't go when it came to the laws of the land.
Thereupon Stubby took a little walk out to the alley and spent a
considerable time in contemplation of the neighbour's chicken-yard.
When he came back he walked right up to his father and standing there,
feet planted, shoulders squared, wanted to know, in a desperate little
voice: “If some one else was to give—say a dollar and eighty cents for
Hero, could I take the other seventy out of my paper money?”
The man turned upon him roughly. “Uh-huh! That's it,
is it? That's why you're getting so smart all of a sudden about
government! Look a-here. Just l'me tell you something. You're lucky if
you git enough to eat this winter. Do you know there's talk of
the factory shuttin' down? Dog tax! Why you're lucky if you git
Stubby had turned away and was standing with his back to his father,
hands in his pockets.
“And l'me tell you some'en else, young man. If you got any dollar
and eighty cents, you give it to your mother!”
As Stubby was turning the corner of the house he called after him:
“How'd you like to have me get you an automobile?”
He went doggedly from house to house the next afternoon, but nobody
had any jobs. When Hero came running out to him that night he patted
him, but didn't speak.
That evening as they were sitting in the back yard—Stubby and Hero
a little apart from the others—his father was discoursing with his
brother about anarchists. They were getting commoner, his father
thought. There were a good many of them at the shop. They didn't call
themselves that, but that was what they were.
“Well, what is an anarchist, anyhow?” Stubby's mother wanted to
“Why, an anarchist,” her lord informed her, “is one that's against
the government. He don't believe in the law and order. The real bad
anarchists shoot them that tries to enforce the laws of the land. Guess
if you'd read the papers these days you'd know.”
Stubby's brain had been going round and round and these words caught
in it as it whirled. The government—the laws of the land—why, it was
the government and the laws of the land that were going to shoot Hero!
It was the government—the laws of the land—that didn't care how hard
you had tried—didn't care whether you had been cheated—didn't
care how you felt—didn't care about anything except getting the
money! His brain got hotter. Well, he didn't believe in the
government, either. He was one of those people—those anarchists—that
were against the laws of the land.
He'd done the very best he could and now the government was going to
take Hero away from him just because he couldn't get—couldn't
get—that other seventy cents.
Stubby's mother didn't hear her son crying that night. That was
because Stubby was successful in holding the pillow over his head.
The next morning he looked in one of the papers he was carrying to
see what it said about anarchists. Sure enough, some place way off
somewhere, the anarchists had shot somebody that was trying to enforce
the laws of the land. The laws of the land—that didn't care.
That afternoon as Stubby tramped around looking for jobs he saw a
good many boys playing with dogs. None of them seemed to be worrying
about whether their dogs had checks. To Stubby's hot little brain and
sore little heart came the thought that they didn't love their dogs any
more than he loved Hero, either. But the government didn't care whether
he loved Hero or not! Pooh!—what was that to the government? All it
cared about was getting the money. He stood for a long time watching a
boy giving his dog a bath. The dog was trying to get away and the boy
and another boy were having lots of fun about it. All of a sudden
Stubby turned and ran away—ran down an alley, ran through a number of
alleys, just kept on running, blinded by the tears.
And that night, in the middle of the night, that something in his
head going round and round, getting hotter and hotter, he decided that
the only thing for him to do was to shoot the policeman who came to
take Hero away on the morning of August first—that would be day after
All night long policemen with revolvers stood around his bed. When
his mother called him at half-past four he was shaking so he could
scarcely get into his clothes.
On his way home from his route Stubby had to pass a police-station.
He went on the other side of the street and stood there looking across.
One of the policemen was playing with a dog!
Suddenly he wanted to rush over and throw himself down at that
policeman's feet—sob out the story—ask him to please, please
wait till he could get that other seventy cents.
But just then the policeman got up and went in the station, and
Stubby was afraid to go in the police-station.
That policeman complicated things for Stubby. Before that it had
been quite simple. The policeman would come to enforce the law of the
land; but he did not believe in the law of the land, so he would just
kill the policeman. But it seemed a policeman wasn't just a person who
enforced the laws of the land. He was also a person who played with a
After a whole day of walking around thinking about it—his eyes
burning, his heart pounding—he decided that the thing to do was to
warn the policeman by writing a letter. He did not know whether real
anarchists warned them or not, but Stubby couldn't get reconciled to
the idea of killing a person without telling him you were going to do
it. It seemed that even a policeman should be told—especially a
policeman who played with a dog.
The following letter was pencilled by a shaking hand, late that
afternoon. It was written upon a barrel in the Lynch wood-shed, on a
piece of wrapping paper, a bristly little head bending over it:
To the Policeman who comes to take my dog 'cause I ain't got the two
fifty—'cause I tried but could only get one eighty—'cause a man was
off his nut and didn't pay me what I earned—
This is to tell you I am an anarchist and do not believe in the
government or the law and the order and will shoot you when you come. I
wouldn't a been an anarchist if I could a got the money and I tried to
get it but I couldn't get it—not enough. I don't think the government
had ought to take things you like like I like Hero so I am against the
Thought I would tell you first.
I don't see how I can shoot you 'cause where would I get the
revolver. So I will have to do it with the butcher knife. Folks are
sometimes killed that way 'cause my father read it in the paper.
If you wanted to take the one eighty and leave Hero till I can get
the seventy I will not do anything to you and would be very much
1113 Willow street.
The letter was properly addressed and sealed—not for nothing had
Stubby's teacher given those instructions in the art of letter writing.
The stamp he paid for out of the dime the man gave him to get a soda
with—and forget his troubles.
Now Bill O'Brien was on the desk at the police-station and Miss
Murphy of the Herald stood in with Bill. That was how it came about
that the next morning a fat policeman, an eager-looking girl and a
young fellow with a kodak descended into the hollow to 1113 Willow
A little boy peeped around the corner of the house—such a
wild-looking little boy—hair all standing up and eyes glittering. A
yellow dog ran out and barked. The boy darted out and grabbed the dog
in his arms and in that moment the girl called to the man with the
black box: “Right now! Quick! Get him!”
They were getting ready to shoot Hero! That box was the way the
police did it! He must—oh, he must—must ... Boy and dog sank
to the ground—but just the same the boy was shielding the dog!
When Stubby had pulled himself together the policeman was holding
Hero. He said that Hero was certainly a fine dog—he had a dog a good
deal like him at home. And Miss Murphy—she was choking back sobs
herself—knew how he could earn the seventy cents that afternoon.
In such wise do a good anarchist and a good story go down under the
same blow. Some of those sobs Miss Murphy choked back got into what she
wrote about Stubby and his yellow dog and the next day citizens with no
sense of the dramatic sent money enough to check Hero through life.
At first Stubby's father said he had a good mind to lick him. But
something in the quality of Miss Murphy's journalism left a hazy
feeling of there being something remarkable about his son. He confided
to his good wife that it wouldn't surprise him much if Stubby was some
day President. Somebody had to be President, said he, and he had
noticed it was generally those who in their youthful days did things
that made lively reading in the newspapers.
XIII. AT TWILIGHT
A breeze from the May world without blew through the class-room, and
as it lifted his papers he had a curious sense of freshness and
mustiness meeting. He looked at the group of students before him, half
smiling at the way the breath of spring was teasing the hair of the
girls sitting by the window. Anna Lawrence was trying to pin hers back
again, but May would have none of such decorum, and only waited long
enough for her to finish her work before joyously undoing it. She
caught the laughing, admiring eyes of a boy sitting across from her and
sought to conceal her pleasure in her unmanageable wealth of hair by a
wry little face, and then the eyes of both strayed out to the trees
that had scented that breeze for them, looking with frank longing at
the campus which stretched before them in all its May glory that sunny
afternoon. He remembered having met this boy and girl strolling in the
twilight the evening before, and as a buoyant breeze that instant swept
his own face he had a sudden, irrelevant consciousness of being
seventy-three years old.
Other eyes were straying to the trees and birds and lilacs of that
world from which the class-room was for the hour shutting them out. He
was used to it—that straying of young eyes in the spring. For more
than forty years he had sat at that desk and talked to young men and
women about philosophy, and in those forty years there had always been
straying eyes in May. The children of some of those boys and girls had
in time come to him, and now there were other children who, before many
years went by, might be sitting upon those benches, listening to
lectures upon what men had thought about life, while their eyes strayed
out where life called. So it went on—May, perhaps, the philosopher
As, with a considerable effort—for the languor of spring, or some
other languor, was upon him too—he brought himself back to the papers
they had handed in, he found himself thinking of those first boys and
girls, now men and women, and parents of other boys and girls. He hoped
that philosophy had, after all, done something more than shut them out
from May. He had always tried, not so much to instruct them in what men
had thought, as to teach them to think, and perhaps now, when May had
become a time for them to watch the straying of other eyes, they were
the less desolate because of the habits he had helped them to form. He
wanted to think that he had done something more than hold them
There was a sadness to-day in his sympathy. He was tired. It was
hard to go back to what he had been saying about the different things
the world's philosophers had believed about the immortality of the
soul. So, as often when his feeling for his thought dragged, he turned
to Gretta Loring. She seldom failed to bring a revival of interest—a
freshening. She was his favourite student. He did not believe that in
all the years there had been any student who had not only pleased, but
helped him as she did.
He had taught her father and mother. And now there was Gretta,
clear-eyed and steady of gaze, asking more of life than either of them
had asked; asking, not only May, but what May meant. For Gretta there
need be no duality. She was one of those rare ones for whom the meaning
of life opened new springs to the joy of life, for whom life
intensified with the understanding of it. He never said a thing that
gratified him as reaching toward the things not easy to say but that he
would find Gretta's face illumined—and always that eager little
leaning ahead for more.
She had that look of waiting now, but to-day it seemed less an
expectant than a troubled look. She wanted him to go on with what he
had been saying about the immortality of the soul. But it was not so
much a demand upon him—he had come to rely upon those demands, as it
was—he had an odd, altogether absurd sense of its being a fear for
him. She looked uncomfortable, fretted; and suddenly he was startled to
see her searching eyes blurred by something that must be tears.
She turned away, and for just a minute it seemed to leave him alone
and helpless. He rubbed his forehead with his hand. It felt hot. It got
that way sometimes lately when he was tired. And the close of that hour
often found him tired.
He believed he knew what she wanted. She would have him declare his
own belief. In the youthful flush of her modernism she was impatient
with that fumbling around with what other men had thought. Despising
the muddled thinking of some of her classmates, she would have him put
it right to them with “As for yourself—”
He tried to formulate what he would care to say. But, perhaps just
because he was too tired to say it right, the life the robin in the
nearest tree was that moment celebrating in song seemed more important
than anything he had to say about his own feeling toward the things men
had thought about the human soul.
It was ten minutes before closing time, but suddenly he turned to
his class with: “Go out-of-doors and think about it. This is no day to
sit within and talk of philosophy. What men have thought about life in
the past is less important than what you feel about it to-day.” He
paused, then added, he could not have said why, “And don't let the
shadow of either belief or unbelief fall across the days that are here
for you now.” Again he stopped, then surprised himself by ending,
“Philosophy should quicken life, not deaden it.”
They were not slow in going, their astonishment in his wanting them
to go quickly engulfed in their pleasure in doing so. It was only
Gretta who lingered a moment, seeming too held by his manner in sending
her out into the sunshine to care about going there. He thought she was
going to come to the desk and speak to him. He was sure she wanted to.
But at the last she went hastily, and he thought, just before she
turned her face away, that it was a tear he saw on her lashes.
Strange! Was she unhappy, she through whom life surged so richly?
And yet was it not true, that where it gave much it exacted much?
Feeling much, and understanding what she felt, and feeling for what she
understood—must she also suffer much? Must one always pay?
He sighed, and began gathering together his papers. Thoughts about
life tired him to-day.
On the steps he paused, unreasonably enough a little saddened as he
watched some of them beginning a tennis game. Certainly they were
losing no time—eager to let go thoughts about life for its pleasures,
very few of them awake to that rich life he had tried to make them
ready for. He drooped still more wearily at the thought that perhaps
the most real gift he had for them was that unexpected ten minutes.
Remembering a book he must have from the library, he turned back. He
went to the alcove where the works on philosophy were to be found, and
was reaching up for the volume he wanted, when a sentence from a lowly
murmured conversation in the next aisle came to him across the stack of
“That's all very well; we know, of course, that he doesn't believe,
but what will he do when it comes to himself?“
It arrested him, coming as it did from one of the girls who had just
left his class-room. He stood there motionless, his hand still reaching
up for the book.
“Do? Why, face it, of course. Face it as squarely as he's faced
every other fact of life.”
That was Gretta, and though, mindful of the library mandate for
silence, her tone was low, it was vibrant with a fine scorn.
“Well,” said the first speaker, “I guess he'll have to face it
before very long.”
That was not answered; there was a movement on the other side of the
barricade of books—it might have been that Gretta had turned away. His
hand dropped down from the high shelf. He was leaning against the
“Haven't you noticed, Gretta, how he's losing his grip?”
At that his head went up sharply; he stood altogether tense as he
waited for Gretta to set the other girl right—Gretta, so sure-seeing,
so much wiser and truer than the rest of them. Gretta would laugh!
But she did not laugh. And what his strained ear caught at last
was—not her scornful denial, but a little gasp of breath suggesting a
“Noticed it? Why it breaks my heart!”
He stared at the books through which her low, passionate voice had
carried. Then he sank to the chair that fortunately was beside him.
Power for standing had gone from him.
“Father says—father's on the board, you know” (it was the first
girl who spoke)—“that they don't know what to do about it. It's not
justice to the school to let him begin another year. These things are
arranged with less embarrassment in the big schools, where a man begins
emeritus at a certain time. Though of course they'll pension him—he's
done a lot for the school.”
He thanked Gretta for her little laugh of disdain. The memory of it
was more comforting—more satisfying—than any attempt to put it into
words could have been.
He heard them move away, their skirts brushing the book-stacks in
passing. A little later he saw them out in the sunshine on the campus.
Gretta joined one of the boys for a game of tennis. Motionless, he sat
looking out at her. She looked so very young as she played.
For an hour he remained at the table in the alcove where he had
overheard what his students had to say of him. And when the hour had
gone by he took up the pen which was there upon the study table and
wrote his resignation to the secretary of the board of trustees. It was
very brief—simply that he felt the time had come when a younger man
could do more for the school than he, and that he should like his
resignation to take effect at the close of the present school year. He
had an envelope, and sealed and stamped the letter—ready to drop in
the box in front of the building as he left. He had always served the
school as best he could; he lost no time now, once convinced, in
rendering to it the last service he could offer it—that of making way
for the younger man.
Looking things squarely in the face, and it was the habit of a
lifetime to look things squarely in the face, he had not been long in
seeing that they were right. Things tired him now as they had not once
tired him. He had less zest at the beginning of the hour, more relief
at the close of it. He seemed stupid in not having seen it for himself,
but possibly many people were a little stupid in seeing that their own
time was over. Of course he had thought, in a vague way, that his
working time couldn't be much longer, but it seemed part of the way
human beings managed with themselves that things in even the very near
future kept the remoteness of future things.
Now he understood Gretta's troubled look and her tears. He knew how
those fine nerves of hers must have suffered, how her own mind had
wanted to leap to the aid of his, how her own strength must have
tormented her in not being able to reach his flagging powers. It seemed
part of the whole hardness of life that she who would care the most
would be the one to see it most understandingly.
What he was trying to do was to see it all very simply, in
matter-of-fact fashion, that there might be no bitterness and the least
of tragedy. It was nothing unique in human history he was facing. One
did one's work; then, when through, one stopped. He tried to feel that
it was as simple as it sounded, but he wondered if back of many of
those brief letters of resignation that came at quitting-time there was
the hurt, the desolation, that there was no use denying to himself was
back of his.
He hoped that most men had more to turn to. Most men of
seventy-three had grandchildren. That would help, surrounding one with
a feeling of the naturalness of it all. But that school had been his
only child. And he had loved it with the tenderness one gives a child.
That in him which would have gone to the child had gone to the school.
The woman whom he loved had not loved him; he had never married. His
life had been called lonely; but lonely though it undeniably had been,
the life he won from books and work and thinking had kept the chill
from his heart. He had the gift of drawing life from all contact with
life. Working with youth, he kept that feeling for youth that does for
the life within what sunshine and fresh air do for the room in which
It was now that the loneliness that blights seemed waiting for
him.... Life used one—and that in the ugly, not the noble sense
of being used. Stripped of the fine fancies men wove around it, what
was it beyond just a matter of being sucked dry and then thrown aside?
Why not admit that, and then face it? And the abundance with which one
might have given—the joy in the giving—had no bearing upon the fact
that it came at last to that question of getting one out of the way. It
was no one's unkindness; it was just that life was like that. Indeed,
the bitterness festered around the thought that it was life
itself—the way of life—not the brutality of any particular people.
“They'll pension him—he's done a lot for the school.” Even the
grateful memory of Gretta's tremulous, scoffing little laugh for the
way it fell short could not follow to the deep place that had been
Getting himself in hand again, and trying to face this as simply and
honestly as he had sought to face the other, he knew that it was true
he had done a great deal for the school. He did not believe it too much
to say he had done more for it than any other man. Certainly more than
any other man he had given it what place it had with men who thought.
He had come to it in his early manhood, and at a time when the school
was in its infancy—just a crude, struggling little Western college.
Gretta Loring's grandfather had been one of its founders—founding it
in revolt against the cramping sectarianism of another college. He had
gloried in the spirit which gave it birth, and it was he who, through
the encroachings of problems of administration and the ensnarements and
entanglements of practicality, had fought to keep unattached and
unfettered that spirit of freedom in the service of truth.
His own voice had been heard and recognised, and a number of times
during the years calls had come from more important institutions, but
he had not cared to go. For year by year there deepened that personal
love for the little college to which he had given the youthful ardour
of his own intellectual passion. All his life's habits were one with
it. His days seemed beaten into the path that cut across the campus.
The vines that season after season went a little higher on the wall out
there indicated his strivings by their own, and the generation that had
worn down even the stones of those front steps had furrowed his
forehead and stooped his shoulders. He had grown old along with it! His
days were twined around it. It was the place of his efforts and
satisfactions (joys perhaps he should not call them), of his falterings
and his hopes. He loved it because he had given himself to it; loved it
because he had helped to bring it up. On the shelves all around him
were books which it had been his pleasure—because during some of those
hard years they were to be had in no other way—to order himself and
pay for from his own almost ludicrously meagre salary. He remembered
the excitement there always was in getting them fresh from the
publisher and bringing them over there in his arms; the satisfaction in
coming in next day and finding them on the shelves. Such had been his
dissipations, his indulgences of self. Many things came back to him as
he sat there going back over busy years, the works on philosophy
looking down upon him, the shadows of that spring afternoon gathering
around him. He looked like a very old man indeed as he at last reached
out for the letter he had written to the trustees, relieving them of
Twilight had come on. On the front steps he paused and looked around
the campus. It was growing dark in that lingering way it has in the
spring—daylight creeping away under protest, night coming gently, as
if it knew that the world having been so pleasant, day would be loath
to go. The boys and girls were going back and forth upon the campus and
the streets. They could not bear to go within. For more than forty
years it had been like that. It would be like that for many times forty
years—indeed, until the end of the world, for it would be the end of
the world when it was not like that. He was glad that they were out in
the twilight, not indoors trying to gain from books something of the
meaning of life. That course had its satisfactions along the way, but
it was surely no port of peace to which it bore one at the last.
He shrunk from going home. There were so many readjustments he must
make, once home. So, lingering, he saw that off among the trees a girl
was sitting alone. She threw back her head in a certain way just then,
and he knew by the gesture that it was Gretta Loring. He wondered what
she was thinking about. What did one who thought think about—over
there on the other side of life? Youth and age looked at life from
opposite sides. Then they could not see it alike, for what one saw in
life seemed to depend so entirely upon how the light was falling from
where one stood.
He could not have said just what it was made him cross the campus
toward her. Part of it was the desire for human sympathy—one thing, at
least, which age did not deaden. But that was not the whole of it, nor
the deepest thing in it. It was an urge of the spirit to find and keep
for itself a place where the light was falling backward upon life.
She was quiet in her greeting, and gentle. Her cheeks were still
flushed, her hair tumbled from her game, but her eyes were thoughtful
and, he thought, sad. He felt that the sadness was because of him; of
him and the things of which he made her think. He knew of her affection
for him, the warmth there was in her admiration of the things for which
he had fought. He had discovered that it hurt her now that others
should be seeing and not he, pained her to watch so sorry a thing as
his falling below himself, wounded both pride and heart that men whom
she would doubtless say had never appreciated him were whispering among
themselves about how to get rid of him. Why, the poor child might even
be tormenting herself with the idea she ought to tell him!
That was why he told her. He pointed to the address on the envelope,
saying: “That carries my resignation, Gretta.”
Her start and the tears which rushed to her eyes told him he was
right about her feeling. She did not seem able to say anything. Her
chin was trembling.
“I see that the time has come,” he said, “when a younger man can do
more for the school than I can hope to do for it.”
Still she said nothing at all, but her eyes were deepening and she
had that very steadfast, almost inspired look that had so many times
quickened him in the class-room.
She was not going to deny it! She was not going to pretend!
After the first feeling of not having got something needed he rose
to her high ground—ground she had taken it for granted he would take.
“And will you believe it, Gretta,” he said, rising to that ground
and there asking, not for the sympathy that bends down, but for a hand
in passing, “there comes a hard hour when first one feels the time has
come to step aside and be replaced by that younger man?”
She nodded. “It must be,” she said, simply; “it must be very much
harder than any of us can know till we come to it.”
She brought him a sense of his advantage in experience—his riches.
To be sure, there was that.
And he was oddly comforted by the honesty in her which could not
stoop to dishonest comforting. In what superficially might seem her
failure there was a very real victory for them both. And there was
nothing of coldness in her reserve! There was the fulness of
understanding, and of valuing the moments too highly for anything there
was to be said about it. There was a great spiritual dignity, a
nobility, in the way she was looking at him. It called upon the whole
of his own spiritual dignity. It was her old demand upon him, but this
time the tears through which her eyes shone were tears of pride in
fulfilment, not of sorrowing for failure.
Suddenly he felt that his life had not been spent in vain, that the
lives of all those men of his day who had fought the good fight for
intellectual honesty—spiritual dignity—had not been spent in vain if
they were leaving upon the earth even a few who were like the girl
It turned him from himself to her. She was what counted—for she was
what remained. And he remained in just the measure that he remained
through her; counted in so far as he counted for her. It was as if he
had been facing in the wrong direction and now a kindly hand had turned
him around. It was not in looking back there he would find himself. He
was not back there to be found. Only so much of him lived as had been
able to wing itself ahead—on in the direction she was moving.
It did not particularly surprise him that when she at last spoke it
was to voice a shade of that same feeling. “I was thinking,” she began,
“of that younger man. Of what he must mean to the man who gives way to
She was feeling her way as she went—groping among the many dim
things that were there. He had always liked to watch her face when she
was thinking her way step by step.
“I think you used a word wrongly a minute ago,” she said, with a
smile. “You spoke of being replaced. But that isn't it. A man like you
isn't replaced; he's”—she got it after a minute and came forth with it
Her face was shining as she turned to him after that. “Don't you
see? He's there waiting to take your place because you got him ready.
Why, you made that younger man! Your whole life has been a getting
ready for him. He can do his work be cause you first did yours. Of
course he can go farther than you can! Wouldn't it be a sorry
commentary on you if he couldn't?”
Her voice throbbed warmly upon that last, and during the pause the
light it had brought still played upon her face. “We were talking in
class about immortality,” she went on, more slowly. “There's one form
of immortality I like to think about. It's that all those who from the
very first have given anything to the world are living in the world
to-day.” There was a rush of tears to her eyes and of affection to her
voice as she finished, very low: “You'll never die. You've deepened the
consciousness of life too much for that.”
They sat there as twilight drew near to night, the old man and the
young girl, silent. The laughter of boys and girls and the good-night
calls of the birds were all around them. The fragrance of life was
around them. It was one of those silences to which come impressions,
faiths, longings, not yet born as thoughts.
Something in the quality of that silence brought the rescuing sense
of its having been good to have lived and done one's part—that sense
which, from places of desolation and over ways rough and steep and
dark, can find its way to the meadows of serenity.