A Daughter of the Sea
by Charles Wesley Sanders
, February 23, 1918
CAPTAIN McAULIFFE, going over the side of his ship, paused as he
caught sight of Captain Winton coming along the wharf. Then McAuliffe
slipped back to the deck and disappeared into his cabin.
Winton grinned maliciously.
I got the fear o' God into his heart at last, all right, he said to
himself. I knowed he was a coward at bottom, and this proves it. He
don't want to meet me.
Winton continued along the wharf as if he had not noticed McAuliffe's
action. He came to a corner on which a low warehouse stood. Without a
backward glance, he passed around the corner. But once shut off from
McAuliffe's view, if the latter should come on deck, he stopped. The
malicious grin was still on his lips.
In his cabin, McAuliffe waited long enough to give Winton time to
climb the hill from the river to the street above. Then he emerged
again and went over the side. He followed the course which Winton had
taken. As he rounded the corner of the warehouse he came face to face
Winton laughed aloud. His merriment brought deep wrinkles into his
weather-beaten face, especially about his mouth and eyes. He pulled
himself up to his six feet two inches and looked down at McAuliffe,
whose height stopped short of six feet.
They were both strong men, but there was a subtle as well as a gross
difference in that strength. Winton was husky. He was built more
heavily than even his height warranted. His legs were like the piles in
the river. He was rotund of waist. His shoulders wore massive. His
unbuttoned shirt collar disclosed a bull neck. His eyes were
slate-colored, cold, quick to show hate, never gentle. His
close-cropped hair was red to its roots. He was human physical force at
its best or worst.
McAuliffe tapered up from his feet. He was slender of leg, slender of
hip, carrying no abdominal excess. But his shoulders spread out almost
to the width of Winton's, and his chest was deep. He had very black
hair, close-cropped like Winton's, and his eyes were a deep brown. He
was rather thin of face, as if he had been drawn a trifle fine in the
recent past. His composed dignity was a foil for Winton's grinning
Whatcha duck below for, all of a sudden? Winton asked, as they
stood eye to eye.
Why do you want to know, Captain Winton? McAuliffe asked.
I don't want to know, Winton retorted. I know a'ready.
Why do you ask me, then?
To hear you lie.
McAuliffe caught at his breath. His hands hardened as they hung at
his sides. Winton's reply was not one to be lightly disregarded. The
captain of a three-and-after fifty years ago had a reputation to
maintain. He could not let another thus question his honesty. Liar
was a strong word. That Winton had thus stigmatized him would pass like
flame along the docks. It would be gossiped about at the ports of Great
Lakes sailing ships. The eye of suspicion, silently questioning
McAuliffe's ability and intention of defending his name, would be on
The two men, as they stood there with the descending July sun at
their backs, were both well aware that six months before Winton would
have hesitated to venture to talk to McAuliffe like that. By nature a
bully, Winton before that time had held McAuliffe in respect. He knew
that there was no fear in McAuliffe's heart then. McAuliffe had proved
that a hundred times. And, habitually a silent man, he had never
boasted. That silence in him had made the garrulous Winton pause.
Winton was wont to measure men as much by what they said as by what
they did. In McAuliffe he saw only a silent man of action.
This change in McAuliffe had been coincident with the return from
school of Dora Colvin. She was the only daughter of Colvin Brothers,
who kept a ships' supply store on River Street. That she was a daughter
of Colvin Brothers was a joke along the water-front. It was said that
her uncle was as much her father as her father really was. It was true
that the uncle spent a little more on her than his brother did. He had
suggested that she be sent East to finish her education, and there had
been nearly a quarrel between the brothers as to who should bear the
expense. They ended by dividing it. The uncle was a bachelor, uncertain
of temper to every one except Dora. She, men said, could wind him about
her little finger.
That was doubtless true; and, in fact, Dora could wind most men about
her little finger. She was an amazing beauty, a big girl with copper-colored hair and wide, gray eyes. When her uncle and her father had
started their store, she had been a tom-boy of thirteen. Her uncle and
her father had been deep-sea men, and had come inland to settle down on
account of Dora. They had never known anything but the sea, and so they
took quite naturally to selling ships' supplies.
Their aim was to make a lady of Dora. She was kept at her books, but
her books seemed not to interest her unduly till she had passed through
such grades as the lake village afforded. She liked the docks and she
liked the decks of moored ships better than she liked the classroom.
But just before she had gone away to be finished, a certain
sedateness had come to her. When she had returned six months before,
she was a self-contained young woman of the world.
Her home-coming caused a flurry among the male population of
Lakeport. She was besieged by many men, from captains to roustabouts.
But she was not to be easily won, and gradually those quickly
discouraged left her alone. At the end of five months, only McAuliffe
and Winton remained as steadfast wooers. And then Winton had been
ordered from the house by Dora's uncle. He had drunk a little too much
black rum. The gossips observed that McAuliffe spent most of his time
ashore at the Colvin home.
And so, to hear you lie, said Winton now.
Let me pass. Winton, McAuliffe said coldly, as he stepped aside.
In a minute. Winton grinned. We got lots of time. Leastwise I
have. Mebbe you think you ain't, but I guess you can spare one minute.
What do you want? McAuliffe demanded.
I want to know when you're goin' to stop callin' on Dora Colvin,
Winton said, and the grin died from his lips.
His face was like red-mottled stone, his eyes like gray. His hamlike
hands were knotted. McAuliffe showed no fear; only hesitation and some
The hesitation vanished as three sailors from McAuliffe's own ship
appeared around the corner of the warehouse. They knew there was bad
blood between the two captains, and, scenting a climax, they stopped.
McAuliffe looked once at them and backed away from Winton.
I have no answer for you to that question, Winton, he said.
He had taken but three paces when Winton sprang forward. One of his
big hands had gone lax, and the open palm smacked against McAuliffe's
cheek. Even so, it was a blow which would have sent a weak man reeling.
McAuliffe retreated a little, his own hand covering the marks which
Winton's heavy palm had made on his cheek. His face was as white as the
foam on the crest of a leaping wave.
Don't do that again, Winton, he said hoarsely. I don't want any
trouble with you. I can't have any trouble with you. I only want you to
leave me alone.
He was retreating as he spoke. Winton poised himself as if he would
strike McAuliffe again, but then he suddenly laughed jeeringly. He
turned to the sailors.
A fine lad you sail under, this. he said. Hell's own spawn, I
say. He turned back to McAuliffe. That'll be all for this time, he
went on. You wouldn't answer my question, so I'll give you an order.
It's this: stay away from Dora Colvins' house to-night. If you go
I'll learn about it. To-morrow I'll beat you with my two fists.
You're done goin' there for good and all. Understand me? McAuliffe
turned away without a word.
Winton watched him go. Then he turned to the sailors once more.
Come, you lads, he said. I'll buy you a drink.
Events transpired thus easily in Winton's thick imagination. He had
seen nothing obscure in the promptings which had led to McAuliffe's
recent conduct. When McAuliffe had begun to seem meek, Winton had
jumped to the conclusion that McAuliffe was afraid of him. In his
opinion, McAuliffe's past reputation had been built upon a bluff.
Winton had called that bluff, and that's all there was to it. The
clothing of the notion was Winton's own. Winton was sure that McAuliffe
would not visit Dora Colvin that night.
But Winton was mistaken in his man. An army of men could not have
kept McAuliffe from seeing Dora that night. He not only wanted to see
her, naturally enough since he worshiped her, but he was smarting under
wrongs. It had taken the last drop of his resolution and courage of the
highest order to restrain him from giving battle to the burly Winton.
He told the girl about it as soon as he was established in her
sitting-room that night. But the recital left Dora cool and composed.
It is one thing to listen to a telling of such an encounter; it is
quite another thing to feel a smarting blow on your cheek. And
McAuliffe had never been taught to turn the other cheek. He had learned
from experience that the best and safest thing to do in an emergency
like that is to strike out as quickly and as forcibly as possible.
He insulted you, of course, Jim, Dora said in all the wisdom which
her education had given her. But he didn't hurt you. You haven't a
mark. You don't want to be brawling along the river-front with a man
like him, now, do you? Ugly beast.
McAuliffe loved Dora so well that he could see through her eyes in
spite of himself. He thought her a wonder-woman, and wonder- women do
not take false positions in their sweetheart's eyes.
Captain McAuliffe came around on another tack.
It's Wednesday, he said. Can't you marry me Saturday night? We'll
be getting under way after dusk some time. Dora, it's hard for me to
follow the route you've picked for me. I've given you my word I would
not brawl, and I wilt not. I'll be a gentleman as you want me to be, or
I'll die trying. But it's difficult when I'm away from you.
Dora Colvin loved her captain dearly. Few women can withstand a plea
of loneliness from the men they love.
Saturday evening, Dora mused, while the light of hope burned in the
captain's deep eyes. Four days. And if you sail after dusk, where
would we spend out honeymoon?
Aboard the ship, said the captain, the light in his eyes a blaze
now. Say 'yes,' Dora. It's fine, fair weather. It will be a nice
passage east. Why not?
Why not, indeed? And so before the captain left, the net result of
Winton's attack on him had been to set forward the captain's
wedding-day by three months.
The captain was in high good humor as he went down the hill toward
his ship. He was worried not at all about Winton or any of his kind. He
was lost in self-congratulation over the success of his sudden plea. He
went aboard ship and slept the sleep of the just.
Meanwhile Captain Winton was guzzling rum in many a barroom. He told
and retold the tale of his slapping Captain McAuliffe's face and not
a sound from him but a whimpering cry. Winton, growing as drunk as he
ever got, swore he would break McAuliffe in two if McAuliffe dared
disobey his mandate.
Winton's spree was somewhat protracted. He heard nothing of McAuliffe
till Saturday morning. In the mean time he had not seen McAuliffe.
Coming to the barroom of the hotel he lived in along toward noon on
Saturday, he was informed by a sensation-seeking bartender that Captain
McAuliffe and Dora Colvin were to be married at five o'clock that
Winton stared at his informant in stupefaction. He swore that the
bartender was a liar. That was Winton's pet retort when he did not wish
to believe. The bartender assured him that the story was quite true.
Forgetting his morning drink, Winton went seeking confirmation. And
he found plenty of it. He stepped from one buzz of gossip into another.
It would have appeared that everybody but himself knew of the event. He
wondered about that till he reflected that he had been sleeping a good
deal in the past few days. When he was awake he had been ugly. Men had
He realized after a while that this was no emergency to be met by
merely slapping McAuliffe's face, or, indeed, by beating McAuliffe
within an inch of his life. He had known all along that Dora was lost
to himself; but the fact that she was to marry McAuliffe, whom he
hated, within a few hours, hurt him with the force of a fresh loss. He
saw that he would have to use his brains to mete vengeance to
McAuliffe, who had had the temerity to disobey him.
He had several drinks that afternoon and at five o'clock he was
aboard his own ship, by now only half loaded. He was standing at the
rail, a sour and sinister figure, when he saw McAuliffe and his bride
come down to the wharf in a closed carriage. McAuliffe stepped out and
proudly handed Dora down. The watching Winton sank his teeth into his
lower lip till he could taste his own blood. He had never seen Dora
look so beautiful. There was a kind of radiance about her. And
McAuliffe walked beside her, and helped her aboard his ship with the
air of a king newly come into his inheritance.
Winton turned from the rail, cursing in low, muttered speech. He was
choked with his anger now. It sickened him, weakened him. He would have
to have a little time before that anger would become a flame. Now it
was wet- blanketed by a dozen other emotions. He hailed a sailor, and
the sailor came on nimble feet. They usually did when Winton used a
tone like that.
When does the Flying Spray sail! he demanded.
I haven't heard, sir, said the man.
Winton cursed him dully and bade him find out. The man was back from
McAuliffe's ship in a few minutes.
She sails just after dusk, sir. he reported.
Send the first mate to me. Winton commanded, and went to his cabin.
The first mate, a prototype in little of his brutal master, appeared.
The Flying Spray sails soon, Winton said. Follow her. If she goes
under her own sail, as she doubtless will, have a steam tug layin' by
to take us out. Don't lose sight of her.
Our cargo will not be aboard till tomorrow night, sir. the mate
Damn the cargo! Winton cried. Do as I tell you. And don't you lose
sight of the Flying Spray.
The mate scuttled aft to give his orders and to make arrangements for
the steam tug. As the summer dusk settled down on the river and
descended later but more quickly on the wide expanse of lake, Winton
emerged from his cabin and went forward. He stood motionless in the bow
of his ship, his red eyes fixed on the stern of the Flying Spray.
His mind was still chaotic. He did not know what he was going to do.
But he was not going to let McAuliffe slip away with his woman like
that. He would keep the Flying Spray in sight.
He would know where McAuliffe went. When he had made up his mind he
would strike, and that would be a blow which McAuliffe would remember
as long as he lived, though Winton hoped he might not live very long.
Black passion swept up through Winton, like thick smoke from the
flame of his wrath. He was lost to whatever decency had been in him. At
his sides his hands closed and unclosed unceasingly. If he had had
McAuliffe there he would gladly have throttled him even if he swung for
it the next minute. He had not known how much he desired the beautiful
girl. He had scoffingly yielded her up when she had flouted him, though
he had meant that McAuliffe should not have her. But now that she
definitely belonged to McAuliffe he would have lost his soul to take
her from him.
The summer night was over the harbor as the Flying Spray went down
the river. There was a brisk breeze and the ship was flying her
foresail and jibs. Winton could see the men standing by to shake out
As the Flying Spray neared the mouth of the river, the steam tug
which the mate had arranged for picked up Winton's ship and started for
the lake. As the tug cast off outside the harbor the Flying Spray was a
quarter of a mile away, standing off to the northeast. Winton set his
own course in pursuit of her and went to the bow again.
As the two ships stood away in their respective positions. Winton saw
ghostlike wisps of fog go floating past the bow of his ship. He cursed
them violently, for he did not want a fog-blanket to shut off his view
of the Flying Spray. But his curses were impotent. The fog thickened,
hilly shapes crowding in fast after the wisps as if those had been
merely advance couriers.
For an hour Winton held to his course, guessing that the Flying Spray
would hold to the one which McAuliffe had originally set. At the end of
the hour the Flying Spray had not been sighted for twenty minutes. Then
overhead Winton heard his sails begin to flap. The little wind there
had been died out. The fog was motionless, hugging down to the bosom of
the lake. Winton's ship came to a standstill. It was becalmed in that
sea of fog.
Winton could glean one comfort from the situation. Since he was
becalmed, McAuliffe was also. The situation might be made to work to
his purpose. He bellowed a few orders and then he began to pace up and
down the deck, a ghostly figure in the fog.
Suddenly he lifted his head and his eyes were on fire. He called the
Three men in the yawl with me, he ordered when the mate came on
The boat was lowered from the stern-davits. Winton ordered the men to
follow the course which his ship had been following when the wind had
In ten minutes the hull of the Flying Spray bulked up ahead of them.
Come up in the lee of her. Winton said in a low, thick voice.
On board the Flying Spray the dogwatch had just ended and McAuliffe,
who had been standing it with the second mate, turned his ship over to
the first mate and went to his cabin. He had barely closed the door
when there was a knock on it. Dora, sitting at the table in the middle
of the room, lifted her head. McAuliffe opened the door. Winton stood
on the threshold.
McAuliffe straightened up and took a forward step. His face was ashen
with fury. Behind him Dora got to her feet. Winton thrust forth his
sodden, red face.
What 're you doing aboard my ship, Winton? McAuliffe demanded.
I came to make a call, Winton said with a grin which was ghastly in
its lack of mirth. Come out on the deck. His hot eyes roved past
McAuliffe and sought the girl's face. The fire in those eyes increased
in intensity. Come out, McAuliffe, and face a man, he cried.
Go up on deck, McAuliffe said in a low voice which was new to his
wife. I'll be there in a minute.
Winton hesitated a moment and then he backed slowly up the stairs,
his eyes clinging to Dora's face till the closing of the door shut her
from his view.
In the cabin McAuliffe turned to Dora.
That man has had the nerve to follow me out here, he said. He has
come for trouble, he is rum-soaked and half-wild with the thought of
losing you. He walked to his wife and put his hands on her shoulders.
I'm going up there and settle with him once and for all, he went on.
Dora, you made me promise not to fight any more. I've kept that
promise till now. I understand everything you told mehow it was
better to live quiet and decent and not mix with these roughnecks. But
there are some things a man can't stand. There are some things a
husband can't stand, at any rate. I'll get Winton to-night or he'll get
me, and I don't think he will get me. You'll stay here, Dora. You'll
promise me to stay here or I'll lock the door.
Can't you have your crew arrest Winton and put him in irons? the
girl asked. He has no right to board your ship unless he is in trouble
and we know he isn't. Have him put in irons, dear.
He probably has some of his men with him, McAuliffe said steadily.
There will be a fight, no matter what. Would you have me remain below
here, hiding behind your skirts, while the crew fights a fight that is
In that school she had gone to in the East they had veneered this
girl who was sprung from a long line of men and women of the salt seas.
For the moment the veneer hid her, but she felt something stronger than
thatsomething which it could not hidesurging up in her soul. Yet
she was not ready to surrender the position she had taken about brawls
and brawling. On the other hand she could not bid her new husband stay
in hiding and let others fight his stinging slap on his face burned in
his brain. Fury seethed in him when he recalled that it was his young
wife whom Winton had pursued.
His attack sent Winton supine and McAuliffe's fingers, strong as
steel, found Winton's thick throat. He threw the whole weight of his
upper body against that grip and the fingers sunk in, closing like a
trap. Winton began to gasp
And then there was a flash of fire in McAuliffe's brain, blackness,
and nothing more. One of Winton's men had struck him from behind, in a
foul effort to curry favor with his brutal master.
The man helped the dazed Winton to his feet. They leaned together,
the fog shrouding them.
He's out, the sailor whispered. Now's your chance to do what you
come to do.
Winton stood a hall minute till his brain cleared. Then he lurched
toward the stairs leading down to the captain's cabin. But he did not
reach the top of it. He suddenly saw Dora emerge from the fog, a
revolver in her hand. The girl's face was as gray as the fog, but
Winton perceived, in the one flashing instant he had, that her hand was
perfectly steady as it held the weapon.
Go back, Captain Winton. the girl said in a low, tense voice, go
back or I'll kill you. Go over the side with your men and get into your
But the animal in Winton was not to be easily cheated. He had no more
notion that the girl would pull that trigger than he had that she could
finally elude him, now that he had come thus far. With a cry, half of
rage, half of triumph, he leaped for her. The revolver spoke.
Winton stood an instant, swaying, muttering. Then he went down to the
deck and sprawled there. Amidships McAuliffe rose unsteadily. The man
who had struck him had crept forward to the forecastle.
McAuliffe went seeking his foe through the fight.
You needn't lock the door, dear, she said.
McAuliffe raised her head and kissed her on the lips. It was a rough
kiss, yet it stirred her strangely, more strongly than any tenderness
could have done at that moment. She wondered about it as her husband
turned, threw open the door, closed it, and mounted the stairs.
On deck McAuliffe saw the big figure of Winton standing at the rail.
Along the rail, shadows of the fog, other men were grouped. McAuliffe
could not make out whether they were men of his own ship or of
He strode up to Winton and faced him. Winton leaned forward. For an
instant they stood eye to eye, breathing thickly, wordless because of
the fury which was burning in the heart of each of them.
Then suddenly McAuliffe's right fist shot out and up and crashed
against Winton's jaw. It was a terrible blow, with all the strength of
McAuliffe's thick chest and wide shoulders behind it. Winton went back
against the rail and clung there for ten seconds while his vision
cleared after the shock. Then he launched himself.
They were locked in each other's arms. The deck was slippery from the
fog which dripped from the rigging and they slid across it in that mad
embrace. What advantage Winton had because of his greater weight was
overcome by McAuliffe's agility. Winton strove to crush the lighter
man, to bend his back till the spine was near to cracking. But
McAuliffe wriggled in his arms and eased the pressure when it became
most serious. His right hand crept up and worried Winton's throat and
eyes. Winton threw back his head to escape that clutching hand and then
McAuliffe broke his hold and darted back.
Winton came forward like a mad animal and McAuliffe met him with
right and left-hand swings. Winton went to his knees. McAuliffe threw
himself upon the other captain. McAuliffe was crazed now. The
remembrance of the fog. Before he reached him, his wife caught him by
Don't go back there, she pleaded. I've shot Wintonkilled him, I
think. I don't want you to see him.
McAuliffe searched her face with his wide eyes. He expected to find
her shaken and afraid. Instead, though she was a little dazed, she had
herself well in hand.
My dear, said McAuliffe, We must look after him. He ought to die,
but his death must not lie at your door.
She nodded, mute. McAuliffe went further aft and came upon Winton's
stretched body. He knelt beside Winton and found his wrist.
You needn't worry, Winton said. I don't die so easy. She just got
me through the shoulder. You cur, I knowed all along she was too good
That was his tribute to the girl and thereafter, while McAuliffe
cleansed and bandaged his wound roughly, he was silent. His men took
him away in the yawl, though McAuliffe urged him to stay till the fog
I'd see you in hell before I'd stay aboard your ship, Winton
As the slow-moving yawl was swallowed by the fog, McAuliffe took his
wife to his cabin again. She faced him there under the low-hung lamp
and spoke before he could find words.
My teaching didn't amount to much, did it? she asked with a touch
of whimsicality. I stayed here one minute after you went on deck. Then
I got the revolver you gave me, even though I had laughed at you when
you had insisted that I keep it by memy father has often told me a
story of my mother how she put to sea in a small boat to rescue the
crew of a stranded ship. I said to myself: this is danger to my man,
too. I will go to him, no matter what. And, oh, Jim, when I faced him
therewith his flaming eyes and his rum-hot breath and his coarse, red
facewhen I knew that somehow he had got the better of you, had hurt
you very likely, I was glad to shoot him. What do you think of that?
I think, said the captain warmly, that that was just the way I
would have had you feel. I got one or two good smashes at him before
his man took me from behind and I'm glad of that, too. The report of it
will get abroad and it will keep me out of brawls. Men will know my old
reputation was rock-founded.
Well, you can take care of yourself, man to man, when the fight is
fair, his wife said.
He caught her in his arms and drew her to him.
You're admiring me for a fighting man, he challenged her.
For an instant her eyelids veiled her eyes and then they unclosed and
she lifted her eyes to his. She lifted her lips, too.