Four Just Men by Edgar Wallace
CHAPTER I. A
CHAPTER II. THE
CHAPTER III. ONE
CHAPTER V. THE
OUTRAGE AT THE
CHAPTER VI. THE
CHAPTER VII. THE
MESSENGER OF THE
CHAPTER IX. THE
CHAPTER X. THREE
CHAPTER XI. A
If you leave the Plaza del Mina, go down the narrow street, where,
from ten till four, the big flag of the United States Consulate hangs
lazily; through the square on which the Hotel de la France fronts,
round by the Church of Our Lady, and along the clean, narrow
thoroughfare that is the High Street of Cadiz, you will come to the
Cafe of the Nations.
At five o'clock there will be few people in the broad, pillared
saloon, and usually the little round tables that obstruct the sidewalk
before its doors are untenanted.
In the late summer (in the year of the famine) four men sat about
one table and talked business.
Leon Gonsalez was one, Poiccart was another, George Manfred was a
notable third, and one, Thery, or Saimont, was the fourth. Of this
quartet, only Thery requires no introduction to the student of
contemporary history. In the Bureau of Public Affairs you will find his
record. As Thery, alias Saimont, he is registered.
You may, if you are inquisitive, and have the necessary permission,
inspect his photograph taken in eighteen positions--with his hands
across his broad chest, full faced, with a three-days' growth of beard,
profile, with--but why enumerate the whole eighteen?
There are also photographs of his ears--and very ugly, bat-shaped
ears they are--and a long and comprehensive story of his life.
Signor Paolo Mantegazza, Director of the National Museum of
Anthropology, Florence, has done Thery the honour of including him in
his admirable work (see chapter on 'Intellectual Value of a Face');
hence I say that to all students of criminology and physiognomy, Thery
must need no introduction.
He sat at a' little table, this man, obviously ill at ease, pinching
his fat cheeks, smoothing his shaggy eyebrows, fingering the white scar
on his unshaven chin, doing all the things that the lower classes do
when they suddenly find themselves placed on terms of equality with
For although Gonsalez, with the light blue eyes and the restless
hands, and Poiccart, heavy, saturnine, and suspicious, and George
Manfred, with his grey-shot beard and single eyeglass, were less famous
in the criminal world, each was a great man, as you shall learn.
Manfred laid down the Heraldo di Madrid, removed his
eyeglass, rubbed it with a spotless handkerchief, and laughed
"These Russians are droll," he commented.
Poiccart frowned and reached for the newspaper. "Who is it--this
"A governor of one of the Southern Provinces."
Manfred's moustache curled in scornful derision.
"Bah! Who ever killed a man with a bomb! Yes, yes; I know it has
been done--but so clumsy, so primitive, so very much like undermining a
city wall that it may fall and slay--amongst others--your enemy."
Poiccart was reading the telegram deliberately and without haste,
after his fashion.
"The Prince was severely injured and the would-be assassin lost an
arm," he read, and pursed his lips disapprovingly. The hands of
Gonsalez, never still, opened and shut nervously, which was Leon's sign
"Our friend here"--Manfred jerked his head in the direction of
Gonsalez and laughed--"our friend has a conscience and----"
"Only once," interrupted Leon quickly, "and not by my wish you
remember, Manfred; you remember, Poiccart"--he did not address
Thery--"I advised against it. You remember?" He seemed anxious to
exculpate himself from the unspoken charge. "It was a miserable little
thing, and I was in Madrid," he went on breathlessly, "and they came to
me, some men from a factory at Barcelona. They said what they were
going to do, and I was horror-stricken at their ignorance of the
elements of the laws of chemistry. I wrote down the ingredients and the
proportions, and begged them, yes, almost on my knees, to use some
other method. 'My children,' I said, 'you are playing with something
that even chemists are afraid to handle. If the owner of the factory is
a bad man, by all means exterminate him, shoot him, wait on him after
he has dined and is slow and dull, and present a petition with the
right hand and--with the left hand--so!'" Leon twisted his knuckles
down and struck forward and upward at an imaginary oppressor. "But they
would listen to nothing I had to say."
Manfred stirred the glass of creamy liquid that stood at his elbow
and nodded his head with an amused twinkle in his grey eyes.
"I remember--several people died, and the principal witness at the
trial of the expert in explosives was the man for whom the bomb was
Thery cleared his throat as if to speak, and the three looked at him
curiously. There was some resentment in Thery's voice.
"I do not profess to be a great man like you, senors. Half the time
I don't understand what you are talking about--you speak of governments
and kings and constitutions and causes. If a man does me an
injury I smash his head"--he hesitated--"I do not know how to say
it...but I mean...well, you kill people without hating them, men who
have not hurt you. Now, that is not my way..." He hesitated again,
tried to collect his thoughts, looked intently at the middle of the
roadway, shook his head, and relapsed into silence.
The others looked at him, then at one another, and each man smiled.
Manfred took a bulky case from his pocket, extracted an untidy
cigarette, re-rolled it deftly and struck a government match on the
sole of his boot.
"Your-way-my-dear-Thery"--he puffed--"is a fool's way. You kill for
benefit; we kill for justice, which lifts us out of the ruck of
professional slayers. When we see an unjust man oppressing his fellows;
when we see an evil thing done against the good God"--Thery crossed him
self--"and against man--and know that by the laws of man this evildoer
may escape punishment--we punish."
"Listen," interrupted the taciturn Poiccart: "once there was a girl,
young and beautiful, up there"--he waved his hand northward with
unerring instinct--"and a priest--a priest, you understand--and the
parents winked at it because it is often done...but the girl was
filled with loathing and shame, and would not go a second time, so he
trapped her and kept her in a house, and then when the bloom was off
turned her out, and I found her. She was nothing to me, but I said,
'Here is a wrong that the law cannot adequately right.' So one night I
called on the priest with my hat over my eyes and said that I wanted
him to come to a dying traveller. He would not have come then, but I
told him that the dying man was rich and was a great person. He mounted
the horse I had brought, and we rode to a little house on the mountain...I
locked the door and he turned round--so! Trapped, and he knew it.
'What are you going to do?' he said with a gasping noise. 'I am going
to kill you, senor,' I said, and he believed me. I told him the story
of the girl...He screamed when I moved towards him, but he might
as well have saved his breath. 'Let me see a priest,' he begged; and I
handed him--a mirror."
Poiccart stopped to sip his coffee.
"They found him on the road next day without a mark to show how he
died," he said simply.
"How?" Thery bent forward eagerly, but Poiccart permitted himself to
smile grimly, and made no response.
Thery bent his brows and looked suspiciously from one to the
"Government, and there are men whom the Government have never heard
of. You remember one Garcia, Manuel Garcia, leader in the Carlist
movement; he is in England; it is the only country where he is safe;
from England he directs the movement here, the great movement. You know
of what I speak?"
"This year as well as last there has been a famine, men have been
dying about the church doors, starving in the public squares; they have
watched corrupt Government succeed corrupt Government; they have seen
millions flow from the public treasury into the pockets of politicians.
This year something will happen; the old regime must go. The Government
know this; they know where the danger lies, they know their salvation
can only come if Garcia is delivered into their hands before the
organisation for revolt is complete. But Garcia is safe for the present
and would be safe for all time were it not for a member of the English
Government, who is about to introduce and pass into law a Bill. When
that is passed, Garcia is as good as dead. You must help us to prevent
that from ever becoming law; that is why we have sent for you."
Thery looked bewildered. "But how?" he stammered.
Manfred drew a paper from his pocket and handed it to Thery. "This,
I think," he said, speaking deliberately, "is an exact copy of the
police description of yourself." Thery nodded. Manfred leant over and,
pointing to a word that occurred half way down the sheet, "Is that your
trade?" he asked.
Thery looked puzzled. "Yes," he replied.
"Do you really know anything about that trade?" asked Manfred
earnestly; and the other two men leant forward to catch the reply.
"I know," said Thery slowly, "everything there is to be known: had
it not been for a--mistake I might have earned great money."
Manfred heaved a sigh of relief and nodded to his two
"Then," said he briskly, "the English Minister is a dead man."
On the fourteenth day of August, 19--, a tiny paragraph appeared at
the foot of an unimportant page in London's most sober journal to the
effect that the Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs had been much
annoyed by the receipt of a number of threatening letters, and was
prepared to pay a reward of fifty pounds to any person who would give
such information as would lead to the apprehension and conviction of
the person or persons, etc. The few people who read London's most sober
journal thought, in their ponderous Athenaeum Club way, that it was a
remarkable thing that a Minister of State should be annoyed at
anything; more remarkable that he should advertise his annoyance, and
most remarkable of all that he could imagine for one minute that the
offer of a reward would put a stop to the annoyance.
News editors of less sober but larger circulated newspapers, wearily
scanning the dull columns of Old Sobriety, read the paragraph
with a newly acquired interest.
"Hullo, what's this?" asked Smiles of the Comet, and cut out
the paragraph with huge shears, pasted it upon a sheet of copy-paper
and headed it:
Who is Sir Philip's Correspondent?
As an afterthought--the Comet being in Opposition--he
prefixed an introductory paragraph, humorously suggesting that the
letters were from an intelligent electorate grown tired of the
shilly-shallying methods of the Government.
The news editor of the Evening World--a white-haired
gentleman of deliberate movement--read the paragraph twice, cut it out
carefully, read it again and, placing it under a paperweight, very soon
forgot all about it.
The news editor of the Megaphone, which is a very bright
newspaper indeed, cut the paragraph as he read it, rang a bell, called
a reporter, all in a breath, so to speak, and issued a few terse
"Go down to Portland Place, try to see Sir Philip Ramon, secure the
story of that paragraph--why he is threatened, what he is threatened
with; get a copy of one of the letters if you can. If you cannot see
Ramon, get hold of a secretary."
And the obedient reporter went forth.
He returned in an hour in that state of mysterious agitation
peculiar to the reporter who has got a 'beat'. The news editor duly
reported to the Editor-in-Chief, and that great man said, "That's very
good, that's very good indeed"--which was praise of the highest
What was 'very good indeed' about the reporter's story may be
gathered from the half-column that appeared in the Megaphone on
the following day:
CABINET MINISTER IN DANGER
THREATS TO MURDER THE FOREIGN SECRETARY
'THE FOUR JUST MEN'
PLOT TO ARREST THE PASSAGE OF THE
ALIENS EXTRADITION BILL--
Considerable comment was excited by the appearance in the news
columns of yesterday's National Journal of the following
The Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs (Sir Philip Ramon) has
during the past few weeks been the recipient of threatening letters,
all apparently emanating from one source and written by one person.
These letters are of such a character that they cannot be ignored by
his Majesty's Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs, who hereby offers
a reward of Fifty pounds (L50) to any person or persons, other than the
actual writer, who will lay such information as will lead to the
apprehension and conviction of the author of these anonymous
So unusual was such an announcement, remembering that anonymous and
threatening letters are usually to be found daily in the letter-bags of
every statesman and diplomat, that the Daily Megaphone immediately
instituted inquiries as to the cause for this unusual departure.
A representative of this newspaper called at the residence of Sir
Philip Ramon, who very courteously consented to be seen.
"It is quite an unusual step to take," said the great Foreign
Secretary, in answer to our representative's question, "but it has been
taken with the full concurrence of my colleagues of the Cabinet. We
have reasons to believe there is something behind the threats, and I
might say that the matter has been in the hands of the police for some
"Here is one of the letters," and Sir Philip produced a sheet of
foreign notepaper from a portfolio, and was good enough to allow our
representative to make a copy.
It was undated, and beyond the fact that the handwriting was of the
flourishing effeminate variety that is characteristic of the Latin
races, it was written in good English.
It ran: Your Excellency,--
The Bill that you are about to pass into law is an unjust one...
It is calculated to hand over to a corrupt and vengeful Government men
who now in England find an asylum from the persecutions of despots and
tyrants. We know that in England opinion is divided upon the merits of
your Bill, and that upon your strength, and your strength alone,
depends the passing into law of the Aliens Political Offences Bill.
Therefore it grieves us to warn you that unless your Government
withdraws this Bill, it will be necessary to remove you, and not alone
you, but any other person who undertakes to carry into law this unjust
(Signed) four just men.
"The Bill referred to," Sir Philip resumed, "is of course the Aliens
Extradition (Political Offences) Bill, which, had it not been for the
tactics of the Opposition, might have passed quietly into law last
Sir Philip went on to explain that the Bill was called into being by
the insecurity of the succession in Spain.
"It is imperative that neither England nor any other country should
harbour propagandists who, from the security of these, or other shores,
should set Europe ablaze. Coincident with the passage of this measure
similar Acts or proclamations have been made in every country in
Europe. In fact, they are all in existence, having been arranged to
come into law simultaneously with ours, last session."
"Why do you attach importance to these letters?" asked the Daily
"Because we are assured, both by our own police and the continental
police, that the writers are men who are in deadly earnest. The 'Four
just men'", as they sign themselves, are known collectively in almost
every country under the sun. Who they are individually we should all
very much like to know. Rightly or wrongly, they consider that justice
as meted out here on earth is inadequate, and have set themselves about
correcting the law. They were the people who assassinated General
Trelovitch, the leader of the Servian Regicides: they hanged the
French Army Contractor, Conrad, in the Place de la Concorde--with a
hundred policemen within call. They shot Hermon le Blois, the
poet-philosopher, in his study for corrupting the youth of the world
with his reasoning."
The Foreign Secretary then handed to our representative a list of
the crimes committed by this extraordinary quartet.
Our readers will recollect the circumstance of each murder, and it
will be remembered that until today--so closely have the police of the
various nationalities kept the secret of the Four Men--no one crime has
been connected with the other; and certainly none of the circumstances
which, had they been published, would have assuredly revealed the
existence of this band, have been given to the public before today.
The Daily Megaphone is able to publish a full list of sixteen
murders committed by the four men.
"Two years ago, after the shooting of le Blois, by some hitch in
their almost perfect arrangements, one of the four was recognised by a
detective as having been seen leaving le Blois's house on the Avenue
Kleber, and he was shadowed for three days, in the hope, that the four
might be captured together. In the end he discovered he was being
watched, and made a bolt for liberty. He was driven to bay in a cafe in
Bordeaux--they had followed him from Paris: and before he was killed he
shot a sergeant de ville and two other policemen. He was photographed,
and the print was circulated throughout Europe, but who he was or what
he was, even what nationality he was, is a mystery to this day."
"But the four are still in existence?"
Sir Philip shrugged his shoulders. "They have either recruited
another, or they are working shorthanded," he said.
In conclusion the Foreign Secretary said:
"I am making this public through the Press, in order that the danger
which threatens, not necessarily myself, but any public man who runs
counter to the wishes of this sinister force, should be recognised. My
second reason is that the public may in its knowledge assist those
responsible for the maintenance of law and order in the execution of
their office, and by their vigilance prevent the committal of further
Inquiries subsequently made at Scotland Yard elicited no further
information on the subject beyond the fact that the Criminal
Investigation Department was in communication with the chiefs of the
The following is a complete list of the murders committed by the
Four Just Men, together with such particulars as the police have been
able to secure regarding the cause for the crimes. We are indebted to
the Foreign Office for permission to reproduce the list.
October 7, 1899.--Thomas Cutler, master tailor, found dead under
suspicious circumstances. Coroner's jury returned a verdict of 'Wilful
murder against some person or persons unknown.'
(Cause of murder ascertained by police: Cutler, who was a man of
some substance, and whose real name was Bentvitch, was a sweater of a
particularly offensive type. Three convictions under the Factory Act.
Believed by the police there was a further and more intimate cause for
the murder not unconnected with Cutler's treatment of women
February 28,1900.--Jacques Ellerman, prefect: shot dead returning
from the Opera House. Ellerman was a notorious evil liver, and upon
investigating his affairs after his death it was found that he had
embezzled nearly a quarter of a million francs of the public funds.
(Kentucky), October, 1900.--Judge Anderson. Found dead in his room,
strangled. Anderson had thrice been tried for his life on charges of
murder. He was the leader of the Anderson faction in the Anderson-Hara
feud. Had killed in all seven of the Hara clan, was three times
indicted and three times released on a verdict of Not Guilty. It will
be remembered that on the last occasion, when charged with the
treacherous murder of the Editor of the Seattle Star, he shook
hands with the packed jury and congratulated them.
October 30, 1900.--Patrick Welch, a notorious grafter and stealer of
public moneys. Sometime City Treasurer; moving spirit in the infamous
Street Paving Syndicate; exposed by the New York Journal. Welch
was found hanging in a little wood on Long Island. Believed at the time
to have been suicide.
March 4, 1901.--Madame Despard. Asphyxiated. This also was regarded
as suicide till certain information came to hands of French police. Of
Madame Despard nothing good can be said. She was a notorious 'dealer in
March 4, 1902 (exactly a year later).--Monsieur Gabriel Lanfin,
Minister of Communication. Found shot in his brougham in the Bois de
Boulogne. His coachman was arrested but eventually discharged. The man
swore he heard no shot or cry from his master. It was raining at the
time, and there were few pedestrians in the Bois.
(Here followed ten other cases, all on a par with those quoted
above, including the cases of Trelovitch and le Blois.)
It was undoubtedly a great story.
The Editor-in-Chief, seated in his office, read it over again and
said, "Very good indeed."
The reporter--whose name was Smith--read it over and grew pleasantly
warm at the consequences of his achievement.
The Foreign Secretary read it in bed as he sipped his morning tea,
and frowningly wondered if he had said too much.
The chief of the French police read it--translated and
telegraphed--in Le Temps, and furiously cursed the talkative
Englishman who was upsetting his plans.
In Madrid, at the Cafe de la Paix, in the Place of the Sun, Manfred,
cynical, smiling, and sarcastic, read extracts to three men--two
pleasantly amused, the other heavy-jowled and pasty of face, with the
fear of death in his eyes.
Somebody--was it Mr Gladstone?--placed it on record that there is
nothing quite so dangerous, quite so ferocious, quite so terrifying as
a mad sheep. Similarly, as we know, there is no person quite so
indiscreet, quite so foolishly talkative, quite so amazingly gauche, as
the diplomat who for some reason or other has run off the rails.
There comes a moment to the man who has trained himself to guard his
tongue in the Councils of Nations, who has been schooled to walk warily
amongst pitfalls digged cunningly by friendly Powers, when the practice
and precept of many years are forgotten, and he behaves humanly. Why
this should be has never been discovered by ordinary people, although
the psychological minority who can generally explain the mental
processes of their fellows, have doubtless very adequate and convincing
reasons for these acts of disbalancement.
Sir Philip Ramon was a man of peculiar temperament.
I doubt whether anything in the wide world would have arrested his
purpose once his mind had been made up. He was a man of strong
character, a firm, square-jawed, big-mouthed man, with that shade of
blue in his eyes that one looks for in peculiarly heartless criminals,
and particularly famous generals. And yet Sir Philip Ramon feared, as
few men imagined he feared, the consequence of the task he had set
There are thousands of men who are physically heroes and morally
poltroons, men who would laugh at death--and live in terror of personal
embarrassments. Coroner's courts listen daily to the tale of such men's
The Foreign Secretary reversed these qualities. Good animal men
would unhesitatingly describe the Minister as a coward, for he feared
pain and he feared death.
"If this thing is worrying you so much," the Premier said kindly--it
was at the Cabinet Council two days following the publication of the
Megaphone's story--"why don't you drop the Bill? After all,
there are matters of greater importance to occupy the time of the
House, and we are getting near the end of the session."
An approving murmur went round the table.
"We have every excuse for dropping it. There must be a horrible
slaughtering of the innocents--Braithewaite's Unemployed Bill must go;
and what the country will say to that, Heaven only knows."
"No, no!" The Foreign Secretary brought his fist down on the table
with a crash. "It shall go through; of that I am determined. We are
breaking faith with the Cortes, we are breaking faith with France, we
are breaking faith with every country in the Union. I have promised the
passage of this measure--and we must go through with it, even though
there are a thousand 'Just Men', and a thousand threats."
The Premier shrugged his shoulders.
"Forgive me for saying so, Ramon," said Bolton, the Solicitor, "but
I can't help feeling you were rather indiscreet to give particulars to
the Press as you did. Yes, I know we were agreed that you should have a
free hand to deal with the matter as you wished, but somehow I did not
think you would have been quite so--what shall I say?--candid."
"My discretion in the matter, Sir George, is not a subject that I
care to discuss," replied Ramon stiffly.
Later, as he walked across Palace Yard with the youthful-looking
Chancellor, Mr Solicitor-General, smarting under the rebuff, said, a
propos of nothing, "Silly old ass." And the youthful guardian of
Britain's finances smiled.
"If the truth be told," he said, "Ramon is in a most awful funk. The
story of the Four Just Men is in all the clubs, and a man I met at the
Carlton at lunch has rather convinced me that there is really something
to be feared. He was quite serious about it--he's just returned from
South America and has seen some of the work done by these men."
"What was that?"
"A president or something of one of these rotten little
republics...about eight months ago--you'll see it in the list...They
hanged him...most extraordinary thing in the world. They took him
out of bed in the middle of the night, gagged him, blindfolded him,
carried him to the public jail, gained admission, and hanged him on the
public gallows--and escaped!"
Mr Solicitor saw the difficulties of such proceedings, and was about
to ask for further information when an under-secretary buttonholed the
Chancellor and bore him off. "Absurd," muttered Mr Solicitor
There were cheers for the Secretary for Foreign Affairs as his
brougham swept through the crowd that lined the approaches to the
House. He was in no wise exalted, for popularity was not a possession
he craved. He knew instinctively that the cheers were called forth by
the public's appreciation of his peril; and the knowledge chilled and
irritated him. He would have liked to think that the people scoffed at
the existence of this mysterious four--it would have given him some
peace of mind had he been able to think 'the people have rejected the
For although popularity or unpopularity was outside his scheme of
essentials, yet he had an unswerving faith in the brute instincts of
the mob. He was surrounded in the lobby of the House with a crowd of
eager men of his party, some quizzical, some anxious, all clamouring
for the latest information--all slightly in fear of the acid-tongued
"Look here, Sir Philip"--it was the stout, tactless member for West
Brondesbury--"what is all this we hear about threatenin' letters?
Surely you're not goin' to take notice of things of that sort--why, I
get two or three every day of my life."
The Minister strode impatiently away from the group, but Tester--the
member--caught his arm.
"Look here--" he began.
"Go to the devil," said the Foreign Secretary plainly, and walked
quickly to his room.
"Beastly temper that man's got, to be sure," said the honourable
member despairingly. "Fact is, old Ramon's in a blue funk. The idea of
making a song about threatenin' letters! Why, I get----"
A group of men in the members' smokeroom discussed the question of
the Just Four in a perfectly unoriginal way.
"It's too ridiculous for words," said one oracularly. "Here are four
men, a mythical four, arrayed against all the forces and established
agencies of the most civilised nation on earth."
"Except Germany," interrupted Scott, MP, wisely.
"Oh, leave Germany out of it for goodness' sake," begged the first
speaker tartly. "I do wish, Scott, we could discuss a subject in which
the superiority of German institutions could not be introduced."
"Impossible," said the cheerful Scott, flinging loose the reins of
his hobby horse: "remember that in steel and iron alone the production
per head of the employee has increased 43 per cent., that her
"Do you think Ramon will withdraw the bill?" asked the senior member
for Aldgate East, disentangling his attention from the babble of
"Ramon? Not he--he'd sooner die."
"It's a most unusual circumstance," said Aldgate East; and three
boroughs, a London suburb, and a midland town nodded and 'thought it
"In the old days, when old Bascoe was a young member"--Aldgate East
indicated an aged senator bent and white of beard and hair, who was
walking painfully toward a seat--"in the old days----"
"Thought old Bascoe had paired?" remarked an irrelevant
"In the old days," continued the member for the East End, "before
the Fenian trouble----"
"----talk of civilisation," went on the enthusiastic Scott.
"Rheinbaken said last month in the Lower House, 'Germany had reached
that point where----'"
"If I were Ramon," resumed Aldgate East profoundly, "I know exactly
what I should do. I should go to the police and say 'Look here----'"
A bell rang furiously and continuously, and the members went
scampering along the corridor. "Division--'vision."
Clause Nine of the Medway Improvement Bill having been
satisfactorily settled and the words 'Or as may hereafter be
determined' added by a triumphant majority of twenty-four, the faithful
Commons returned to the interrupted discussion.
"What I say, and what I've always said about a man in the Cabinet,"
maintained an important individual, "is that he must, if he is a true
statesman, drop all consideration for his own personal feelings."
"Hear!" applauded somebody.
"His own personal feelings," repeated the orator. "He must put his
duty to the state before all other--er--considerations. You remember
what I said to Barrington the other night when we were talking out the
Estimates? I said, 'The right honourable gentleman has not, cannot
have, allowed for the strong and almost unanimous desires of the great
body of the electorate. The action of a Minister of the Crown must
primarily be governed by the intelligent judgment of the great body of
the electorate, whose fine, feelings'--no--'whose higher instincts'--
no--that wasn't it--at any rate I made it very clear what the duty of a
Minister was," concluded the oracle lamely.
"Now I----" commenced Aldgate East, when an attendant approached
with a tray on which lay a greenish-grey envelope.
"Has any gentleman dropped this?" he inquired, and, picking up the
letter, the member fumbled for his eyeglasses.
"To the Members of the House of Commons," he read, and looked over
his pince-nez at the circle of men about him.
"Company prospectus," said the stout member for West Brondesbury,
who had joined the party; "I get hundreds. Only the other day----"
"Too thin for a prospectus," said Aldgate East, weighing the letter
in his hand.
"Patent medicine, then," persisted the light of Brondesbury. "I get
one every morning--'Don't burn the candle at both ends', and all that
sort of rot. Last week a feller sent me----"
"Open it," someone suggested, and the member obeyed. He read a few
lines and turned red.
"Well, I'm damned!" he gasped, and read aloud:
The Government is about to pass into law a measure which will place in
the hands of the most evil Government of modern times men who are
patriots and who are destined to be the saviours of their countries. We
have informed the Minister in charge of this measure, the title of
which appears in the margin, that unless he withdraws this Bill we will
surely slay him.
We are loath to take this extreme step, knowing that otherwise he is
an honest and brave gentleman, and it is with a desire to avoid
fulfilling our promise that we ask the members of the Mother of
Parliaments to use their every influence to force the withdrawal of
Were we common murderers or clumsy anarchists we could with ease
wreak a blind and indiscriminate vengeance on the members of this
assembly, and in proof thereof, and as an earnest that our threat is no
idle one, we beg you to search beneath the table near the recess in
this room. There you will find a machine sufficiently charged to
destroy the greater portion of this building.
(Signed) Four Just Men
Postscript.--We have not placed either detonator or fuse in the
machine, which may therefore be handled with impunity.
As the reading of the letter proceeded the faces of the listeners
There was something very convincing about the tone of the letter,
and instinctively all eyes sought the table near the recess.
Yes, there was something, a square black something, and the crowd of
legislators shrank back. For a moment they stood spellbound--and then
there was a mad rush for the door.
"Was it a hoax?" asked the Prime Minister anxiously, but the hastily
summoned expert from Scotland Yard shook his head.
"Just as the letter described it," he said gravely, "even to the
absence of fuses."
"Was it really----"
"Enough to wreck the House, sir," was the reply.
The Premier, with a troubled face, paced the floor of his private
He stopped once to look moodily through the window that gave a view
of a crowded terrace and a mass of excited politicians gesticulating
and evidently all speaking at once.
"Very, very serious--very, very serious," he muttered. Then aloud,
"We said so much we might as well continue. Give the newspapers as full
an account of this afternoon's happenings as they think necessary--give
them the text of the letter." He pushed a button and his secretary
"Write to the Commissioner telling him to offer a reward of a
thousand pounds for the arrest of the man who left this thing and a
free pardon and the reward to any accomplice."
The Secretary withdrew and the Scotland Yard expert waited.
"Have your people found how the machine was introduced?"
"No, sir; the police have all been relieved and been subjected to
separate interrogation. They remember seeing no stranger either
entering or leaving the House."
The Premier pursed his lips in thought.
"Thank you," he said simply, and the expert withdrew.
On the terrace Aldgate East and the oratorical member divided
"I must have been standing quite close to it," said the latter
impressively; "'pon my word it makes me go cold all over to think
about it. You remember, Mellin? I was saying about the duty of the
"I asked the waiter," said the member for Aldgate to an interested
circle, "when he brought the letter: 'Where did you find it?'
"On the floor, sir!" he said. "I thought it was a medicine
advertisement; I wasn't going to open it, only somebody----"
"It was me," claimed the stout gentleman from Brondesbury proudly;
"you remember I was saying----''
"I knew it was somebody," continued Aldgate East graciously. "I
opened it and read the first few lines. 'Bless my soul,' I
"You said, 'Well, I'm damned,'" corrected Brondesbury.
"Well, I know it was something very much to the point," admitted
Aldgate East. "I read it--and, you'll quite understand, I couldn't
grasp its significance, so to speak. Well----"
The three stalls reserved at the Star Music Hall in Oxford Street
were occupied one by one. At half past seven prompt came Manfred,
dressed quietly; at eight came Poiccart, a fairly prosperous
middle-aged gentleman; at half past eight came Gonsalez, asking in
perfect English for a programme. He seated himself between the two
When pit and gallery were roaring themselves hoarse over a patriotic
song, Manfred smilingly turned to Leon, and said:
"I saw it in the evening papers."
Leon nodded quickly.
"There was nearly trouble," he said quietly. "As I went in somebody
said, 'I thought Bascoe had paired,' and one of them almost came up to
me and spoke."
To say that England was stirred to its depths--to quote more than
one leading article on the subject--by the extraordinary occurrence in
the House of Commons, would be stating the matter exactly.
The first intimation of the existence of the Four Just Men had been
received with pardonable derision, particularly by those newspapers
that were behindhand with the first news. Only the Daily
Megaphone had truly and earnestly recognised how real was the
danger which threatened the Minister in charge of the obnoxious Act.
Now, however, even the most scornful could not ignore the significance
of the communication that had so mysteriously found its way into the
very heart of Britain's most jealously guarded institution. The story
of the Bomb Outrage filled the pages of every newspaper throughout the
country, and the latest daring venture of the Four was placarded the
length and breadth of the Isles.
Stories, mostly apocryphal, of the men who were responsible for the
newest sensation made their appearance from day to day, and there was
no other topic in the mouths of men wherever they met but the strange
quartet who seemed to hold the lives of the mighty in the hollows of
Never since the days of the Fenian outrages had the mind of the
public been so filled with apprehension as it was during the two days
following the appearance in the Commons of the 'blank bomb', as one
journal felicitously described it.
Perhaps in exactly the same kind of apprehension, since there was a
general belief, which grew out of the trend of the letters, that the
Four menaced none other than one man.
The first intimation of their intentions had excited widespread
interest. But the fact that the threat had been launched from a small
French town, and that in consequence the danger was very remote, had
somehow robbed the threat of some of its force. Such was the vague
reasoning of an ungeographical people that did not realise that Dax is
no farther from London than Aberdeen.
But here was the Hidden Terror in the Metropolis itself. Why, argued
London, with suspicious sidelong glances, every man we rub elbows with
may be one of the Four, and we none the wiser.
Heavy, black-looking posters stared down from blank walls, and
filled the breadth of every police noticeboard.
Whereas, on August 18, at about 4.30 o'clock in the afternoon, an
infernal machine was deposited in the Members' Smoke-Room by some
person or persons unknown.
And whereas there is reason to believe that the person or persons
implicated in the disposal of the aforesaid machine are members of an
organised body of criminals known as The Four Just Men, against whom
warrants have been issued on charges of wilful murder in London, Paris,
New York, New Orleans, Seattle (USA), Barcelona, Tomsk, Belgrade,
Christiania, Capetown and Caracas.
Now, therefore, the above reward will be paid by his Majesty's
Government to any person or persons who shall lay such information as
shall lead to the apprehension of any of or the whole of the persons
styling themselves The Four Just Men and identical with the band before
And, furthermore, a free pardon and the reward will be paid to any
member of the band for such information, providing the person laying
such information has neither committed nor has been an accessory before
or after the act of any of the following murders.
Ryday Montgomery, His Majesty's Secretary of State for Home Affairs.
J. B. Calfort, Commissioner of Police.
Here followed a list of the sixteen crimes alleged against the four
God Save the King
All day long little knots of people gathered before the broadsheets,
digesting the magnificent offer.
It was an unusual hue and cry, differing from those with which
Londoners were best acquainted. For there was no appended description
of the men wanted; no portraits by which they might be identified, no
stereotyped 'when last seen was wearing a dark blue serge suit, cloth
cap, check tie', on which the searcher might base his scrutiny of the
It was a search for four men whom no person had ever consciously
seen, a hunt for a will-o'-the-wisp, a groping in the dark after
Detective Superintendent Falmouth, who was a very plain-spoken man
(he once brusquely explained to a Royal Personage that he hadn't got
eyes in the back of his head), told the Assistant Commissioner exactly
what he thought about it.
"You can't catch men when you haven't got the slightest idea who or
what you're looking for. For the sake of argument, they might be women
for all we know--they might be chinamen or niggers; they might be tall
or short; they might--why, we don't even know their nationality!
They've committed crimes in almost every country in the world. They're
not French because they killed a man in Paris, or Yankee because they
strangled Judge Anderson."
"The writing," said the Commissioner, referring to a bunch of
letters he held in his hand.
"Latin; but that may be a fake. And suppose it isn't? There's no
difference between the handwriting of a Frenchman, Spaniard,
Portuguese, Italian, South American, or Creole--and, as I say, it might
be a fake, and probably is."
"What have you done?" asked the Commissioner.
"We've pulled in all the suspicious characters we know. We've
cleaned out Little Italy, combed Bloomsbury, been through Soho, and
searched all the colonies. We raided a place at Nunhead last night--a
lot of Armenians live down there, but----"
The detective's face bore a hopeless look.
"As likely as not," he went on, "we should find them at one of the
swagger hotels--that's if they were fools enough to bunch together; but
you may be sure they're living apart, and meeting at some unlikely spot
once or twice a day."
He paused, and tapped his fingers absently on the big desk at which
he and his superior sat.
"We've had de Courville over," he resumed. "He saw the Soho crowd,
and what is more important, saw his own man who lives amongst them--and
it's none of them, I'll swear--or at least he swears, and I'm prepared
to accept his word."
The Commissioner shook his head pathetically.
"They're in an awful stew in Downing Street," he said. "They do not
know exactly what is going to happen next."
Mr Falmouth rose to his feet with a sigh and fingered the brim of
"Nice time ahead of us--I don't think," he remarked
"What are the people thinking about it?" asked the Commissioner.
"You've seen the papers?"
Mr .Commissioner's shrug was uncomplimentary to British
"The papers! Who in Heaven's name is going to take the slightest
notice of what is in the papers!" he said petulantly.
"I am, for one," replied the calm detective; "newspapers are more
often than not led by the public; and it seems to me the idea of
running a newspaper in a nutshell is to write so that the public will
say, 'That's smart--it's what I've said all along.'"
"But the public themselves--have you had an opportunity of gathering
their idea?" Superintendent Falmouth nodded. "I was talking in the Park
to a man only this evening--a master-man by the look of him, and
presumably intelligent. 'What's your idea of this Four Just Men
business?' I asked. 'It's very queer,' he said: 'do you think there's
anything in it?'--and that," concluded the disgusted police officer,
"is all the public thinks about it."
But if there was sorrow at Scotland Yard, Fleet Street itself was
all a-twitter with pleasurable excitement. Here was great news indeed:
news that might be heralded across double columns, blared forth in
headlines, shouted by placards, illustrated, diagramised, and
illuminated by statistics.
"Is it the Mafia?" asked the Comet noisily, and went on to
prove that it was.
The Evening World, with its editorial mind lingering lovingly
in the 'sixties, mildly suggested a vendetta, and instanced 'The
The Megaphone stuck to the story of the Four Just Men, and
printed pages of details concerning their nefarious acts. It
disinterred from dusty files, continental and American, the full
circumstances of each murder; it gave the portraits and careers of the
men who were slain, and, whilst in no way palliating the offence of the
Four, yet set forth justly and dispassionately the lives of the
victims, showing the sort of men they were.
It accepted warily the reams of contributions that flowed into the
office; for a newspaper that has received the stigma 'yellow' exercises
more caution than its more sober competitors. In newspaper-land a dull
lie is seldom detected, but an interesting exaggeration drives an
unimaginative rival to hysterical denunciations.
And reams of Four Men anecdotes did flow in. For suddenly, as if by
magic, every outside contributor, every literary gentleman who made a
speciality of personal notes, every kind of man who wrote, discovered
that he had known the Four intimately all his life.
'When I was in Italy...' wrote the author of Come Again
(Hackworth Press, 6s.: 'slightly soiled', Farring-don Book Mart,
2d.) 'I remember I heard a curious story about these Men of
'No spot in London is more likely to prove the hiding-place of the
Four Villains than Tidal Basin,' wrote another gentleman, who stuck
Collins in the north-east corner of his manuscript. 'Tidal Basin
in the reign of Charles II was known as...'
"Who's Collins?" asked the super-chief of the Megaphone of
his hard-worked editor.
"A liner," described the editor wearily, thereby revealing that
even the newer journalism had not driven the promiscuous contributor
from his hard-fought field; "he does police-courts, fires,
inquests, and things. Lately he'; taken to literature and writes
Picturesque-Bits-of-Old London and Famous Tombstones-of-Hornsey
Throughout the offices of the newspapers the same thing was
happening. Every cable that arrived, ever; piece of information that
reached the sub-editor's basket was coloured with the impending tragedy
uppermost ii men's minds. Even the police-court reports contained some
allusion to the Four. It was the overnight drunk an disorderly's
justification for his indiscretion.
"The lad has always been honest," said the boy's tearful mother;
"it's reading these horrible stories about the Four Foreigners that's
made him turn out like this"; and the magistrate took a lenient view o
To all outward showing, Sir Philip Ramon, the man mostly interested
in the development of the plot, was the least concerned.
He refused to be interviewed any further; he declined to discuss the
possibilities of assassination, even with the Premier, and his answer
to letters of appreciation that came to him from all parts of the
country was an announcement in the Morning Post asking his
correspondents to be good enough to refrain from persecuting him with
picture postcards, which found no other repository than his wastepaper
He had thought of adding an announcement of his intention of
carrying the Bill through Parliament at whatever cost, and was only
deterred by the fear of theatricality.
To Falmouth, upon whom had naturally devolved the duty of protecting
the Foreign Secretary from harm, Sir Philip was unusually gracious, and
incidentally permitted that astute officer to get a glimpse of the
terror in which a threatened man lives.
"Do you think there's any danger, Superintendent?" he asked, not
once but a score of times; and the officer, stout defender of an
infallible police force, was very reassuring.
"For," as he argued to himself, "what is the use of frightening a
man who is half scared of death already? If nothing happens, he will
see I have spoken the truth, and if--if--well, he won't be able to call
me a liar."
Sir Philip was a constant source of interest to the detective, who
must have shown his thoughts once or twice. For the Foreign Secretary,
who was a remarkably shrewd man, intercepting a curious glance of the
police officer, said sharply, "You wonder why I still go on with the
Bill knowing the danger? Well, it will surprise you to learn that I do
not know the danger, nor can I imagine it! I have never been
conscious of physical pain in my life, and in spite of the fact that I
have a weak heart, I have never had so much as a single ache. What
death will be, what pangs or peace it may bring, I have no conception.
I argue with Epictetus that the fear of death is by way of being an
impertinent assumption of a knowledge of the hereafter, and that we
have no reason to believe it is any worse condition than our present. I
am not afraid to die--but I am afraid of dying."
"Quite so, sir," murmured the sympathetic but wholly uncomprehending
detective, who had no mind for nice distinctions.
"But," resumed the Minister--he was sitting in his study in Portland
Place--"if I cannot imagine the exact process of dissolution, I can
imagine and have experienced the result of breaking faith with the
chancellories, and I have certainly no intention of laying up a store
of future embarrassments for fear of something that may after all be
Which piece of reasoning will be sufficient to indicate what the
Opposition of the hour was pleased to term 'the tortuous mind of the
right honourable gentleman'.
And Superintendent Falmouth, listening with every indication of
attention, yawned inwardly and wondered who Epictetus was.
"I have taken all possible precautions, sir," said the detective in
the pause that followed the recital of this creed. "I hope you won't
mind for a week or two being followed about by some of my men. I want
you to allow two or three officers to remain in the house whilst you
are here, and of course there will be quite a number on duty at the
Sir Philip expressed his approval, and later, when he and the
detective drove down to the House in a closed brougham, he understood
why cyclists rode before and on either side of the carriage, and why
two cabs followed the brougham into Palace Yard.
At Notice Time, with a House sparsely filled, Sir Philip rose in his
place and gave notice that he would move the second reading of the
Aliens Extradition (Political Offences) Bill, on Tuesday week, or, to
be exact, in ten days.
That evening Manfred met Gonsalez in North Tower Gardens and
remarked on the fairy-like splendour of the Crystal Palace grounds by
A Guards' band was playing the overture to Tann-hduser, and
the men talked music.
"What of Thery?" asked Manfred.
"Poiccart has him today; he is showing him the sights." They both
"And you?" asked Gonsalez.
"I have had an interesting day; I met that delightfully naive
detective in Green Park, who asked me what I thought of ourselves!"
Gonsalez commented on the movement in G minor, and Manfred nodded
his head, keeping time with the music.
"Are we prepared?" asked Leon quietly.
Manfred still nodded and softly whistled the number. He stopped with
the final crash of the band, and joined in the applause that greeted
"I have taken a place," he said, clapping his hands. "We had better
"Is everything there?"
Manfred looked at his companion with a twinkle in his eye.
The band broke into the National Anthem, and the two men rose and
The throng about the bandstand melted away in the gloom, and Manfred
and his companion turned to go.
Thousands of fairy lamps gleamed in the grounds, and there was a
strong smell of gas in the air.
"Not that way this time?" questioned, rather than asserted,
"Most certainly not that way," replied Manfred decidedly.
When an advertisement appeared in the Newspaper Proprietor
announcing that there was--
For sale: An old-established zinco-engraver's business with a
splendid new plant and a stock of chemicals.
Everybody in the printing world said "That's Etherington's." To the
uninitiated a photo-engraver's is a place of buzzing saws, and lead
shavings, and noisy lathes, and big bright arc lamps.
To the initiated a photo-engraver's is a place where works of art
are reproduced by photography on zinc plates, and consequently used for
To the very knowing people of the printing world, Etherington's was
the worst of its kind, producing the least presentable of pictures at a
price slightly above the average.
Etherington's had been in the market (by order of the trustees) for
three months, but partly owing to its remoteness from Fleet Street (it
was in Carnaby Street), and partly to the dilapidated condition of the
machinery (which shows that even an official receiver has no moral
sense when he starts advertising), there had been no bids.
Manfred, who interviewed the trustee in Carey Street, learnt that
the business could be either leased or purchased; that immediate
possession in either circumstances was to be had; that there were
premises at the top of the house which had served as a dwelling-place
to generations of caretakers, and that a banker's reference was all
that was necessary in the way of guarantee.
"Rather a crank," said the trustee at a meeting of creditors,
"thinks that he is going to make a fortune turning out photogravures of
Murillo at a price within reach of the inartistic. He tells me that he
is forming a small company to carry on the business, and that so soon
as it is formed he will buy the plant outright."
And sure enough that very day Thomas Brown, merchant; Arthur W.
Knight, gentleman; James Selkirk, artist; Andrew Cohen, financial
agent; and James Leech, artist, wrote to the Registrar of Joint Stock
Companies, asking to be formed into a company, limited by shares, with
the object of carrying on business as photo-engravers, with which
object they had severally subscribed for the shares set against their
(In parenthesis, Manfred was a great artist.)
And five days before the second reading of the Aliens Extradition
Act, the company had entered into occupation of their new premises in
preparation to starting business.
"Years ago, when I first came to London," said Manfred, "I
learned the easiest way to conceal one's identity was to disguise
oneself as a public enemy. There's a wealth of respectability behind
the word 'limited', and the pomp and circumstance of a company
directorship diverts suspicion, even as it attracts attention."
Gonsalez printed a neat notice to the effect that the Fine Arts
Reproduction Syndicate would commence business on October 1, and a
further neat label that 'no hands were wanted', and a further terse
announcement that travellers and others could only be seen by
appointment, and that all letters must be addressed to the Manager.
It was a plain-fronted shop, with a deep basement crowded with the
dilapidated plant left by the liquidated engraver. The ground floor had
been used as offices, and neglected furniture and grimy files
There were pigeonholes filled with old plates, pigeonholes filled
with dusty invoices, pigeonholes in which all the debris that is
accumulated in an office by a clerk with salary in arrear was
The first floor had been a workshop, the second had been a store,
and the third and most interesting floor of all was that on which were
the huge cameras and the powerful arc lamps that were so necessary an
adjunct to the business.
In the rear of the house on this floor were the three small rooms
that had served the purpose of the bygone caretaker.
In one of these, two days after the occupation, sat the four men of
Autumn had come early in the year, a cold driving rain was falling
outside, and the fire that burnt in the Georgian grate gave the chamber
an air of comfort.
This room alone had been cleared of litter, the best furniture of
the establishment had been introduced, and on the ink-stained
writing-table that filled the centre of the apartment stood the remains
of a fairly luxurious lunch.
Gonsalez was reading a small red book, and it may be remarked that
he wore gold-rimmed spectacles; Poiccart was sketching at a corner of
the table, and Manfred was smoking a long thin cigar and studying a
manufacturing chemist's price list. Thery (or as some prefer to call
him Saimont) alone did nothing, sitting a brooding heap before the
fire, twiddling his fingers, and staring absently at the leaping little
flames in the grate.
Conversation was carried on spasmodically, as between men whose
minds were occupied by different thoughts. Thery concentrated the
attentions of the three by speaking to the point. Turning from his
study of the fire with a sudden impulse he asked:
"How much longer am I to be kept here?"
Poiccart looked up from his drawing and remarked:
"That is the third time he has asked today."
"Speak Spanish!" cried Thery passionately. "I am tired of this new
language. I cannot understand it, any more than I can understand
"You will wait till it is finished," said Manfred, in the staccato
patois of Andalusia; "we have told you that."
Thery growled and turned his face to the grate.
"I am tired of this life," he said sullenly. "I want to walk about
without a guard--I want to go back to Jerez, where I was a free man. I
am sorry I came away."
"So am I," said Manfred quietly; "not very sorry though--I hope for
your sake I shall not be."
"Who are you?" burst forth Thery, after a momentary silence. "What
are you? Why do you wish to kill? Are you anarchists? What money do you
make out of this? I want to know."
Neither Poiccart nor Gonsalez nor Manfred showed any resentment at
the peremptory demand of their recruit. Gonsalez's clean-shaven,
sharp-pointed face twitched with pleasurable excitement, and his cold
blue eyes narrowed.
"Perfect! perfect!" he murmured, watching the other man's face:
"pointed nose, small forehead and--articu-lorum se ipsos torquentium
sonus; gemitus, mugitusque parum explanatis----"
The physiognomist might have continued Seneca's picture of the Angry
Man, but Thery sprang to his feet and glowered at the three.
"Who are you?" he asked slowly. "How do I know that you are not to
get money for this? I want to know why you keep me a prisoner, why you
will not let me see the newspapers, why you never allow me to walk
alone in the street, or speak to somebody who knows my language? You
are not from Spain, nor you, nor you--your Spanish is--yes, but you are
not of the country I know. You want me to kill--but you will not say
Manfred rose and laid his hand on the other's shoulder.
"Senor," he said--and there was nothing but kindness in his
eyes--"restrain your impatience, I beg of you. I again assure you that
we do not kill for gain. These two gentlemen whom you see have each
fortunes exceeding six million pesetas, and I am even richer; we kill
and we will kill because we are each sufferers through acts of
injustice, for which the law gave us no remedy. If--if----" he
hesitated, still keeping his grey eyes fixed unflinchingly on the
Spaniard. Then he resumed gently: "If we kill you it will be the first
act of the kind."
Thery was on his feet, white and snarling, with his back to the
wall; a wolf at bay, looking from one to the other with fierce
"Me--me!" he breathed, "kill me?"
Neither of the three men moved save Manfred, who dropped his
outstretched hand to his side.
"Yes, you." He nodded as he spoke. "It would be new work for us, for
we have never slain except for justice--and to kill you would be an
Poiccart looked at Thery pityingly.
"That is why we chose you," said Poiccart, "because there was always
a fear of betrayal, and we thought--it had better be you."
"Understand," resumed Manfred calmly, "that not a hair of your head
will be harmed if you are faithful--that you will receive a reward that
will enable you to live--remember the girl at Jerez."
Thery sat down again with a shrug of indifference but his hands were
trembling as he struck a match to light his cigarette.
"We will give you more freedom--you shall go out every day. In a few
days we shall all return to Spain. They called you the silent man in
the prison at Granada--we shall believe that you will remain so."
After this the conversation became Greek to the Spaniard, for the
men spoke in English.
"He gives very little trouble," said Gonsalez. "Now that we have
dressed him like an Englishman, he does not attract attention. He
doesn't like shaving every day; but it is necessary, and luckily he is
fair. I do not allow him to speak in the street, and this tries his
Manfred turned the talk into a more serious channel.
"I shall send two more warnings, and one of those must be delivered
in his very stronghold. He is a brave man."
"What of Garcia?" asked Poiccart.
"I saw him on Sunday night--a fine old man, fiery, and oratorical. I
sat at the back of a little hall whilst he pleaded eloquently in French
for the rights of man. He was a Jean-Jacques Rousseau, a Mirabeau, a
broad-viewed Bright, and the audience was mostly composed of Cockney
youths, who had come that they might boast they had stood in the temple
Poiccart tapped the table impatiently.
"Why is it, George, that an element of bathos comes into all these
"You remember Anderson? When we had gagged him and bound him to the
chair, and had told him why he had to die--when there were only the
pleading eyes of the condemned, and the half-dark room with a
flickering lamp, and you and Leon and poor Clarice masked and silent,
and I had just sentenced him to death--you remember how there crept
into the room the scent of frying onions from the kitchen below."
"I, too, remember," said Leon, "the case of the regicide."
Poiccart made a motion of agreement.
"You mean the corsets," he said, and the two nodded and laughed.
"There will always be bathos," said Manfred; "poor Garcia with a
nation's destinies in his hand, an amusement for shop-girls--tragedy
and the scent of onions--a rapier thrust and the whalebone of
corsets--it is inseparable."
And all the time Thery smoked cigarettes, looking into the fire with
his head on his hands.
"Going back to this matter we have on our hands," said Gonsalez. "I
suppose that there is nothing more to be done till--the day?"
"There are our fine art reproductions."
"And after," persisted Poiccart.
"There is a case in Holland, Hermannus van der Byl, to wit; but it
will be simple, and there will be no necessity to warn."
Poiccart's face was grave.
"I am glad you have suggested van der Byl, he should have been dealt
with before--Hook of Holland or Flushing?"
"If we have time, the Hook by all means."
"I will see to him," said Gonsalez easily; "we will go overland to
Jerez--where the girl is," he added laughingly.
The object of their discussion finished his tenth cigarette and sat
up in his chair with a grunt.
"I forgot to tell you," Leon went on, "that today, when we were
taking our exercise walk, Thery was considerably interested in the
posters he saw everywhere, and was particularly curious to know why so
many people were reading them. I had to find a lie on the spur of the
minute, and I hate lying"--Gonsalez was perfectly sincere. "I invented
a story about racing or lotteries or something of the sort, and he was
Thery had caught his name in spite of its anglicised pronunciation,
and looked inquiry.
"We will leave you to amuse our friend," said Manfred, rising.
"Poiccart and I have a few experiments to make."
The two left the room, traversed the narrow passage, and paused
before a small door at the end. A larger door on the right, padlocked
and barred, led to the studio. Drawing a small key from his pocket,
Manfred opened the door, and, stepping into the room, switched on a
light that shone dimly through a dust-covered bulb. There had been some
attempt at restoring order from the chaos. Two shelves had been cleared
of rubbish, and on these stood rows of bright little phials, each
bearing a number. A rough table had been pushed against the wall
beneath the shelves, and on the green baize with which the table was
covered was a litter of graduated measures, test tubes, condensers,
delicate scales, and two queer-shaped glass machines, not unlike gas
Poiccart pulled a chair to the table, and gingerly lifted a metal
cup that stood in a dish of water. Manfred, looking over his shoulder,
remarked on the consistency of the liquid that half filled the vessel,
and Poiccart bent his head, acknowledging the remark as though it were
"Yes," he said, satisfied, "it is a complete success, the formula is
quite right. Some day we may want to use this."
He replaced the cup in its bath, and reaching beneath the table,
produced from a pail a handful of ice-dust, with which he carefully
surrounded the receptacle.
"I regard that as the multum in farvo of explosives," he
said, and took down a small phial from the shelf, lifted the stopper
with the crook of his little finger, and poured a few drops of a
whitish liquid into the metal cup.
"That neutralises the elements," said Poiccart, and gave a sigh of
relief. "I am not a nervous man, but the present is the first
comfortable moment I have had for two days."
"It makes an abominable smell," said Manfred, with his handkerchief
to his nose.
A thin smoke was rising from the cup.
"I never notice those things," Poiccart replied, dipping a thin
glass rod into the mess. He lifted the rod, and watched reddish drops
dripping from the end.
"That's all right," he said.
"And it is an explosive no more?" asked Manfred.
"It is as harmless as a cup of chocolate."
Poiccart wiped the rod on a rag, replaced the phial, and turned to
"And now?" he asked.
Manfred made no answer, but unlocked an old-fashioned safe that
stood in the corner of the room. From this he removed a box of polished
wood. He opened the box and disclosed the contents.
"If Thery is the good workman he says he is, here is the bait that
shall lure Sir Philip Ramon to his death," he said.
Poiccart looked. "Very ingenious," was his only comment.
Then---"Does Thery know, quite know, the stir it has created?"
Manfred closed the lid and replaced the box before he replied.
"Does Thery know that he is the fourth Just Man?" he asked; then
slowly, "I think not--and it is as well as he does not know; a thousand
pounds is roughly thirty-three thousand pesetas, and there is the free
pardon--and the girl at Jerez," he added thoughtfully.
A brilliant idea came to Smith, the reporter, and he carried it to
"Not bad," said the editor, which meant that the idea was really
very good--"not bad at all."
"It occurred to me," said the gratified reporter, "that one or two
of the four might be foreigners who don't understand a word of
"Quite so," said the chief; "thank you for the suggestion. I'll have
it done tonight."
Which dialogue accounts for the fact that the next morning the
Megaphone appeared with the police notice in French, Italian,
THE editor of the Megaphone, returning from dinner, met the
super-chief on the stairs. The super-chief, boyish of face, withdrew
his mind from the mental contemplation of a new project (Megaphone
House is the home of new projects) and inquired after the Four Just
"The excitement is keeping up," replied the editor. "People are
talking of nothing else but the coming debate on the Extradition Bill,
and the Government is taking every precaution against an attack upon
"What is the feeling?"
The editor shrugged his shoulders.
"Nobody really believes that anything will happen in spite of the
The super-chief thought for a moment, and then quickly:
"What do you think?"
The editor laughed.
"I think the threat will never be fulfilled; for once the Four have
struck against a snag. If they hadn't warned Ramon they might have done
something, but forewarned----"
"We shall see," said the super-chief, and went home.
The editor wondered, as he climbed the stairs, how much longer the
Four would fill the contents bill of his newspaper, and rather hoped
that they would make their attempt, even though they met with a
failure, which he regarded as inevitable.
His room was locked and in darkness, and he fumbled in his pocket
for the key, found it, turned the lock, opened the door and
"I wonder," he mused, reaching out of his hand and pressing down the
switch of the light...
There was a blinding flash, a quick splutter of flame, and the room
was in darkness again.
Startled, he retreated to the corridor and called for a light.
"Send for the electrician," he roared; "one of these damned fuses
A lamp revealed the room to be filled with a pungent smoke; the
electrician discovered that every globe had been carefully removed from
its socket and placed on the table.
From one of the brackets suspended a curly length of thin wire which
ended in a small black box, and it was from this that thick fumes were
"Open the windows," directed the editor; and a bucket of water
having been brought, the little box was dropped carefully into it.
Then it was that the editor discovered the letter--the greenish-grey
letter that lay upon his desk. He took it up, turned it over, opened
it, and noticed that the gum on the flap was still wet.
(ran the note), when you turned on your light this evening you
probably imagined for an instant that you were a victim of one of those
'outrages' to which you are fond of referring. We owe you an apology
for any annoyance we may have caused you. The removal of your lamp and
the substitution of a 'plug' connecting a small charge of magnesium
powder is the cause of your discomfiture. We ask you to believe that it
would have been as simple to have connected a charge of nitroglycerine,
and thus have made you your own executioner. We have arranged this as
evidence of our inflexible intention to carry out our promise in
respect of the Aliens Extradition Act. There is no power on earth that
can save Sir Philip Ramon from destruction, and we ask you, as the
directing force of a great medium, to throw your weight into the scale
in the cause of justice, to call upon your Government to withdraw an
unjust measure, and save not only the lives of many inoffensive persons
who have found an asylum in your country, but also the life of a
Minister of the Crown whose only fault in our eyes is his zealousness
in an unrighteous cause.
the four just men
"Whew!" whistled the editor, wiping his forehead and eyeing the
sodden box floating serenely at the top of the bucket.
"Anything wrong, sir?" asked the electrician daringly.
"Nothing," was the sharp reply. "Finish your work, refix these
globes, and go."
The electrician, ill-satisfied and curious, looked at the floating
box and the broken length of wire.
"Curious-looking thing, sir," he said. "If you ask me--
"I don't ask you anything; finish your work," the great journalist
"Beg pardon, I'm sure," said the apologetic artisan.
Half an hour later the editor of the Megaphone sat discussing
the situation with Welby.
Welby, who is the greatest foreign editor in London, grinned amiably
and drawled his astonishment.
"I have always believed that these chaps meant business," he said
cheerfully, "and what is more, I feel pretty certain that they will
keep their promise. When I was in Genoa"--Welby got much of his
information first-hand--"when I was in Genoa--or was it Sofia?--I met a
man who told me about the Trelovitch affair. He was one of the men who
assassinated the King of Servia, you remember. Well, one night he left
his quarters to visit a theatre--the same night he was found dead in
the public square with a sword thrust through his heart. There were two
extraordinary things about it." The foreign editor ticked them on off
his fingers. "First, the General was a noted swordsman, and there was
every evidence that he had not been killed in cold blood, but had been
killed in a duel; the second was that he wore corsets, as many of these
Germanised officers do, and one of his assailants had discovered this
fact, probably by a sword thrust, and had made him discard them; at any
rate when he was found this frippery was discovered close by his
"Was it known at the time that it was the work of the Four?" asked
Welby shook his head.
"Even I had never heard of them before," he said resentfully. Then
asked, "What have you done about your little scare?"
"I've seen the hall porters and the messengers, and every man on
duty at the time, but the coming and the going of our mysterious
friend--I don't suppose there was more than one--is unexplained. It
really is a remarkable thing. Do you know, Welby, it gives me quite an
uncanny feeling; the gum on the envelope was still wet; the letter must
have been written on the premises and sealed down within a few seconds
of my entering the room."
"Were the windows open?"
"No; all three were shut and fastened, and it would have been
impossible to enter the room that way."
The detective who came to receive a report of the circumstances
endorsed this opinion.
"The man who wrote this letter must have left your room not longer
than a minute before you arrived," he concluded, and took charge of the
Being a young and enthusiastic detective, before finishing his
investigations he made a most minute search of the room, turning up
carpets, tapping walls, inspecting cupboards, and taking laborious and
unnecessary measurements with a foot-rule.
"There are a lot of our chaps who sneer at detective stories," he
explained to the amused editor, "but I have read almost everything that
has been written by Gaboriau and Conan Doyle, and I believe in taking
notice of little things. There wasn't any cigar ash or anything of that
sort left behind, was there?" he asked wistfully.
"I'm afraid not," said the editor gravely.
"Pity," said the detective, and wrapping up the 'infernal machine'
and its appurtenances, he took his departure.
Afterwards the editor informed Welby that the disciple of Holmes had
spent half an hour with a magnifying glass examining the floor.
"He found half a sovereign that I lost weeks ago, so it's really an
All that evening nobody but Welby and the chief knew what had
happened in the editor's room. There was some rumour in the
sub-editor's department that a small accident had occurred in the
"Chief busted a fuse in his room and got a devil of a fright," said
the man who attended to the Shipping List.
"Dear me," said the weather expert, looking up from his chart, "do
you know something like that happened to me: the other night----"
The chief had directed a few firm words to the detective before his
"Only you and myself know anything about this occurrence," said the
editor, "so if it gets out I shall know it comes from Scotland
"You may be sure nothing will come from us," was the detective's
reply: "we've got into too much hot water already."
"That's good," said the editor, and 'that's good' sounded like a
So that Welby and the chief kept the matter a. secret till
half an hour before the paper went to press.
This may seem to the layman an extraordinary circumstance, but
experience has shown most men who control newspapers that news has an
unlucky knack of leaking out before it appears in type.
Wicked compositors--and even compositors can be wicked--have been
known to screw up copies of important and exclusive news, and throw
them out of a convenient window so that they have fallen close to a
patient man standing in the street below and have been immediately
hurried off to the office of a rival newspaper and sold for more than
their weight in gold. Such cases have been known.
But at half past eleven the buzzing hive of Megaphone House began to
hum, for then it was that the sub-editors learnt for the first time of
It was a great story--yet another Megaphone scoop, headlined
half down the page with the 'Just four' again--outrage at the office
of the Megaphone--devilish ingenuity--Another Threatening
Letter--The Four Will Keep Their Promise--Remarkable Document--Will the
Police save Sir Philip Ramon?
"A very good story," said the chief complacently, reading the
He was preparing to leave, and was speaking to Welby by the
"Not bad," said the discriminating Welby. "What I think--hullo!"
The last was addressed to a messenger who appeared with a
"Gentleman wants to speak to somebody, sir--bit excited, so I
brought him up; he's a foreigner, and I can't understand him, so I
brought him to you"--this to Welby.
"What do you want?" asked the chief in French.
The man shook his head, and said a few words in a strange
"Ah!" said Welby, "Spanish--what do you wish?" he said in that
"Is this the office of that paper?" The man produced a grimy copy of
"Can I speak to the editor?"
The chief looked suspicious.
"I am the editor," he said.
The man looked over his shoulder, then leant forward.
"I am one of The Four Just Men," he said hesitatingly. Welby took a
step towards him and scrutinised him closely.
"What is your name?" he asked quickly.
"Miguel Thery of Jerez," replied the man.
It was half past ten when, returning from a concert, the cab that
bore Poiccart and Manfred westward passed through Hanover Square and
turned off to Oxford Street.
"You ask to see the editor," Manfred was explaining; "they take you
up to the offices; you explain your business to somebody; they are very
sorry, but they cannot help you; they are very polite, but not to the
extent of seeing you off the premises, so, wandering about seeking your
way out, you come to the editor's room and, knowing that he is out,
slip in, make your arrangements, walk out, locking the door after you
if nobody is about, addressing a few farewell words to an imaginary
occupant, if you are seen, and voila!"
Poiccart bit the end of his cigar.
"Use for your envelope a gum that will not dry under an hour and you
heighten the mystery," he said quietly, and Manfred was amused.
"The envelope-just-fastened is an irresistible attraction to an
The cab speeding along Oxford Street turned into Edgware Road, when
Manfred put up his hand and pushed open the trap in the roof.
"We'll get down here," he called, and the driver pulled up to the
"I thought you said Pembridge Gardens?" he remarked as Manfred paid
"So I did," said Manfred; "goodnight."
They waited chatting on the edge of the pavement until the cab had
disappeared from view, then turned back to the Marble Arch, crossed to
Park Lane, walked down that plutocratic thoroughfare and round into
Piccadilly. Near the Circus they found a restaurant with a long
bar and many small alcoves, where men sat around marble tables,
drinking, smoking, and talking. In one of these, alone, sat Gonsalez,
smoking a long cigarette and wearing on his clean-shaven mobile face a
look of meditative content.
Neither of the men evinced the slightest sign of surprise at meeting
him--yet Manfred's heart missed a beat, and into the pallid cheeks of
Poiccart crept two bright red spots.
They seated themselves, a waiter came and they gave their orders,
and when he had gone Manfred asked in a low tone, "Where is Thery?"
Leon gave the slightest shrug.
"Thery has made his escape," he answered calmly.
For a minute neither man spoke, and Leon continued:
"This morning, before you left, you gave him a bundle of
"They were English newspapers," he said. "Thery does not know a word
of English. There were pictures in them--I gave them to amuse him."
"You gave him, amongst others, the Megaphone?"
"Yes--ha!" Manfred remembered.
"The offer of a reward was in it--and the free pardon--printed in
Manfred was gazing into vacancy.
"I remember," he said slowly. "I read it afterwards."
"It was very ingenious," remarked Poiccart commendingly.
"I noticed he was rather excited, but I accounted for this by the
fact that we had told him last night of the method we intended adopting
for the removal of Ramon and the part he was to play."
Leon changed the topic to allow the waiter to serve the refreshments
that had been ordered.
"It is preposterous," he went on without changing his key, "that a
horse on which so much money has been placed should not have been sent
to England at least a month in advance."
"The idea of a bad Channel-crossing leading to the scratching of the
favourite of a big race is unheard of," added Manfred severely.
The waiter left them.
"We went for a walk this afternoon," resumed Leon, "and were passing
along Regent Street, he stopping every few seconds to look in the
shops, when suddenly--we had been staring at the window of a
photographer's--I missed him. There were hundreds of people in the
street--but no Thery...I have been seeking him ever since."
Leon sipped his drink and looked at his watch.
The other two men did nothing, said nothing.
A careful observer might have noticed that both Manfred's and
Poiccart's hands strayed to the top button of their coats.
"Perhaps not so bad as that," smiled Gonsalez.
Manfred broke the silence of the two.
"I take all blame," he commenced, but Poiccart stopped him with a
"If there is any blame, I alone am blameless," he said with a short
laugh. "No, George, it is too late to talk of blame. We underrated the
cunning of m'sieur, the enterprise of the English newspapers
"The girl at Jerez," concluded Leon.
Five minutes passed in silence, each man thinking rapidly.
"I have a car not far from here," said Leon at length. "You had told
me you would be at this place by eleven o'clock; we have the naphtha
launch at Burnham-on-Crouch--we could be in France by daybreak."
Manfred looked at him. "What do you think yourself?" he asked.
"I say stay and finish the work," said Leon.
"And I," said Poiccart quietly but decisively.
Manfred called the waiter.
"Have you the last editions of the evening papers?"
The waiter thought he could get them, and returned with two.
Manfred scanned the pages carefully, then threw them aside.
"Nothing in these," he said. "If Thery has gone to the police we
must hide and use some other method to that agreed upon, or we could
strike now. After all, Thery has told us all we want to know,
"That would be unfair to Ramon." Poiccart finished the sentence in
such a tone as summarily ended that possibility. "He has still two
days, and must receive yet another, and last, warning."
"Then we must find Thery."
It was Manfred who spoke, and he rose, followed by Poiccart and
"If Thery has not gone to the police--where would he go?"
The tone of Leon's question suggested the answer.
"To the office of the newspaper that published the Spanish
advertisement," was Manfred's reply, and instinctively the three men
knew that this was the correct solution.
"Your motor-car will be useful," said Manfred, and all three left
In the editor's room Thery faced the two journalists.
"Thery?" repeated Welby; "I do not know that name. Where do you come
from? What is your address?"
"I come from Jerez in Andalusia, from the wine farm of Sienor."
"Not that," interrupted Welby; "where do you come from now--what
part of London?"
Thery raised his hands despairingly.
"How should I know? There are houses and streets and people--and it
is in London, and I was to kill a man, a Minister, because he had made
a wicked law--they did not tell me----"
"They--who?" asked the editor eagerly.
"The other three."
"But their names?"
Thery shot a suspicious glance at his questioner.
"There is a reward," he said sullenly, "and a pardon. I want these
before I tell----"
The editor stepped to his desk.
"If you are one of the Four you shall have your reward--you shall
have some of it now." He pressed a button and a messenger came to the
"Go to the composing room and tell the printer not to allow his men
to leave until I give orders."
Below, in the basement, the machines were thundering as they flung
out the first numbers of the morning news.
"Now"--the editor turned to Thery, who had stood, uneasily shifting
from foot to foot whilst the order was being given--"now, tell me all
Thery did not answer; his eyes were fixed on the floor.
"There is a reward and a pardon," he muttered doggedly.
"Hasten!" cried Welby. "You will receive your reward and the pardon
also. Tell us, who are the Four Just Men? Who are the other three?
Where are they to be found?"
"Here," said a clear voice behind him; and he turned as a stranger,
closing the door as he entered, stood facing the three men--a stranger
in evening dress, masked from brow to chin.
There was a revolver in the hand that hung at his side.
"I am one," repeated the stranger calmly; "there are two others
waiting outside the building."
"How did you get here--what do you want?" demanded the editor, and
stretched his hand to an open drawer in his desk.
"Take your hand away"--and the thin barrel of the revolver rose with
a jerk. "How I came here your doorkeeper will explain, when he recovers
consciousness. Why I am here is because I wish to save my life--not an
unreasonable wish. If Thery speaks I may be a dead man--I am about to
prevent him speaking. I have no quarrel with either of you gentlemen,
but if you hinder me I shall kill you," he said simply. He spoke all
the while in English, and Thery, with wide-stretched eyes and distended
nostrils, shrank back against the wall, breathing quickly.
"You," said the masked man, turning to the terror-stricken informer
and speaking in Spanish, "would have betrayed your comrades--you would
have thwarted a great purpose, therefore it is just that you should
He raised the revolver to the level of Thery's breast, and Thery
fell on his knees, mouthing the prayer he could not articulate.
"By God--no!" cried the editor, and sprang forward.
The revolver turned on him.
"Sir," said the unknown--and his voice sank almost to a
whisper--"for God's sake do not force me to kill you."
"You shall not commit a cold-blooded murder," cried the editor in a
white heat of anger, and moved forward, but Welby held him back. "What
is the use?" said Welby in an undertone; "he means it--we can do
"You can do something," said the stranger, and his revolver dropped
to his side.
Before the editor could answer there was a knock at the door.
"Say you are busy"; and the revolver covered Thery, who was a
whimpering, huddled heap by the wall.
"Go away," shouted the editor, "I am busy."
"The printers are waiting," said the voice of the messenger.
"Now," asked the chief, as the footsteps of the boy died away; "what
can we do?"
"You can save this man's life."
"Give me your word of honour that you will allow us both to depart,
and will neither raise an alarm nor leave this room for a quarter of an
The editor hesitated.
"How do I know that the murder you contemplate will not be committed
as soon as you get clear?"
The other laughed under his mask.
"How do I know that as soon as I have left the room you will not
raise an alarm?"
"I should have given my word, sir," said the editor stiffly.
"And I mine," was the quiet response; "And my word has never been
In the editor's mind a struggle was going on; here in his hand was
the greatest story of the century; another minute and he would have
extracted from Thery the secret of the Four.
Even now a bold dash might save everything--and the printers were
waiting...but the hand that held the revolver was the hand of a
resolute man, and the chief yielded.
"I agree, but under protest," he said. "I warn you that your arrest
and punishment is inevitable."
"I regret," said the masked man with a slight bow, "that I cannot
agree with you--nothing is inevitable save death. Come, Thery," he
said, speaking in Spanish. "On my word as a Caballero I will not harm
Thery hesitated, then slunk forward with his head bowed and his eyes
fixed on the floor.
The masked man opened the door an inch, listened, and in the moment
came the inspiration of the editor's life.
"Look here," he said quickly, the man giving place to the
journalist, "when you get home will you write us an article about
yourselves? You needn't give us any embarrassing particulars, you
know--something about your aspirations, your raison d'etre"
"Sir," said the masked man--and there was a note of admiration in
his voice--"I recognise in you an artist. The article will be delivered
tomorrow"; and opening the door the two men stepped into the darkened
Blood-red placards, hoarse newsboys, overwhelming headlines, and
column after column of leaded type told the world next day how near the
Four had been to capture. Men in the train leant forward, their
newspapers on their knees, and explained what they would have done had
they been in the editor of the Megaphone's position. People
stopped talking about wars and famines and droughts and street
accidents and parliaments and ordinary everyday murders and the German
Emperor, in order to concentrate their minds upon the topic of the
hour. Would the Four Just Men carry out their promise and slay the
Secretary for Foreign Affairs on the morrow?
Nothing else was spoken about. Here was a murder threatened a month
ago, and, unless something unforeseen happened, to be committed
No wonder that the London Press devoted the greater part of its
space to discussing the coming of Thery and his recapture.
'...It is not so easy to understand,' said the Telegram,
'why, having the miscreants in their hands, certain journalists
connected with a sensational and halfpenny contemporary allowed them to
go free to work their evil designs upon a great statesman whose
unparalleled...We say if, for unfortunately in these days of cheap
journalism every story emanating from the sanctum sanctorum of
sensation-loving sheets is not to be accepted on its pretensions; so
if, as it stated, these desperadoes really did visit the office of a
contemporary last night...' At noonday Scotland Yard circulated
broadcast a hastily printed sheet:
Wanted, on suspicion of being connected with a criminal organisation
known as the Four Just Men, miguel thery, alias saimont,
alias le chico, late of Jerez, Spain, a Spaniard speaking no
English. Height 5 feet 8 inches. Eyes brown, hair black, slight black
moustache, face broad. Scars: white scar on cheek, old knife wound on
body. Figure, thick-set.
The above reward will be paid to any person or persons who shall
give such information as shall lead to the identification of the said
Thery with the band known as the Four Just Men and his apprehension.
From which may be gathered that, acting on the information furnished
by the editor and his assistant at two o'clock in the morning, the
Direct Spanish Cable had been kept busy; important personages had been
roused from their beds in Madrid, and the history of Thery as recorded
in the Bureau had been reconstructed from pigeon-hole records for the
enlightenment of an energetic Commissioner of Police.
Sir Philip Ramon, sitting writing in his study at Portland Place,
found a difficulty in keeping his mind upon the letter that lay before
It was a letter addressed to his agent at Branfell, the huge estate
over which he, in the years he was out of office, played squire.
Neither wife nor chick nor child had Sir Philip.'...If by any
chance these men succeed in carrying out their purpose I have made
ample provision not only for yourself but for all who have rendered me
faithful service,' he wrote--from which may be gathered the tenor of
During these past few weeks, Sir Philip's feelings towards the
possible outcome of his action had undergone a change.
The irritation of a constant espionage, friendly on the one hand,
menacing on the other, had engendered so bitter a feeling of
resentment, that in this newer emotion all personal fear had been
swallowed up. His mind was filled with one unswerving determination, to
carry through the measure he had in hand, to thwart the Four Just Men,
and to vindicate the integrity of a Minister of the Crown. 'It would be
absurd,' he wrote in the course of an article entitled Individuality
in its Relation to the Public Service, and which was published some
months later in the Quarterly Review--'it would be monstrous to
suppose that incidental criticism from a wholly unauthoritative source
should affect or in any way influence a member of the Government in his
conception of the legislation necessary for the millions of people
entrusted to his care. He is the instrument, duly appointed, to put
into tangible form the wishes and desires of those who naturally look
to him not only to furnish means and methods for the betterment of
their conditions, or the amelioration of irksome restrictions upon
international commercial relations, but to find them protection from
risks extraneous of purely commercial liabilities...in such a case a
Minister of the Crown with a due appreciation of his responsibilities
ceases to exist as a man and becomes merely an unhuman automaton.'
Sir Philip Ramon was a man with very few friends. He had none of the
qualities that go to the making of a popular man. He was an honest man,
a conscientious man, a strong man. He was the cold-blooded, cynical
creature that a life devoid of love had left him. He had no
enthusiasm--and inspired none. Satisfied that a certain procedure was
less wrong than any other, he adopted it. Satisfied that a measure was
for the immediate or ultimate good of his fellows, he carried that
measure through to the bitter end. It may be said of him that he had no
ambitions--only aims. He was the most dangerous man in the Cabinet,
which he dominated in his masterful way, for he knew not the meaning of
the blessed word 'compromise'.
If he held views on any subject under the sun, those views were to
be the views of his colleagues.
Four times in the short history of the administration had
Rumoured Resignation of a Cabinet Minister filled the placards
of the newspapers, and each time the Minister whose resignation was
ultimately recorded was the man whose views had clashed with the
Foreign Secretary. In small things, as in great, he had his way.
His official residence he absolutely refused to occupy, and No. 44
Downing Street was converted into half office, half palace. Portland
Place was his home, and from there he drove every morning, passing the
Horse Guards clock as it finished the last stroke of ten.
A private telephone wire connected his study in Portland Place with
the official residence, and but for this Sir Philip had cut himself
adrift from the house in Downing Street, to .occupy which had been the
ambition of the great men of his party.
Now, however, with the approach of the day on which every effort
would be taxed, the police insisted upon his taking up his quarters in
Here, they said, the task of protecting the Minister would be
simplified. No. 44 Downing Street they knew. The approaches could be
better guarded, and, moreover, the drive--that dangerous
drive!--between Portland Place and the Foreign Office would be
It took a considerable amount of pressure and pleading to induce Sir
Philip to take even this step, and it was only when it was pointed out
that the surveillance to which he was being subjected would not be so
apparent to himself that he yielded.
"You don't like to find my men outside your door with your shaving
water," said Superintendent Falmouth bluntly. "You objected to one of
my men being in your bathroom when you went in the other morning, and
you complained about a plain-clothes officer driving on your box--well,
Sir Philip, in Downing Street I promise that you shan't even see
This clinched the argument.
It was just before leaving Portland Place to take up his new
quarters that he sat writing to his agent whilst the detective waited
outside the door.
The telephone at Sir Philip's elbow buzzed--he hated bells--and the
voice of his private secretary asked with some anxiety how long he
"We have got sixty men on duty at 44," said the secretary, zealous
and young, "and today and tomorrow we shall----" And Sir Philip
listened with growing impatience to the recital.
"I wonder you have not got an iron safe to lock me in," he said
petulantly, and closed the conversation.
There was a knock at the door and Falmouth put his head inside.
"I don't want to hurry you, sir," he said, "but----"
So the Foreign Secretary drove off to Downing Street in something
remarkably like a temper.
For he was not used to being hurried, or taken charge of, or ordered
hither and thither. It irritated him further to see the now familiar
cyclists on either side of the carriage, to recognise at every few
yards an obvious policeman in mufti admiring the view from the
sidewalk, and when he came to Downing Street and found it barred to all
carriages but his own, and an enormous crowd of morbid sightseers
gathered to cheer his ingress, he felt as he had never felt before in
He found his secretary waiting in his private office with the rough
draft of the speech that was to introduce the second reading of the
"We are pretty sure to meet with a great deal of opposition,"
informed the secretary, "but Mainland has sent out three-line whips,
and expects to get a majority of thirty-six--at the very least."
Ramon read over the notes and found them refreshing.
They brought back the old feeling of security and importance. After
all, he was a great Minister of State. Of course the threats were too
absurd--the police were to blame for making so much fuss; and of course
the Press--yes, that was it--a newspaper sensation.
There was something buoyant, something almost genial in his air,
when he turned with a half smile to his secretary.
"Well, what about my unknown friends--what do the blackguards call
themselves?--the Four Just Men?"
Even as he spoke he was acting a part; he had not forgotten their
title, it was with him day and night.
The secretary hesitated; between his chief and himself the Four Just
Men had been a tabooed subject.
"They--oh, we've heard nothing more than you have read," he said
lamely; "we know now who Thery is, but we can't place his three
The Minister pursed his lips.
"They give me till tomorrow night to recant," he said.
"You have heard from them again?"
"The briefest of notes," said Sir Philip lightly.
Sir Philip frowned. "They will keep their promise," he said shortly,
for the 'otherwise' of his secretary had sent a coldness into his heart
that he could not quite understand.
In the top room in the workshop at Carnaby Street, Thery, subdued,
sullen, fearful, sat facing the three. "I want you to quite
understand," said Manfred, "that we bear you no ill-will for what you
have done. I think, and Senor Poiccart thinks, that Senor Gonsalez did
right to spare your life and bring you back to us."
Thery dropped his eyes before the half-quizzical smile of the
"Tomorrow night you will do as you agreed to do--if the necessity
still exists. Then you will go----" he paused.
"Where?" demanded Thery in sudden rage. "Where in the name of Heaven?
I have told them my name, they will know who I am--they will find
that by writing to the police. Where am I to go?"
He sprang to his feet, glowering on the three men, his hands
trembling with rage, his great frame shaking with the intensity of his
"You betrayed yourself," said Manfred quietly; "that is your
punishment. But we will find a place for you, a new Spain under other
skies--and the girl at Jerez shall be there waiting for you."
Thery looked from one to the other suspiciously. Were they laughing
There was no smile on their faces; Gonsalez alone looked at him with
keen, inquisitive eyes, as though he saw some hidden meaning in the
"Will you swear that?" asked Thery hoarsely, "will you swear that by
"I promise that--if you wish it I will swear it," said Manfred. "And
now," he went on, his voice changing, "you know what is expected of you
tomorrow night--what you have to do?"
"There must be no hitch--no bungling; you and I and Poiccart and
Gonsalez will kill this unjust man in a way that the world will never
guess--such an execution as shall appall mankind. A swift death, a sure
death, a death that will creep through cracks, that will pass by the
guards unnoticed. Why, there never has been such a thing
done--such----" he stopped dead with flushed cheeks and kindling eyes,
and met the gaze of his two companions. Poiccart impassive, sphinxlike,
Leon interested and analytic. Manfred's face went a duller red.
"I am sorry," he said almost humbly; "for the moment I had forgotten
the cause, and the end, in the strangeness of the means."
He raised his hand deprecatingly.
"It is understandable," said Poiccart gravely, and Leon pressed
The three stood in embarrassed silence for a moment, then Manfred
"To work!" he said, and led the way to the improvised
Inside Thery took off his coat. Here was his province, and from
being the cowed dependant he took charge of the party, directing them,
instructing, commanding, until he had the men of whom, a few minutes
before, he had stood in terror running from studio to laboratory, from
floor to floor.
There was much to be done, much testing, much calculating, many
little sums to be worked out on paper, for in the killing of Sir Philip
Ramon all the resources of modern science were to be pressed into the
service of the Four.
"I am going to survey the land," said Manfred suddenly, and
disappearing into the studio returned with a pair of step-ladders.
These he straddled in the dark passage, and mounting quickly pushed up
a trapdoor that led to the flat roof of the building.
He pulled himself up carefully, crawled along the leaden surface,
and raising himself cautiously looked over the low parapet.
He was in the centre of a half mile circle of uneven roofs. Beyond
the circumference of his horizon London loomed murkily through smoke
and mist. Below was a busy street. He took a hasty survey of the roof
with its chimney stacks, its unornamental telegraph pole, its leaden
floor and rusty guttering; then, through a pair of field-glasses, made
a long, careful survey southward. He crawled slowly back to the
trapdoor, raised it, and let himself down very gingerly till his feet
touched the top of the ladder. Then he descended rapidly, closing the
door after him.
"Well?" asked Thery with something of triumph in his voice.
"I see you have labelled it," said Manfred.
"It is better so--since we shall work in the dark," said Thery.
"Did you see then----?" began Poiccart.
"Very indistinctly--one could just see the Houses of Parliament
dimly, and Downing Street is a jumble of roofs."
Thery had turned to the work that was engaging his attention.
Whatever was his trade he was a deft workman. Somehow he felt that he
must do his best for these men. He had been made forcibly aware of
their superiority in the last days, he had now an ambition to assert
his own skill, his individuality, and to earn commendation from these
men who had made him feel his littleness.
Manfred and the others stood aside and watched him in silence. Leon,
with a perplexed frown, kept his eyes fixed on the workman's face. For
Leon Gonsalez, scientist, physiognomist (his translation of the
Theologi Physiognomia Humana of Lequetius is regarded today as
the finest), was endeavouring to reconcile the criminal with the
After a while Thery finished.
"All is now ready," he said with a grin of satisfaction: "let me
find your Minister of State, give me a minute's speech with him, and
the next minute he dies."
His face, repulsive in repose, was now demoniacal. He was like some
great bull from his own country made more terrible with the snuffle of
blood in his nostrils.
In strange contrast were the faces of his employers. Not a muscle of
either face stirred. There was neither exultation nor remorse in their
expressions--only a curious something that creeps into the set face of
the judge as he pronounces the dread sentence of the law. Thery saw
that something, and it froze him to his very marrow.
He threw up his hands as if to ward them off.
"Stop! stop!" he shouted; "don't look like that, in the name of
God--don't, don't!" He covered his face with shaking hands.
"Like what, Thery?" asked Leon softly.
Thery shook his head.
"I cannot say--like the judge at Granada when he says--when he says,
'Let the thing be done!'"
"If we look so," said Manfred harshly, "it is because we are
judges--and not alone judges but executioners of our judgment."
"I thought you would have been pleased," whimpered Thery.
"You have done well," said Manfred gravely.
"Bueno, bueno!" echoed the others.
"Pray God that we are successful," added Manfred solemnly, and Thery
stared at this strange man in amazement.
Superintendent Falmouth reported to the Commissioner that afternoon
that all arrangements were now complete for the protection of the
"I've filled up 44 Downing Street," he said; "there's practically a
man in every room. I've got four of our best men on the roof, men in
the basement, men in the kitchens."
"What about the servants?" asked the Commissioner.
"Sir Philip has brought up his own people from the country, and now
there isn't a person in the house from the private secretary to the
doorkeeper whose name and history I do not know from A to Z."
The Commissioner breathed an anxious sigh.
"I shall be very glad when tomorrow is over," he said. "What are the
"There has been no change, sir, since we fixed things up the morning
Sir Philip came over. He remains at 44 all day tomorrow until half past
eight, goes over to the House at nine to move the reading of the Bill,
returns at eleven."
"I have given orders for the traffic to be diverted along the
Embankment between a quarter to nine and a quarter after, and the same
at eleven," said the Commissioner. "Four closed carriages will drive
from Downing Street to the House, Sir Philip will drive down in a car
There was a rap at the door--the conversation took place in the
Commissioner's office--and a police officer entered. He bore a card in
his hand, which he laid upon the table.
"Senor Jose di Silva," read the Commissioner, "the Spanish Chief of
Police," he explained to the Superintendent. "Show him in, please."
Senor di Silva, a lithe little man, with a pronounced nose and a
beard, greeted the Englishmen with the exaggerated politeness that is
peculiar to Spanish official circles.
"I am sorry to bring you over," said the Commissioner, after he had
shaken hands with the visitor and had introduced him to Falmouth; "we
thought you might be able to help us in our search for Thery."
"Luckily I was in Paris," said the Spaniard; "yes, I know Thery, and
I am astounded to find him in such distinguished company. Do I know the
Four?"--his shoulders went up to his ears--"who does? I know of
them--there was a case at Malaga, you know?...Thery is not a good
criminal. I was astonished to learn that he had joined the band."
"By the way," said the chief, picking up a copy of the police notice
that lay on his desk, and running his eye over it, "your people omitted
to say--although it really isn't of very great importance--what is
The Spanish policeman knitted his brow.
"Thery's trade! Let me remember." He thought for a moment. "Thery's
trade? I don't think I know; yet I have an idea that it is something to
do with rubber. His first crime was stealing rubber; but if you want to
know for certain----"
The Commissioner laughed.
"It really isn't at all important," he said lightly.
There was yet another missive to be handed to the doomed Minister.
In the last he had received there had occurred the sentence: One
more warning you shall receive, and so that we may be assured it shall
not go astray, our next and last message shall be delivered into your
hands by one of us in person.
This passage afforded the police more comfort than had any episode
since the beginning of the scare. They placed a curious faith in the
honesty of the Four Men; they recognised that these were not ordinary
criminals and that their pledge was inviolable. Indeed, had they
thought otherwise the elaborate precautions that they were taking to
ensure the safety of Sir Philip would not have been made. The honesty
of the Four was their most terrible characteristic.
In this instance it served to raise a faint hope that the men who
were setting at defiance the establishment of the law would overreach
themselves. The letter conveying this message was the one to which Sir
Philip had referred so airily in his conversation with his secretary.
It had come by post, bearing the date mark, Balham, 12.15.
"The question is, shall we keep you absolutely surrounded, so that
these men cannot by any possible chance carry out their threat?" asked
Superintendent Falmouth in some perplexity, "or shall we apparently
relax our vigilance in order to lure one of the Four to his destruction?"
The question was directed to Sir Philip Ramon as he sat huddled up
in the capacious depths of his office chair.
"You want to use me as a bait?" he asked sharply.
The detective expostulated.
"Not exactly that, sir; we want to give these men a chance----"
"I understand perfectly," said the Minister, with some show of
The detective resumed:
"We know now how the infernal machine was smuggled into the House;
on the day on which the outrage was committed an old member, Mr.
Bascoe, the member for North Torrington, was seen to enter the
"Well?" asked Sir Philip in surprise.
"Mr. Bascoe was never within a hundred miles of the House of Commons
on that date," said the detective quietly. "We might never have found
it out, for his name did not appear in the division list. We've been
working quietly on that House of Commons affair ever since, and it was
only a couple of days ago that we made the discovery."
Sir Philip sprang from his chair and nervously paced the floor of
"Then they are evidently well acquainted with the conditions of life
in England," he asserted rather than asked.
"Evidently; they've got the lay of the land, and that is one of the
dangers of the situation."
"But," frowned the other, "you have told me there were no dangers,
no real dangers."
"There is this danger, sir," replied the detective, eyeing the
Minister steadily, and dropping his voice as he spoke, "men who are
capable of making such disguise are really outside the ordinary run of
criminals. I don't know what their game is, but whatever it is, they
are playing it thoroughly. One of them is evidently an artist at that
sort of thing, and he's the man I'm afraid of--today."
Sir Philip's head tossed impatiently.
"I am tired of all this, tired of it"--and he thrashed the edge of
his desk with an open palm--"detectives and disguises and masked
murderers until the atmosphere is, for all the world, like that of a
"You must have patience for a day or two," said the plain-spoken
The Four Just Men were on the nerves of more people than the Foreign
"And we have not decided what is to be our plan for this evening,"
"Do as you like," said Sir Philip shortly, and then: "Am I to be
allowed to go to the House tonight?"
"No; that is not part of the programme," replied the detective.
Sir Philip stood for a moment in thought.
"These arrangements; they are kept secret, I suppose?"
"Who knows of them?"
"Yourself, the Commissioner, your secretary, and myself."
"And no one else?"
"No one; there is no danger likely to arise from that source. If
upon the secrecy of your movements your safety depended it would be
"Have these arrangements been committed to writing?" asked Sir
"No, sir; nothing has been written; our plans have been settled upon
and communicated verbally; even the Prime Minister does not know."
Sir Philip breathed a sigh of relief.
"That is all to the good," he said, as the detective rose to go.
"I must see the Commissioner. I shall be away for less than half an
hour; in the meantime I suggest that you do not leave your room," he
Sir Philip followed him out to the ante-room, in which sat Hamilton,
"I have had an uncomfortable feeling," said Falmouth, as one of his
men approached with a long coat, which he proceeded to help the
detective into, "a sort of instinctive feeling this last day or two,
that I have been watched and followed, so that I am using a car to
convey me from place to place: they can't follow that, without
attracting some notice." He dipped his hand into the pocket and brought
out a pair of motoring goggles. He laughed somewhat shamefacedly as he
adjusted them. "This is the only disguise I ever adopt, and I might
say, Sir Philip," he added with some regret, "that this is the first
time during my twenty-five years of service that I have ever played the
fool like a stage detective."
After Falmouth's departure the Foreign Minister returned to his
He hated being alone: it frightened him. That there were two score
detectives within call did not dispel the feeling of loneliness. The
terror of the Four was ever with him, and this had so worked upon his
nerves that the slightest noise irritated him. He played with the
penholder that lay on the desk. He scribbled inconsequently on the
blotting-pad before him, and was annoyed to find that the scribbling
had taken the form of numbers of figure 4.
Was the Bill worth it? Was the sacrifice called for? Was the measure
of such importance as to justify the risk? These things he asked
himself again and again, and then immediately, What sacrifice? What
"I am taking the consequence too much for granted," he muttered,
throwing aside the pen, and half turning from the writing-table. "There
is no certainty that they will keep their words; bah! it is impossible
that they should----"
There was a knock at the door.
"Hullo, Superintendent," said the Foreign Minister as the knocker
entered. "Back again already!"
The detective, vigorously brushing the dust from his moustache with
a handkerchief, drew an official-looking blue envelope from his
"I thought I had better leave this in your care," he said, dropping
his voice; "it occurred to me just after I had left; accidents happen,
The Minister took the document.
"What is it?" he asked.
"It is something which would mean absolute disaster for me if by
chance it was found in my possession," said the detective, turning to
"What am I to do with it?"
"You would greatly oblige me by putting it in your desk until I
return"; and the detective stepped into the anteroom, closed the door
behind him and, acknowledging the salute of the plain-clothes officer
who guarded the outer door, passed to the motor-car that awaited
Sir Philip looked at the envelope with a puzzled frown.
It bore the superscription Confidential and the address,
Department A, C1D, Scotland Yard.
'Some confidential report,' thought Sir Philip, and an angry doubt
as to the possibility of it containing particulars of the police
arrangements for his safety filled his mind. He had hit by accident
upon the truth had he but known. The envelope contained those
He placed the letter in a drawer of his desk and drew some papers
They were copies of the Bill for the passage of which he was daring
It was not a long document. The clauses were few in number, the
objects, briefly described in the preamble, were tersely defined. There
was no fear of this Bill failing to pass on the morrow. The
Government's majority was assured. Men had been brought back to town,
stragglers had been whipped in, prayers and threats alike had assisted
in concentrating the rapidly dwindling strength of the administration
on this one effort of legislation; and what the frantic entreaties of
the Whips had failed to secure, curiosity had accomplished, for members
of both parties were hurrying to town to be present at a scene which
might perhaps be history, and, as many feared, tragedy.
As Sir Philip conned the paper he mechanically formed in his mind
the line of attack--for, tragedy or no, the Bill struck at too many
interests in the House to allow of its passage without a stormy debate.
He was a master of dialectics, a brilliant casuist, a coiner of phrases
that stuck and stung. There was nothing for him to fear in the debate.
If only----It hurt him to think of the Four Just Men. Not so much
because they threatened his life--he had gone past that--but the mere
thought that there had come a new factor into his calculations, a new
and terrifying force, that could not be argued down or brushed aside
with an acid jest, nor intrigued against, nor adjusted by any
parliamentary method. He did not think of compromise. The possibility
of making terms with his enemy never once entered his head.
"I'll go through with it!" he cried, not once but a score of times;
"I'll go through with it!" and now, as the moment grew nearer to hand,
his determination to try conclusions with this new world-force grew
stronger than ever.
The telephone at his elbow purred--he was sitting at his desk with
his head on his hands--and he took the receiver. The voice of his house
steward reminded him that he had arranged to give instructions for the
closing of the house in Portland Place.
For two or three days, or until this terror had subsided, he
intended his house should be empty. He would not risk the lives of his
servants. If the Four intended to carry out their plan they would run
no risks of failure, and if the method they employed were a bomb, then,
to make assurance doubly sure, an explosion at Downing Street might
well synchronize with an outrage at Portland Place.
He had finished his talk, and was replacing the receiver when a
knock at the door heralded the entry of the detective.
He looked anxiously at the Minister.
"Nobody been, sir?" he asked.
Sir Philip smiled.
"If by that you mean have the Four delivered their ultimatum in
person, I can comfort your mind--they have not."
The detective's face was evidence of his relief.
"Thank Heaven!" he said fervently. "I had an awful dread that whilst
I was away something would happen. But I have news for you, sir."
"Yes, sir, the Commissioner has received a long cable from America.
Since the two murders in that country one of Pinkerton's men has been
engaged in collecting data. For years he has been piecing together the
scrappy evidence he has been able to secure, and this is his
cable-gram." The detective drew a paper from his pocket and, spreading
it on the desk, read:
Pinkerton, Chicago, to Commissioner of Police, Scotland yard,
Warn Ramon that the Four do not go outside their promise. If they
have threatened to kill in a certain manner at a certain time they will
be punctual. We have proof of this characteristic. After Anderson's
death small memorandum book was discovered outside window of room
evidently dropped. Book was empty save for three pages, which were
filled with neatly written memoranda headed 'Six methods of execution'.
It was initialled 'C.' (third letter in alphabet). Warn Ramon against
following: drinking coffee in any form, opening letters or parcels,
using soap that has not been manufactured under eye of trustworthy
agent, sitting in any room other than that occupied day and night by
police officer. Examine his bedroom; see if there is any method by
which heavy gases can be introduced. We are sending two men by
'Lucania' to watch.
The detective finished reading. 'Watch' was not the last word in the
original message, as he knew. There had been an ominous postscript,
Afraid they will arrive too late.
"Then you think----?" asked the statesman.
"That your danger lies in doing one of the things that Pinkerton
warns us against," replied the detective. "There is no fear that the
American police are talking idly. They have based their warning on some
sure knowledge, and that is why I regard their cable as important."
There was a sharp rap on the panel of the door, and without waiting
for invitation the private secretary walked into the room, excitedly
waving a newspaper.
"Look at this!" he cried, "read this! The Four have admitted their
"What!" shouted the detective, reaching for the journal.
"What does this mean?" asked Sir Philip sharply.
"Only this, sir: these beggars, it appears, have actually written an
article on their 'mission'."
"In what newspaper?"
"The Megaphone. It seems when they recaptured Thery the
editor asked the masked man to write him an article about himself, and
they've done it; and it's here, and they've admitted defeat,
The detective had seized the paper and broke in upon the incoherent
"The Creed of the Four Just Men" he read. "Where is their
confession of failure?"
"Half way down the column--I have marked the passage--here"; and the
young man pointed with a trembling finger to a paragraph.
"'We leave nothing to chance,'" read the detective, "'if the
slightest hitch occurs, if the least detail of our plan miscarries, we
acknowledge defeat. So assured are we that our presence on earth is
necessary for the carrying out of a great plan, so certain are we that
we are the indispensable instruments of a divine providence, that we
dare not, for the sake of our very cause, accept unnecessary risks. It
is essential therefore that the various preliminaries to every
execution should be carried out to the full. As an example, it will be
necessary for us to deliver our final warning to Sir Philip Ramon; and
to add point to this warning, it is, by our code, essential that that
should be handed to the Minister by one of us in person. All
arrangements have been made to carry this portion of our programme into
effect. But such are the extraordinary exigencies of our system that
unless this warning can be handed to Sir Philip in accordance with our
promise, and before eight o'clock this evening, our arrangements fall
to the ground, and the execution we have planned must be forgone.'"
The detective stopped reading, with disappointment visible on every
line of his face.
"I thought, sir, by the way you were carrying on that you had
discovered something new. I've read all this, a copy of the article was
sent to the Yard as soon as it was received."
The secretary thumped the desk impatiently.
"But don't you see!" he cried, "don't you understand that there is
no longer any need to guard Sir Philip, that there is no reason to use
him as a bait, or, in fact, to do anything if we are to believe these
men--look at the time----"
The detective's hand flew to his pocket; he drew out his watch,
looked at the dial, and whistled.
"Half past eight, by God!" he muttered in astonishment, and the
three stood in surprised silence.
Sir Philip broke the silence.
"Is it a ruse to take us off our guard?" he said hoarsely.
"I don't think so," replied the detective slowly, "I feel sure that
it is not; nor shall I relax my watch--but I am a believer in the
honesty of these men--I don't know why I should say this, for I have
been dealing with criminals for the past twenty-five years, and never
once have I put an ounce of faith in the word of the best of 'em, but
somehow I can't disbelieve these men. If they have failed to deliver
their message they will not trouble us again."
Ramon paced his room with quick, nervous steps.
"I wish I could believe that," he muttered; "I wish I had your
A tap on the door panel.
"An urgent telegram for Sir Philip," said a grey-haired
The Minister stretched out his hand, but the detective was before
"Remember Pinkerton's wire, sir," he said, and ripped open the brown
Just received a telegram handed in at Charing Cross
7.52. Begins: We have delivered our last message to the
foreign Secretary, signed Four. Ends. Is this true?
"What does this mean?" asked Falmouth in bewilderment when he had
"It means, my dear Mr. Falmouth," replied Sir Philip testily, "that
your noble Four are liars and braggarts as well as murderers; and it
means at the same time, I hope, an end to your ridiculous faith in
The detective made no answer, but his face was clouded and he bit
his lips in perplexity.
"Nobody came after I left?" he asked.
"You have seen no person besides your secretary and myself?"
"Absolutely nobody has spoken to me, or approached within a dozen
yards of me," Ramon answered shortly.
Falmouth shook his head despairingly.
"Well--I--where are we?" he asked, speaking more to himself than to
anybody in the room, and moved towards the door.
Then it was that Sir Philip remembered the package left in his
"You had better take your precious documents," he said, opening his
drawer and throwing the package left in his charge on to the table.
The detective looked puzzled.
"What is this?" he asked, picking up the envelope.
"I'm afraid the shock of finding yourself deceived in your estimate
of my persecutors has dazed you," said Sir Philip, and added pointedly,
"I must ask the Commissioner to send an officer who has a better
appreciation of the criminal mind, and a less childlike faith in the
honour of murderers."
"As to that, sir," said Falmouth, unmoved by the outburst, "you must
do as you think best. I have discharged my duty to my own satisfaction;
and I have no more critical taskmaster than myself. But what I am more
anxious to hear is exactly what you mean by saying that I handed any
papers into your care."
The Foreign Secretary glared across the table at the imperturbable
"I am referring, sir," he said harshly, "to the packet which you
returned to leave in my charge."
The detective stared.
"I--did--not--return," he said in a strained voice. "I have left no
papers in your hands." He picked up the package from the table, tore it
open, and disclosed yet another envelope. As he caught sight of the
grey-green cover he gave a sharp cry.
"This is the message of the Four," said Falmouth.
The Foreign Secretary staggered back a pace, white to the lips.
"And the man who delivered it?" he gasped.
"Was one of the Four Just Men," said the detective grimly. "They
have kept their promise."
He took a quick step to the door, passed through into the ante-room
and beckoned the plain-clothes officer who stood on guard at the outer
"Do you remember my going out?" he asked.
"Yes, sir--both times."
"Both times, eh!" said Falmouth bitterly, "and how did I look the
His subordinate was bewildered at the form the question took.
"As usual, sir," he stammered.
"How was I dressed?" ';
The constable considered.
"In your long dust-coat."
"I wore my goggles, I suppose?"
"I thought so," muttered Falmouth savagely, and raced down the broad
marble stairs that led to the entrance-hall. There were four men on
duty who saluted him as he approached.
"Do you remember my going out?" he asked of the sergeant in
"Yes, sir--both times," the officer replied.
"Damn your 'both times'!" snapped Falmouth; "how long had I been
gone the first time before I returned?"
"Five minutes, sir," was the astonished officer's reply.
"They just gave themselves time to do it," muttered Falmouth, and
then aloud, "Did I return in my car?"
"Ah!"--hope sprang into the detective's breast--"did you notice the
number?" he asked, almost fearful to hear the reply.
The detective could have hugged the stolid officer.
"Good--what was it?"
The detective made a rapid note of the number.
"Jackson," he called, and one of the men in mufti stepped forward
"Go to the Yard; find out the registered owner of this car. When you
have found this go to the owner; ask him to explain his movements; if
necessary, take him into custody."
Falmouth retraced his steps to Sir Philip's study. He found the
statesman still agitatedly walking up and down the room, the secretary
nervously drumming his fingers on the table, and the letter still
"As I thought," explained Falmouth, "the man you saw was one of the
Four impersonating me. He chose his time admirably: my own men were
deceived. They managed to get a. car exactly similar in build
and colour to mine, and, watching their opportunity, they drove to
Downing Street a few minutes after I had left. There is one last chance
of our catching him--luckily the sergeant on duty noticed the number of
the car, and we might be able to trace him through that--hullo." An
attendant stood at the door.
Would the Superintendent see Detective Jackson?
Falmouth found him waiting in the hall below.
"I beg your pardon, sir," said Jackson, saluting, "but is there not
some mistake in this number?"
"Why?" asked the detective sharply.
"Because," said the man, "A17164 is the number of your own car."
Final warning was brief and to the point:
We allow you until tomorrow evening to reconsider your position in
the matter of the Aliens Extradition Bill. If by six o'clock no
announcement is made in the afternoon newspapers of your withdrawing
this measure we shall have no other course to pursue but to fulfil our
promise. You will die at eight in the evening. We append for your
enlightenment a concise table of the secret police arrangements made
for your safety tomorrow. Farewell.
(Signed) four just men
Sir Philip read this over without a tremor. He read too the slip of
paper on which was written, in the strange foreign hand, the details
that the police had not dared to put into writing.
"There is a leakage somewhere," he said, and the two anxious
watchers saw that the face of their charge was grey and drawn.
"These details were known only to four," said the detective quietly,
"and I'll stake my life that it was neither the Commissioner nor
"Nor I!" said the private secretary emphatically.
Sir Philip shrugged his shoulders with a weary laugh.
"What does it matter?--they know," he exclaimed; "by what uncanny
method they learnt the secret I neither know nor care. The question is,
can I be adequately protected tomorrow night at eight o'clock?"
Falmouth shut his teeth.
"Either you'll come out of it alive or, by the Lord, they'll kill
two," he said, and there was a gleam in his eye that spoke for his
The news that yet another letter had reached the great statesman was
on the streets at ten o'clock that night. It circulated through the
clubs and theatres, and between the acts grave-faced men stood in the
vestibules discussing Ramon's danger. The House of Commons was seething
with excitement. In the hope that the Minister would come down, a
strong House had gathered, but the members were disappointed, for it
was evident soon after the dinner recess that Sir Philip had no
intention of showing himself that night.
"Might I ask the right honourable the Prime Minister whether it is
the intention of His Majesty's Government to proceed with the Aliens
Extradition (Political Offences) Bill," asked the Radical Member for
West Deptford, "and whether he has not considered, in view of the
extraordinary conditions that this Bill has called into life, the
advisability of postponing the introduction of this measure?"
The question was greeted with a chorus of 'hear-hears', and the
Prime Minister rose slowly and turned an amused glance in the direction
of the questioner.
"I know of no circumstance that is likely to prevent my right
honourable friend, who is unfortunately not in his place tonight, from
moving the second reading of the Bill tomorrow," he said, and sat
"What the devil was he grinning at?" grumbled West Deptford to a
"He's deuced uncomfortable, is JK," said the other wisely, "deuced
uncomfortable; a man in the Cabinet was telling me today that old JK
has been feeling deuced uncomfortable. 'You mark my words,' he said,
'this Four Just Men business is making the Premier deuced
uncomfortable,'" and the hon. member subsided to allow West Deptford
to digest his neighbour's profundities.
"I've done my best to persuade Ramon to drop the Bill," the Premier
was saying, "but he is adamant, and the pitiable thing is that he
believes in his heart of hearts that these fellows intend keeping
"It is monstrous," said the Colonial Secretary hotly; "it is
inconceivable that such a state of affairs can last. Why, it strikes at
the root of everything, it unbalances every adjustment of
"It is a poetical idea," said the phlegmatic Premier, "and the
standpoint of the Four is quite a logical one. Think of the enormous
power for good or evil often vested in one man: a capitalist
controlling the markets of the world, a speculator cornering cotton or
wheat whilst mills stand idle and people starve, tyrants and despots
with the destinies of nations between their thumb and finger--and then
think of the four men, known to none; vague, shadowy figures stalking
tragically through the world, condemning and executing the capitalist,
the corner maker, the tyrant--evil forces all, and all beyond reach of
the law. We have said of these people, such of us as are touched with
mysticism, that God would judge them. Here are men arrogating to
themselves the divine right of superior judgment. If we catch them they
will end their lives unpicturesquely, in a matter-of-fact, commonplace
manner in a little shed in Pentonville Gaol, and the world will never
realise how great are the artists who perish."
The Premier smiled.
"Here, I think, these men have just overreached themselves. Had they
been content to slay first and explain their mission afterwards I have
little doubt that Ramon would have died. But they have warned and
warned and exposed their hand a dozen times over. I know nothing of the
arrangements that are being made by the police, but I should imagine
that by tomorrow night it will be as difficult to get within a dozen
yards of Ramon as it would be for a Siberian prisoner to dine with the
"Is there no possibility of Ramon withdrawing the Bill?" asked the
The Premier shook his head.
"Absolutely none," he said.
The rising of a member of the Opposition front bench at that moment
to move an amendment to a clause under discussion cut short the
The House rapidly emptied when it became generally known that Ramon
did not intend appearing, and the members gathered in the smoking-room
and lobby to speculate upon the matter which was uppermost in their
In the vicinity of Palace Yard a great crowd had gathered, as in
London crowds will gather, on the off-chance of catching a glimpse of
the man whose name was in every mouth. Street vendors sold his
portrait, frowsy men purveying the real life and adventures of the Four
Just Men did a roaring trade, and itinerant street singers, introducing
extemporised verses into their repertoire, declaimed the courage of
that statesman bold, who dared for to resist the threats of coward
alien and deadly anarchist.
There was praise in these poor lyrics for Sir Philip, who was trying
to prevent the foreigner from taking the bread out of the mouths of
honest working men.
The humour of which appealed greatly to Manfred, who, with Poiccart,
had driven to the Westminster end of the Embankment; having dismissed
their cab, they were walking to Whitehall.
"I think the verse about the 'deadly foreign anarchist' taking the
bread out of the mouth of the home-made variety is distinctly good,"
Both men were in evening dress, and Poiccart wore in his button-hole
the silken button of a Chevalier of the Legion d'Honneur.
"I doubt whether London has had such a sensation since--when?"
Poiccart's grim smile caught the other's eye and he smiled in
"I asked the same question of the maitre d'hotel," he said slowly,
like a man loath to share a joke; "he compared the agitation to
the atrocious East-End murders."
Manfred stopped dead and looked with horror on his companion.
"Great heavens!" he exclaimed in distress, "it never occurred to me
that we should be compared with--him!"
They resumed their walk.
"It is part of the eternal bathos," said Poiccart serenely; "even De
Quincey taught the English nothing. The God of Justice has but one
interpreter here, and he lives in a public-house in Lancashire, and is
an expert and dexterous disciple of the lamented Marwood, whose system
he has improved upon."
They were traversing that portion of Whitehall from which Scotland
A man, slouching along with bent head and his hands thrust deep into
the pockets of his tattered coat, gave them a swift sidelong glance,
stopped when they had passed, and looked after them. Then he turned and
quickened his shuffle on their trail. A press of people and a seeming
ceaseless string of traffic at the corner of Cockspur Street brought
Manfred and Poiccart to a standstill, waiting for an opportunity to
cross the road. They were subjected to a little jostling as the knot of
waiting people thickened, but eventually they crossed and walked
towards St Martin's Lane.
The comparison which Poiccart had quoted still rankled with
"There will be people at His Majesty's tonight," he said,
"applauding Brutus as he asks, 'What villain touched his body and not
for justice?' You will not find a serious student of history, or any
commonplace man of intelligence, for the matter of that, who, if you
asked, Would it not have been God's blessing for the world if Bonaparte
had been assassinated on his return from Egypt? would not answer
without hesitation, Yes. But we--we are murderers!"
"They would not have erected a statue of Napoleon's assassin," said
Poiccart easily, "any more than they have enshrined Felton, who slew a
profligate and debauched Minister of Charles I. Posterity may do us
justice," he spoke half mockingly; "for myself I am satisfied with the
approval of my conscience."
He threw away the cigar he was smoking, and put his hand to the
inside pocket of his coat to find another. He withdrew his hand without
the cigar and whistled a passing cab.
Manfred looked at him in surprise.
"What is the matter? I thought you said you would walk?"
Nevertheless he entered the hansom and Poiccart followed, giving his
direction through the trap, "Baker Street Station."
The cab was rattling through Shaftesbury Avenue before Poiccart gave
"I have been robbed," he said, sinking his voice, "my watch has
gone, but that does not matter; the pocketbook with the notes I made
for the guidance of Thery has gone--and that matters a great deal."
"It may have been a common thief," said Manfred: "he took the
Poiccart was feeling his pockets rapidly.
"Nothing else has gone," he said; "it may have been as you say, a
pickpocket, who will be content with the watch and will drop the
notebook down the nearest drain; but it may be a police agent."
"Was there anything in it to identify you?" asked Manfred, in a
"Nothing," was the prompt reply; "but unless the police are blind
they would understand the calculations and the plans. It may not come
to their hands at all, but if it does and the thief can recognise us we
are in a fix."
The cab drew up at the down station at Baker Street, and the two men
"I shall go east," said Poiccart, "we will meet in the morning. By
that time I shall have learnt whether the book has reached Scotland
And with no other farewell than this the two men parted.
If Billy Marks had not had a drop of drink he would have been
perfectly satisfied with his night's work. Filled, however, with that
false liquid confidence that leads so many good men astray, Billy
thought it would be a sin to neglect the opportunities that the gods
had shown him. The excitement engendered by the threats of the Four
Just Men had brought all suburban London to Westminster, and on the
Surrey side of the bridge Billy found hundreds of patient suburbanites
waiting for conveyance to Streatham, Camberwell, Clapham, and
So, the night being comparatively young, Billy decided to work the
He touched a purse from a stout old lady in black, a Waterbury watch
from a gentleman in a top hat, a small hand mirror from a dainty bag,
and decided to conclude his operations with the exploration of a
superior young lady's pocket.
Billy's search was successful. A purse and a lace handkerchief
rewarded him, and he made arrangements for a modest retirement. Then it
was that a gentle voice breathed into his ear. "Hullo, Billy!"
He knew the voice, and felt momentarily unwell.
"Hullo, Mister Howard," he exclaimed with feigned joy; "'ow are
you, sir? Fancy meetin' you!"
"Where are you going, Billy?" asked the welcome Mr. Howard, taking
Billy's arm affectionately.
"'Ome," said the virtuous Billy.
"Home it is," said Mr. Howard, leading the unwilling Billy from the
crowd; "home, sweet home, it is, Billy." He called another young man,
with whom he seemed to be acquainted: "Go on that car, Porter, and see
who has lost anything. If you can find anyone bring them along"; and
the other young man obeyed.
"And now," said Mr. Howard, still holding Billy's arm
affectionately, "tell me how the world has been using you."
"Look 'ere, Mr. Howard," said Billy earnestly, "what's the game?
where are you takin' me?"
"The game is the old game," said Mr. Howard sadly--"the same old
game, Bill, and I'm taking you to the same old sweet spot."
"You've made a mistake this time, guv'nor," cried Bill fiercely, and
there was a slight clink.
"Permit me, Billy," said Mr Howard, stooping quickly and picking up
the purse Billy had dropped.
At the police station the sergeant behind the charge desk pretended
to be greatly overjoyed at Billy's arrival, and the gaoler, who put
Billy into a steel-barred dock, and passed his hands through cunning
pockets, greeted him as a friend.
"Gold watch, half a chain, gold, three purses, two handkerchiefs,
and a red moroccer pocketbook," reported the gaoler.
The sergeant nodded approvingly.
"Quite a good day's work, William," he said.
"What shall I get this time?" inquired the prisoner, and Mr Howard,
a plain-clothes officer engaged in filling in particulars of the
charge, opined nine moons.
"Go on!" exclaimed Mr Billy Marks in consternation.
"Fact," said the sergeant; "you're a rogue and a vagabond, Billy,
you're a petty larcenist, and you're for the sessions this time--Number
This latter was addressed to the gaoler, who bore Billy off to the
cells protesting vigorously against a police force that could only
tumble to poor blokes, and couldn't get a touch on sanguinary murderers
like the Four Just Men.
"What do we pay rates and taxes for?" indignantly demanded Billy
through the grating of his cell.
"Fat lot you'll ever pay, Billy," said the gaoler, putting the
double lock on the door.
In the charge office Mr Howard and the sergeant were examining the
stolen property, and three owners, discovered by PC Porter, were laying
claim to their own.
"That disposes of all the articles except the gold watch and the
pocketbook," said the sergeant after the claimants had gone, "gold
watch, Elgin half-hunter N05029020, pocketbook containing no papers, no
card, no address, and only three pages of writing. What this means I
don't know." The sergeant handed the book to Howard. The page that
puzzled the policeman contained simply a list of streets. Against each
street was scrawled a cabalistic character.
"Looks like the diary of a paperchase," said Mr Howard. "What is on
the other pages?" They turned the leaf. This was filled with
"H'm," said the disappointed sergeant, and again turned overleaf.
The contents of this page was understandable and readable although
evidently written in a hurry as though it had been taken down at
"The chap who wrote this must have had a train to catch," said the
facetious Mr Howard, pointing to the abbreviations:
Will not leave D.S., except for Hs. Will drive to Hs in M.C. (4
dummy brghms first), 8.30. At 2 600 p arve traf divtd Embank, 80 spls.
inside D.S. One each rm, three each cor, six basmt, six rf. All drs
wide opn allow each off see another, all spls will carry revr. Nobody
except F and H to approach R. In Hse strange gal filled with spl, all
press vouched for. 200 spl. in cor. If nee battalion guards at
The policeman read this over slowly.
"Now what the devil does that mean?" asked the sergeant
It was at that precise moment that Constable Howard earned his
"Let me have that book for ten minutes," he said excitedly. The
sergeant handed the book over with wondering stare.
"I think I can find an owner for this," said Howard, his hand
trembling as he took the book, and ramming his hat on his head he ran
out into the street.
He did not stop running until he reached the main road, and finding
a cab he sprang in with a hurried order to the driver.
"Whitehall, and drive like blazes," he called, and in a few minutes
he was explaining his errand to the inspector in charge of the cordon
that guarded the entrance of Downing Street.
"Constable Howard, 946 L. reserve," he introduced himself. "I've a
very important message for Superintendent Falmouth."
That officer, looking tired and beaten, listened to the policeman's
"It looks to me," went on Howard breathlessly, "as though this has
something to do with your case, sir. D.S. is Downing Street, and----"
He produced the book and Falmouth snatched at it.
He read a few words and then gave a triumphant cry.
"Our secret instructions," he cried, and catching the constable by
the arm he drew him to the entrance hall.
"Is my car outside?" he asked, and in response to a whistle a car
drew up. "Jump in, Howard," said the detective, and the car slipped
"Who is the thief?" asked the senior.
"Billy Marks, sir," replied Howard; "you may not know him, but down
at Lambeth he is a well-known character."
"Oh, yes," Falmouth hastened to correct, "I know Billy very well
indeed--we'll see what he has to say."
The car drew up at the police station and the two men jumped
The sergeant rose to his feet as he recognised the famous Falmouth,
"I want to see the prisoner Marks," said Falmouth shortly, and
Billy, roused from his sleep, came blinking into the charge office.
"Now, Billy," said the detective, "I've got a few words to say to
"Why, it's Mr Falmouth," said the astonished Billy, and something
like fear shaded his face. "I wasn't in that 'Oxton affair, s'help
"Make your mind easy, Billy; I don't want you for anything, and if
you'll answer my questions truthfully, you may get off the present
charge and get a reward into the bargain."
Billy was suspicious.
"I'm not going to give anybody away if that's what you mean," he
"Nor that either," said the detective impatiently. "I want to know
where you found this pocketbook," and he held it up.
"Found it lyin' on the pavement," he lied.
"I want the truth," thundered Falmouth.
"Well," said Billy sulkily, "I pinched it."
"I didn't stop to ask him his name," was the impudent reply.
The detective breathed deeply.
"Now, look here," he said, lowering his voice, "you've heard about
the Four Just Men?"
Billy nodded, opening his eyes in amazement at the question.
"Well," exclaimed Falmouth impressively, "the man to whom this
pocketbook belongs is one of them."
"What!" cried Billy.
"For his capture there is a reward of a thousand pounds offered. If
your description leads to his arrest that thousand is yours."
Marks stood paralysed at the thought.
"A thousand--a thousand?" he muttered in a dazed fashion, "and I
might just as easily have caught him."
"Come, come!" cried the detective sharply, "you may catch him
yet--tell us what he looked like."
Billy knitted his brows in thought.
"He looked like a gentleman," he said, trying to recall from the
chaos of his mind a picture of his victim; "he had a white weskit, a
white shirt, nice patent shoes----"
"But his face--his face!" demanded the detective.
"His face?" cried Billy indignantly, "how do I know what it looked
like? I don't look a chap in the face when I'm pinching his watch, do I?"
"You cursed dolt, you infernal fool!" stormed the detective,
catching Billy by the collar and shaking him like a rat. "Do you mean
to tell me that you had one of the Four Just Men in your hand, and did
not even take the trouble to look at him?"
Billy wrenched himself free.
"You leave me alone!" he said defiantly. "How was I to know it was
one of the Four Just Men, and how do you know it was?" he added with a
cunning twist of his face. Billy's mind was beginning to work rapidly.
He saw in this staggering statement of the detective a chance of making
capital out of the position which to within a few minutes he had
regarded as singularly unfortunate.
"I did get a bit of a glance at 'em," he said, "they----"
"Them--they?" said the detective quickly. "How many were there?"
"Never mind," said Billy sulkily. He felt the strength of his
"Billy," said the detective earnestly, "I mean business; if you know
anything you've got to tell us!'
"Ho!" cried the prisoner in defiance. "Got to, 'ave I? Well, I know
the lor as well as you--you can't make a chap speak if he don't want.
The detective signalled the other police officers to retire, and
when they were out of earshot he dropped his voice and said:
"Harry Moss came out last week."
Billy flushed and lowered his eyes.
"I don't know no Harry Moss," he muttered doggedly.
"Harry Moss came out last week," continued the detective shortly,
"after doing three years for robbery with violence--three years and ten
"I don't know anything about it," said Marks in the same tone.
"He got clean away and the police had no clues," the detective went
on remorselessly, "and they might not have caught him to this day,
only--only 'from information received' they took him one night out of
his bed in Leman Street."
Billy licked his dry lips, but did not speak.
"Harry Moss would like to know who he owes his three stretch to--and
the ten. Men who've had the cat have a long memory, Billy."
"That's not playing the game, Mr. Falmouth," cried Billy thickly.
"I--I was a bit hard up, an' Harry Moss wasn't a pal of mine--and the
p'lice wanted to find out----"
"And the police want to find out now," said Falmouth.
Billy Marks made no reply for a moment.
"I'll tell you all there is to be told," he said at last, and
cleared his throat. The detective stopped him.
"Not here," he said. Then turning to the officer in charge:
"Sergeant, you may release this man on bail--I will stand sponsor."
The humorous side of this appealed to Billy at least, for he grinned
sheepishly and recovered his former spirits.
"First time I've been bailed out by the p'lice," he remarked
The motor-car bore the detective and his charge to Scotland Yard,
and in Superintendent Falmouth's office Billy prepared to unburden
"Before you begin," said the officer, "I want to warn you that you
must be as brief as possible. Every minute is precious."
So Billy told his story. In spite of the warning there were
embellishments, to which the detective was forced to listen
At last the pickpocket reached the point.
"There was two of 'em, one a tall chap and one not so tall. I heard
one say 'My dear George'--the little one said that, the one I took the
ticker from and the pocketbook. Was there anything in the notebook?"
Billy asked suddenly.
"Go on," said the detective.
"Well," resumed Billy, "I follered 'em up to the end of the street,
and they was waitin' to cross towards Charing Cross Road when I lifted
the clock, you understand?"
"What time was this?"
"'Arf past ten--or it might've been eleven."
"And you did not see their faces?"
The thief shook his head emphatically.
"If I never get up from where I'm sittin' I didn't, Mr Falmouth," he
The detective rose with a sigh.
"I'm afraid you're not much use to me, Billy," he said ruefully.
"Did you notice whether they wore beards, or were they clean-shaven,
Billy shook his head mournfully.
"I could easily tell you a lie, Mr Falmouth," he said frankly, "and
I could easily pitch a tale that would take you in, but I'm playin' it
square with you."
The detective recognised the sincerity of the man and nodded.
"You've done your best, Billy," he said, and then: "I'll tell you what
I'm going to do. You are the only man in the world who has ever seen one
of the Four Just Men--and lived to tell the story. Now, although you
cannot remember his face, perhaps if you met him again in the street you
would know him--there may be some little trick of walking, some habit of
holding the hands that you cannot recall now, but if you saw again you
would recognise. I shall therefore take upon myself the responsibility
of releasing you from custody until the day after tomorrow. I want you
to find this man you robbed. Here is a sovereign; go home, get a little
sleep, turn out as early as you can and go west." The detective went to
his desk, and wrote a dozen words on a card. "Take this: if you see the
man or his companion, follow them, show this card to the first policeman
you meet, point out the man, and you'll go to bed a thousand pounds
richer than when you woke."
Billy took the card.
"If you want me at any time you will find somebody here who will
know where I am. Goodnight," and Billy passed into the street, his
brain in a whirl, and a warrant written on a visiting card in his
The morning that was to witness great events broke bright and clear
over London. Manfred, who, contrary to his usual custom, had spent the
night at the workshop in Carnaby Street, watched the dawn from the flat
roof of the building.
He lay face downwards, a rug spread beneath him, his head resting on
his hands. Dawn with its white, pitiless light, showed his strong face,
seamed and haggard. The white streaks in his trim beard were
accentuated in the light of morning. He looked tired and disheartened,
so unlike his usual self that Gonsalez, who crept up through the trap
just before the sun rose, was as near alarmed as it was possible for
that phlegmatic man to be. He touched him on the arm and Manfred
"What is the matter?" asked Leon softly.
Manfred's smile and shake of head did not reassure the
"Is it Poiccart and the thief?"
"Yes," nodded Manfred. Then speaking aloud, he asked: "Have you ever
felt over any of our cases as you feel in this?"
They spoke in such low tones as almost to approach whispering.
Gonsalez stared ahead thoughtfully.
"Yes," he admitted, "once--the woman at Warsaw. You remember how
easy it all seemed, and how circumstance after circumstance thwarted
us...till I began to feel, as I feel now, that we should fail."
"No, no, no!" said Manfred fiercely. "There must be no talk of
failure, Leon, no thought of it."
He crawled to the trapdoor and lowered himself into the corridor,
and Gonsalez followed.
"Thery?" he asked.
They were entering the studio, and Manfred had his hand on the door
handle when a footstep sounded on the bottom floor.
"Who's there?" cried Manfred, and a soft whistle from below sent him
"Poiccart!" he cried.
Poiccart it was, unshaven, dusty, weary.
"Well?" Manfred's ejaculation was almost brutal in its
"Let us go upstairs," said Poiccart shortly. The three men ascended
the dusty stairway, not a word being spoken until they had reached the
Then Poiccart spoke:
"The very stars in their courses are fighting against us," he said,
throwing himself into the only comfortable chair in the room, and
flinging his hat into a corner. "The man who stole my pocketbook has
been arrested by the police. He is a well-known criminal of a
sneak-thief order, and unfortunately he had been under observation
during the evening. The pocketbook was found in his possession, and all
might have been well, but an unusually smart police officer associated
the contents with us.
"After I had left you I went home and changed, then made my way to
Downing Street. I was one of the curious crowd that stood watching the
guarded entrance. I knew that Falmouth was there, and I knew, too, if
there was any discovery made it would be communicated immediately to
Downing Street. Somehow I felt sure the man was an ordinary thief, and
that if we had anything to fear it was from a chance arrest. Whilst I
was waiting a cab dashed up, and out an excited man jumped. He was
obviously a policeman, and I had just time to engage a hansom when
Falmouth and the new arrival came flying out. I followed them in the
cab as fast as possible without exciting the suspicion of the driver.
Of course, they outdistanced us, but their destination was evident. I
dismissed the cab at the corner of the street in which the police
station is situated, and walked down and found, as I had expected, the
car drawn up at the door.
"I managed to get a fleeting glance at the charge room--I was afraid
that any interrogation there might be would have been conducted in the
cell, but by the greatest of good luck they had chosen the charge room.
I saw Falmouth, and the policeman, and the prisoner. The latter, a
mean-faced, long-jawed man with shifty eyes--no, no, Leon, don't
question me about the physiognomy of the man--my view was for
photographic purposes--I wanted to remember him.
"In that second I could see the detective's anger, the thief's
defiance, and I knew that the man was saying that he could not
"Ha!" It was Manfred's sigh of relief that put a period to
"But I wanted to make sure," resumed the latter. "I walked back the
way I had come. Suddenly I heard the hum of the car behind me, and it
passed me with another passenger. I guessed that they were taking the
man back to Scotland Yard.
"I was content to walk back; I was curious to know what the police
intended doing with their new recruit. Taking up a station that gave me
a view of the entrance of the street, I waited. After a while the man
came out alone. His step was light and buoyant. A glimpse I got of his
face showed me a strange blending of bewilderment and gratification. He
turned on to the Embankment, and I followed close behind."
"There was a danger that he was being shadowed by the police, too,"
"Of that I was well satisfied," Poiccart rejoined. "I took a very
careful survey before I acted. Apparently the police were content to
let him roam free. When he was abreast of the Temple steps he stopped
and looked undecidedly left and right, as though he were not quite
certain as to what he should do next. At that moment I came abreast of
him, passed him, and then turned back, fumbling in my pockets.
"'Can you oblige me with a match?'" I asked.
"He was most affable; produced a box of matches and invited me to
"I took a match, struck it, and lit my cigar, holding the match so
that he could see my face."
"That was wise," said Manfred gravely.
"It showed his face too, and out of the corner of my eye I watched
him searching every feature. But there was no sign of recognition and I
began a conversation. We lingered where we had met for a while and then
by mutual consent we walked in the direction of Blackfriars, crossed
the bridge, chatting on inconsequent subjects, the poor, the weather,
the newspapers. On the other side of the bridge is a coffee-stall. I
determined to make my next move. I invited him to take a cup of coffee,
and when the cups were placed before us, I put down a sovereign. The
stall-keeper shook his head, said he could not change it. 'Hasn't your
friend any small change?' he asked.
"It was here that the vanity of the little thief told me what I
wanted to know. He drew from his pocket, with a nonchalant air--a
sovereign. 'This is all that I have got,' he drawled. I found some
coppers--I had to think quickly. He had told the police something,
something worth paying for--what was it? It could not have been a
description of ourselves, for if he had recognised us then, he would
have known me when I struck the match and when I stood there, as I did,
in the full glare of the light of the coffee-stall. And then a cold
fear came to me. Perhaps he had recognised me, and with a thief's
cunning was holding me in conversation until he could get assistance to
Poiccart paused for a moment, and drew a small phial from his
pocket; this he placed carefully on the table.
"He was as near to death then as ever he has been in his life," he
said quietly, "but somehow the suspicion wore away. In our walk we had
passed three policemen--there was an opportunity if he had wanted
"He drank his coffee and said, 'I must be going home.'
"'Indeed!' I said. 'I suppose I really ought to go home too--I have
a lot of work to do tomorrow.' He leered at me. 'So have I,' he said
with a grin, 'but whether I can do it or not I don't know.'
"We had left the coffee-stall, and now stopped beneath a lamp that
stood at the corner of the street.
"I knew that I had only a few seconds to secure the information I
wanted--so I played bold and led directly to the subject. 'What of
these Four Just Men?' I asked, just as he was about to slouch away. He
turned back instantly. 'What about them?' he asked quickly. I led him
on from that by gentle stages to the identity of the Four. He was eager
to talk about them, anxious to know what I thought, but most concerned
of all about the reward. He was engrossed in the subject, and then
suddenly he leant forward, and, tapping me on the chest, with a grimy
forefinger, he commenced to state a hypothetical case."
Poiccart stopped to laugh--his laugh ended in a sleepy yawn.
"You know the sort of questions," said he, "and you know how very
naive the illiterate are when they are seeking to disguise their
identities by elaborate hypotheses. Well, that is the story. He--Marks
is his name--thinks he may be able to recognise one of us by some
extraordinary trick of memory. To enable him to do this, he has been
granted freedom--tomorrow he would search London, he said."
"A full day's work," laughed Manfred.
"Indeed," agreed Poiccart soberly, "but hear the sequel. We parted,
and I walked westward perfectly satisfied of our security. I made for
Covent Garden Market, because this is one of the places in London where
a man may be seen at four o'clock in the morning without exciting
"I had strolled through the market, idly watching the busy scene,
when, for some cause that I cannot explain, I turned suddenly on my
heel and came face to face with Marks! He grinned sheepishly, and
recognised me with a nod of his head.
"He did not wait for me to ask him his business, but started in to
explain his presence.
"I accepted his explanation easily, and for the second time that
night invited him to coffee. He hesitated at first, then accepted. When
the coffee was brought, he pulled it to him as far from my reach as
possible, and then I knew that Mr Marks had placed me at fault, that I
had underrated his intelligence, that all the time he had been
unburdening himself he had recognised me. He had put me off my
"But why----?" began Manfred.
"That is what I thought," the other answered. "Why did he not have
me arrested?" He turned to Leon, who had been a silent listener. "Tell
us, Leon, why?"
"The explanation is simple," said Gonsalez quietly: "why did not
Thery betray us?--cupidity, the second most potent force of
civilisation. He has some doubt of the reward. He may fear the honesty
of the police--most criminals do so; he may want witnesses." Leon
walked to the wall, where his coat hung. He buttoned it thoughtfully,
ran his hand over his smooth chin, then pocketed the little phial that
stood on the table.
"You have slipped him, I suppose?" he asked.
"At 700 Red Cross Street, in the Borough--it is a common
Leon took a pencil from the table and rapidly sketched a head upon
the edge of a newspaper.
"Like this?" he asked.
Poiccart examined the portrait.
"Yes," he said in surprise; "have you seen him?"
"No," said Leon carelessly, "but such a man would have such a
He paused on the threshold.
"I think it is necessary." There was a question in his assertion. It
was addressed rather to Manfred, who stood with his folded arms and
knit brow staring at the floor.
For answer Manfred extended his clenched fist. Leon saw the
down-turned thumb, and left the room.
Billy Marks was in a quandary. By the most innocent device in the
world his prey had managed to slip through his fingers. When Poiccart,
stopping at the polished doors of the best hotel in London, whither
they had strolled, casually remarked that he would not be a moment and
disappeared into the hotel, Billy was nonplussed. This was a
contingency for which he was not prepared. He had followed the suspect
from Blackfriars; he was almost sure that this was the man he had
robbed. He might, had he wished, have called upon the first constable
he met to take the man into custody; but the suspicion of the thief,
the fear that he might be asked to share the reward with the man who
assisted him restrained him. And besides, it might not be the man at
all, argued Billy, and yet----
Poiccart was a chemist, a man who found joy in unhealthy
precipitates, who mixed evil-smelling drugs and distilled, filtered,
carbonated, oxydized, and did all manner of things in glass tubes, to
the vegetable, animal, and mineral products of the earth.
Billy had left Scotland Yard to look for a man with a discoloured
hand. Here again, he might, had he been less fearful of treachery, have
placed in the hands of the police a very valuable mark of
It seems a very lame excuse to urge on Billy's behalf that this
cupidity alone stayed his hand when he came face to face with the man
he was searching for. And yet it was so. Then again there was a sum in
simple proportion to be worked out. If one Just Man was worth a
thousand pounds, what was the commercial value of four? Billy was a
thief with a business head. There were no waste products in his day's
labour. He was not a conservative scoundrel who stuck to one branch of
his profession. He would pinch a watch, or snatch a till, or pass snide
florins with equal readiness. He was a butterfly of crime, flitting
from one illicit flower to another, and nor above figuring as the X of
So that when Poiccart disappeared within the magnificent portals of
the Royal Hotel in Northumberland Avenue, Billy was hipped. He realised
in a flash that his captive had gone whither he could not follow
without exposing his hand; that the chances were he had gone for ever.
He looked up and down the street; there was no policeman in sight. In
the vestibule, a porter in shirt sleeves was polishing brasses. It was
still very early; the streets were deserted, and Billy, after a few
moment's hesitation, took a course that he would not have dared at a
more conventional hour.
He pushed open the swing doors and passed into the vestibule. The
porter turned on him as he entered and favoured him with a suspicious
"What do you want?" asked he, eyeing the tattered coat of the
visitor in some disfavour.
"Look 'ere, old feller," began Billy, in his most conciliatory
Just then the porter's strong right arm caught him by the coat
collar, and Billy found himself stumbling into the street.
"Outside--you," said the porter firmly.
It needed this rebuff to engender in Marks the necessary
self-assurance to carry him through.
Straightening his ruffled clothing, he pulled Falmouth's card from
his pocket and returned to the charge with dignity.
"I am a p'lice officer," he said, adopting the opening that he knew
so well, "and if you interfere with me, look out, young feller!"
The porter took the card and scrutinised it.
"What do you want?" he asked in more civil tones. He would have
added 'sir', but somehow it stuck in his throat. If the man is a
detective, he argued to himself, he is very well disguised.
"I want that gentleman that came in before me," said Billy.
The porter scratched his head.
"What is the number of his room?" he asked.
"Never mind about the number of his room," said Billy rapidly. "Is
there any back way to this hotel--any way a man can get out of it? I
mean, besides through the front entrance?"
"Half a dozen," replied the porter.
"Take me round to one of them, will you?" he asked. And the porter
led the way.
One of the tradesmen's entrances was from a small back street; and
here it was that a street scavenger gave the information that Marks had
feared. Five minutes before a man answering to the description had
walked out, turned towards the Strand and, picking up a cab in the
sight of the street cleaner, had driven off.
Baffled, and with the added bitterness that had he played boldly he
might have secured at any rate a share of a thousand pounds,
Billy walked slowly to the Embankment, cursing the folly that had
induced him to throw away the fortune that was in his hands. With hands
thrust deep into his pockets, he tramped the weary length of the
Embankment, going over again and again the incidents of the night and
each time muttering a lurid condemnation of his error. It must have
been an hour after he had lost Poiccart that it occurred to him all was
not lost. He had the man's description, he had looked at his face, he
knew him feature by feature. That was something, at any rate. Nay, it
occurred to him that if the man was arrested through his description he
would still be entitled to the reward--or a part of it. He dared not
see Falmouth and tell him that he had been in company with the man all
night without effecting his arrest. Falmouth would never believe him,
and, indeed, it was curious that he should have met him.
This fact struck Billy for the first time. By what strange chance
had he met this man? Was it possible--the idea frightened Marks--that
the man he had robbed had recognised him, and that he had deliberately
sought him out with murderous intent?
A cold perspiration broke upon the narrow forehead of the thief.
These men were murderers, cruel, relentless murderers: suppose----?
He turned from the contemplation of the unpleasant possibilities to
meet a man who was crossing the road towards him. He eyed the stranger
doubtingly. The newcomer was a young-looking man, clean-shaven, with
sharp features and restless blue eyes. As he came closer, Marks noted
that first appearance had been deceptive; the man was not so young as
he looked. He might have been forty, thought Marks. He approached,
looked hard at Billy, then beckoned him to stop, for Billy was walking
"Is your name Marks?" asked the stranger authoritatively.
"Yes, sir," replied the thief.
"Have you seen Mr Falmouth?"
"Not since last night," replied Marks in surprise.
"Then you are to come at once to him."
"Where is he?"
"At Kensington Police Station--there has been an arrest, and he
wants you to identify the man."
Billy's heart sank.
"Do I get any of the reward?" he demanded, "that is if I recognise
The other nodded and Billy's hopes rose.
"You must follow me," said the newcomer, "Mr Falmouth does not wish
us to be seen together. Take a first-class ticket to Kensington and get
into the next carriage to mine--come."
He turned and crossed the road toward Charing Cross, and Billy
followed at a distance.
He found the stranger pacing the platform and gave no sign of
recognition. A train pulled into the station and Marks followed his
conductor through a crowd of workmen the train had discharged. He
entered an empty first-class carriage, and Marks, obeying instructions,
took pos session of the adjoining compartment, and found himself the
Between Charing Cross and Westminster Marks had time to review his
position. Between the last station and St James's Park, he invented his
excuses to the detective; between the Park and Victoria he had
completed his justification for a share of the reward. Then as the
train moved into the tunnel for its five minutes' run to Sloane Square,
Billy noticed a draught, and turned his head to see the stranger
standing on the footboard of the swaying carriage, holding the
Marks was startled.
"Pull up the window on your side," ordered the man, and Billy,
hypnotised by the authoritative voice, obeyed. At that moment he heard
the tinkle of broken glass.
He turned with an angry snarl.
"What's the game?" he demanded.
For answer the stranger swung himself clear of the door and, closing
it softly, disappeared.
"What's his game?" repeated Marks drowsily. Looking down he saw a
broken phial at his feet, by the phial lay a shining sovereign. He
stared stupidly at it for a moment, then, just before the train ran
into Victoria Station, he stooped to pick it up...
A passenger leisurely selecting his compartment during the wait at
Kensington opened a carriage door and staggered back coughing. A
solicitous porter and an alarmed station official ran forward and
pulled open the door, and the sickly odour of almonds pervaded the
A little knot of passengers gathered and peered over one another's
shoulders, whilst the station inspector investigated. By and by came a
doctor, and a stretcher, and a policeman from the street without.
Together they lifted the huddled form of a dead man from the
carriage and laid it on the platform.
"Did you find anything?" asked the policeman.
"A sovereign and a broken bottle," was the reply.
The policeman fumbled in the dead man's pockets.
"I don't suppose he'll have any papers to show who he is," he said
with knowledge. "Here's a first-class ticket--it must be a case of
suicide. Here's a card----"
He turned it over and read it, and his face underwent a change.
He gave a few hurried instructions, then made his way to the nearest
Superintendent Falmouth, who had snatched a few hours' sleep at the
Downing Street house, rose with a troubled mind and an uneasy feeling
that in spite of all his precautions the day would end disastrously. He
was hardly dressed before the arrival of the Assistant Commissioner was
"I have your report, Falmouth," was the official's greeting; "you
did perfectly right to release Marks--have you had news of him this
"H'm," said the Commissioner thoughtfully. "I wonder whether----" He
did not finish his sentence. "Has it occurred to you that the Four may
have realised their danger?"
The detective's face showed surprise.
"Why, of course, sir."
"Have you considered what their probable line of action will
"N--no--unless it takes the form of an attempt to get out of the
"Has it struck you that whilst this man Marks is looking for them,
they are probably seeking him?"
"Bill is smart," said the detective uneasily.
"So are they," said the Commissioner with an emphatic nod. "My
advice is, get in touch with Marks and put two of your best men to
"That shall be done at once," replied Falmouth; "I am afraid that it
is a precaution that should have been taken before."
"I am going to see Sir Philip," the Commissioner went on, and he
added with a dubious smile, "I shall be obliged to frighten him a
"What is the idea?"
"We wish him to drop this Bill. Have you seen the morning
"They are unanimous that the Bill should be abandoned--they say
because it is not sufficiently important to warrant the risk, that the
country itself is divided on its merit; but as a matter of fact
they are afraid of the consequence; and upon my soul I'm a little
He mounted the stairs, and was challenged at the landing by one of
This was a system introduced after the episode of the disguised
'detective'. The Foreign Minister was now in a state of siege. Nobody
had to be trusted, a password had been initiated, and every precaution
taken to ensure against a repetition of the previous mistake.
His hand was raised to knock upon the panel of the study, when he
felt his arm gripped. He turned to see Falmouth with white face and
"They've finished Billy," said the detective breathlessly. "He has
just been found in a railway carriage at Kensington."
The Commissioner whistled.
"How was it done?" he asked.
Falmouth was the picture of haggard despair.
"Prussic acid gas," he said bitterly; "they are scientific. Look
you, sir, persuade this man to drop his damned Bill."
He pointed to the door of Sir Philip's room. "We shall never save
him. I have got the feeling in my bones that he is a doomed man."
"Nonsense!" the Commissioner answered sharply.
"You are growing nervous--you haven't had enough sleep, Falmouth.
That isn't spoken like your real self--we must save him."
He turned from the study and beckoned one of die officers who
guarded the landing.
"Sergeant, tell Inspector Collins to send an emergency call
throughout the area for reserves to gather immediately. I will put such
a cordon round Ramon today," he went on addressing Falmouth, "that no
man shall reach him without the fear of being crushed to death."
And within an hour there was witnessed in London a scene that has no
parallel in the history of the Metropolis. From every district there
came a small army of policemen. They arrived by train, by tramway car,
by motorbus, by every vehicle and method of traction that could be
requisitioned or seized. They streamed from the stations, they poured
through the thoroughfares, till London stood aghast at the realisation
of the strength of her civic defences.
Whitehall was soon packed from end to end; St James's Park was black
with them. Automatically Whitehall, Charles Street, Birdcage Walk, and
the eastern end of the Mall were barred to all traffic by solid
phalanxes of mounted constables. St George's Street was in the hands of
the force, the roof of every house was occupied by a uniformed man. Not
a house or room that overlooked in the slightest degree the Foreign
Secretary's residence but was subjected to a rigorous search. It was as
though martial law had been proclaimed, and indeed two regiments of
Guards were under arms the whole of the day ready for any emergency. In
Sir Philip's room the Commissioner, backed by Falmouth, made his last
appeal to the stubborn man whose life was threatened.
"I tell you, sir," said the Commissioner earnestly, "we can do no
more than we have done, and I am still afraid. These men affect me as
would something supernatural. I have a horrible dread that for all our
precautions we have left something out of our reckoning; that we are
leaving unguarded some avenue which by their devilish ingenuity they
may utilise. The death of this man Marks has unnerved me--the Four are
ubiquitous as well as omnipotent. I beg of you, sir, for God's sake,
think well before you finally reject their terms. Is the passage of
this Bill so absolutely necessary?"--he paused--"is it worth your
life?" he asked with blunt directness; and the crudity of the question
made Sir Philip wince.
He waited some time before he replied, and when he spoke his voice
was low and firm.
"I shall not withdraw," he said slowly, with a dull, dogged evenness
of tone. "I shall not withdraw in any circumstance.
"I have gone too far," he went on, raising his hand to check
Falmouth's appeal. "I have got beyond fear, I have even got beyond
resentment; it is now to me a question of justice. Am I right in
introducing a law that will remove from this country colonies of
dangerously intelligent criminals, who, whilst enjoying immunity from
arrest, urge ignorant men forward to commit acts of violence and
treason? If I am right, the Four Just Men are wrong. Or are they right:
is this measure an unjust thing, an act of tyranny, a piece of
barbarism dropped into the very centre of twentieth-century thought, an
anachronism? If these men are right, then I am wrong. So it has come to
this, that I have to satisfy my mind as to the standard of right and
wrong that I must accept--and I accept my own."
He met the wondering gaze of the officers with a calm, unflinching
"You were wise to take the precautions you have," he resumed
quietly. "I have been foolish to chafe under your protective care."
"We must take even further precautions," the Commissioner
interrupted; "between six and half past eight o'clock tonight we wish
you to remain in your study, and under no circumstance to open the door
to a single person--even to myself or Mr Falmouth. During that time you
must keep your door locked." He hesitated. "If you would rather have
one of us with you----"
"No, no," was the Minister's quick reply; "after the impersonation
of yesterday I would rather be alone."
The Commissioner nodded. "This room is anarchist-proof," he said,
waving his hand round the apartment. "During the night we have made a
thorough inspection, examined the floors, the wall, the ceiling, and
fixed steel shields to the shutters."
He looked round the chamber with the scrutiny of a man to whom every
visible object was familiar.
Then he noticed something new had been introduced. On the table
stood a blue china bowl full of roses.
"This is new," he said, bending his head to catch the fragrance of
the beautiful flowers.
"Yes," was Ramon's careless reply, "they were sent from my house in
Hereford this morning."
The Commissioner plucked a leaf from one of the blooms and rolled it
between his fingers. "They look so real," he said paradoxically, "that
they might even be artificial."
As he spoke he was conscious that he associated the roses in some
He passed slowly down the noble marble stairway--a policeman
stood on every other step--and gave his views to Falmouth.
"You cannot blame the old man for his decision; in fact, I admire
him today more than I have ever done before. But"--there was a sudden
solemnity in his voice--"I am afraid--I am afraid."
Falmouth said nothing.
"The notebook tells nothing," the Commissioner continued, "save the
route that Sir Philip might have taken had he been anxious to arrive at
44 Downing Street by back streets. The futility of the plan is almost
alarming, for there is so much evidence of a strong subtle mind behind
the seeming innocence of this list of streets that I am confident that
we have not got hold of the true inwardness of its meaning."
He passed into the streets and threaded his way between crowds of
policemen. The extraordinary character of the precautions taken by the
police had the natural result of keeping the general public ignorant of
all that was happening in Downing Street. Reporters were prohibited
within the magic circle, and newspapers, and particularly the evening
newspapers, had to depend upon such information as was grudgingly
offered by Scotland Yard. This was scanty, while their clues and
theories, which were many, were various and wonderful.
The Megaphone, the newspaper that regarded itself as being
the most directly interested in the doings of the Four Just Men,
strained every nerve to obtain news of the latest developments. With
the coming of the fatal day, excitement had reached an extraordinary
pitch; every fresh edition of the evening newspapers was absorbed as
soon as it reached the streets. There was little material to satisfy
the appetite of a sensation-loving public, but such as there was, was
given. Pictures of 44 Downing Street, portraits of the Minister, plans
of the vicinity of the Foreign Office, with diagrams illustrating
existing police precautions, stood out from columns of letterpress
dealing, not for the first but for the dozenth time, with the careers
of the Four as revealed by their crimes.
And with curiosity at its height, and all London, all England, the
whole of the civilised world, talking of one thing and one thing only
there came like a bombshell the news of Marks' death.
Variously described as one of the detectives engaged in the case, as
a foreign police officer, as Falmouth himself, the death of Marks grew
from 'Suicide in a Railway Carriage' to its real importance. Within an
hour the story of tragedy, inaccurate in detail, true in substance,
filled the columns of the Press. Mystery on mystery! Who was this
ill-dressed man, what part was he playing in the great game, how came
he by his death? asked the world instantly; and little by little,
pieced together by ubiquitous newsmen, the story was made known. On top
of this news came the great police march on Whitehall. Here was
evidence of the serious view the authorities were taking.
'From my vantage place,' wrote Smith in the Megaphone, 'I
could see the length of Whitehall. It was the most wonderful spectacle
that London has ever witnessed. I saw nothing but a great sea of black
helmets reaching from one end of the broad thoroughfare to the other.
Police! the whole vicinity was black with police; they thronged side
streets, they crowded into the Park, they formed not a cordon, but a
mass through which it was impossible to penetrate.'
For the Commissioners of Police were leaving nothing to chance. If
they were satisfied that cunning could be matched by cunning, craft by
craft, stealth by counter-stealth, they would have been content to
defend their charge on conventional lines. But they were outmanoeuvred.
The stake was too high to depend upon strategy--this was a case that
demanded brute force. It is difficult, writing so long after the event,
to realise how the terror of the Four had so firmly fastened upon the
finest police organisation in the world, to appreciate the panic that
had come upon a body renowned for its clearheadedness.
The crowd that blocked the approaches to Whitehall soon began to
grow as the news of Billy's death circulated, and soon after two
o'clock that afternoon, by order of the Commissioner, Westminster
Bridge was closed to all traffic, vehicular or passenger. The section
of the Embankment that runs between Westminster and Hunger-ford Bridge
was next swept by the police and cleared of curious pedestrians;
Northumberland Avenue was barred, and before three o'clock there was no
space within five hundred yards of the official residence of Sir Philip
Ramon that was not held by a representative of the law. Members of
Parliament on their way to the House were escorted by mounted men, and,
taking on a reflected glory, were cheered by the crowd. All that
afternoon a hundred thousand people waited patiently, seeing nothing,
save, towering above the heads of a host of constabulary, the spires
and towers of the Mother of Parliaments, or the blank faces of the
buildings--in Trafalgar Square, along the Mall as far as the police
would allow them, at the lower end of Victoria Street, eight deep along
the Albert Embankment, growing in volume every hour. London waited,
waited in patience, orderly, content to stare steadfastly at nothing,
deriving no satisfaction for their weariness but the sense of being as
near as it was humanly possible to be to the scene of a tragedy. A
stranger arriving in London, bewildered by this gathering, asked for
the cause. A man standing on the outskirts of the Embankment throng
pointed across the river with the stem of his pipe.
"We're waiting for a man to be murdered," he said simply, as one who
describes a familiar function.
About the edge of these throngs newspaper boys drove a steady trade.
From hand to hand the pink sheets were passed over the heads of the
crowd. Every half hour brought a new edition, a new theory, a new
description of the scene in which they themselves were playing an
ineffectual if picturesque part. The clearing of the Thames Embankment
produced an edition; the closing of Westminster Bridge brought another;
the arrest of a foolish Socialist who sought to harangue the crowd in
Trafalgar Square was worthy of another. Every incident of the day was
faithfully recorded and industriously devoured.
All that afternoon they waited, telling and retelling the story of
the Four, theorising, speculating, judging. And they spoke of the
culmination as one speaks of a promised spectacle, watching the
slow-moving hands of Big Ben ticking off the laggard minutes. "Only two
more hours to wait," they said at six o'clock, and that sentence, or
rather the tone of pleasurable anticipation in which it was said,
indicated the spirit of the mob. For a mob is a cruel thing, heartless
Seven o'clock boomed forth, and the angry hum of talk ceased. London
watched in silence, and with a quicker beating heart, the last hour
crawl round the great clock's dial.
There had been a slight alteration in the arrangements at Downing
Street, and it was after seven o'clock before Sir Philip, opening the
door of his study, in which he had sat alone, beckoned the Commissioner
and Falmouth to approach. They walked towards him, stopping a few feet
from where he stood.
The Minister was pale, and there were lines on his face that had not
been there before. But the hand that held the printed paper was steady
and his face was sphinxlike.
"I am about to lock my door," he said calmly. "I presume that the
arrangements we have agreed upon will be carried out?"
"Yes, sir," answered the Commissioner quietly.
Sir Philip was about to speak, but he checked himself.
After a moment he spoke again.
"I have been a just man according to my lights," he said half to
himself. "Whatever happens I am satisfied that I am doing the right
thing--What is that?"
Through the corridor there came a faint roar.
"The people--they are cheering you," said Falmouth, who just before
had made a tour of inspection.
The Minister's lip curled in disdain and the familiar acid crept
into his voice.
"They will be terribly disappointed if nothing happens," he said
bitterly. "The people! God save me from the people, their sympathy,
their applause, their insufferable pity."
He turned and pushed open the door of his study, slowly closed the
heavy portal, and the two men heard the snick of the lock as he turned
Falmouth looked at his watch.
"Forty minutes," was his laconic comment.
In the dark stood the Four Men.
"It is nearly time," said the voice of Manfred, and Thery shuffled
forward and groped on the floor for something.
"Let me strike a match," he grumbled in Spanish.
It was Poiccart's sharp voice that arrested him; it was Gonsalez who
stooped quickly and passed sensitive fingers over the floor.
He found one wire and placed it in Thery's hand, then he reached up
and found the other, and Thery deftly tied them together.
"Is it not time?" asked Thery, short of breath from his
Manfred was examining the illuminated dial of his watch. In silence
"It is time," said Manfred solemnly, and Thery stretched out his
Stretched out his hand--and groaned and collapsed.
The three heard the groan, felt rather than saw the swaying figure
of the man, and heard the thud of him as he struck the floor.
"What has happened?" whispered a tremorless voice; it was
Manfred was at Thery's side fumbling at his shirt.
"Thery has bungled and paid the consequence," he said in a hushed
"We shall see, we shall see," said Manfred, still with his fingers
over the heart of the fallen man.
That forty minutes was the longest that Falmouth ever remembered
spending. He had tried to pass it pleasantly by recounting some of the
famous criminal cases in which he had played a leading role. But he
found his tongue wandering after his mind. He grew incoherent, almost
hysterical. The word had been passed round that there was to be no
talking in tones above a whisper, and absolute silence reigned, save an
occasional sibilant murmur as a necessary question was asked or
Policemen were established in every room, on the roof, in the
basement, in every corridor, and each man was armed. Falmouth looked
round. He sat in the secretary's office, having arranged for Hamilton
to be at the House. Every door stood wide open, wedged back, so that no
group of policemen should be out of sight of another.
"I cannot think what can happen," he whispered for the twentieth
time to his superior. "It is impossible for those fellows to keep their
"The question, to my mind, is whether they will keep their other
promise," was the Commissioner's reply, "whether having found that they
have failed they will give up their attempt. One thing is certain," he
proceeded, "if Ramon comes out of this alive, his rotten Bill will pass
He looked at his watch. To be exact, he had held his watch in his
hand since Sir Philip had entered his room.
"It wants five minutes." He sighed anxiously.
He walked softly to the door of Sir Philip's room and listened.
"I can hear nothing," he said.
The next five minutes passed more slowly than any of the
"It is just on the hour," said Falmouth in a strained voice. "We
The distant chime of Big Ben boomed once.
"The hour!" he whispered, and both men listened.
"Two," muttered Falmouth, counting the strokes.
"Five--what's that?" he muttered quickly.
"I heard nothing--yes, I heard something." He sprang to the door and
bent his head to the level of the keyhole. "What is that? What----"
Then from the room came a quick, sharp cry of pain, a crash--and
"Quick--this way, men!" shouted Falmouth, and threw his weight
against the door.
It did not yield a fraction of an inch.
Three burly constables flung themselves against the panels, and the
door smashed open.
Falmouth and the Commissioner ran into the room.
"My God!" cried Falmouth in horror.
Sprawled across the table at which he had been sitting was the
figure of the Foreign Secretary.
The paraphernalia that littered his table had been thrown to the
floor as in a struggle.
The Commissioner stepped to the fallen man and raised him. One look
at the face was sufficient.
"Dead!" he whispered hoarsely. He looked around--save for the police
and the dead man the room was empty.
THE court was again crowded today in anticipation of the evidence of
the Assistant Commissioner of Police and Sir Francis Katling, the
famous surgeon. Before the proceedings recommenced the Coroner remarked
that he had received a great number of letters from all kinds of people
containing theories, some of them peculiarly fantastic, as to the cause
of Sir Philip Ramon's death.
"The police inform me that they are eager to receive suggestions,"
said the Coroner, "and will welcome any view however bizarre."
The Assistant Commissioner of Police was the first witness called,
and gave in detail the story of the events that had led up to the
finding of the late Secretary's dead body. He then went on to describe
the appearance of the room. Heavy bookcases filled two sides of the
room, the third or south-west was pierced with three windows, the
fourth was occupied by a case containing maps arranged on the roller
Were the windows fastened?--Yes.
And adequately protected?--Yes; by wooden folding shutters sheathed
Was there any indication that these had been tampered with?--None
Did you institute a search of the room?--Yes; a minute search.
By the Foreman of the Jury: Immediately?--Yes: after the body was
removed every article of furniture was taken out of the room, the
carpets were taken up, and the walls and ceilings stripped.
And nothing was found?--Nothing.
Is there a fireplace in the room?--Yes.
Was there any possibility of any person effecting an entrance by
that method?--Absolutely none.
You have seen the newspapers?--Yes; some of them.
You have seen the suggestion put forward that the deceased was slain
by the introduction of a deadly gas?--Yes.
Was that possible?--I hardly think so.
By the Foreman: Did you find any means by which such a gas could be
introduced?--(The witness hesitated.) None, except an old disused
gaspipe that had an opening above the desk. (Sensation.)
Was there any indication of the presence of such a gas?
No smell?--None whatever.
But there are gases which are at once deadly and scentless--carbon
dioxide, for example?--Yes; there are.
By the Foreman: Did you test the atmosphere for the presence of such
a gas?--No; but I entered the room before it would have had time to
dissipate; I should have noticed it.
Was the room disarranged in any way?--Except for the table there was
Did you find the contents of the table disturbed?--Yes.
Will you describe exactly the appearance of the table?
--One or two heavy articles of table furniture, such as the silver
candlesticks, etc., alone remained in their positions. On the floor
were a number of papers, the inkstand, a pen, and (here the witness
drew a notecase from his pocket and extracted a small black shrivelled
object) a smashed flower bowl and a number of roses.
Did you find anything in the dead man's hand?--Yes, I found
The detective held up a withered rosebud, and a thrill of horror ran
through the court.
That is a rose?--Yes.
The Coroner consulted the Commissioner's written report.
Did you notice anything peculiar about the hand?--Yes, where the
flower had been there was a round black stain. (Sensation.)
Can you account for that?--No.
By the Foreman: What steps did you take when you discovered this?--I
had the flowers carefully collected and as much of the water as was
possible absorbed by clean blotting-paper: these were sent to the Home
Office for analysis.
Do you know the result of that analysis?--So far as I know, it has
Did the analysis include leaves from the rose you have in your
The Assistant Commissioner then went on to give details of the
police arrangements for the day. It was impossible, he emphatically
stated, for any person to have entered or left 44 Downing Street
without being observed. Immediately after the murder the police on duty
were ordered to stand fast. Most of the men, said the witness, were on
duty for twenty-six hours at a stretch.
At this stage there was revealed the most sensational feature of the
inquiry. It came with dramatic suddenness, and was the result of a
question put by the Coroner, who constantly referred to the
Commissioner's signed statement that lay before him.
You know of a man called Thery?--Yes.
He was one of a band calling themselves 'The Four Just Men'?--I
A reward was offered for his apprehension?--Yes.
He was suspected of complicity in the plot to murder Sir Philip
Has he been found?--Yes.
This monosyllabic reply drew a spontaneous cry of surprise from the
When was he found?--This morning.
Where?--On Romney Marshes.
Was he dead?--Yes. (Sensation.)
Was there anything peculiar about the body? (The whole court waited
for the answer with bated breath.)--Yes; on his right palm was a stain
similar to that found on the hand of Sir Philip Ramon!
A shiver ran through the crowd of listeners.
Was a rose found in his hand also?--No.
By the Foreman: Was there any indication how Thery came to where he
The witness added that no papers or documents of any kind were found
upon the man.
Sir Francis Katling was the next witness.
He was sworn and was accorded permission to give his evidence from
the solicitor's table, on which he had spread the voluminous notes of
his observations. For half an hour he devoted himself to a purely
technical record of his examinations. There were three possible causes
of death. It might have been natural: the man's weak heart was
sufficient to cause such; it might have been by asphyxiation; it might
have been the result of a blow that by some extraordinary means left no
There were no traces of poison?--None.
You have heard the evidence of the last witness?--Yes.
And that portion of the evidence that dealt with a black stain?--Yes.
Did you examine that stain?--Yes.
Have you formed any theories regarding it?--Yes; it seems to me as
if it were formed by an acid.
Carbolic acid, for instance?--Yes; but there was no indication of
any of the acids of commerce.
You saw the man Thery's hand?--Yes.
Was the stain of a similar character?--Yes, but larger and more
Were there any signs of acid?--None.
By the Foreman: You have seen many of the fantastic theories put
forward by the Press and public?--Yes; I have paid careful attention to
And you see nothing in them that would lead you to believe that the
deceased met his end by the method suggested?--No.
Gas?--Impossible; it must have been immediately detected.
The introduction into the room of some subtle poison that would
asphyxiate and leave no trace?--Such a drug is unknown to medical
You have seen the rose found in Sir Philip's hand?--Yes.
How do you account for that?--I cannot account for it.
Nor for the stain?--No.
By the Foreman: You have formed no definite opinion regarding the
cause of death?--No; I merely submit one of the three suggestions I
Are you a believer in hypnotism?--Yes, to a certain extent.
In hypnotic suggestion?--Again, to a certain extent.
Is it possible that the suggestion of death coming at a certain hour
so persistently threatened might have led to death?--I do not quite
Is it possible that the deceased is a victim to hypnotic
suggestion?--I do not believe it possible.
By the Foreman: You speak of a blow leaving no contusion. In your
experience have you ever seen such a case?--Yes; twice.
But a blow sufficient to cause death?--Yes.
Without leaving a bruise or any mark whatever?--Yes; I saw a case in
Japan where a man by exerting a peculiar pressure on the throat
produced instant death.
Is that ordinary?--No; it is very unordinary; sufficiently so to
create a considerable stir in medical circles. The case was recorded in
the British Medical Journal in 1896.
And there was no contusion or bruise?--Absolutely none whatever.
The famous surgeon then read a long extract from the British
Medical Journal bearing out this statement.
Would you say that the deceased died in this way?--It is
By the Foreman: Do you advance that as a serious
With a few more questions of a technical character the examination
As the great surgeon left the box there was a hum of conversation,
and keen disappointment was felt on all sides. It had been hoped that
the evidence of the medical expert would have thrown light into dark
places, but it left the mystery of Sir Philip Ramon's death as far from
explanation as ever.
Superintendent Falmouth was the next witness called.
The detective, who gave his evidence in clear tones, was evidently
speaking under stress of very great emotion. He seemed to appreciate
very keenly the failure of the police to safeguard the life of the dead
Minister. It is an open secret that immediately after the tragedy both
the officer and the Assistant Commissioner tendered their resignations,
which, at the express instruction of the Prime Minister, were not
Mr Falmouth repeated a great deal of the evidence already given by
the Commissioner, and told the story of how he had stood on duty
outside the Foreign Secretary's door at the moment of the tragedy. As
he detailed the events of that evening a deathly silence came upon the
You say you heard a noise proceeding from the study?
What sort of a noise?--Well, it is hard to describe what I heard; it
was one of those indefinite noises that sounded like a chair being
pulled across a soft surface.
Would it be a noise like the sliding of a door or panel?
That is the noise as you described it in your report?--Yes.
Was any panel discovered?--No.
Or any sliding door?--No.
Would it have been possible for a person to have secreted himself in
any of the bureaux or bookcases?--No; these were examined.
What happened next?--I heard a click and a cry from Sir Philip, and
endeavoured to burst open the door.
By the Foreman: It was locked?--Yes. And Sir Philip was alone?--Yes;
it was by his wish: a wish expressed earlier in the day.
After the tragedy did you make a systematic search both inside and
outside the house?--Yes.
Did you make any discovery?--None, except that I made a discovery
curious in itself, but having no possible bearing on the case now.
What was this?--Well, it was the presence on the window-sill of the
room of two dead sparrows.
Were these examined?--Yes; but the surgeon who dissected them gave
the opinion that they died from exposure and had fallen from the
Was there any trace of poison in these birds?--None that could be
At this point Sir Francis Katling was recalled. He had seen the
birds. He could find no trace of poison.
Granted the possibility of such a gas as we have already spoken
of--a deadly gas with the property of rapid dissipation--might not the
escape of a minute quantity of such a fume bring about the death of
these birds?--Yes, if they were resting on the window-sill.
By the Foreman: Do you connect these birds with the tragedy?--I do
not, replied the witness emphatically.
Superintendent Falmouth resumed his evidence.
Were there any other curious features that struck you?--None.
The Coroner proceeded to question the witness concerning the
relations of Marks with the police.
Was the stain found on Sir Philip's hand, and on the hand of the man
Thery, found also on Marks?--No.
It was as the court was dispersing, and little groups of men stood
discussing the most extraordinary verdict ever given by a coroner's
jury, 'Death from some unknown cause, and wilful murder against some
person or persons unknown', that the Coroner himself met on the
threshold of the court a familiar face.
"Hullo, Carson!" he said in surprise, "you here too; I should have
thought that your bankrupts kept you busy--even on a day like
"Extraordinary," agreed the other.
"Were you there all the time?"
"Yes," replied the spectator.
"Did you notice what a bright foreman we had?"
"Yes; I think he would make a smarter lawyer than a company
"You know him, then?"
"Yes," yawned the Official Receiver; "poor devil, he thought he was
going to set the Thames on fire, floated a company to reproduce
photogravures and things--took Etherington's off our hands, but it's
"Has he failed?" asked the Coroner in surprise.
"Not exactly failed. He's just given it up, says the climate doesn't
suit him--what is his name again?"
"Manfred," said the Coroner.
Falmouth sat on the opposite side of the Chief Commissioner's desk, his
hands clasped before him. On the blotting-pad lay a thin sheet of grey
notepaper. The Commissioner picked it up again and re-read it.
When you receive this
[it ran] we who for want of a better title call ourselves The
Four Just Men will be scattered throughout Europe, and there is little
likelihood of your ever tracing us. In no spirit of boastful-ness we
say: We have accomplished that which we set ourselves to accomplish. In
no sense of hypocrisy we repeat our regret that such a step as we took
Sir Philip Ramon's death would appear to have been an accident. This
much we confess. Thery bungled--and paid the penalty. We depended too
much upon his technical knowledge. Perhaps by diligent search you will
solve the mystery of Sir Philip Ramon's death--when such a search is
rewarded you will realise the truth of this statement. Farewell.
"It tells us nothing," said the Commissioner. Falmouth shook his
head despairingly. "Search!" he said bitterly; "we have searched the
house in Downing Street from end to end--where else can we search?"
"Is there no paper amongst Sir Philip's documents that might
conceivably put you on the track?"
"None that we have seen."
The chief bit the end of his pen thoughtfully.
"Has his country house been examined?"
"I didn't think that necessary."
"Nor Portland Place?"
"No: it was locked up at the time of the murder."
The Commissioner rose.
"Try Portland Place," he advised. "At present it is in the hands of
Sir Philip's executors."
The detective hailed a hansom, and in a quarter of an hour found
himself knocking upon the gloomy portals of the late Foreign
Secretary's town house. A grave manservant opened the door; it was Sir
Philip's butler, a man known to Falmouth, who greeted him with a
"I want to make a search of the house, Perks," he said. "Has
anything been touched?"
The man shook his head.
"No, Mr Falmouth," he replied, "everything is just as Sir Philip
left it. The lawyer gentlemen have not even made an inventory."
Falmouth walked through the chilly hall to the comfortable little
room set apart for the butler.
"I should like to start with the study," he said.
"I'm afraid there will be a difficulty, then, sir," said Perks
"Why?" demanded Falmouth sharply.
"It is the only room in the house for which we have no key. Sir
Philip had a special lock for his study and carried the key with him.
You see, being a Cabinet Minister, and a very careful man, he was very
particular about people entering his study."
A number of Sir Philip's private keys were deposited at Scotland
He scribbled a brief note to his chief and sent a footman by cab to
Whilst he was waiting he sounded the butler.
"Where were you when the murder was committed, Perks?" he asked.
"In the country: Sir Philip sent away all the servants, you will
"And the house?"
"Was empty--absolutely empty."
"Was there any evidence on your return that any person had effected
"None, sir; it would be next to impossible to burgle this house.
There are alarm wires fixed communicating with the police station, and
the windows are automatically locked."
"There were no marks on the doors or windows that would lead you to
believe that an entrance had been attempted?"
The butler shook his head emphatically.
"None; in the course of my daily duty I make a very careful
inspection of the paintwork, and I should have noticed any marks of the
In half an hour the footman, accompanied by a detective, returned,
and Falmouth took from the plain-clothed officer a small bunch of
The butler led the way to the first floor.
He indicated the study, a massive oaken door, fitted with a
Very carefully Falmouth made his selection of keys. Twice he tried
unsuccessfully, but at the third attempt the lock turned with a click,
and the door opened noiselessly.
He stood for a moment at the entrance, for the room was in
"I forgot," said Perks, "the shutters are closed--shall I open
"If you please," said the detective.
In a few minutes the room was flooded with light.
It was a plainly furnished apartment, rather similar in appearance
to that in which the Foreign Secretary met his end. It smelt mustily of
old leather, and the walls of the room were covered with bookshelves.
In the centre stood a big mahogany writing-table, with bundles of
papers neatly arranged.
Falmouth took a rapid and careful survey of this desk. It was thick
with accumulated dust. At one end, within reach of the vacant chair
stood an ordinary table telephone.
"No bells," said Falmouth.
"No," replied the butler. "Sir Philip disliked bells-there is a
"Of course," he said quickly. "I remember--hullo!"
He bent forward eagerly.
"Why, what has happened to the telephone?"
The detective, returned, and Falmouth took from the plain-clothed officer
a small bunch of keys.
The butler led the way to the first floor.
He indicated the study, a massive oaken door, fitted with a
Very carefully Falmouth made his selection of keys. Twice he tried
unsuccessfully, but at the third attempt the lock turned with a click,
and the door opened noiselessly.
He stood for a moment at the entrance, for the room was in
"I forgot," said Perks, "the shutters are closed--shall I open
"If you please," said the detective.
In a few minutes the room was flooded with light.
It was a plainly furnished apartment, rather similar in appearance
to that in which the Foreign Secretary met his end. It smelt mustily of
old leather, and the walls of the room were covered with bookshelves.
In the centre stood a big mahogany writing-table, with bundles of
papers neatly arranged.
Falmouth took a rapid and careful survey of this desk. It was thick
with accumulated dust. At one end, within reach of the vacant chair
stood an ordinary table telephone.
"No bells," said Falmouth.
"No," replied the butler. "Sir Philip disliked bells--there is a
"Of course," he said quickly. "I remember--hullo!"
He bent forward eagerly.
"Why, what has happened to the telephone?"
He might well ask, for its steel was warped and twisted. Beneath
where the vulcanite receiver stood was a tiny heap of black ash, and of
the flexible cord that connected it with the outside world nothing
remained but a twisted piece of discoloured wire.
The table on which it stood was blistered as with some great
The detective drew a long breath.
He turned to his subordinate.
"Run across to Miller's in Regent Street--the electrician--and ask
Mr Miller to come here at once."
He was still standing gazing at the telephone when the electrician
"Mr Miller," said Falmouth slowly, "what has happened to this
The electrician adjusted his pince-nez and inspected the ruin.
"H'm," he said, "it rather looks as though some linesman had been
"Linesman? What do you mean?" demanded Falmouth.
"I mean the workmen engaged to fix telephone wires." He made another
"Cannot you see?"
He pointed to the battered instrument.
"I see that the machine is entirely ruined--but why?"
The electrician stooped and picked up the scorched wire from the
"What I mean is this," he said. "Somebody has attached a wire
carrying a high voltage--probably an electric-lighting wire--to this
telephone line: and if anybody had happened to have been at----" He
stopped suddenly, and his face went white.
"Good God!" he whispered, "Sir Philip Ramon was electrocuted!"
For a while not one of the party spoke. Then Falmouth's hand darted
into his pocket and he drew out the little notebook which Billy Marks
"That is the solution," he cried; "here is the direction the wires
took--but how is it that the telephone at Downing Street was not
destroyed in a similar manner?"
The electrician, white and shaking, shook his head impatiently.
"I have given up trying to account for the vagaries of electricity,"
he said; "besides, the current, the full force of the current, might
have been diverted--a short circuit might have been effected--anything
might have happened."
"Wait!" said Falmouth eagerly. "Suppose the man making the
connection had bungled--had taken the full force of the current
himself--would that have brought about this result?"
"'Thery bungled--and paid the penalty,'" quoted Falmouth slowly.
"Ramon got a slight shock--sufficient to frighten him--he had a weak
heart--the burn on his hand, the dead sparrows! By Heaven! it's as
clear as daylight!"
Later, a strong force of police raided the house in Carnaby Street,
but they found nothing--except a half-smoked cigarette bearing the name
of a London tobacconist, and the counterfoil of a passage ticket to New
It was marked per RMS 'Lucania', and was for three
When the Lucania arrived at New York she was searched from
stem to stern, but the Four Just Men were not discovered.
It was Gonsalez who had placed the 'clue' for the police to