by Edith Wharton
AT nine o'clock on an August morning Mr. Frederick Tilney descended
the terrace steps of Sea Lodge and strolled across the lawn to the
The upper windows of the long white facade above the terrace were
all close-shuttered, for at nine o'clock Newport still sleeps, and he
who is stirring enough to venture forth at that unwonted hour may enjoy
what no wealth could buy a little later — the privilege of being
Though Mr. Tilney's habits of life, combined with the elegance of
his appearance, declared him to be socially disposed, he was not
insensible to the rarer pleasures of self-communion, and on this
occasion he found peculiar gratification in the thought of having to
himself the whole opulent extent of turf and flower border between
Ochre Point and Bailey's Beach. The morning was brilliant, with a blue
horizon line pure of fog, and such a sparkle on every leaf and grass
blade, and on every restless facet of the ever-moving sea, as would
have tempted a less sophisticated fancy to visions of wet bows and a
leaping stern, or of woodland climbs up the course of a mountain
But it was so long since Mr. Tilney had found a savor in such
innocent diversions, that the unblemished fairness of the morning
suggested to him only a lazy well-being associated with escape from
social duties, and the chance to finish the French novel over which he
had fallen asleep at three o'clock that morning.
It was odd how he was growing to value his rare opportunities of
being alone. He who in his earlier years had depended on the stimulus
of companionship as the fagged diner-out depends on the fillip of his
first glass of champagne, was now beginning to watch for and cherish
every momentary escape from the crowd. It had grown to such a passion
with him, this craving to have the world to himself, that he had
overcome the habit of late rising, and learned to curtail the
complications of his toilet, in order to secure a half hour of solitude
before he was caught back into the whizzing social machinery.
"And talk of the solitude of the desert, it's nothing to the
Newport cliffs at this hour," he mused, as he threw himself down on a
shaded seat invitingly placed near the path which follows the shore.
"Sometimes I feel as if the sea, and the cliffs, and the skyline out
there, were all a part of the stupid show — the expensive stage
setting of a rottenly cheap play — to be folded up and packed away
with the rest of the rubbish when the performance is over; and it's
good to come out and find it here at this hour, all by itself, and not
giving a hang for the ridiculous goings-on of which it happens to be
made the temporary background. Well — there's one comfort: none of the
other fools really see it — it's here only for those who seek it out
at such an hour — and as I'm the only human being who does, it's here
only for me, and belongs only to me, and not to the impenetrable asses
who think they own it because they've paid for it at so many thousand
dollars a foot!"
And Mr. Tilney, throwing out his chest with the irrepressible pride
of possessorship, cast an eye of approval along the windings of the
deserted path which skirted the lawn of Sea Lodge and lost itself in
the trim shrubberies of the adjoining estate.
"Yes — it's mine — all mine — and this is the only real
possessorship, after all! No fear of intruders at this hour — no need
of warning signposts, and polite requests to keep to the path. I don't
suppose anybody ever walked along this path at my hour, and I don't
care who walks here for the rest of the day!" But at this point his
meditations were interrupted by the sight of a white gleam through the
adjacent foliage; and a moment later all his theories as to the habits
of his neighbors had been rudely shattered by the appearance of a lady
who, under the sheltering arch of a wide lace sunshade, was advancing
indolently toward his seat.
"Why, you've got my bench!" she exclaimed, passing before him, with
merriment and indignation mingling in her eyes as sun and wind
contended on the ripples behind her.
"Your bench?" echoed Tilney, rising at her approach, and
dissembling his annoyance under a fair pretense of hospitality. "If
ever I thought anything on earth was mine, it's this bench."
The lady, who was young, tall and critical-looking, drew her
straight brows together and smilingly pondered his assertion.
"I suppose you thought that because it happens to stand in the
grounds of Sea Lodge instead of Cliffwood — we haven't any benches, by
the way; but my theory is a little different, as it happens. I think
things belong only to the people who know how to appreciate them."
"Why, so do I — if the bench isn't mine, at least the theory is!"
"Well, it's mine too, and it makes the bench mine, you see," the
young lady argued with earnestness, "because hitherto I've been the
only person who appreciated sitting on it at this hour."
"Ah, hitherto, perhaps — but not since I arrived here last week. I
haven't missed a morning," Tilney declared.
She smiled. "That explains the misunderstanding. I've been away for
a week, and before that no one ever ever sat on my bench at this hour."
"And since then no one has ever ever sat on my bench at this hour;
but, my dear Miss Grantham," Tilney gallantly concluded, "I shall be
only too honored if you will make the first exception to this rule by
sitting on it in my company this morning."
Miss Grantham was evidently a young lady of judicial temper, for
she weighed this assertion as carefully as the other, before answering,
with a slight tinge of condescension: "I don't know that you have any
more right to ask me to sit on my bench, than I have to ask you to sit
on yours, but for my part I am magnanimous enough to assume just for
once that it's ours."
Tilney bowed his thanks and seated himself at her side. "I realize
how magnanimous it is of you," he returned, "for, just as you came
round the corner, I was saying to myself that this bench was really the
only thing in the world I could call my own — "
"And now I've taken half of it away from you! But then," she
rejoined, "you've taken the other half from me; and as I was under the
same delusion as yourself, we are both in the same situation, and had
better accommodate ourselves as best we can to the diminished glory of
"It would be ungrateful of me to reject so reasonable a proposal;
but in return for my consent, would you mind telling me how you happen
to attach such excessive importance to the ownership of this bench?"
"It isn't the bench alone — it's the bench and the hour. They are
the only things I have to myself."
Tilney met her lovely eyes with a look of intelligence. "Ah, that's
surprising — very surprising."
"Why so?" she exclaimed, a little resentfully.
"Because it's so exactly my own feeling."
Miss Grantham smiled and caressed the folds of her lace gown. "And
is it so surprising that we should happen to have the same feelings?"
"Not in all respects, I trust; but I never suspected you of an
inclination for solitude."
She returned his scrutiny with a glance as penetrating. "Well, you
don't look like a recluse yourself; yet I think I should have guessed
that you sometimes have a longing to be alone."
"A longing? Good heavens, it's a passion, it's becoming a mania!"
"Ah, how well I understand that. It's the only thing that can tear
me from my bed!"
"I confess one doesn't associate you with the sunrise," he said,
letting his glance rest with amusement on the intricate simplicity of
"And you!" she smiled back at him. "If our friends were to be told
that Fred Tilney and Belle Grantham were to be found sitting on the
cliffs at nine o'clock in the morning, the day after the Summerton ball
"And that they had come there, not to meet each other, but to
escape from every one else — "
"Oh, there's the point: that's what makes it interesting. If we're
in the same box why shouldn't we be on the same bench?"
"It requires no argument to convince me that we should. But are we
in the same box? You see I've just come, and when I saw you last night
I supposed you were stopping with the Summertons."
She shook her head. "No, I'm next door, at Cliffwood, for the
"At Cliffwood? With the Bixbys?" He glanced at the fantastic
chimneys and profusely carved gables which made the neighboring villa
rise from its shrubberies like a piece montee from a flower-decked
"Well, why not, if you're at Sea Lodge with Mr. Magraw?"
"Oh, I'm only a poor itinerant devil — "
"And what am I but a circulating beauty? Didn't you know I'd gone
into the business too? I hope you won't let professional jealousy
interfere with our friendship."
"I'm not sure that I can help it, if you've really gone into the
business. But when I last saw you — where was it? — oh, in Athens —
"Things were different, were they not?" she interposed. "I was
sketching and you were archaeologizing — do you remember that divine
day at Delphi? Not that you took much notice of me, by the way — "
"Wasn't one warned off the premises by the report that you were
engaged to Lord Pytchley?"
She colored, and negligently dropped her sunshade between her eyes
and his. "Well, I wasn't, you see — and my sketches were not good
enough to sell. So I've taken to this kind of thing instead. But I
thought you meant to stick to your digging."
He hesitated. "I was very keen about it for a time; but I had a
touch of the sun out in Greece that summer; and a rich fellow picked me
up on his steam yacht and carried me off to the Black Sea and then to a
salmon river in Norway. I meant to go back, but I dawdled, and the
first thing I knew they put another chap in my place. And now I'm
Hutchins Magraw's secretary."
He sat staring absently at the distant skyline, and perceiving that
he was no longer conscious of her presence she quietly shifted her
sunshade and let her eyes rest for a moment on his moody profile.
"Yes — that's what I call it, too. I'm Mrs. Bixby's secretary —
or Sadie's, I forget which. But how much writing do you do?"
"Well, not much. The butler attends to the invitations."
"I merely keep an eye on Sadie's spelling, and see that she doesn't
sign herself 'lovingly' to young men. Mrs. Bixby has no correspondents,
and the dinner invitations are engraved."
"And what are your other duties?"
"Oh, the usual things — reminding Mrs. Bixby not to speak of her
husband as Mr. Bixby, not to send in her cards when people are at home,
not to let the butler say 'fine claret' in a sticky whisper in people's
ears, not to speak of town as 'the city,' and not to let Mr. Bixby tell
what things cost. Mrs. Bixby takes the bit in her teeth at times, but
Sadie is such a dear adaptable creature that, when I've broken her of
trying to relieve her callers of their hats, I shall really have
nothing left to do. That habit is hard to eradicate, because she is
such a good girl, and it was so carefully inculcated at her finishing
Tilney reflected. "Magraw is a good fellow too. There's really
nothing to do except to tone him down a little — as you say, one feels
as if one didn't earn one's keep."
She flashed round upon him instantly. "Ah, but I didn't say that. I
said the ostensible duties were easy — but how about the others?"
He looked at her a little consciously. "What do you mean by the
"I don't know how far you live up to your duties, but I'm horribly
conscientious about mine. And of course what we're both paid for is to
be introducers," she said.
"Introducers?" He colored slightly and, flinging his arm over the
back of the bench, turned to command a fuller view of her face. "Yes,
that is what we're paid for, I suppose."
"And that's what I hate about it, don't you?"
"Uncommonly," he assented with emphasis.
It isn't that the Bixbys are not nice people — they are, deep
down, you know — or at least they would be, if they were leading a
real life among their real friends. But the very fact that one is
abetting them to lead a false life, and renounce and deny their past,
and impose themselves on people who wouldn't look at them if it were
not for their money, and who rather resent their intrusion as it is —
well, if one oughtn't to be paid well for doing such a job as that, I
don't know what it is to work for my living!"
Tilney continued to observe with appreciation the dramatic play of
feature by means of which she expressed her rising disgust at her task;
but when she ended he merely said in a detached tone: "It's charming
how you've preserved your illusions."
"My illusions? Why, I haven't enough left for decency!"
"Oh, yes, you have. About the Bixbys, and what they would be if one
hadn't egged them on. Why not say to yourself that, if they were not
vulgar at heart, they would never have let themselves be taken in by
this kind of humbug?"
"Is that what you say about Mr. Magraw?"
"I've told you that Magraw is a good fellow. But when I ran across
him he was simply aching to see the show, and all I've done is to get
him a seat in the front row."
"Yes — but are you not expected to do something more for him?"
"Something more — in what line?"
"Well, I think the Bixbys expect me to make a match for Sadie."
"The deuce they do! Well, we'll marry her to my man."
Miss Grantham uttered a cry of dismay. "Don't suggest it even in
joke! Don't you see what a catastrophe it would be?"
"Why should it be a catastrophe?"
"Don't you really see? In the first place we should both be out of
a job, and in the second, I should earn the everlasting enmity of the
Bixbys. What they want for Sadie is not money but position. Mrs. Bixby
tells me that every day."
Tilney received this in meditative silence: then he said with a
slight laugh: "Well, if position is all they want, why don't you choose
me as your candidate?"
Miss Grantham did not echo his laugh; she simply concentrated her
gaze on his with a slowly deepening interest before answering: "It's a
funny idea — but I believe they might do worse."
Tilney's hilarity increased.
"At any rate," she continued, without noticing it, "there's one
thing that you and no one else can do for them, and I really believe
that Mrs. Bixby, in her present mood, would be capable of rewarding you
with her daughter's hand."
"Good heavens! Then I should have to take a look at Miss Bixby
before doing it."
"Oh, Sadie's charming. Didn't you notice her last night at the
ball? I managed to smuggle her in, though I couldn't get the others
invited. What Mrs. Bixby wants," Miss Grantham earnestly continued,
"what she's absolutely sickening for at this moment, is to have Sadie
invited to Aline Leicester's little Louis XV. dance to-morrow night.
And you are the only person in Newport who can do it. I didn't even
have a chance to try — for the very day my invitation came I happened
to meet Aline, and she said at once: 'Belle, I see the Bixbys in your
eye; but I don't see them in my ballroom.' After that, I tried a little
wire-pulling, but it simply made her more obstinate — you know her
latest pose is to snub the new millionaires; and you are the only
person who can persuade her to make an exception for the Bixbys.
Aline's family feeling is tremendously strong, and every one knows you
are her favorite cousin."
Tilney listened attentively to this plea; but when it had ended he
said, with a discouraging gesture: "I was just going to try to get an
invitation for Magraw!"
"Lump them together, then — it will be just as easy; and if you
should want Mr. Bixby to do anything for you — such as putting you on
to a good tip — "
"Thanks, but I've been put on to too many good tips. If it weren't
for the good tips I've had, I should be living like a gentleman on my
"Well, you'll make Mrs. Bixby think you the most eligible young man
in Newport. And if you could persuade Aline to ask Sadie to the dinner
before the dance — "
" Comme vous y allez! What would be my return for that?"
She rose with a charming gesture. "Who knows, after all? Perhaps
only the pleasure of doing me a very great favor."
"That settles it. I'll do what I can. But how about getting your
costumes at such short notice?"
"Oh, we cabled out to Worth on the chance." She held out her hand
for good-by. "If only there were something I could do for you!"
"Well, there is, as it happens," he rejoined with a smile. "If I
succeed in my attempt, let Magraw dance the cotillon with you at
She hesitated, visibly embarrassed. "I should be delighted, of
course. I'm engaged already, but that's nothing. Only — I'm going to
be horribly frank — the Bixbys are rather a heavy load, and I'm not
sure I can carry your friend too!"
"Oh, yes, you can. That's my reason for asking you. You see, I
really can't help Magraw much. It takes a woman to give a man a start.
Aline will say, 'Oh, bring him, if you choose' — but when he comes she
won't take any notice of him, or introduce him to any of the nice
women. He was too shy to go to the Summertons' last night — he's
really very shy under his loudness — so Aline's dance will be his
first appearance in Newport; and if he's seen dancing the cotillon with
you, at a little souterie like that, with only a handful of people in
the room, why, he's made, and my hard work is over for the season."
She smiled. "If you take a fancy to Sadie, perhaps it's over for
"And if you — by George! No, I don't think I want you to dance the
cotillon with Magraw."
"Why not? Do you grudge me a comfortable home for my old age?"
He stood gazing at her as though for the first time his eyes took
in the full measure of her grace.
"No — but I grudge him even a cotillon with you."
"Ah, you and I were not made to dance cotillons with one another;
or do anything together, except conspire at sunrise for each other's
material advancement. And that reminds me — I shan't see you again
to-day, for we are going to Narragansett on Mr. Bixby's yacht, and
to-night we have a dinner at home. But if you succeed with Aline, will
you send me a line in the evening?"
He shook his head as they clasped hands once more. "No; but I'll
tell you about it here to-morrow morning."
"Very well — I'll be punctual!" she called out to him, as she sped
away through the shrubbery.
It was, in fact, Miss Grantham who was first on the scene the next
morning; and so eager was she to learn the result of the mission with
which she had charged her friend, that, instead of profiting by her few
moments of solitude, she sat watching the path and chafing at Mr.
When he arrived, politeness restrained the question on her lips;
but his first word was to assure her of his success. "You are to bring
Miss Bixby to the dinner," he announced.
"Oh, thank you, thank you — you're wonderful!" she exclaimed; "and
if there's anything in the world I can do — " She paused suddenly,
remembering her side of the compact, and added with nobility: "If it is
of any possible advantage to Mr. Magraw to make my acquaintance, I
shall be very glad — "
She had already observed in Tilney a marked depression of manner,
which even this handsome reaffirmation of her purpose did not dispel.
"Oh," he merely said, "I did not mean to hold you so closely to
your bargain — " and with that he seated himself at her side, and
lapsed into a state of dumb preoccupation.
Miss Grantham suffered this as long as it was possible for a young
lady of spirit to endure; then she determined to make Mr. Tilney aware
of her presence by withdrawing it.
"I am afraid," she said, rising with a smile, "that, though you
welcomed me so handsomely yesterday, my being here seriously interferes
with your enjoyment of the hour, and I am going to propose a
compromise. Since it is agreed that we are joint proprietors of this
bench, and entitled to an equal share of its advantages, and since our
sitting on it together practically negatives those advantages, I
suggest that we occupy it on alternate mornings — and to show my
gratitude for the favor you have done me, I will set the example by
Tilney met her smile with a look of unrelieved melancholy. "I don't
wonder," he said, "that you find solitude less oppressive than my
company; but since our purpose in seeking this bench is to snatch an
hour's quiet enjoyment, and since enjoyment of any sort is impossible
to me to-day, it is obviously you who are entitled to remain here, and
I who ought to take myself away." And he held out his hand in farewell.
Miss Grantham detained it in hers. "To have you surrender your
rights because you are too miserable to enjoy them, leaves me with no
heart to profit by my own; and if you wish me to remain you must stay
also, and tell me what it is that troubles you."
She reseated herself as she spoke, and Tilney, with a deprecating
gesture, resumed his place at her side.
"My dear Miss Grantham, the subject is too trifling to mention; I
was only trying to calculate how long one could live in Venice on a
"Why in Venice — and why a hundred dollars?"
"Because, when my passage is paid, it will be all the ready money I
possess, and I have always heard that one could live very moderately in
Miss Grantham flushed and threw a quick glance at him. "You're not
thinking of deserting?" she cried, reproachfully.
The young man returned her look. "Deserting — whom?" he inquired.
"Well, me, if you choose! You can't think the comfort it's been to
me, since yesterday, to know that there were two of us. I understand
now how humane it is to chain convicts together!"
Tilney considered this with a faint smile. "How long have you been
at it?" he asked.
"At the Bixbys? I joined them last April in Paris."
"Ah, well — I've been six months with Magraw. It wasn't so bad
when we were yachting and knocking about the world — but since we've
taken to society it has become unendurable."
"Yes. I didn't mind ordering the Bixbys' dresses as much as I mind
providing opportunities for their wearing them."
"I don't so much mind trotting Magraw about — though you know it's
nonsense about your having to dance with him this evening — "
"No matter about that. What is it that bothers you?"
"The whole preposterous situation. Magraw's the best fellow in the
world — but there are moments when he takes me for the butler."
"Oh, I know," she sympathized. "Mrs. Bixby — "
"That isn't the worst, though: it's the reaction. He took me for
the butler yesterday afternoon — and in the evening I found a ruby
scarf pin on my dressing table."
But her sympathy was ready for any demand on it. "I know, I know —
" she reiterated; and then, breaking off, she added with a mounting
color: "You know I couldn't go to the dance to-night if Mrs. Bixby
didn't pay for my dress."
"Oh, the cases are not the same; and it's different for a woman."
"Why are the cases not the same? And why should I not be humiliated
by what humiliates you?"
He shrugged his shoulders ironically. "I'm not humiliated by
anything that poor Magraw does to me; I'm humiliated by what I do to
"What you do?"
"Yes. What right have I to behave like a gentleman, and return his
"At least you do return them? And I can't return the dresses. Oh,
it's detestable either way!" she exclaimed.
"Yes, especially when one succumbs to the weakness of hating them
instead of one's self. I hate Magraw this morning," he confessed.
She rose with an impatient glance at her watch. "Dear me, I must
go. I promised Sadie to see the dressmaker at half-past nine: she's
coming to alter our fancy dresses. You see I felt sure you would get
Sadie's invitation. I want you to know her," she continued. "She's
really a very nice girl. I should like her immensely if I didn't have
to accept so many favors from her."
"Ah, you've just expressed my feeling about Magraw. I really should
like your opinion of him," he added.
"Well, you shall have it — to-morrow morning."
"Here?" he rejoined with sudden interest.
"Why not? You know I mean to dance with him this evening."
The morning after the dance it was Miss Grantham's turn to arrive
late at the tryst; and when she did so, it was with the air of having a
duty to discharge rather than a pleasure to enjoy.
"Mr. Tilney," she said, advancing resolutely to the bench on which
he sat awaiting her, "my only object in coming this morning is — "
He rose with extended hand. "To let me thank you, I hope, for the
generous way in which you fulfilled your share of the compact? It was
awfully good of you to be so nice to Magraw."
She colored vividly, but held his gaze. "As it happens, I liked Mr.
Magraw. But if I had known the means you had used to obtain his
invitation — "
Tilney colored in turn, but they continued to face each other
"Did Aline betray me? How like a woman!" he exclaimed.
"I can quite understand," Miss Grantham witheringly continued, "the
importance you attached to having Mr. Magraw invited to your cousin's
dance. You had to make some return for the scarf pin. But to use my
name as a pretext — to tell Aline Leicester that I was trying to marry
"Oh, I didn't say trying — I said you meant to," Tilney corrected.
"As if that made it any better! To let that man think — "
"He'll never hear of it; and you don't seem to realize that it's
not easy to extract an invitation from Aline."
"I don't know that it was absolutely necessary that Mr. Magraw
should receive one!"
Tilney, at this, raised his head with a challenging air. "You
appeared to think it absolutely necessary that Miss Bixby should."
"Well — I don't see — "
"You don't see how I got hers? I dare say you'll think the same
method is even more objectionable when the situation is reversed — "
She stared at him with growing disapproval. "You don't mean to say
that you let Aline think you wanted to marry Sadie Bixby?"
"I told you there was nothing I wouldn't stoop to. I suppose you
think that horribly low."
Her stare resolved itself into a faint sound of laughter. "Good
heavens, how enchanted Mrs. Bixby will be!"
"The deuce she will — but of course the joke can easily be
"To whom? To Mrs. Bixby? I'm glad you think so. I should have said
it would be difficult."
"Oh, Mrs. Bixby will never hear of it. I told Aline in the
strictest confidence — "
"Every one at the dance was congratulating me on my conquest of Mr.
Magraw. I don't see why Aline should keep one secret and not the
Tilney's brow darkened ominously. "Well, at any rate, I'll soon
"A thousand thanks. And I suppose you leave it to me to undeceive
Sadie? She talked of you all the way home. Of course, you're almost the
only decent man she's met."
"Ah, then the remedy is simple enough. You've only to introduce a
"Yes, I've thought of that." Miss Grantham examined him with a cold
smile. "But are you quite sure you want me to?"
Tilney met her question with another. "What on earth do you mean?"
"I'm not stupid in such cases, and I could see that Sadie was
interested. Did you find her so perfectly impossible?"
"Impossible? I thought her very pretty."
"That's going to the other extreme — but she certainly looked her
best last night. Still, before deciding, I should want you to see her
by daylight — and without the paint — "
"Oh, she had on very little paint. One could see her own color
"Yes — she has an unfortunate way of getting red — "
"At that age I should call it blushing."
Miss Grantham's face grew suddenly stern. "Of course," she said, "I
should never forgive myself if you were only trifling with Sadie — "
Tilney paused. "But if I were in earnest — ?" he suggested.
She gazed at him intently for a moment. "After all, I might be
saving her from something worse!"
For two mornings after that Tilney, to his secret regret, had the
bench on the cliffs to himself. On the third morning he was detained
indoors somewhat later than usual on pressing business of his
employer's; and when he emerged from the house he was surprised, and
considerably dismayed, to find his seat tenanted by the incongruous
figure of Mr. Hutchins Magraw.
Given his patron's unmatutinal habits, and rooted indifference to
the beauties of nature, it was impossible to conceive what whim had
drawn him to so unlikely a spot at so improbable an hour; and Tilney's
first impulse was to approach the seat, and allay his curiosity by
direct inquiry. Hardly, however, had he begun to advance when the
flutter of a white skirt through the Cliffwood shrubberies caused him
to retreat abruptly into the covert of lilac bushes edging the lawn. It
was by a mere accident, of course, that an unknown female, wearing a
white gown, happened to be walking along the path from that particular
direction. The path was open to the public, and there was no reason to
assume any coincidence between —
Tilney drew a sharp breath. Mr. Magraw had risen and was advancing
in the direction of the approaching petticoat; and as it was impossible
for him to recognize its wearer from where he sat, it was obvious that
he expected some one, and that the invisible female was no casual
stroller drawn forth by the beauty of the morning. The next moment this
conjecture was unpleasantly confirmed; for Miss Grantham emerged from
the shrubbery, and placed her hand in Mr. Magraw's without perceptible
surprise. He, then, had also been expected; and she had actually had
the effrontery to select, as the scene of their tryst, the seat which,
by every right of friendship, should have been kept sacred to her
conversations with Fred Tilney!
"The idea of telling him about my bench!" Resentment of her perfidy
was for the moment uppermost in Tilney's breast, or was, at any rate,
the only sentiment to which he chose to give explicit expression. But
other considerations surged indignantly beneath it — wonder at woman's
unaccountableness, disgust at her facility, disappointment, above all,
that this one little episode, saved from the wreckage of many shattered
illusions, should have had so premature and unpoetic an ending.
"Magraw — if only it hadn't been Magraw!"
He had meant to turn away and reenter the house; but a feeling of
mingled curiosity and wretchedness kept him rooted in his hiding place,
while he followed with his eyes the broad swaggering back of Mr.
Hutchins Magraw, as it attended Miss Grantham's slender silhouette
across the lawn.
"I hadn't realized how disgustingly fat the man has grown. One
would think a fellow with that outline would know better than to rig
himself out in a check a foot square, and impale his double chin on the
points of that preposterous collar! It's odd how little the most
fastidious women notice such details. If they did, fewer men would make
themselves ridiculous. Why are they standing there, looking up at the
house? Perhaps, after all, it was an accident, their meeting. No —
they're making straight for the bench — by George, I believe they were
looking at the house to make sure I wasn't coming! Don't be alarmed, my
dear Miss Grantham, I've no desire to interfere with your amusements. I
see now, though, why Magraw was in such a hurry to have me balance his
bank book this morning. Just a dodge to keep me indoors, of course.
It's beastly bad taste, anyhow, to make a poor devil like me go over a
bank book with such an indecently big balance. That's the kind of thing
that makes a man turn socialist. Why the devil should Magraw have all
those millions while I — well, to be sure, poor devil, he needs them
all to make up for his other deficiencies. I'd like to see how long
Belle Grantham would share that bench with him if it weren't for his
bank account! It must be hard work to talk to Magraw at nine o'clock in
the morning. I wonder what the deuce she's saying to him?"
The two objects of Tilney's contemplation had by this time settled
themselves on the seat which their observer still chose to call his
own, and something in their attitudes seemed to announce that theirs
was no transient alighting, but the deliberate installation which
precedes an earnest talk.
"Well, she could talk to anybody, at any hour of the day or night!
That's her trade, poor girl, as much as it is mine. Only I can't see
why she should give Magraw my particular hour. Now that I've given him
such a good start they've plenty of other chances of meeting. But
perhaps she's afraid of competition, and wants to clinch the business
by this morning interview. Poor girl! How she must hate it at heart!
I'll do her the justice to say that if she had enough to keep body and
soul together she'd never look at a Magraw. But if this hand-to-mouth
life is hard on a man it's ten times worse for a woman — and her day
is over sooner, too. Poor girl! No wonder she shrinks at the idea of
growing old in such a trade. To see people cooling off, and the
newcomers crowding her out — how can I blame her for being afraid to
face such a future? Why, I ought to do what I can to help her — but to
help her to Magraw! Bah — there's something rotten in our social
system; but it isn't her fault, and only a primitive ass of a man would
be fool enough to blame her, instead of pitying her as a fellow
At this point Miss Grantham started up with an apprehensive gesture
with which Tilney was painfully familiar. "She's had to look at her
watch to realize how time was flying! She doesn't seem to find it goes
so slowly with Magraw. Perhaps my pity's wasted, after all. That's the
way she always lingers on after she has said she couldn't possibly stay
another minute. Poor Magraw! She's playing him for all she's worth, and
I don't suppose he even knows he's on the hook. Oh, I don't blame her
— not in the least! — only I think she might have chosen another
place for their meetings. Hardened wretch as I am, I was beginning to
have a sentiment for that bench — it would never have occurred to me
to sit there with Miss Bixby, for instance. It's queer how a woman's
taste deteriorates when she associates with common men — but I mean to
let Miss Grantham know that, though she's welcome to Magraw, she can't
have my bench into the bargain!"
By this time the couple under observation had completed their
lingering adieux, the gentleman returning across the lawn to his house,
while the lady retraced her way toward Cliffwood. Tilney remained in
concealment while Mr. Magraw strode by within a few feet, the fatuous
smile of self-complacency upon his lips; then the young man, emerging
behind his patron's back, struck across the lawn and overtook Miss
Grantham as she turned into the adjoining grounds.
She paused as she became aware of Tilney's approach, and cast a
rapid glance in the direction from which he had come; but he had taken
care not to show himself till Magraw had vanished in the shrubberies,
and he was quick to note the look of reassurance in Miss Grantham's
eyes. She held out her hand, blushing slightly, but self-possessed.
"J'ai failli attendre!" she quoted with an indulgent smile; and the
smile had well-nigh stung her companion to immediate retaliation. But
he meditated a subtler revenge, and dissembling his resentment, asked
innocently: "Have you been here long?"
"It has certainly seemed so," she replied in the same tone.
"Well, at any rate, my involuntary delay has enabled you to enjoy
what you originally came out to seek;" and, in reply to her puzzled
glance, he added pointedly: "The pleasures of solitude."
Unmoved by the thrust, she turned a smiling look on him. "But what
if you have made them lose their flavor?"
"Then it was almost worth my while to have stayed away!"
She held out her hand. "The experiment was so successful that you
need not try it again," she said sweetly. "But time flies, and I must
hasten back into captivity."
He detained her hand to ask sentimentally: "I hope you are not
losing your taste for freedom?" and she replied, as she hastened away:
"Come and see — come and see to-morrow!"
He stood in the path where she had left him, and slowly drew from
his pocket Mr. Magraw's latest gift — a jeweled cigarette case. He
took out the cigarettes, transferred them to his pocket, and then, with
a free swing of the arm, flung their receptacle into the sea.
"Do you come and see to-morrow!" he muttered, addressing himself to
Miss Grantham's retreating figure; then he lit a cigarette, and walked
rapidly back to Sea Lodge.
"I shouldn't have thought it of her!" he said as he entered the
TO BE CONCLUDED.
TWO mornings later Tilney, with a beating heart, descended the
terrace of Sea Lodge, and once more directed himself toward the bench
on the cliff.
He was not only on time, but a few minutes before the hour; yet it
was something of a surprise to him to find the bench still untenanted.
He seated himself, lit a cigarette with deliberation, and drew from his
pocket a note stamped Cliffwood and bearing the date of the previous
"Dear Mr. Tilney,"
it ran, "much as I dislike to intrude upon the solitude which I
know you value so highly, I must ask you to spare me a few moments
to-morrow morning; and I send this line in advance in order that my
coming may not interfere with any other arrangements.
Tilney re-read this note with an air of considerable complacency;
then he laid it carefully back in his notecase, and rose to meet Miss
Grantham as she made her appearance around the curve of the path.
The morning was chilly, and veiled in a slight haze, too
translucent to be called a fog, but perceptible enough to cast a faint
grayness over sea and sky. Seen in this tempered light, Miss Grantham's
face seemed to lose its usual vivacity and be subdued to the influence
of the atmosphere; and her manner of greeting Tilney had the same tinge
"I must excuse myself," she began, "for again intruding on your
privacy — "
"My privacy?" Tilney gallantly interposed. "Was it not long since
understood between us that the privacy of this spot belongs as much to
you as to me?"
"Long since — yes," she replied; "but so much has happened in the
interval." She paused, and added in a significant tone: "Since I came
here yesterday morning, and found you sitting on this bench with Sadie
Tilney feigned a successful show of embarrassment. "You came here
yesterday morning — ?"
"By appointment, as you evidently do not remember," she continued
coldly. "It is a mistake one does not make twice, and my only object in
asking to see you this morning — "
"One moment," Tilney interposed. "Before you go on, I must say in
my own defense that I assumed our compact about the use of this seat
had been abrogated when I came out the day before yesterday, and found
you sharing it with Magraw."
There was no mistaking the effect of this thrust. Her color rose
painfully, and she forced a laugh as she replied: "The day before
yesterday? Ah, yes — that was the morning you were so late. Mr. Magraw
saw me from the house, and took pity on my deserted state."
Tilney colored also at this fresh evidence of her duplicity.
"I beg your pardon — but does not your memory deceive you? It
seemed to me that Magraw was waiting on the bench, and that it was you
who took pity — if I am not mistaken."
She drew herself up and flashed an outraged glance at him. "You
were watching us, then?" she exclaimed.
"Oh — watching! I was merely repairing to our seat at my usual
"At your usual hour? But Mr. Magraw told me you were not coming —
that you would be busy all the morning with some writing — " She broke
off, seeing herself more deeply involved with each word.
"Some writing he had given me to do? Precisely," Tilney answered
with scorn. "Only, he had underrated either my impatience to see you,
or my head for figures — or both."
She received this in an embarrassed silence, and softened by her
embarrassment he added: "It is not for me to discuss your arrangements;
but I confess I wondered a little that you chose our bench as a
She hesitated a moment, and then said in a deprecating tone: "It is
the only place where I can see anyone alone!"
"And you wished to see Magraw alone?"
Their eyes met defiantly, but hers fell first as she answered: "Yes
— I did wish to."
Tilney bowed ceremoniously. "In that case, of course, nothing
remains to be said."
They had both remained standing during this short colloquy, but she
now seated herself and signed to him to do the same.
"Yes — something remains for me to say; and it was for the purpose
of saying it that I asked you to meet me this morning."
Tilney, without replying, placed himself at the opposite end of the
"What I wish to ask," she continued in a decisive tone, "is your
object in meeting Miss Bixby here yesterday."
The temerity of the question was so surprising to her companion
that for a moment he gazed at her without speaking; then he replied
with a faint smile: "If there is any right of priority in such
inquiries, perhaps I am entitled to ask first what was your object in
meeting Magraw here the day before that."
She repressed her impatience, and returned gently: "The cases are
surely not quite alike; but I thought I had already given you my
"That you wished to see him alone? Well, I had the same object in
asking Miss Bixby to meet me."
"But you must see that in the case of a young girl — especially a
girl as inexperienced as Sadie — "
Tilney raised his hand with a deprecating gesture. "Are you not
falling into the conventional mistake of assuming that a man cannot
seek to be alone with a young girl except for the purpose of making
love to her?"
"Well, what other purpose — ?"
He looked at her calmly. "Then it was to promote that purpose that
you asked Magraw to meet you here the day before I met Miss Bixby?"
It was Miss Grantham's turn to color, and she fulfilled the
obligation handsomely. "I see no object in such cross-questioning — "
"Ah, pardon me, but it was you who began it."
"It was my duty to question you about Sadie. You can't imagine I do
it for my pleasure — but her parents are too inexperienced to protect
"To protect her? Then you consider me hopelessly detrimental — ?"
Miss Grantham drew a quick breath. "Why not have told me at once
that you wished to marry her? Every one is saying so, of course; but I
could not help remembering that your intentions have not always been so
"Specific?" he suggested ironically.
"Well, you are still unmarried," she observed.
"Yes," he said musingly. "It takes a pretty varied experience of
life to find out that there are worse states than marriage."
Miss Grantham rose with a smile. "Since you have found it out," she
said generously, "I can congratulate you with perfect sincerity. Sadie
is a dear little creature — " "But too good for me? Is that what you
meant to add?"
"No, for when you find out how good she is you'll want to be worthy
He received this in silence, but when she held out her hand for
good-by he said: "I wonder if it's not my duty to protect Magraw? He
hasn't even an inexperienced parent."
She met his smile steadily, but he felt the sudden resistance of
her hand. "Mr. Magraw," she returned, withdrawing it, "would be quite
safe if Sadie were."
"If Sadie — ?"
She broke into a laugh. "If you're planning to take the bread out
of my mouth, I must do something in the way of self-preservation." And
as he remained silent, feeling a rather tragic import under her
pleasantry, she added wearily: "I can't begin this kind of thing over
again — I simply can't!"
Tilney's discouraged gesture showed his comprehension of her words.
"To whom do you say it?" he exclaimed.
"Well, then, let us drop phrases, and admit frankly that we're
trying to marry each other's wards — or whatever you choose to call
He did not answer, and she continued, with a kind of nervous
animation: "And that we'll do all we can — that we honorably can — to
help each other's plans, and see each other through."
The young man still remained silent, his eyes absently fixed on the
line of sea from which the veil of mist was gradually receding; and
before he had found a reply a footman, hastening across the lawn from
the house, broke in upon his meditations.
"Beg pardon, sir, but Mr. Magraw wishes you to come in immediately,
sir, to answer the telephone for him."
Tilney turned abruptly toward his companion. "By heaven, yes, we'll
see each other through!" he exclaimed.
Though Tilney and Miss Grantham had parted without any reference to
future meetings at the same spot, each was now drawn to the bench on
the cliffs by a new motive — the not unpardonable desire to see if the
other had again extended its hospitality to a third party.
Their mutual reconnoitering did not, for several mornings, carry
them farther than the most distant point from which the bench was
visible; when, perceiving it to be untenanted, they respectively
retreated, without having discovered each other's manoeuvre.
The fifth day, however, was so foggy that distant espionage was
impossible; and Tilney's suspicions having been aroused by the unusual
amount of correspondence with which his patron had burdened him
overnight, he determined to ascertain by direct inspection if the
sanctity of the bench had again been violated. It would have been hard
to say why, in his own thoughts, he still applied such terms to the
possibility of Miss Grantham's resorting to the spot in company with
her suitor. Tilney fully acquiesced in the inevitableness of the course
they had agreed upon; but if his reason accepted the consequences, his
sensibilities made the process unpleasant to contemplate. He would have
been prepared to append his signature to a matrimonial contract drawn
up between Miss Grantham and his employer; but it irritated him that an
arrangement so purely utilitarian should be disguised under the
charming futilities of courtship.
"The real grossness is not in viewing marriage as a business
partnership, but in pretending that one doesn't," he summed up, as he
crossed the damp lawn with the waves of gray fog coiling around him
like a phantom sea.
Through their pale surges he could just discern, as he approached
the bench, an indeterminate outline hovering near it; and the outline
proclaiming itself, on nearer inspection, as of his own sex, Tilney was
about to turn aside when another figure appeared from the direction of
"It's odd," he mused, trying to philosophize upon his own
discomfiture — "it's odd how the fog distorts a silhouette. I could
have sworn I should have known hers anywhere, and yet this deceptive
vapor — or my nerves, or the two together — make her look so much
shorter — and I'll swear I never saw her swing her arm as she walked.
I suppose it comes from associating with a bounder like — "
He drew back with a suppressed exclamation as the small feminine
outline showed more clearly through a partial break in the fog.
"Why, it looks — no, it can't be! Hanged if I know, she's so
bundled up. Well, it's not she, at any rate; and if Magraw, at this
stage of the proceedings, has the indecency to be meeting other women
here, it's almost my duty to the poor girl to let her know before it's
too late to break with him."
He was surprised at the immediate sense of lightness which this
conclusion produced in him. He was sorry for Miss Grantham, of course,
when she'd so nearly landed her man; but, hang it, there were as good
fish in the sea — and meanwhile she must, at all costs, be saved from
the humiliation of committing herself farther. His first impulse had
been the somewhat cruel one of putting the unvarnished facts before
her; but farther reflection made him shrink from this course, and cast
about for some more humane expedient.
"If she could only be made to think that she can do better than
Magraw — and she ought to, with half a chance, poor child! I can't be
wholly sorry that she should not be sacrificed to this particular
monster — not that Magraw's not a good fellow in himself; I daresay
the Minotaur was liked in his own set — but he should have stayed
there, that's all."
While engaged in these considerations, Tilney had prudently
withdrawn into the Cliffwood shrubberies; and he was just deciding to
effect his escape through the Bixbys' grounds, rather than run the
chance of being discovered by the tenants of the bench, when, on
issuing from his retreat, he beheld the indistinct gleam of a white
dress half way down the Cliffwood lawn. This time, even though the fog
had thickened, there was no mistaking the form and movement of the
shrouded figure; or was it some subtler sense than that of sight that
so positively assured him of Miss Grantham's nearness? At any rate, he
advanced to meet her without a moment's hesitation, determined to
protect her, by whatever expedient, from the embarrassment of
interrupting the colloquy on the bench. He had but a moment in which to
consider how this should be effected; but it was not the first time he
had trusted to his gift of improvisation in delicate situations, and he
was now sustained by the unwonted sense of his complete
disinterestedness. The progress of his own affairs had in fact made it
impossible for him to interfere from personal motives; and he thus had
the support of knowing that his intervention was quite unaffected by
"I'm almost glad," he reflected, "that I am committed, if one of
the first consequences is to enable me to act as her friend, without
any afterthought, or any possibility of her suspecting me of not
playing fair. One of my reasons for wanting to settle my own future has
always been the desire to help her; and little Sadie is far too good a
girl not to understand — "
At this point he found himself face to face with Miss Grantham,
who, suddenly discerning him through the fog, drew back with a slight
start of surprise.
"I had a feeling that I might meet you this morning," he said in a
tone of undisguised pleasure; and even as he spoke, his half-formed
plan for her rescue began to dissolve in the glow of happiness which
her nearness always produced. He was annoyed to find that his
self-control was so completely at the mercy of her presence; but he
could no more resist the sudden reaction of his pulses from reason to
feeling than he could dispel the softly enveloping fog which seemed to
act as the accomplice of his wishes.
"If I can only make her think she can do better than Magraw," he
kept mechanically repeating to himself; but the only expedient that
occurred to him was one which both prudence and honor rejected.
Miss Grantham's first words threw his ideas into still deeper
"Mr. Tilney," she said, without heeding his greeting, "are you, or
are you not, engaged to Sadie Bixby?"
The abruptness of the inquiry, and the sternness of her tone, had a
not wholly unpleasing effect on the young man; but their only
perceptible result was to reduce him to an embarrassed silence.
Miss Grantham gave a faint laugh. "I suppose I may consider myself
answered? And in that case, I have only to apologize for asking so
indiscreet a question — "
Tilney cleared his throat nervously. "I am not aware that I have
either answered your question or shown that I regarded it as indiscreet
"Your silence did both," she returned with some impatience. He made
no reply, and after a moment's pause she added, with a sudden
assumption of playfulness: "Well, if this is really to be our last
meeting, as I suppose it is — shall we not celebrate it by sitting
together for a few moments on our dear old bench?"
As she spoke she began to move in the direction of the seat,
apparently assuming that her companion would offer no opposition to her
proposal. But Tilney, with a vague exclamation, laid his hand on her
arm. "Don't you think it's rather too damp to sit out of doors?"
He reddened under the laugh with which she met this incongruous
"My poor friend — would she really mind so much? I was foolish
enough to think you might give me this last morning — "
"The whole day is at your service," he interposed nervously, "but
"Ah, yes; there will always be a but between us now. No wonder men
get on so much better than women; they are so much more prudent! Now,
even if I were engaged to Mr. Magraw — " She broke off, and he fancied
he could see her flush through the fog.
He turned on her abruptly. "Are you? There's the point!" he
She drew back, slightly disconcerted, but recovering herself at
once, added in the same playful tone: "I was about to say that, even if
I were, I should not feel there was any disloyalty to my future in
giving this last hour to our past."
Her light emphasis on the pronoun threw him into a glow of
pleasure, through which discretion and foresight loomed as remote as
objects in the fog; but when she added, with a half-sad laugh: "I
should not hesitate to go back to our bench for the last time — " he
broke out, with a fresh leap of apprehension: "Ah, but you couldn't, if
it meant to you what it does to me!"
He had spoken the words at haphazard, snatching at them as the
readiest means of diverting her purpose; but once uttered they seemed
to fill the whole air, and to create a silence which neither speaker
had, for a moment, the courage to fill.
Womanlike, Miss Grantham was the first to recover her
self-possession. "I am sure," she said sweetly, "that we shall both
look back often on our quiet morning talks, and I can't think that the
persons with whom our futures may be associated will be defrauded by
our treasuring such memories."
She spoke with a sadness so poignant to Tilney that for a moment he
stood without replying, and during the pause she again advanced a few
steps nearer to the bench.
The young man broke into a scornful laugh. " Defrauded? Good
heavens — one can't defraud people of treasures they are utterly
incapable of valuing!"
She caught this up with a vehemence that surprised him. "Oh, do you
feel that too? It's just what I mean," she exclaimed.
"Feel it — ?" He stopped before her, blocking her way. "Do you
suppose I've felt anything else, night or day, since the accursed day
when we agreed — ?"
He interrupted himself with a last effort at self-control, and she
replied in a low tone of exquisite pleading: "Well, then, if you do
feel it, why not go back for a moment to our bench?"
Tilney groaned. "Can't we talk as well here? Let us walk a little
way — we shall be alone anywhere in this fog." ("Anywhere but on that
confounded bench," he mentally added.)
Miss Grantham uttered an ironical exclamation. "Ah, you've promised
her, I see. Was it one of the conditions? In that case, of course — "
"There were no conditions — and if there had been — "
"Oh, be careful! I want to talk of our past, and not of our
Tilney groaned again. "If only it could be our future — Belle,
what a beastly bad turn we've done each other, after all!"
"Don't let us talk of the present, either, please." She laid a
restraining touch on his arm. "Why should we give each other this pain
when it's too late?"
"Too late?" He paused, remembering that, for him at least, it was
too late; but an irresistible impulse prompted him to add: "If it
hadn't been, tell me at least — would you have dared to, Belle?"
They stood looking at each other, mysteriously isolated in the
magic circle of the fog.
"Dared? I am daring more now — more than I have courage for!" she
murmured, half to herself.
The admission had well-nigh broken down the last barriers of
Tilney's self-restraint; but at the moment of surrender he suddenly
recalled his own state of bondage. He had but to lead Miss Grantham to
the bench, and she would find herself free; but when she turned to
reward him as liberators expect to be rewarded, with what a sorry
countenance must he refuse her gift!
He dropped the hand he had caught in his, and said in a low voice:
"You were right just now, and I was wrong. We must not even talk of our
past, lest we should be tempted to think of our present or our future.
I happen to know that I am not doing anyone a serious wrong in speaking
to you as I have; but my own case is different."
"Your own case is different?" Miss Grantham interposed, with a
sudden change of voice and expression. "If you think you can make love
to me without doing Mr. Magraw a serious wrong, I should like to know
why I may not listen to you without — "
Tilney received her attack with a disarming humility. "I said the
cases were different, because, in a moment of incredible folly, I have
tried to attract the interest of a trustful, affectionate girl — "
Miss Grantham interrupted him with a laugh. "Do you mean that," she
asked ironically, "for a description of Sadie Bixby?"
Her tone aroused an incongruous flash of resentment in Tilney. "I
see no difficulty," he returned, "in identifying the young lady from my
"If you really believe them to apply to her, I cannot see how you
can excuse yourself for being here with me at this moment!" She laughed
again, and then, to Tilney's surprise, drew nearer, and once more laid
her hand on his arm.
"My poor friend, it is I who am the real offender, and not you.
Believe me, I would not have let you speak to me as you have to-day, if
I had not known — if I had not almost felt it my duty to be kind to
you — to do what I could to atone — "
"To be kind to me? To atone? What on earth are you talking about?"
exclaimed Tilney, startled by this unexpected echo of his inmost
"Alas, it was a foolish impulse, and one which only our old
friendship could justify. I forgot for a moment that I was not free, in
my desire to prepare you — to console you in advance — for a blow —
"A blow? You're not married?" burst from Tilney.
She paused, and gazed at him wonderingly but not unkindly.
"I was speaking of yourself — yourself and Sadie. I feel myself so
deeply to blame — "
Tilney interrupted her with an air of inexpressible relief. "We're
both to blame for abetting each other in such suicidal folly. As if
either of us was made to give up life and liberty for a bank-balance!
But I don't reproach you, Belle — it was more my fault than yours; and
I deserve that I should be the one to pay the penalty!"
"The penalty? The penalty of marrying Sadie?" she breathlessly
"Of marrying any one but you!" he returned recklessly; and at the
retort, a veil of sadness fell suddenly upon her eager face.
"It's too late to think of that now; but if you really feel as you
say — "
Tilney again cut her short. "It's too late for me, I know; but if
you really feel as you say, thank Heaven, Belle, it's not too late for
She drew back a step, and both paused, as though dazed by the shock
of their flying words. But as Tilney again approached her, she raised
her hand and said gravely: "I don't know what you mean, but I can
explain what I mean if you'll only — "
"One moment, please. I can explain, too, if you'll only — "
He caught her hand, and began to lead her hurriedly across the lawn
to the bench.
"Only what?" she panted, trying to keep pace with his flying
strides; and he called back across his shoulder: "Only come to the
bench — and be quick!"
"To the bench? Why, haven't I been trying all this time to take you
there?" she cried after him, between tears and laughter.
"Yes; but I didn't know; at least you didn't know — "
"Didn't know what?"
"Whom you'd find there!"
She pulled back at this, detaining him forcibly. "Good heavens,"
she gasped, "do you mean to say that you've known all this time?"
"Do you think I should have dared to say what I have if I hadn't —
"Hadn't known about Sadie — ?"
" Sadie? I suppose you mean Magraw?"
"Mr. Magraw?" She stopped short, and snatched her hand away with an
"Mr. Tilney, who do you think is sitting on that bench?"
He faced around on her with equal indignation. "I don't think: I
know. Magraw is sitting there with a woman."
"You're utterly mistaken! I happen to know that it's Sadie Bixby
who is sitting there with a man."
There was a long pause between them, charged with a gradual rush of
inner enlightenment; then Tilney suddenly burst into a huge,
"Well, then, don't you see — ?"
"I don't see anything more than if the fog were inside me!" she
"Don't you see that Magraw and Miss Bixby must be sitting there
together, and that, in that case, nothing remains for you and me but to
find a new seat for ourselves?"